Resources

In an analytical chemistry laboratory, a student standardizes a sodium hydroxide solution by determining the density of a high-purity primary standard aqueous sodium chloride solution. A calibrated 25.00 mL25.00\text{ mL} volumetric transfer pipet delivers an aliquot of the NaCl\text{NaCl} solution into a tared weighing bottle. The tare mass of the empty bottle is 32.415 g32.415\text{ g}, and the gross mass of the bottle with solution is 58.192 g58.192\text{ g}. (a) Calculate the experimental density of the solution in g/mL\text{g/mL}. (b) If the official CRC Handbook accepted density for this exact mass fraction of NaCl\text{NaCl} at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} is 1.0345 g/mL1.0345\text{ g/mL}, calculate the percent error to four significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL}; (b) −0.3383%-0.3383\%

Steps

Part (a): Experimental Density Calculation

  1. Determine the mass of the delivered solution: The mass of the liquid sample is found by subtracting the tare mass of the empty weighing bottle from the gross mass (bottle plus solution): Mass of solution (m)=mgross−mtare\text{Mass of solution } (m) = m_{\text{gross}} - m_{\text{tare}} m=58.192 g−32.415 g=25.777 gm = 58.192\text{ g} - 32.415\text{ g} = 25.777\text{ g} Both measurements are precise to the thousandths place (0.001 g0.001\text{ g}), so the difference retains five significant figures.
  2. Calculate the experimental density: Density (ρ\rho) is mass per unit volume: ρexp=mV\rho_{\text{exp}} = \frac{m}{V} Substitute the calculated mass and the delivered volume (25.00 mL25.00\text{ mL}): ρexp=25.777 g25.00 mL=1.03108 g/mL\rho_{\text{exp}} = \frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 1.03108\text{ g/mL}
  3. Apply significant figure rules: The volume measurement (25.00 mL25.00\text{ mL}) contains four significant figures, which limits the final quotient to four significant figures: ρexp=1.031 g/mL\rho_{\text{exp}} = 1.031\text{ g/mL}

Part (b): Percent Error Calculation

  1. State the percent error formula: Percent error quantifies the deviation of an experimental result from an accepted literature value: Percent Error=Experimental Value−Accepted ValueAccepted Value×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{\text{Experimental Value} - \text{Accepted Value}}{\text{Accepted Value}} \times 100\%
  2. Substitute the values: Using the experimental density of 1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL} and the accepted value of 1.0345 g/mL1.0345\text{ g/mL}: Percent Error=1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% Percent Error=−0.0035 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.338327…%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{-0.0035\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.338327\dots\%
  3. Round to four significant figures: Expressed to four significant figures as specified: Percent Error=−0.3383%\text{Percent Error} = -0.3383\%

(Note: The negative sign indicates that the experimentally measured density is lower than the accepted literature value).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the gross mass of the weighing bottle and solution instead of subtracting the tare mass to find the net solution mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Density=58.192 g25.00 mL=2.328 g/mL\text{Density} = \frac{58.192\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 2.328\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    m=58.192 g−32.415 g=25.777 g  ⟹  ρ=25.777 g25.00 mL=1.031 g/mLm = 58.192\text{ g} - 32.415\text{ g} = 25.777\text{ g} \implies \rho = \frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 1.031\text{ g/mL}

    You divided the gross mass (58.192 g58.192\text{ g}) by the volume without subtracting the tare mass of the empty weighing bottle (32.415 g32.415\text{ g}). Density requires the net mass of the liquid sample alone.

  2. Step 2

    Percent error=2.328−1.03451.0345×100%=125.0%\text{Percent error} = \frac{2.328 - 1.0345}{1.0345} \times 100\% = 125.0\%

    Correct

    Percent Error=1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.3383%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.3383\%

    You correctly applied the percent error formula experimental−acceptedaccepted×100%\frac{\text{experimental} - \text{accepted}}{\text{accepted}} \times 100\%, but your result was affected by the incorrect density value carried over from part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the definition of density as mass divided by volume.

You correctly set up and evaluated the percent error equation using your experimental value.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Gross vs. Net Mass (Omission of Tare Subtraction)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated gross mass (container plus contents) with net mass (contents only) when calculating density from gravimetric measurements.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Tare vs. Gross Mass
  • Mass of liquid=Mass of bottle and liquid (gross)−Mass of empty bottle (tare)\text{Mass of liquid} = \text{Mass of bottle and liquid (gross)} - \text{Mass of empty bottle (tare)}

  • Always verify whether a given mass measurement includes the container before using it in density calculations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the net mass of the delivered NaCl\text{NaCl} solution: m=58.192 g−32.415 g=25.777 gm = 58.192\text{ g} - 32.415\text{ g} = 25.777\text{ g}.

  2. Calculate the experimental density: ρexp=25.777 g25.00 mL=1.03108 g/mL≈1.031 g/mL\rho_{\text{exp}} = \frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 1.03108\text{ g/mL} \approx 1.031\text{ g/mL}.

  3. Substitute the corrected density into the percent error equation: Percent Error=1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.3383%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.3383\%.

Final answer

(a) 1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL}; (b) −0.3383%-0.3383\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before calculating density, write down an explicit subtraction step for net mass whenever a container or weighing vessel is mentioned.

  • Check whether your calculated density is chemically reasonable; an aqueous salt solution should have a density near 1.0 g/mL1.0\text{ g/mL}, whereas 2.3 g/mL2.3\text{ g/mL} is an immediate signal that container mass was included.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides by the experimental value instead of the accepted true value in the percent error denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Mass=58.192 g−32.415 g=25.777 g\text{Mass} = 58.192\text{ g} - 32.415\text{ g} = 25.777\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    Density=25.777 g/25.00 mL=1.031 g/mL\text{Density} = 25.777\text{ g} / 25.00\text{ mL} = 1.031\text{ g/mL}

  3. Step 3

    Percent error=(1.0311−1.0345)/1.0311∗100%=−0.3297%\text{Percent error} = (1.0311 - 1.0345) / 1.0311 * 100\% = -0.3297\%

    Correct

    Percent error=1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.3383%\text{Percent error} = \frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.3383\%

    You divided by the experimental density (1.0311 g/mL1.0311\text{ g/mL}) instead of the accepted reference value (1.0345 g/mL1.0345\text{ g/mL}). The accepted value represents the standard base of comparison and must always serve as the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the net mass of the delivered aliquot by tare subtraction.

You applied the density formula ρ=mV\rho = \frac{m}{V} properly and maintained four significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong denominator in percent error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated your measured value as the benchmark reference rather than anchoring the relative error against the accepted true value in the denominator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Base in Percent Error
  • Percent Error=Experimental−AcceptedAccepted×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{\text{Experimental} - \text{Accepted}}{\text{Accepted}} \times 100\%

  • Always place the true, literature, or accepted standard value in the denominator when calculating relative or percent error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the accepted literature density: ρaccepted=1.0345 g/mL\rho_{\text{accepted}} = 1.0345\text{ g/mL}.

  2. Substitute your experimental density (1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL}) and the accepted value into the standard formula: 1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%\frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\%.

  3. Compute the numerator: 1.031−1.0345=−0.0035 g/mL1.031 - 1.0345 = -0.0035\text{ g/mL}.

  4. Divide by 1.0345 g/mL1.0345\text{ g/mL} and multiply by 100%100\%: −0.00351.0345×100%=−0.338327…%\frac{-0.0035}{1.0345} \times 100\% = -0.338327\dots\%.

  5. Round to four significant figures as requested: −0.3383%-0.3383\%.

Final answer

(a) 1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL}; (b) −0.3383%-0.3383\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the mnemonic: error is relative to the truth, so the true/accepted value anchors the denominator.

  • Double-check whether your percent error formula asks for signed error or absolute percent error; here, keep the sign to indicate if your result is higher or lower than the accepted value.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the volume from the net mass rather than dividing mass by volume to compute density.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mass=58.192 g−32.415 g=25.777 g\text{Mass} = 58.192\text{ g} - 32.415\text{ g} = 25.777\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    Density=25.777−25.00=0.7770 g/mL\text{Density} = 25.777 - 25.00 = 0.7770\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    ρ=mV=25.777 g25.00 mL=1.031 g/mL\rho = \frac{m}{V} = \frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 1.031\text{ g/mL}

    Density is a ratio defined as mass divided by volume (ρ=mV\rho = \frac{m}{V}), not mass minus volume. Subtracting two quantities with different physical dimensions (g\text{g} and mL\text{mL}) is dimensionally invalid.

  3. Step 3

    Percent error=(0.7770−1.0345)1.0345×100%=−24.89%\text{Percent error} = \frac{(0.7770 - 1.0345)}{1.0345} \times 100\% = -24.89\%

    Correct

    Percent error=1.031 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.3383%\text{Percent error} = \frac{1.031\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.3383\%

    You applied the standard percent error formula correctly, but your result was thrown off because you used the incorrect density from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the mass of the liquid aliquot using tare subtraction.

You correctly recalled and structured the formula for percent error as Experimental−AcceptedAccepted×100%\frac{\text{Experimental} - \text{Accepted}}{\text{Accepted}} \times 100\%.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula/definition confusion

You used subtraction instead of division when computing density from mass and volume.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing ratio-based physical properties with difference operations, leading to dimensional inconsistency between mass (grams) and volume (milliliters).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Consistency Check
  • You can only add or subtract quantities that have identical units; to relate quantities with different units like g\text{g} and mL\text{mL}, use multiplication or division.

  • Always write out your units explicitly during calculation: 25.777 g25.00 mL\frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} yields g/mL\text{g/mL}, whereas 25.777 g−25.00 mL25.777\text{ g} - 25.00\text{ mL} is not physically meaningful.

Definition of Density
  • Density represents mass per unit volume: ρ=mV\rho = \frac{m}{V}.

  • Whenever you calculate density, set it up as a fraction with mass in the numerator and volume in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ρ=25.777 g25.00 mL=1.03108… g/mL≈1.031 g/mL\rho = \frac{25.777\text{ g}}{25.00\text{ mL}} = 1.03108\dots\text{ g/mL} \approx 1.031\text{ g/mL}

  2. Percent Error=1.03108 g/mL−1.0345 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{1.03108\text{ g/mL} - 1.0345\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\%

  3. Percent Error=−0.00342 g/mL1.0345 g/mL×100%=−0.3383%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{-0.00342\text{ g/mL}}{1.0345\text{ g/mL}} \times 100\% = -0.3383\%

Final answer

(a) 1.031 g/mL1.031\text{ g/mL}; (b) −0.3383%-0.3383\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Include units in every algebraic step so that unit cancellation confirms whether an operation should be division or subtraction.

  • Review the fundamental definitions of intensive properties (density, concentration, molar mass) as ratios rather than differences.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A student determines the density of an unknown organic liquid. An empty graduated cylinder has a mass of 42.810 g42.810\text{ g}. When filled with 15.00 mL15.00\text{ mL} of the liquid, the total mass is 54.635 g54.635\text{ g}. Calculate the density of the liquid to four significant figures.

Answer

0.7883 g/mL0.7883\text{ g/mL}. First find the net mass: m=54.635 g−42.810 g=11.825 gm = 54.635\text{ g} - 42.810\text{ g} = 11.825\text{ g}. Then divide by volume: ρ=11.825 g15.00 mL=0.78833… g/mL\rho = \frac{11.825\text{ g}}{15.00\text{ mL}} = 0.78833\dots\text{ g/mL}, which rounds to 0.7883 g/mL0.7883\text{ g/mL}.

02

A 50.00 mL50.00\text{ mL} volumetric flask has a tare mass of 38.254 g38.254\text{ g}. Filled with sucrose solution, its gross mass is 92.414 g92.414\text{ g}. (a) Calculate the experimental density. (b) If the accepted density is 1.0810 g/mL1.0810\text{ g/mL}, determine the percent error to four significant figures.

Answer

(a) 1.083 g/mL1.083\text{ g/mL}; (b) +0.2035%+0.2035\%. Net mass is 92.414 g−38.254 g=54.160 g92.414\text{ g} - 38.254\text{ g} = 54.160\text{ g}. Density is ρ=54.160 g50.00 mL=1.0832 g/mL≈1.083 g/mL\rho = \frac{54.160\text{ g}}{50.00\text{ mL}} = 1.0832\text{ g/mL} \approx 1.083\text{ g/mL}. Percent error is 1.0832−1.08101.0810×100%=+0.2035%\frac{1.0832 - 1.0810}{1.0810} \times 100\% = +0.2035\%.

03

In a pycnometer experiment, an empty pycnometer weighs 21.340 g21.340\text{ g}. When filled with water (density 0.9982 g/mL0.9982\text{ g/mL}), it weighs 46.295 g46.295\text{ g}. When emptied, dried, and filled with an unknown oil, it weighs 42.750 g42.750\text{ g}. Calculate the density of the unknown oil to four significant figures.

Answer

0.8580 g/mL0.8580\text{ g/mL}. Water mass is 46.295−21.340=24.955 g46.295 - 21.340 = 24.955\text{ g}. Pycnometer volume is V=24.955 g0.9982 g/mL=25.000 mLV = \frac{24.955\text{ g}}{0.9982\text{ g/mL}} = 25.000\text{ mL}. Oil net mass is 42.750−21.340=21.410 g42.750 - 21.340 = 21.410\text{ g}. Oil density is ρ=21.410 g25.000 mL=0.8564 g/mL\rho = \frac{21.410\text{ g}}{25.000\text{ mL}} = 0.8564\text{ g/mL} (using intermediate unrounded volume 25.0000 mL25.0000\text{ mL}, ρ=21.41024.955/0.9982=0.85637≈0.8564 g/mL\rho = \frac{21.410}{24.955/0.9982} = 0.85637 \approx 0.8564\text{ g/mL}).

Loading workspace…