Resources

An analytical chemist is tasked with establishing the phase boundary of a liquid-liquid mixture. At 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}, the mutual solubility limit of diethyl ether in water is 6.04 g6.04\text{ g} per 100 g100\text{ g} of water. If a student adds x gramsx\text{ grams} of diethyl ether to an Erlenmeyer flask containing exactly 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of pure water at 20∘C20^\circ\text{C} and stirs thoroughly, determine the maximum mass xx (in g\text{g}) of diethyl ether that can be dissolved such that the system remains a strictly single-phase homogeneous mixture rather than forming a heterogeneous two-phase system.

Answer and steps

Final answer

x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

Steps

Understanding Phase Boundaries in Liquid-Liquid Mixtures

A homogeneous mixture consists of a single phase with uniform composition and properties throughout. When a liquid solute dissolves completely in a liquid solvent, the molecules intermix completely at the molecular level, forming a single continuous liquid layer.

However, if the amount of added liquid exceeds its solubility limit (saturation point) at that temperature, the excess liquid cannot dissolve. Instead, the liquids separate into two distinct, immiscible or partially miscible liquid layers separated by a visible boundary (meniscus), creating a heterogeneous mixture.

Therefore, the maximum amount of diethyl ether that can be added while keeping the mixture strictly single-phase corresponds to the exact saturation mass in the given amount of water.


Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Identify the given solubility ratio: At 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}, the solubility of diethyl ether in water is: Solubility=6.04 g diethyl ether100 g water\text{Solubility} = \frac{6.04\text{ g diethyl ether}}{100\text{ g water}}
  2. Set up the proportion for the given solvent mass: For 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of pure water, let xx be the maximum mass of diethyl ether that can dissolve completely: x250.0 g water=6.04 g diethyl ether100 g water\frac{x}{250.0\text{ g water}} = \frac{6.04\text{ g diethyl ether}}{100\text{ g water}}
  3. Solve for xx: x=250.0 g water×6.04 g diethyl ether100 g waterx = 250.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{6.04\text{ g diethyl ether}}{100\text{ g water}} x=2.500⋅6.04 g=15.1 gx = 2.500 \cdot 6.04\text{ g} = 15.1\text{ g}

Common Pitfall to Avoid

  • Exceeding the saturation limit: Adding any amount greater than 15.1 g15.1\text{ g} (such as 15.2 g15.2\text{ g}) does not increase the concentration in the aqueous phase; instead, the excess ether separates and floats to the top due to its lower density, forming a heterogeneous two-phase system.

The maximum mass of diethyl ether that maintains a single homogeneous phase is x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the mass of solvent with the total mass of the solution, dividing by 100 g of solution instead of establishing the ratio per mass of water plus solute, or applying an inverted ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Solubility ratio=100 g water6.04 g ether\text{Solubility ratio} = \frac{100\text{ g water}}{6.04\text{ g ether}}

    Correct

    Solubility ratio=6.04 g ether100 g water\text{Solubility ratio} = \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}

    You inverted the solubility ratio by placing the solvent mass in the numerator and the solute mass in the denominator. To determine the dissolved mass of diethyl ether from a given mass of water, the conversion factor must have grams of diethyl ether in the numerator and grams of water in the denominator so that the water units cancel.

  2. Step 2

    x=250.0(100/6.04)  ⟹  x=250.0×(1006.04)x = \frac{250.0}{(100/6.04)} \implies x = 250.0 \times \left(\frac{100}{6.04}\right)

    Correct

    x=250.0 g water×6.04 g ether100 g waterx = 250.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}

    You multiplied the mass of water by the inverted ratio 1006.04\frac{100}{6.04}. Setting up dimensional analysis with units shows that this produces g2 water/g ether\text{g}^2\text{ water}/\text{g ether} rather than grams of ether.

  3. Step 3

    x=4139 gx = 4139\text{ g}

    Correct

    x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

    This value follows directly from the inverted calculation. A mass of 4139 g4139\text{ g} of ether in 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of water is physically impossible for a sparingly soluble liquid and would result in an extensive two-phase heterogeneous mixture.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two numerical values (6.04 g6.04\text{ g} and 100 g100\text{ g}) that define the mutual solubility limit at 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}.

You recognized that the maximum dissolved solute mass is directly proportional to the total mass of water present (250.0 g250.0\text{ g}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Conversion Factor in Dimensional Analysis

No, this was a conceptual setup error rather than a simple arithmetic slip because the unit conversion factor was inverted from the start.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You did not track the units during dimensional analysis, causing you to multiply by mass of solventmass of solute\frac{\text{mass of solvent}}{\text{mass of solute}} rather than mass of solutemass of solvent\frac{\text{mass of solute}}{\text{mass of solvent}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Cancellation Check
  • Always write out explicit units for both numerator and denominator in every conversion factor: given unit×desired unitgiven unit=desired unit\text{given unit} \times \frac{\text{desired unit}}{\text{given unit}} = \text{desired unit}.

  • Check that 'g water\text{g water}' cancels out, leaving only 'g ether\text{g ether}' in the numerator.

Physical Sanity Check
  • In a sparingly soluble liquid-liquid mixture, the dissolved solute mass must be much smaller than the solvent mass.

  • Compare 4139 g4139\text{ g} to 250.0 g250.0\text{ g}; dissolving over 4 kg4\text{ kg} of solute in a single cup of water indicates an inverted factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct proportionality with solute in the numerator: x250.0 g water=6.04 g ether100 g water\frac{x}{250.0\text{ g water}} = \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}.

  2. Multiply both sides by 250.0 g water250.0\text{ g water}: x=250.0 g water×6.04 g ether100 g waterx = 250.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}.

  3. Calculate the product: x=2.500×6.04 g=15.1 gx = 2.500 \times 6.04\text{ g} = 15.1\text{ g}.

Final answer

x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write complete unit labels (e.g., 'g ether\text{g ether}' vs. 'g water\text{g water}') inside fractions rather than bare numbers.

  • Perform a quick physical reality check whenever the calculated solute mass vastly exceeds the solvent mass for a partially miscible system.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats the solubility limit of 6.04 g per 100 g as a mass percent of 6.04% of the total solution rather than per mass of solvent, setting x / (250.0 + x) = 0.0604 and solving for x = 16.07 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mass percent of ether=6.04%  ⟹  x(250.0+x)=0.0604\text{Mass percent of ether} = 6.04\% \implies \frac{x}{(250.0 + x)} = 0.0604

    Correct

    x250.0 g water=6.04 g ether100 g water\frac{x}{250.0\text{ g water}} = \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}

    Solubility is reported as mass of solute per 100 g100\text{ g} of pure solvent (water), not per 100 g100\text{ g} of total solution. The denominator must be the mass of water alone (250.0 g250.0\text{ g}), not total solution mass (250.0+x250.0 + x).

  2. Step 2

    x=0.0604×(250.0+x)  ⟹  x=15.1+0.0604x  ⟹  0.9396x=15.1x = 0.0604 \times (250.0 + x) \implies x = 15.1 + 0.0604x \implies 0.9396x = 15.1

    Correct

    x=250.0 g water×6.04 g ether100 g waterx = 250.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100\text{ g water}}

    Your algebraic isolation of xx was mathematically sound, but it operated on the incorrect initial formula.

  3. Step 3

    x=16.1 gx = 16.1\text{ g}

    Correct

    x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

    Because the initial equation treated solubility as mass percent of total solution, the calculated mass is slightly overestimated.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that maintaining a single phase requires finding the exact maximum dissolved mass at saturation.

You accurately manipulated the linear equation algebraically to solve for the unknown variable xx.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Solute-solvent ratio confused with mass percent

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated solubility (mass of solute per mass of solvent, msolutemsolvent\frac{m_{\text{solute}}}{m_{\text{solvent}}}) with mass fraction/percentage (mass of solute per total mass of solution, msolutemsolute+msolvent\frac{m_{\text{solute}}}{m_{\text{solute}} + m_{\text{solvent}}}). When a problem states '6.04 g6.04\text{ g} per 100 g100\text{ g} of water', the denominator is pure water alone, not total solution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator Check: Solvent vs. Solution
  • Solubility expressed as 'g/100 g H2O\text{g}/100\text{ g }\text{H}_2\text{O}' compares solute to pure solvent, whereas mass percent compares solute to total solution (solute + solvent).

  • Always verify whether the given ratio specifies 'per 100 g100\text{ g} of solvent' or 'percent by mass of solution' before forming an equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the direct proportion based on the definition of solubility: x250.0 g water=6.04 g ether100.0 g water\frac{x}{250.0\text{ g water}} = \frac{6.04\text{ g ether}}{100.0\text{ g water}}.

  2. Multiply both sides by 250.0 g water250.0\text{ g water}: x=250.0×6.04100.0x = 250.0 \times \frac{6.04}{100.0}.

  3. Calculate the product: x=2.500×6.04 g=15.1 gx = 2.500 \times 6.04\text{ g} = 15.1\text{ g}.

Final answer

x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between solubility ratios (solute/solvent) and mass fractions (solute/solution).

  • Check units explicitly during setup: write 'g solute/g solvent\text{g solute} / \text{g solvent}' to prevent inserting total solution in the denominator.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the scaling factor between 250.0 g and 100 g of water, dividing 250.0 by 100 incorrectly as 2.0 instead of 2.5.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Scaling factor=250.0/100=2.0\text{Scaling factor} = 250.0 / 100 = 2.0

    Correct

    Scaling factor=250.0 g100 g=2.500\text{Scaling factor} = \frac{250.0\text{ g}}{100\text{ g}} = 2.500

    You divided 250.0250.0 by 100100 and truncated or rounded the result to 2.02.0 instead of keeping the exact decimal value 2.52.5.

  2. Step 2

    x = 6.04 ×\times 2.0   ⟹  \implies x = 12.08 g\text{ g}

    Correct

    x = 6.04 g\text{ g} ×\times 2.500 = 15.1 g\text{ g}

    Your multiplication followed logically from your scaling factor of 2.02.0, but because the scaling factor was incorrect, the calculated mass of dissolved ether is too low.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the maximum amount of solute for a single-phase homogeneous mixture corresponds to its saturation solubility.

You correctly set up a proportional scaling relationship based on the mass ratio of water.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arithmetic scaling error

You wrote 250.0/100=2.0250.0 / 100 = 2.0 instead of 2.52.5.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You prematurely rounded or dropped the fractional remainder when dividing 250.0250.0 by 100100, treating 250/100250 / 100 as an integer division rather than evaluating the exact decimal quotient.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Decimal division precision
  • Dividing by powers of 1010 shifts the decimal point without truncating non-zero digits: 250.0100=2.500\frac{250.0}{100} = 2.500.

  • Shift the decimal point two places to the left and retain all significant figures rather than rounding to the nearest integer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the base solubility by the corrected scaling factor: x=6.04 g×2.500x = 6.04\text{ g} \times 2.500.

  2. Evaluate the product: x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}.

Final answer

x=15.1 gx = 15.1\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check divisions involving powers of 1010 by shifting the decimal point directly.

  • Keep exact fractional or decimal multipliers before rounding, reserving significant-figure rounding for the final reported value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

At 25∘C25^\circ\text{C}, the solubility of 1-butanol in water is 7.3 g7.3\text{ g} per 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of water. What is the maximum mass (in g\text{g}) of 1-butanol that can dissolve in 450.0 g450.0\text{ g} of water to maintain a single-phase homogeneous mixture?

Answer

x=450.0 g water×7.3 g 1-butanol100.0 g water=4.500×7.3 g=32.85 g≈33 gx = 450.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{7.3\text{ g 1-butanol}}{100.0\text{ g water}} = 4.500 \times 7.3\text{ g} = 32.85\text{ g} \approx 33\text{ g} (or 32.9 g32.9\text{ g}).

02

A solution is prepared by adding 28.0 g28.0\text{ g} of an organic ester to 400.0 g400.0\text{ g} of water at 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}. The solubility limit of this ester in water is 6.50 g6.50\text{ g} per 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of water. Determine whether the resulting mixture is homogeneous or heterogeneous, and find the mass of undissolved ester that forms a separate layer.

Answer

Maximum soluble mass: 400.0 g water×6.50 g ester100.0 g water=26.0 g400.0\text{ g water} \times \frac{6.50\text{ g ester}}{100.0\text{ g water}} = 26.0\text{ g}. Because the added mass (28.0 g28.0\text{ g}) exceeds 26.0 g26.0\text{ g}, the system is heterogeneous (two phases). Undissolved ester mass =28.0 g−26.0 g=2.0 g= 28.0\text{ g} - 26.0\text{ g} = 2.0\text{ g}.

03

At 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}, ethyl acetate has a solubility of 8.3 g8.3\text{ g} per 100 g100\text{ g} of water. What minimum mass of water (in g\text{g}) is required to completely dissolve 24.9 g24.9\text{ g} of ethyl acetate so that no second phase appears?

Answer

Here the unknown is solvent mass, so invert the factor to cancel grams of solute: mass of water=24.9 g ethyl acetate×100 g water8.3 g ethyl acetate=3.0×100 g=300 g water\text{mass of water} = 24.9\text{ g ethyl acetate} \times \frac{100\text{ g water}}{8.3\text{ g ethyl acetate}} = 3.0 \times 100\text{ g} = 300\text{ g water}.

Loading workspace…