Resources

Consider the positron emission (β+\beta^+ decay) of carbon-11: 611C→ZAX++10β+νe{}^{11}_{6}\text{C} \rightarrow {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X} + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta + \nu_e Applying the strict nuclear charge conservation convention ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}}, calculate the atomic number ZZ and mass number AA of the daughter nuclide X\text{X}, avoiding the sign confusion between positron charge (+1+1) and beta-minus charge (−1-1).

Answer and steps

Final answer

A=11A = 11, Z=5Z = 5, daughter nuclide is boron-11 (511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

Steps

01

Determine the Mass Number (AA)

To balance a nuclear equation, two fundamental conservation laws must be satisfied:

  1. Conservation of Mass Number (AA): The total number of nucleons (protons and neutrons) before the decay must equal the total number of nucleons after the decay: ∑Areactants=∑Aproducts\sum A_{\text{reactants}} = \sum A_{\text{products}}
  2. Conservation of Nuclear Charge (ZZ): The total nuclear charge (atomic numbers and particle charges) before the decay must equal the total nuclear charge after the decay: ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}}

The reactant is carbon-11, and the products are nuclide X\text{X}, a positron (+10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta), and an electron neutrino (νe\nu_e, which has no mass number or charge, i.e., 00νe{}^{0}_{0}\nu_e): 11=A+0+011 = A + 0 + 0 A=11A = 11

02

Determine the Atomic Number (ZZ)

Apply the conservation of charge: 6=Z+(+1)+06 = Z + (+1) + 0 Z=6−1=5Z = 6 - 1 = 5

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse positron emission (β+\beta^+ decay) with electron emission (β−\beta^- decay). A standard beta particle (β−\beta^-) has a charge of −1-1, which would cause the daughter's atomic number to increase (6−(−1)=76 - (-1) = 7). A positron (β+\beta^+) has a charge of +1+1, so the daughter's atomic number decreases by 11 (6−1=56 - 1 = 5).

03

Identify the Daughter Nuclide

Look up the element with atomic number Z=5Z = 5 on the periodic table:

  • Element 55 is boron (B\ce{B}).

Thus, the daughter nuclide is boron-11, written as 511B{}^{11}_{5}\ce{B}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses positron emission with beta-minus decay by using a charge of -1 for the emitted beta particle, incorrectly yielding Z = 7.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A=11−0=11A = 11 - 0 = 11

  2. Step 2

    6=Z−1  ⟹  Z=6+1=76 = Z - 1 \implies Z = 6 + 1 = 7

    Correct

    6=Z+(+1)  ⟹  Z=6−1=56 = Z + (+1) \implies Z = 6 - 1 = 5

    A positron (+10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta) carries a nuclear charge of +1+1, not −1-1. Setting up the conservation of charge gives 6=Z+16 = Z + 1, so Z=6−1=5Z = 6 - 1 = 5.

  3. Step 3

    A=11,Z=7A = 11, Z = 7

    Correct

    A=11,Z=5A = 11, Z = 5

    Your final atomic number is incorrect due to the sign error on the positron charge in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the conservation of nucleon number (AA) to find A=11A = 11.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Confusion in Beta Decay Particles

You assigned a charge of −1-1 to a positron (beta+\\beta^+), confusing it with an electron/beta-minus particle (beta−\\beta^-).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Positron emission involves the emission of a positively charged beta particle (+10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta), which decreases the daughter nucleus's atomic number by 1. Treating all beta radiation as having a −1-1 charge leads to adding rather than subtracting 1 from ZZ.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Particle Charge
  • Positron emission (beta+\\beta^+) emits +10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta (charge +1+1); electron emission (beta−\\beta^-) emits −10β{}^{0}_{-1}\beta (charge −1-1).

  • Check the superscript and subscript on the beta particle symbol before setting up the equation: ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}}.

Set Up Charge Conservation Explicitly
  • For parent nuclide Z1A1P→Z2A2D++10β{}^{A_1}_{Z_1}\text{P} \rightarrow {}^{A_2}_{Z_2}\text{D} + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta, charge conservation is Z1=Z2+(+1)Z_1 = Z_2 + (+1).

  • Solve for the daughter nuclide's atomic number: Z2=Z1−1Z_2 = Z_1 - 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the conservation of charge using the positron's charge of +1+1: 6=Z+1+06 = Z + 1 + 0.

  2. Subtract 11 from both sides to isolate ZZ: Z=6−1=5Z = 6 - 1 = 5.

  3. Combine the values: mass number A=11A = 11, atomic number Z=5Z = 5 (corresponding to boron-11, 511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B}).

Final answer

A=11A = 11, Z=5Z = 5 (daughter nuclide is boron-11, 511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between β+\beta^+ decay (proton converts to a neutron, emitting a +1+1 positron) and β−\beta^- decay (neutron converts to a proton, emitting a −1-1 electron).

  • Always write out the full nuclide symbol with both mass number and explicit sign on the charge, such as +10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta, to prevent algebraic sign errors.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student correctly identifies the positron charge as +1 but incorrectly adds it to the reactant charge instead of subtracting it when solving for Z, yielding Z = 7.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    11=A+0  ⟹  A=1111 = A + 0 \implies A = 11

  2. Step 2

    Z=6+1=7Z = 6 + 1 = 7

    Correct

    6=Z+1+0  ⟹  Z=6−1=56 = Z + 1 + 0 \implies Z = 6 - 1 = 5

    Nuclear charge conservation states that ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}}, which gives 6=Z+16 = Z + 1. Solving for ZZ requires subtracting 11 from 66, yielding Z=5Z = 5.

  3. Step 3

    A=11, Z=7A = 11,\, Z = 7

    Correct

    A=11, Z=5A = 11,\, Z = 5 (daughter nuclide is 511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

    Your final mass number is correct, but the atomic number is affected by the algebraic sign error in step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the emitted positron carries a mass number of 00.

You correctly balanced the total nucleon number across the reaction to find A=11A = 11.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nuclear charge balancing sign error

You set Z=6+1Z = 6 + 1 rather than solving the conservation equation 6=Z+16 = Z + 1.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the daughter charge as the sum of the parent and emitted particle charges, or applied the β−\beta^- decay trend (ZZ increases) to positron (β+\beta^+) decay, where a nuclear proton converts into a neutron and decreases ZZ by 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Set up the strict equality before isolating variables
  • Write ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}} explicitly before solving for the unknown.

  • Write Zparent=Zdaughter+ZparticleZ_{\text{parent}} = Z_{\text{daughter}} + Z_{\text{particle}}, then isolate Zdaughter=Zparent−ZparticleZ_{\text{daughter}} = Z_{\text{parent}} - Z_{\text{particle}}.

Physical sense check for $\beta^+$ decay
  • Positron emission converts a proton into a neutron (p→n+e++νep \rightarrow n + e^+ + \nu_e).

  • Verify that the atomic number ZZ decreases by 11 while the mass number AA stays unchanged.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the conservation of nuclear charge: ∑Zreactants=∑Zproducts\sum Z_{\text{reactants}} = \sum Z_{\text{products}}.

  2. Substitute the charges: 6=Z+(+1)+06 = Z + (+1) + 0.

  3. Subtract 11 from both sides to isolate ZZ: Z=6−1=5Z = 6 - 1 = 5.

Final answer

A=11A = 11, Z=5Z = 5, daughter nuclide is boron-11 (511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write the complete linear equality for atomic numbers with the arrow acting as an equals sign: Zleft=ZrightZ_{\text{left}} = Z_{\text{right}}.

  • Perform a quick nucleon identity check: in β+\beta^+ decay, losing positive charge from the nucleus must reduce ZZ.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mistakenly treats the positron as carrying a mass of 1, resulting in an incorrect mass number A = 10.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    11=A+1  ⟹  A=11−1=1011 = A + 1 \implies A = 11 - 1 = 10

    Correct

    11=A+0  ⟹  A=1111 = A + 0 \implies A = 11

    A positron (+10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta) is the antimatter counterpart of an electron; it has negligible nucleon mass and carries a mass number of 00, not 11. Setting the mass contribution of the positron to 11 incorrectly subtracted one nucleon from the daughter nuclide.

  2. Step 2

    6=Z+1  ⟹  Z=56 = Z + 1 \implies Z = 5

  3. Step 3

    A=10 , Z=5A = 10\text{ , } Z = 5

    Correct

    A=11 , Z=5A = 11\text{ , } Z = 5 (daughter nuclide 511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

    Your value for ZZ is correct, but your final answer includes the incorrect mass number propagated from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the conservation equation for nuclear charge (ZZ).

You accurately handled the +1+1 charge of the emitted positron to find Z=5Z = 5.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass number misassignment for beta particles

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the positron as carrying a mass number of 11, likely confusing its +1+1 charge with the mass number of a proton or neutron. Electrons and positrons always have a mass number (AA) of 00 in nuclear notation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclide and Particle Notation Check
  • In standard nuclear notation ZAX{}^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the superscript AA is the total mass number (nucleons: protons + neutrons) and the subscript ZZ is the nuclear charge.

  • Always verify that positrons (+10β{}^{0}_{+1}\beta or +10e{}^{0}_{+1}\text{e}) and beta particles (−10β{}^{0}_{-1}\beta or −10e{}^{0}_{-1}\text{e}) have a superscript of 00.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply conservation of mass number using A=0A = 0 for the positron: 11=A+0+011 = A + 0 + 0.

  2. Solve for AA: A=11A = 11.

  3. Combine with your correct atomic number Z=5Z = 5 to identify element 55 as boron (511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B}).

Final answer

A=11A = 11, Z=5Z = 5 (daughter nuclide is 511B{}^{11}_{5}\text{B})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the isotopic symbols for common nuclear particles (alpha, beta-minus, beta-plus/positron, neutron, proton).

  • Practice balancing equations where beta particles or positrons are emitted to reinforce that AA does not change during beta decays.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Nitrogen-13 undergoes positron emission (713N→ZAX++10β+νe{}^{13}_{7}\text{N} \rightarrow {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X} + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta + \nu_e). Determine the mass number AA, atomic number ZZ, and chemical symbol of the daughter nuclide X\text{X}.

Answer

A=13A = 13, Z=6Z = 6, daughter nuclide is 613C{}^{13}_{6}\text{C}. Conservation of mass: 13=A+0  ⟹  A=1313 = A + 0 \implies A = 13. Conservation of charge: 7=Z+1  ⟹  Z=67 = Z + 1 \implies Z = 6, which corresponds to carbon.

02

Phosphorus-30 decays by positron emission: 1530P→ZAX++10β+νe{}^{30}_{15}\text{P} \rightarrow {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X} + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta + \nu_e Write the balanced nuclear equation and identify the daughter nuclide X\text{X}.

Answer

1530P→1430Si++10β+νe{}^{30}_{15}\text{P} \rightarrow {}^{30}_{14}\text{Si} + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta + \nu_e. Mass balance: 30=A+0  ⟹  A=3030 = A + 0 \implies A = 30. Charge balance: 15=Z+1  ⟹  Z=1415 = Z + 1 \implies Z = 14 (silicon, Si\text{Si}).

03

Compare the daughter nuclides produced when sodium-22 undergoes positron emission versus when sodium-24 undergoes beta-minus emission (1122Na→Z1A1X1++10β,1124Na→Z2A2X2+−10β{}^{22}_{11}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}^{A_1}_{Z_1}\text{X}_1 + {}^{0}_{+1}\beta, \quad {}^{24}_{11}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}^{A_2}_{Z_2}\text{X}_2 + {}^{0}_{-1}\beta). Determine (A1,Z1,X1)(A_1, Z_1, \text{X}_1) and (A2,Z2,X2)(A_2, Z_2, \text{X}_2).

Answer

For 1122Na{}^{22}_{11}\text{Na}: A1=22A_1 = 22, Z1=11−1=10Z_1 = 11 - 1 = 10, so X1\text{X}_1 is neon-22 (1022Ne{}^{22}_{10}\text{Ne}). For 1124Na{}^{24}_{11}\text{Na}: A2=24A_2 = 24, Z2=11−(−1)=12Z_2 = 11 - (-1) = 12, so X2\text{X}_2 is magnesium-24 (1224Mg{}^{24}_{12}\text{Mg}). Notice that β+\beta^+ decreases ZZ by 1, while β−\beta^- increases ZZ by 1.

Loading workspace…