Resources

A student investigates the gas-phase exothermic synthesis of methanol: CO(g)+2H2(g)⇌CH3OH(g)\text{CO}(g) + 2\text{H}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons \text{CH}_3\text{OH}(g), ΔH∘=−90.7 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ = -90.7\text{ kJ/mol}. The reaction is at dynamic equilibrium inside a cylinder fitted with a frictionless piston at total pressure P1=3.00 atmP_1 = 3.00\text{ atm} and temperature T=500 KT = 500\text{ K}. The student introduces 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of pure, unreactive helium gas (He\text{He}) into the cylinder under two different operational conditions: Condition A (rigid container at constant volume) and Condition B (movable piston maintaining constant total pressure). Predict the direction of the net equilibrium shift (shifts right, shifts left, or no shift) for Condition A and Condition B, explicitly addressing the common sign/convention trap regarding inert gas addition.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Condition A (constant volume): No shift, because partial pressures and concentrations of reacting species remain unchanged; Condition B (constant total pressure): Shifts left (toward reactants), because cylinder expansion dilutes reacting gases, lowering their partial pressures and driving the system toward the side with more moles of gas (33 moles of gas vs. 11 mole).

Steps

01

Write the Equilibrium Expression and Identify Stoichiometry

To determine how adding an unreactive gas like He\ce{He} affects a dynamic equilibrium, we analyze how the partial pressures (or molar concentrations) of the reacting species change under each operational constraint.

The reversible reaction is: CO(g)+2H2(g)⇌CH3OH(g)\ce{CO}(g) + 2\ce{H}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons \ce{CH}_3\ce{OH}(g)

The reaction quotient in terms of partial pressures is: Qp=PCH3OHPCO⋅(PH2)2Q_p = \frac{P_{\ce{CH}_3\ce{OH}}}{P_{\ce{CO}} \cdot (P_{\ce{H}_2})^2}

Count the moles of gaseous species on each side:

  • Reactants: 1 mol CO+2 mol H2=3 moles of gas1\text{ mol }\ce{CO} + 2\text{ mol }\ce{H}_2 = 3\text{ moles of gas}
  • Products: 1 mol CH3OH=1 mole of gas1\text{ mol }\ce{CH}_3\ce{OH} = 1\text{ mole of gas}
  • Δngas=1−(1+2)=−2\Delta n_{\text{gas}} = 1 - (1 + 2) = -2

02

Condition A — Constant Volume (Rigid Container)

According to Dalton's Law and the Ideal Gas Law: Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i R T}{V}

  • When He(g)\ce{He}(g) is introduced into a rigid container of fixed volume VV at constant temperature TT, the moles of reacting gases (nCOn_{\ce{CO}}, nH2n_{\ce{H}_2}, nCH3OHn_{\ce{CH}_3\ce{OH}}) have not changed.
  • Consequently, the individual partial pressures PiP_i and the molar concentrations [i]=niV[i] = \frac{n_i}{V} of all reacting species remain completely unchanged, even though the total pressure Ptotal=∑Pi+PHeP_{\text{total}} = \sum P_i + P_{\ce{He}} increases.
  • Because no individual partial pressure changes, Qp=KpQ_p = K_p.

Conclusion for Condition A: No shift.

Common Trap: A frequent mistake is assuming that an increase in total pressure automatically causes the system to shift toward the side with fewer gas molecules. Le Châtelier's principle responds to changes in the concentrations or partial pressures of the actual equilibrium components, not to the presence of an inert spectator gas at fixed volume.


03

Condition B — Constant Total Pressure (Movable Piston)

Under a movable, frictionless piston maintaining constant PtotalP_{\text{total}}:

  • Adding He(g)\ce{He}(g) adds moles of gas to the container. To keep the total pressure constant at 3.00 atm3.00\text{ atm}, the piston moves outward and the container volume VV increases (expansion/dilution).
  • The partial pressure of any reacting gas is Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}}, where Xi=nintotalX_i = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}}. Since ntotaln_{\text{total}} increases due to added helium while nin_i is initially unchanged, each mole fraction XiX_i decreases, causing every reacting gas's partial pressure PiP_i to decrease.
  • Substituting into the reaction quotient: Qp=PCH3OHPCO⋅(PH2)2∝V−1V−1⋅V−2=V2Q_p = \frac{P_{\ce{CH}_3\ce{OH}}}{P_{\ce{CO}} \cdot (P_{\ce{H}_2})^2} \propto \frac{V^{-1}}{V^{-1} \cdot V^{-2}} = V^2 Since VV increases, QpQ_p becomes greater than KpK_p (Qp>KpQ_p > K_p).
  • Alternatively, by Le Châtelier's principle, the system opposes the overall decrease in reacting gas partial pressures by shifting toward the side that produces more moles of gas (3 moles of reactant gas3\text{ moles of reactant gas} versus 1 mole of product gas1\text{ mole of product gas}).

Conclusion for Condition B: Shifts left (toward reactants).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student believes that adding any gas increases the total pressure and always shifts the equilibrium toward the side with fewer moles of gas, failing to realize that inert gas at constant volume does not change reactant partial pressures.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Adding He gas increases the total pressure inside the rigid cylinder. Higher pressure favors the side with fewer gas moles (3 mol reactant vs 1 mol product). ⟹ Equilibrium shifts right.

    Correct

    In a rigid cylinder (V=constantV = \text{constant}), adding unreactive He(g)\text{He}(g) increases total pressure, but each reacting gas's partial pressure Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} remains unchanged. Therefore, Qp=KpQ_p = K_p and there is no shift.

    You treated an increase in total pressure caused by an unreactive gas as an equilibrium stress. However, Le Châtelier's principle responds only to changes in the concentrations or partial pressures of the reacting components. Because volume and temperature are constant, the partial pressures of CO\text{CO}, H2\text{H}_2, and CH3OH\text{CH}_3\text{OH} do not change, so the system does not shift.

  2. Step 2

    Total pressure is kept constant at 3.00 atm, so pressure does not change. Since total pressure is unchanged, the partial pressures do not change. ⟹ No shift.

    Correct

    To keep total pressure constant when adding He(g)\text{He}(g), the piston must move outward to increase volume (VV). This dilution decreases the partial pressure of each reacting gas (Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}}), causing the equilibrium to shift left toward the side with more gas moles (3 mol3\text{ mol} vs. 1 mol1\text{ mol}).

    You assumed that constant total pressure guarantees constant partial pressures. In reality, adding helium increases the total moles (ntotaln_{\text{total}}), which decreases the mole fraction Xi=nintotalX_i = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}} and partial pressure Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} of every reacting gas. To counteract this drop in reacting gas pressures, the reaction shifts toward the side with more moles of gas (left).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly counted the gaseous stoichiometry on both sides of the balanced equation (3 mol3\text{ mol} of reactants vs. 1 mol1\text{ mol} of product).

You recognized that adding gas into a rigid container increases the total pressure inside the vessel.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inert Gas Equilibrium Stress Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You relied on the total pressure of the container rather than evaluating whether the partial pressures or molar concentrations (Pi=niRTV=[i]RTP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} = [i]RT) of the actual reacting gases changed under each volume constraint.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Constant Volume ($V = \text{constant}$)
  • Adding an inert gas changes PtotalP_{\text{total}}, but does not change VV, TT, or any nin_i.

  • Calculate Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V}; since no reactant or product partial pressure changes, Qp=KpQ_p = K_p and no shift occurs.

Constant Total Pressure ($P_{\text{total}} = \text{constant}$)
  • Adding an inert gas under a movable piston forces the container volume VV to expand to maintain pressure.

  • Recognize that expansion dilutes all reacting species (Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} decreases), shifting equilibrium toward the side with more moles of gas.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the equilibrium quotient expression: Qp=PCH3OHPCO⋅(PH2)2Q_p = \frac{P_{\text{CH}_3\text{OH}}}{P_{\text{CO}} \cdot (P_{\text{H}_2})^2}.

  2. For Condition A (rigid vessel, constant VV): Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} is unchanged for all reacting species   ⟹  Qp=Kp  ⟹  \implies Q_p = K_p \implies No shift.

  3. For Condition B (movable piston, constant PtotalP_{\text{total}}): volume must expand (VV increases) as helium enters.

  4. Because volume increases, Pi=XiPtotal=nintotalPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}} P_{\text{total}} decreases for all reacting species.

  5. The system shifts toward the side with more moles of gas to counteract the decrease in partial pressures (3 mol3\text{ mol} of reactant gas vs. 1 mol1\text{ mol} of product gas).

Final answer

Condition A: No shift; Condition B: Shifts left (toward reactants).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} and Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} before deciding whether an inert gas affects equilibrium.

  • Ask yourself first: 'Did the container volume change?' If volume is constant, adding an inert gas never shifts the position of equilibrium.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that because helium is chemically inert, adding it can never perturb the equilibrium regardless of volume changes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    a) Helium is an inert noble gas and does not participate in the reaction. Partial pressures of the reacting gases are unchanged at constant volume. No shift.

  2. Step 2

    b) Helium is inert and does not react with CO\ce{CO}, HX2\ce{H2}, or CHX3OH\ce{CH3OH}. Adding an unreactive substance cannot change the equilibrium position. No shift.

    Correct

    Condition B (constant total pressure): Shifts left (toward reactants). To maintain constant total pressure with added moles of gas, the cylinder volume must expand, lowering the partial pressures of all reacting species and favoring the side with more moles of gas (3 mol3\text{ mol} vs. 1 mol1\text{ mol}).

    You treated chemical inertness as a guarantee that the system cannot be perturbed. Under constant total pressure with a movable piston, adding gas forces the cylinder to expand. This dilution reduces the partial pressure of every reacting species (Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} decreases because XiX_i decreases), which increases the reaction quotient QpQ_p relative to KpK_p and causes the system to shift left toward the side with more gas moles.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified helium as a chemically unreactive spectator gas.

You correctly applied Dalton's law of partial pressures to show that constant volume preserves the individual partial pressures of the reacting species.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inert gas equilibrium perturbation under constant pressure

Assuming that because a gas does not chemically react, introducing it can never change the equilibrium state.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing chemical inertness with physical non-interference. While an inert gas does not appear in the stoichiometric equation or the equilibrium expression, adding it under constant total pressure forces an increase in system volume. This volumetric expansion dilutes all reacting species, altering their partial pressures and shifting the equilibrium toward the side with more moles of gas.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Constant Volume vs. Constant Pressure
  • At constant VV, Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i R T}{V} is unaffected by adding an inert gas. At constant PtotalP_{\text{total}}, VV must increase to accommodate additional moles, lowering each Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i R T}{V}.

  • Always check the mechanical boundary condition (rigid container vs. movable piston) before concluding whether an inert gas affects equilibrium.

Evaluate Dilution with Le Châtelier's Principle
  • Lowering all gaseous partial pressures by expansion shifts the equilibrium toward the side with more total stoichiometric moles of gas (larger ∑ngas\sum n_{\text{gas}}).

  • Count Δngas=nproducts−nreactants\Delta n_{\text{gas}} = n_{\text{products}} - n_{\text{reactants}} to determine whether expansion shifts the reaction forward or backward.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that adding 1.00 mol He1.00\text{ mol }\ce{He} into a cylinder with a movable piston increases the total gas moles ntotaln_{\text{total}} while keeping TT and PtotalP_{\text{total}} constant.

  2. By the ideal gas law V=ntotalRTPtotalV = \frac{n_{\text{total}}RT}{P_{\text{total}}}, the container volume VV must increase (expansion).

  3. Each reacting gas has partial pressure Pi=XiPtotal=(nintotal)PtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} = \left(\frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}}\right) P_{\text{total}}. Because ntotaln_{\text{total}} increases, every PiP_i decreases.

  4. Compare gas stoichiometry: Reactants have 1+2=3 mol of gas1 + 2 = 3\text{ mol of gas}, while products have 1 mol of gas1\text{ mol of gas}.

  5. By Le Châtelier's principle, the equilibrium shifts toward the side with more moles of gas to counteract the decrease in pressure, which is to the left (toward reactants).

Final answer

Condition A: No shift; Condition B: Shifts left (toward reactants).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing rigid-wall systems from movable-piston systems whenever inert gases are introduced.

  • Write out the reaction quotient QpQ_p explicitly in terms of mole fractions and PtotalP_{\text{total}} to verify how changes in total moles affect QpQ_p relative to KpK_p.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student miscounts stoichiometric coefficients by ignoring the coefficient of hydrogen, concluding that the reaction shifts right when the volume expands under Condition B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    At constant volume, the partial pressures of reactants and products remain constant.   ⟹  Qp=Kp\implies Q_p = K_p.   ⟹  \implies No shift.

  2. Step 2

    The piston moves out and volume increases to keep total pressure constant.   ⟹  \implies Partial pressures decrease, favoring the side with more moles of gas.

  3. Step 3

    Reactants have 1+1=2 moles1 + 1 = 2\text{ moles} and product has 1 mole of CH3OH1\text{ mole of }\text{CH}_3\text{OH}.

    Correct

    Reactants have 1 mol CO+2 mol H2=3 moles of gas1\text{ mol }\text{CO} + 2\text{ mol }\text{H}_2 = 3\text{ moles of gas}, and products have 1 mol CH3OH=1 mole of gas1\text{ mol }\text{CH}_3\text{OH} = 1\text{ mole of gas}.

    You overlooked the stoichiometric coefficient of 22 in front of H2(g)\text{H}_2(g) in the balanced equation CO(g)+2H2(g)⇌CH3OH(g)\text{CO}(g) + 2\text{H}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons \text{CH}_3\text{OH}(g). The reactant side has 1+2=3 moles of gas1 + 2 = 3\text{ moles of gas}, not 2 moles2\text{ moles}.

  4. Step 4

    Wait, product side is favored when pressure drops if product has more moles.   ⟹  \implies Equilibrium shifts right.

    Correct

    Because the reactant side has more moles of gas (3 moles3\text{ moles} vs. 1 mole1\text{ mole}), the equilibrium shifts left (toward reactants).

    Because dilution favors the side with more moles of gas and the reactants have 3 moles of gas3\text{ moles of gas} compared to 1 mole of product gas1\text{ mole of product gas}, the equilibrium must shift left toward reactants, not right.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly concluded that adding an inert gas at constant volume causes no equilibrium shift.

You correctly identified that adding an inert gas at constant total pressure increases container volume and lowers the partial pressures of the reacting gases.

You correctly applied the principle that an expansion/dilution favors the side of the reaction with more moles of gas.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric coefficient omission during mole count

You treated H2(g)\text{H}_2(g) as having a stoichiometric coefficient of 11 instead of 22 when tallying reactant gas moles.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted explicit stoichiometric multipliers when summing gaseous moles across the balanced equation, and subsequently misidentified which side had more gaseous moles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Tallying Gaseous Moles
  • For any gaseous shift analysis, Δngas=∑ngas, products−∑ngas, reactants\Delta n_{\text{gas}} = \sum n_{\text{gas, products}} - \sum n_{\text{gas, reactants}}, counting every explicit stoichiometric coefficient.

  • Always circle each stoichiometric coefficient in the balanced equation before summing reactant and product gas moles.

Connecting Volume Expansion to Shift Direction
  • Increasing volume lowers all partial pressures (Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}}), driving the reaction toward the side with strictly more moles of gas.

  • Compare the total reactant gas moles (1+2=31 + 2 = 3) directly to product gas moles (11) and select the larger sum.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. From CO(g)+2H2(g)⇌CH3OH(g)\text{CO}(g) + 2\text{H}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons \text{CH}_3\text{OH}(g), reactant gas moles =1+2=3 moles= 1 + 2 = 3\text{ moles} and product gas moles =1 mole= 1\text{ mole}.

  2. Because VV expands at constant total pressure, partial pressures decrease, favoring the side with more moles of gas (3>13 > 1).

  3. Therefore, the net equilibrium shift under Condition B is to the left (toward reactants).

Final answer

Condition A: No shift; Condition B: Shifts left (toward reactants).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review balanced chemical equations carefully by annotating the coefficient of each gaseous species before performing Le Châtelier predictions.

  • Double-check that you explicitly match the side with more moles to the corresponding direction (left for reactants, right for products).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Consider the equilibrium PCl5(g)⇌PCl3(g)+Cl2(g)\text{PCl}_5(g) \rightleftharpoons \text{PCl}_3(g) + \text{Cl}_2(g). Predict the direction of shift when neon gas is introduced at constant total pressure inside a cylinder with a movable piston.

Answer

Shifts right (toward products). Adding neon at constant total pressure causes the cylinder volume to expand, decreasing the partial pressures of all reacting gases. The system counteracts this dilution by shifting toward the side with more gaseous moles (2 mol2\text{ mol} vs. 1 mol1\text{ mol}).

02

For the reaction 2SO2(g)+O2(g)⇌2SO3(g)2\text{SO}_2(g) + \text{O}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\text{SO}_3(g), explain using the reaction quotient QpQ_p why adding krypton gas into a rigid container at constant temperature does not affect equilibrium.

Answer

No shift occurs because QpQ_p remains equal to KpK_p. In a rigid container, volume VV and temperature TT are constant. Since Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} and none of the mole quantities nSO2n_{\text{SO}_2}, nO2n_{\text{O}_2}, or nSO3n_{\text{SO}_3} change, every individual partial pressure is constant; therefore Qp=PSO32PSO22⋅PO2=KpQ_p = \frac{P_{\text{SO}_3}^2}{P_{\text{SO}_2}^2 \cdot P_{\text{O}_2}} = K_p.

03

A mixture of H2(g)+I2(g)⇌2HI(g)\text{H}_2(g) + \text{I}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\text{HI}(g) is at equilibrium. Unreactive argon gas is added under constant total pressure. Predict and justify the direction of the equilibrium shift.

Answer

No shift. Adding argon at constant total pressure causes volume expansion, decreasing each gas's partial pressure by a factor of k<1k < 1. Here Δngas=2−(1+1)=0\Delta n_{\text{gas}} = 2 - (1 + 1) = 0, so Qp=(kPHI)2(kPH2)(kPI2)=k2k2Qp,initial=KpQ_p = \frac{(k P_{\text{HI}})^2}{(k P_{\text{H}_2})(k P_{\text{I}_2})} = \frac{k^2}{k^2} Q_{p,\text{initial}} = K_p. Because both sides have equal moles of gas, dilution affects both sides equally.

Loading workspace…