Resources
Consider the neutralization of the weak diprotic acid phosphorous acid, (where only two protons are ionizable: , ), using a strong base, potassium hydroxide, . (a) Write the balanced net ionic equation for the complete stoichiometric neutralization when reacted with two equivalents of hydroxide. (b) Explain why must be retained in its un-ionized molecular form in the net ionic equation rather than written as separated ions.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) is a weak acid with incomplete dissociation in aqueous solution, so convention requires writing weak electrolytes as intact molecular formulas in net ionic equations.
Steps
Write the balanced molecular equation
Phosphorous acid, , is diprotic because only the two protons bound to oxygen atoms are ionizable; the hydrogen atom bonded directly to phosphorus is non-acidic. Neutralizing it completely requires two moles of hydroxide ion () per mole of acid:
Determine which species dissociate to write the complete ionic equation
To convert the molecular equation into an ionic equation, classify each substance by its electrolyte strength in aqueous solution:
- : A soluble strong base that completely dissociates into and .
- : A soluble ionic salt that completely dissociates into and .
- : A pure liquid and weak electrolyte that remains as molecular .
- : A weak acid (, ) that exists predominantly as un-ionized molecules in solution rather than free ions.
Writing the strong electrolytes in separated ionic form yields the complete ionic equation:
Cancel spectator ions to obtain the net ionic equation
The potassium ions, , appear identically on both sides of the reaction and do not participate in the proton-transfer process. Removing these spectator ions gives the balanced net ionic equation:
Common Pitfall: Do not remove all three hydrogen atoms from . Because it is diprotic, full neutralization produces the phosphite ion , not .
Explain why remains molecular
By convention, species in net ionic equations are written in the chemical form that predominates in aqueous solution:
- Strong electrolytes (strong acids, strong bases, and soluble salts) dissociate almost into ions.
- Weak electrolytes (weak acids and weak bases) undergo only slight ionization at equilibrium, remaining mostly intact as neutral molecules.
Because is a weak acid, the majority of the substance exists as undissociated molecules rather than free and ions; therefore, it must be represented in its intact molecular formula.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes all three hydrogens are ionizable because of the formula H3PO3 and reacts it with three equivalents of hydroxide to form PO3^3-.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Phosphorous acid is diprotic because only the two hydrogen atoms bonded to oxygen are acidic, while the hydrogen bonded directly to phosphorus cannot be removed by base. Complete neutralization consumes equivalents of to form , not .
- Step 2
is a weak acid that only partially ionizes in water, so it predominantly exists as undissociated molecules.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly kept in molecular form on the reactant side.
You provided an accurate explanation based on the incomplete dissociation of weak electrolytes in aqueous solution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that every hydrogen atom appearing in the chemical formula of an oxyacid is ionizable, overlooking the diprotic nature of phosphorous acid where only protons on electronegative oxygen atoms can dissociate.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ionizable Protons in Oxyacids
Only hydrogen atoms bonded to oxygen ( groups) are acidic; hydrogens bonded directly to a central atom with low polarity (like ) are non-ionizable.
Check the molecular structure or given values to determine the true number of transferable protons before balancing the neutralization reaction.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that has two ionizable protons, meaning stoichiometric neutralization requires .
Remove two protons from to form and .
Combine with the weak acid reactant to form the final net ionic equation: .
(a) ; (b) is a weak acid that dissociates only slightly in aqueous solution, so it predominantly exists as undissociated molecules and must be written in intact molecular form.
02 The student confuses a net ionic equation with a complete ionic equation by failing to cancel the spectator potassium ions.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You wrote the complete ionic equation instead of the net ionic equation. Spectator ions that appear unchanged on both sides (here, ) must be eliminated.
- Step 2
Phosphorous acid is a weak electrolyte that does not fully dissociate into ions in aqueous solution.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that phosphorous acid is a diprotic acid that yields the phosphite ion when reacted with two equivalents of base.
You accurately kept the weak acid intact as rather than incorrectly splitting it into ions.
You provided a clear, accurate rationale in part (b) based on the incomplete ionization of weak electrolytes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou provided the total (complete) ionic equation instead of taking the final step to cancel spectator ions () to obtain the net ionic equation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Complete vs. Net Ionic Equation
A complete ionic equation shows all soluble strong electrolytes separated into ions, whereas a net ionic equation eliminates identical spectator ions from both sides.
Always compare the reactant and product sides of your ionic equation. Cross out any ion that is identical in formula, state, and charge on both sides.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart from your complete ionic equation: .
Identify and cancel the spectator ions, which are the potassium ions appearing on both sides.
Write the final net ionic equation with the remaining species: .
(a) ; (b) Phosphorous acid is a weak electrolyte that dissociates only slightly in water, existing predominantly as un-ionized molecules.
03 The student incorrectly fully dissociates the weak acid into separate aqueous ions in the net ionic equation as if it were a strong acid.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You treated as if it completely dissociates into free ions. Because is a weak acid, it remains undissociated in the net ionic equation, reacting directly as intact molecules with hydroxide ions.
- Step 2
"Because it is diprotic, it splits into and which cancel out."
Correctis a weak electrolyte that undergoes only slight ionization in aqueous solution, so convention requires representing it in its predominant undissociated molecular form.
Being diprotic describes the number of ionizable protons, not acid strength. Furthermore, is a newly formed product ion rather than a spectator ion present on both sides, so it does not cancel out.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that neutralizing protons with hydroxide ions yields water molecules.
You correctly recognized that phosphorous acid donates two protons and corresponds to the divalent conjugate base .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakefalse
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated acid proticity with electrolyte strength, assuming that weak acids dissociate fully into free aqueous ions and that the resulting conjugate base behaves as an unreactive spectator ion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Representation of Electrolytes
Only strong electrolytes (strong acids, strong bases, and soluble ionic salts) are written as separated aqueous ions. Weak acids, weak bases, insoluble solids, and pure liquids remain in their intact molecular formulas.
Check the or electrolyte classification before writing the complete ionic equation. If a substance is a weak acid, do not break it into free ions.
- Identifying True Spectator Ions
Spectator ions must appear in identical chemical form, state, and quantity on both the reactant and product sides.
Notice that is generated during the reaction as a product; it was not an independent ion on the reactant side, so it cannot be canceled.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the molecular equation: .
Dissociate only the strong electrolytes: .
Cancel the spectator ion from both sides.
(a) ; (b) is a weak electrolyte that exists predominantly as un-ionized molecules in solution, so convention requires writing it in intact molecular form.
Lock it in
How do you identify whether a hydrogen in an oxyacid of phosphorus is ionizable?
Only hydrogens bonded to oxygen () are acidic and ionizable; hydrogens bonded directly to phosphorus () are non-acidic because the bond is nonpolar.
Similar question
Write the balanced net ionic equation for the complete stoichiometric neutralization of hypophosphorous acid, (a monoprotic weak acid), using aqueous sodium hydroxide, .
Answer
. Because is monoprotic, it reacts in a molar ratio with hydroxide to form the hypophosphite ion .
Write the balanced net ionic equation for the complete neutralization of oxalic acid, (a weak diprotic acid), by barium hydroxide, , noting that barium oxalate () is an insoluble precipitate.
Answer
. Oxalic acid is a weak diprotic acid that donates to , and the resulting oxalate ion precipitates with barium.
A solution of phosphorous acid, , is titrated with strong base to the first stoichiometric equivalence point using one equivalent of . Write the balanced net ionic equation for this first neutralization step.
Answer
. Reaction with one equivalent of hydroxide removes the first acidic proton (corresponding to ) to yield the dihydrogen phosphite ion .