Resources
Students frequently classify trimethylamine, , as capable of hydrogen bonding because it contains nitrogen and multiple hydrogen atoms. State whether pure liquid trimethylamine exhibits intermolecular hydrogen bonding, contrast this with its constitutional isomer propylamine, , and explain the essential structural convention that governs whether an amine can engage in self-association via hydrogen bonding.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Pure liquid trimethylamine does not exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding; it exhibits only dipole-dipole interactions and London dispersion forces. Propylamine exhibits hydrogen bonding in addition to dipole-dipole and dispersion forces. The governing structural convention is that self-associated hydrogen bonding requires both a hydrogen-bond donor (a hydrogen atom covalently bonded directly to , , or ) and a hydrogen-bond acceptor (an electronegative atom with an unshared lone pair); trimethylamine is a tertiary amine with three bonds and zero bonds, providing only acceptor capacity and zero donor capacity in a pure substance.
Steps
Requirements for Intermolecular Hydrogen Bonding
For molecules in a pure liquid to engage in self-association via hydrogen bonding, two structural components must be present simultaneously within the same species:
- Hydrogen-Bond Donor: A hydrogen atom covalently bonded directly to a strongly electronegative atom (, , or ). The large electronegativity difference polarizes the bond, giving the hydrogen atom a substantial partial positive charge () and leaving its nucleus relatively unshielded.
- Hydrogen-Bond Acceptor: An electronegative atom (, , or ) with at least one non-bonding lone pair of electrons bearing a partial negative charge ().
Analysis of Pure Trimethylamine,
- Structure: Trimethylamine is a tertiary () amine. The central nitrogen atom is bonded to three methyl groups () and possesses one lone pair:
- Donor Capacity: All nine hydrogen atoms are covalently bonded to carbon atoms ( bonds). Because carbon and hydrogen have very similar electronegativities ( vs. ), bonds are essentially nonpolar and cannot act as hydrogen-bond donors. There are zero bonds.
- Acceptor Capacity: The nitrogen atom possesses a lone pair, making it an effective hydrogen-bond acceptor.
- Conclusion for Pure Liquid: Because there are no hydrogen-bond donors present in the molecule, pure liquid trimethylamine cannot form intermolecular hydrogen bonds with itself. The predominant intermolecular forces holding pure trimethylamine molecules together are dipole-dipole attractions and London dispersion forces.
Comparison with Propylamine,
- Structure: Propylamine is a primary () amine and a constitutional isomer of trimethylamine (both have the molecular formula ).
- Donor and Acceptor Capacity: The nitrogen atom is bonded to an alkyl chain and two hydrogen atoms, giving two polarized bonds (donors) alongside its lone pair (acceptor).
- Intermolecular Forces: Because both donor () and acceptor () sites coexist in every molecule, pure propylamine molecules engage extensively in intermolecular hydrogen bonding, in addition to dipole-dipole interactions and London dispersion forces.
Common Pitfall: A molecule containing both nitrogen and hydrogen does not automatically exhibit hydrogen bonding in a pure sample. The hydrogen atoms must be bonded directly to the nitrogen atom (), not to an adjacent carbon atom. Tertiary amines can accept hydrogen bonds from protic solvents (like water), but they cannot form hydrogen bonds with one another.
Summary of Amine Self-Association Conventions
- Primary () Amines (): Contain two bonds and one lone pair act as both donor and acceptor exhibit hydrogen bonding.
- Secondary () Amines (): Contain one bond and one lone pair act as both donor and acceptor exhibit hydrogen bonding.
- Tertiary () Amines (): Contain zero bonds and one lone pair act only as an acceptor no hydrogen bonding in pure liquid.
Typical errors
01 A student believes that simply containing electronegative nitrogen and hydrogen atoms anywhere in the molecule is sufficient for intermolecular hydrogen bonding, incorrectly concluding that pure trimethylamine forms hydrogen bonds.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) Trimethylamine contains and .
- Step 2
b) Pure liquid trimethylamine exhibits intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
CorrectPure liquid trimethylamine does not exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding; its predominant intermolecular forces are dipole-dipole attractions and London dispersion forces.
Because all nine hydrogen atoms are covalently bonded to carbon rather than nitrogen, there are no hydrogen-bond donor groups available to form hydrogen bonds between trimethylamine molecules.
- Step 3
c) Both trimethylamine and propylamine exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding because both contain nitrogen and hydrogen.
CorrectPropylamine () exhibits intermolecular hydrogen bonding because it possesses two bonds, whereas trimethylamine does not exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Merely having nitrogen and hydrogen atoms in the same molecular formula is not sufficient; propylamine has two direct bonds acting as donors, whereas trimethylamine has zero.
- Step 4
d) An amine can self-associate via hydrogen bonding as long as it has a nitrogen atom with a lone pair and hydrogen atoms present in the molecule.
CorrectAn amine can self-associate via hydrogen bonding only if it possesses both a hydrogen-bond acceptor (a nitrogen atom with a lone pair) and at least one hydrogen-bond donor (a hydrogen atom bonded directly to nitrogen, as in primary and secondary amines).
Self-association requires a direct covalent bond within the molecule; hydrogen atoms attached to carbon () are not sufficiently polarized to participate as hydrogen-bond donors.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that trimethylamine contains one nitrogen atom and nine hydrogen atoms.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that containing both an electronegative atom () and hydrogen atoms anywhere in a molecular formula satisfies the requirement for intermolecular hydrogen bonding, overlooking that a hydrogen atom must be covalently bonded directly to , , or to act as a hydrogen-bond donor.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Donor Requirement
A hydrogen-bond donor requires a hydrogen atom directly bonded to , , or .
Inspect the structural formula to confirm whether any atom is bonded directly to the electronegative heteroatom.
- Pure Substance Self-Association
For a pure liquid to self-associate via hydrogen bonding, each molecule must contain both an active donor (, , ) and an acceptor lone pair.
Classify the amine as primary (, two ), secondary (, one ), or tertiary (, zero ). Only and amines self-associate.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the Lewis structure of trimethylamine: nitrogen is bonded to three methyl groups, forming three bonds and zero bonds.
Recognize that all hydrogen atoms belong to nonpolar bonds, which lack the partial positive charge () needed to act as hydrogen-bond donors.
Identify the intermolecular forces in pure liquid trimethylamine as dipole-dipole attractions (from its trigonal pyramidal dipole) and London dispersion forces.
Contrast this with propylamine, which contains a primary amine group () with two polar bonds, enabling extensive intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Pure liquid trimethylamine does not exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding; it exhibits only dipole-dipole interactions and London dispersion forces. Propylamine exhibits hydrogen bonding in addition to dipole-dipole and dispersion forces. The governing structural convention is that self-association requires both a hydrogen-bond donor () and an acceptor (); tertiary amines like trimethylamine lack bonds and can only act as acceptors.
02 A student confuses the requirement of an N-H bond donor for self-association with the presence of a lone pair acceptor, concluding that having a lone pair on nitrogen is the sole requirement for self-association.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Pure liquid trimethylamine does not exhibit intermolecular hydrogen bonding. ⟹ Propylamine has intermolecular hydrogen bonding, while trimethylamine does not.
- Step 2
The nitrogen atom has a lone pair in the hybrid orbital. ⟹ An amine can engage in self-association via hydrogen bonding simply if the nitrogen has an available lone pair to accept a hydrogen bond.
CorrectFor an amine to engage in self-association via hydrogen bonding, each molecule must possess both an bond (hydrogen-bond donor) and an unshared lone pair on nitrogen (hydrogen-bond acceptor).
You stated that having a lone pair to accept a hydrogen bond is sufficient for self-association. In a pure substance, molecules must act as both donors and acceptors; because trimethylamine lacks any bonds, it has no hydrogen atoms capable of donating into a hydrogen bond.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that pure liquid trimethylamine cannot form intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
You correctly contrasted trimethylamine with its primary amine isomer, propylamine.
You recognized that the nitrogen atom contains a lone pair.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the presence of an electron lone pair (acceptor ability) as the sole requirement for hydrogen bonding, overlooking that pure-substance self-association requires an internal donor (a hydrogen atom directly bonded to , , or ) to interact with that lone pair.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Donor vs. Acceptor Requirement
Self-association via hydrogen bonding in a pure substance requires each molecule to contain both a donor ( directly bonded to , , or ) and an acceptor (a lone pair on an electronegative atom).
Always check for at least one bond when determining if a pure amine can hydrogen-bond with itself.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the hydrogen-bonding components: a hydrogen-bond donor requires an atom covalently bonded to , , or , while an acceptor requires a lone pair on an electronegative atom.
Evaluate pure trimethylamine, : it has a nitrogen lone pair (acceptor) but only bonds and zero bonds (no donor).
State the general convention: tertiary () amines cannot self-associate because they lack an donor, whereas primary () and secondary () amines possess bonds and thus self-associate readily.
Pure liquid trimethylamine cannot engage in self-association via hydrogen bonding because it lacks bonds (donors); self-association requires both a hydrogen-bond donor () and an acceptor (lone pair on ) within the same molecule.
Lock it in
What two structural components must a molecule possess to engage in self-associated hydrogen bonding in a pure liquid?
A hydrogen-bond donor (a hydrogen atom bonded directly to , , or ) and a hydrogen-bond acceptor (an unshared lone pair on an electronegative atom).
Similar question
Determine whether pure liquid diethyl ether, , exhibits intermolecular hydrogen bonding, and state its primary intermolecular forces.
Answer
No intermolecular hydrogen bonding. Diethyl ether has an oxygen atom with lone pairs (acceptor) but lacks an bond (no donor). Its predominant intermolecular forces are dipole-dipole attractions and London dispersion forces.
Rank the following constitutional isomers of molecular formula in order of increasing boiling point, and justify your ranking based on their ability to self-associate via hydrogen bonding: trimethylamine (), ethylmethylamine (), and propylamine ().
Answer
Trimethylamine < Ethylmethylamine < Propylamine. Trimethylamine () has zero bonds and cannot form hydrogen bonds in a pure liquid (lowest boiling point, ). Ethylmethylamine () has one bond and forms hydrogen bonds (intermediate boiling point, ). Propylamine () has two bonds, allowing a more extensive hydrogen-bonding network (highest boiling point, ).
A mixture contains trimethylamine, , dissolved in liquid methanol, . Identify all types of intermolecular forces that occur specifically between a trimethylamine molecule and a methanol molecule, clearly designating donor and acceptor roles.
Answer
Hydrogen bonding, dipole-dipole interactions, and London dispersion forces occur between the two species. Methanol acts as the hydrogen-bond donor through its strongly polarized group (), while trimethylamine acts as the hydrogen-bond acceptor through the non-bonding electron lone pair on its nitrogen atom ().