Resources

A chemist dissolves 18.4 g18.4\text{ g} of glycerol (C3H8O3\text{C}_3\text{H}_8\text{O}_3, molar mass =92.09 g/mol= 92.09\text{ g/mol}), a non-volatile non-electrolyte solute, in 175.0 g175.0\text{ g} of pure water (Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, normal freezing point =0.00∘C= 0.00^\circ\text{C}). Rather than finding the new freezing point, calculate the percent depression of the freezing point relative to the normal boiling point elevation of the exact same solution, given Kb=0.512∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}. Specifically, determine the numerical ratio ΔTfΔTb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} and express it as a percentage (ΔTfΔTb×100%)(\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\%).

Answer and steps

Final answer

ΔTfΔTb×100%=363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = 363\% (Ratio =3.63= 3.63)

Steps

Method 1: Direct Algebraic Ratio (Simplest Method)

Colligative properties depend only on the concentration of solute particles, not their identity. For a non-volatile, non-electrolyte solute (i=1i = 1) dissolved in water, the freezing point depression (ΔTf\Delta T_f) and boiling point elevation (ΔTb\Delta T_b) are given by:

ΔTf=i⋅Kf⋅m\Delta T_f = i \cdot K_f \cdot m ΔTb=i⋅Kb⋅m\Delta T_b = i \cdot K_b \cdot m

Since both phenomena are evaluated for the exact same solution, the molality (mm) and the van 't Hoff factor (i=1i = 1) are identical and cancel out when taking their ratio:

ΔTfΔTb=i⋅Kf⋅mi⋅Kb⋅m=KfKb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{i \cdot K_f \cdot m}{i \cdot K_b \cdot m} = \frac{K_f}{K_b}

Substitute the given cryoscopic and ebullioscopic constants for water:

ΔTfΔTb=1.86∘C⋅kg/mol0.512∘C⋅kg/mol≈3.6328\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}}{0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}} \approx 3.6328

Expressed as a percentage:

ΔTfΔTb×100%=3.6328×100%≈363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = 3.6328 \times 100\% \approx 363\%


Method 2: Step-by-Step Calculation via Molality

To verify the result numerically using the given mass quantities:

  1. Find the moles of solute (glycerol, CX3HX8OX3\ce{C3H8O3}): n=massmolar mass=18.4 g92.09 g/mol≈0.1998 moln = \frac{\text{mass}}{\text{molar mass}} = \frac{18.4\text{ g}}{92.09\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.1998\text{ mol}
  2. Calculate the molality (mm) of the solution: mass of water in kg=175.0 g1000 g/kg=0.1750 kg\text{mass of water in kg} = \frac{175.0\text{ g}}{1000\text{ g/kg}} = 0.1750\text{ kg} m=0.1998 mol0.1750 kg≈1.1417 mol/kgm = \frac{0.1998\text{ mol}}{0.1750\text{ kg}} \approx 1.1417\text{ mol/kg}
  3. Compute ΔTf\Delta T_f and ΔTb\Delta T_b: ΔTf=Kf⋅m=1.86∘C⋅kg/mol⋅1.1417 mol/kg≈2.124∘C\Delta T_f = K_f \cdot m = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \cdot 1.1417\text{ mol/kg} \approx 2.124^\circ\text{C} ΔTb=Kb⋅m=0.512∘C⋅kg/mol⋅1.1417 mol/kg≈0.5845∘C\Delta T_b = K_b \cdot m = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \cdot 1.1417\text{ mol/kg} \approx 0.5845^\circ\text{C}
  4. Determine the ratio and percentage: ΔTfΔTb=2.124∘C0.5845∘C≈3.63\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{2.124^\circ\text{C}}{0.5845^\circ\text{C}} \approx 3.63 ΔTfΔTb×100%=3.63×100%=363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = 3.63 \times 100\% = 363\%

Common Pitfall

A common mistake is spending time calculating the new actual temperatures (Tf=−2.12∘CT_f = -2.12^\circ\text{C} and Tb=100.58∘CT_b = 100.58^\circ\text{C}) or taking a ratio of the absolute Celsius temperatures. The question specifically asks for the ratio of the colligative changes (ΔTf\Delta T_f and ΔTb\Delta T_b), which directly reduces to the ratio of the solvent's intrinsic constants KfKb\frac{K_f}{K_b}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the ratio as ΔT_b / ΔT_f instead of ΔT_f / ΔT_b, yielding approximately 27.5%.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔTfΔTb=KbKf\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{K_b}{K_f}

    Correct

    ΔTfΔTb=KfKb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{K_f}{K_b}

    Since ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m and ΔTb=iKbm\Delta T_b = i K_b m, dividing ΔTf\Delta T_f by ΔTb\Delta T_b places KfK_f in the numerator and KbK_b in the denominator.

  2. Step 2

    =0.5121.86≈0.2753  ⟹  0.2753×100%=27.5%= \frac{0.512}{1.86} \approx 0.2753 \implies 0.2753 \times 100\% = 27.5\%

    Correct

    =1.860.512≈3.6328  ⟹  3.6328×100%≈363%= \frac{1.86}{0.512} \approx 3.6328 \implies 3.6328 \times 100\% \approx 363\%

    You calculated the division and converted your decimal to a percentage correctly, but the result is inverted because of the flipped ratio in the first step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You realized that calculating the solution's molality was unnecessary because it cancels out in the ratio.

You correctly converted your decimal value into a percentage.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You mismatched the corresponding colligative constants when setting up the quotient, placing the boiling point constant (KbK_b) in the numerator corresponding to freezing point depression (ΔTf\Delta T_f).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Numerator-to-Numerator Alignment
  • When taking a ratio AB=cA⋅xcB⋅x\frac{A}{B} = \frac{c_A \cdot x}{c_B \cdot x}, the constant for AA must stay in the numerator: AB=cAcB\frac{A}{B} = \frac{c_A}{c_B}.

  • Always write the full formulas ΔTf=Kfm\Delta T_f = K_f m and ΔTb=Kbm\Delta T_b = K_b m before canceling common factors.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ΔTfΔTb=Kf⋅mKb⋅m=KfKb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{K_f \cdot m}{K_b \cdot m} = \frac{K_f}{K_b}

  2. Substitute the given constants: 1.86∘C⋅kg/mol0.512∘C⋅kg/mol≈3.6328\frac{1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}}{0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}} \approx 3.6328

  3. Multiply by 100%100\% to express as a percentage: 3.6328×100%≈363%3.6328 \times 100\% \approx 363\%

Final answer

ΔTfΔTb×100%=363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = 363\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out both colligative equations explicitly before canceling common terms to ensure each constant stays in its proper position.

  • Check whether your final ratio makes physical sense: water's KfK_f (1.861.86) is larger than KbK_b (0.5120.512), so ΔTf\Delta T_f must be larger than ΔTb\Delta T_b, giving a ratio greater than 100%100\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student calculates the ratio of the final temperatures on the Celsius scale (T_f / T_b) rather than the ratio of temperature changes (ΔT_f / ΔT_b).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    m=(18.4/92.09)/0.175=0.1998/0.175=1.142 mol/kgm = (18.4 / 92.09) / 0.175 = 0.1998 / 0.175 = 1.142\text{ mol/kg}

  2. Step 2

    ΔTf=1.86×1.142=2.12∘C  ⟹  ΔTb=0.512×1.142=0.585∘C\Delta T_f = 1.86 \times 1.142 = 2.12^\circ\text{C} \implies \Delta T_b = 0.512 \times 1.142 = 0.585^\circ\text{C}

  3. Step 3

    Tf=0−2.12=−2.12∘C  ⟹  Tb=100+0.585=100.585∘C  ⟹  Ratio=(−2.12/100.585)×100%=−2.11%T_f = 0 - 2.12 = -2.12^\circ\text{C} \implies T_b = 100 + 0.585 = 100.585^\circ\text{C} \implies \text{Ratio} = (-2.12 / 100.585) \times 100\% = -2.11\%

    Correct

    ΔTfΔTb×100%=2.12∘C0.585∘C×100%≈363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = \frac{2.12^\circ\text{C}}{0.585^\circ\text{C}} \times 100\% \approx 363\%

    You calculated the final Celsius temperatures TfT_f and TbT_b and divided them, rather than dividing the colligative temperature changes ΔTf\Delta T_f and ΔTb\Delta T_b. Taking ratios of temperatures on relative scales like Celsius is physically invalid, and the question asked specifically for ΔTfΔTb×100%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the molality of the glycerol solution.

You correctly applied the colligative property formulas to find ΔTf\Delta T_f and ΔTb\Delta T_b.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Temperature Change with Final Temperature

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the colligative property change values (ΔT\Delta T) with the final absolute mixture temperatures (TT), leading you to compute a ratio of final Celsius temperatures instead of the requested ratio of changes ΔTfΔTb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify What the Ratio Requires
  • A question asking for a ratio of colligative effects asks for ΔT1ΔT2\frac{\Delta T_1}{\Delta T_2}, not T1T2\frac{T_1}{T_2}.

  • Always divide the positive change magnitudes ΔT\Delta T, never final readings on non-absolute temperature scales like Celsius.

Look for Algebraic Simplification
  • For the same solution, molality mm and van 't Hoff factor ii are identical, so ΔTfΔTb=iKfmiKbm=KfKb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{i K_f m}{i K_b m} = \frac{K_f}{K_b}.

  • Check whether solute concentrations cancel out before performing multi-step numerical calculations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the ratio of the colligative temperature changes directly: ΔTfΔTb=2.12∘C0.585∘C≈3.63\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{2.12^\circ\text{C}}{0.585^\circ\text{C}} \approx 3.63 (or using constants directly: KfKb=1.860.512≈3.6328\frac{K_f}{K_b} = \frac{1.86}{0.512} \approx 3.6328).

  2. Multiply the resulting ratio by 100%100\% to express it as a percentage: 3.6328×100%≈363%3.6328 \times 100\% \approx 363\%.

Final answer

ΔTfΔTb×100%=363%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} \times 100\% = 363\% (Ratio =3.63= 3.63)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Watch for the Greek letter delta (Δ\Delta), which specifies a difference or change rather than a state reading.

  • Avoid taking ratios of temperatures on the Celsius or Fahrenheit scales, as zero on those scales is arbitrary.

  • Notice when concentration terms cancel out so you can solve comparison questions in a single step using the solvent constants.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A solution is prepared using benzene as the solvent (Kf=5.12∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 5.12^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, Kb=2.53∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 2.53^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}) with an unknown non-volatile solute. What is the ratio ΔTfΔTb\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} expressed as a percentage?

Answer

202%202\%. Key step: ΔTfΔTb=KfKb=5.122.53≈2.0237  ⟹  202%\frac{\Delta T_f}{\Delta T_b} = \frac{K_f}{K_b} = \frac{5.12}{2.53} \approx 2.0237 \implies 202\%.

02

An aqueous solution of urea has a boiling point elevation of ΔTb=0.256∘C\Delta T_b = 0.256^\circ\text{C}. Given Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} and Kb=0.512∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, find its freezing point depression ΔTf\Delta T_f without explicitly solving for molality.

Answer

ΔTf=0.930∘C\Delta T_f = 0.930^\circ\text{C}. Key step: ΔTf=ΔTb×KfKb=0.256∘C×1.860.512=0.256×3.6328=0.930∘C\Delta T_f = \Delta T_b \times \frac{K_f}{K_b} = 0.256^\circ\text{C} \times \frac{1.86}{0.512} = 0.256 \times 3.6328 = 0.930^\circ\text{C}.

03

Two identical mass samples of a non-electrolyte solute are dissolved separately: one in water (Kf=1.86K_f = 1.86, Kb=0.512K_b = 0.512) and one in ethanol (Kf=1.99K_f = 1.99, Kb=1.22K_b = 1.22). If each has the same molality, find the ratio of the freezing point depression in water to the boiling point elevation in ethanol, ΔTf,waterΔTb,ethanol\frac{\Delta T_{f,\text{water}}}{\Delta T_{b,\text{ethanol}}}, as a percentage.

Answer

152%152\%. Key step: Since molalities are equal, ΔTf,waterΔTb,ethanol=Kf,waterKb,ethanol=1.861.22≈1.5246  ⟹  152%\frac{\Delta T_{f,\text{water}}}{\Delta T_{b,\text{ethanol}}} = \frac{K_{f,\text{water}}}{K_{b,\text{ethanol}}} = \frac{1.86}{1.22} \approx 1.5246 \implies 152\%.

Loading workspace…