Resources

A generic pure substance XX has a phase diagram with a triple point at Tt=150 KT_t = 150\text{ K} and Pt=0.40 atmP_t = 0.40\text{ atm}, and a critical point at Tc=420 KT_c = 420\text{ K} and Pc=65 atmP_c = 65\text{ atm}. The solid-liquid coexistence boundary has a positive slope (dP/dT>0dP/dT > 0). A sample of pure substance XX is initially maintained at a constant pressure of P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} and an initial temperature of T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K}. The sample is then heated isobarically to a final temperature of T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K}. Identify the sequence of phase transitions the sample undergoes during this heating process, and specify the state of matter at T1T_1 and T2T_2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Initial state at 100 K100\text{ K}: Solid; Final state at 300 K300\text{ K}: Liquid; Phase transition sequence: Melting (solid to liquid) only.

Steps

01

Locate the Pressure on the Phase Diagram

A standard phase diagram has pressure (PP) on the vertical axis and temperature (TT) on the horizontal axis:

  • Triple point: (Tt,Pt)=(150 K,0.40 atm)(T_t, P_t) = (150\text{ K}, 0.40\text{ atm})
  • Critical point: (Tc,Pc)=(420 K,65 atm)(T_c, P_c) = (420\text{ K}, 65\text{ atm})

The heating occurs at a constant pressure of P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}. Because: Pt<1.00 atm<PcP_t < 1.00\text{ atm} < P_c a horizontal line at P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} lies strictly above the triple point pressure. Therefore, the sample can exist as a liquid, and heating will traverse from solid to liquid before reaching the vapor phase (unlike pressures below 0.40 atm0.40\text{ atm}, where sublimation occurs).


02

Determine the Phase at the Initial Temperature (T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K})

  • The triple point temperature is Tt=150 KT_t = 150\text{ K}.
  • The solid-liquid coexistence boundary starts at (150 K,0.40 atm)(150\text{ K}, 0.40\text{ atm}) and has a positive slope (dPdT>0\frac{dP}{dT} > 0), meaning the melting temperature TmT_m increases as pressure increases. At P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}, the melting point satisfies Tm>150 KT_m > 150\text{ K}.
  • Because the initial temperature T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K} is well below TmT_m (and below TtT_t), the substance lies in the low-temperature, higher-pressure domain of the phase diagram.

Hence, the initial state at 100 K100\text{ K} is solid.


03

Determine the Phase Transitions and Final State (T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K})

  • As the temperature increases from 100 K100\text{ K} at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, the isobaric path crosses the solid-liquid equilibrium boundary at Tm≈150 KT_m \approx 150\text{ K}. The substance undergoes melting (solid →\to liquid).
  • The liquid-vapor boundary begins at the triple point (150 K,0.40 atm)(150\text{ K}, 0.40\text{ atm}) and terminates at the critical point (420 K,65 atm)(420\text{ K}, 65\text{ atm}). Over the pressure span from 0.40 atm0.40\text{ atm} to 65 atm65\text{ atm}, the boiling point rises toward 420 K420\text{ K}, placing the normal boiling line well above 300 K300\text{ K}.
  • Therefore, at T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K} and P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}, the sample remains between the melting curve and the vaporization curve.

Hence, the final state at 300 K300\text{ K} is liquid.


04

Summary

  • Initial state at 100 K100\text{ K}: Solid
  • Final state at 300 K300\text{ K}: Liquid
  • Phase transition sequence: Melting (solid to liquid) only

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student incorrectly assumes that heating a substance across temperatures crossing the triple point temperature always results in direct sublimation because they confuse isobaric heating above the triple point pressure with heating below it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Initial state at T1=100 K: solid\text{Initial state at } T_1 = 100\text{ K: solid}

  2. Step 2

    Since the sample is heated past Tt=150 K, it undergoes sublimation directly from solid to gas.  ⟹  Sequence of phase transitions: sublimation (solid to gas)\text{Since the sample is heated past } T_t = 150\text{ K},\text{ it undergoes sublimation directly from solid to gas.} \implies \text{Sequence of phase transitions: sublimation (solid to gas)}

    Correct

    P=1.00 atm>Pt=0.40 atm  ⟹  Heating crosses the solid-liquid line; phase transition is melting (solid to liquid) only.P = 1.00\text{ atm} > P_t = 0.40\text{ atm} \implies \text{Heating crosses the solid-liquid line; phase transition is melting (solid to liquid) only.}

    Direct sublimation from solid to gas only occurs when the system pressure is below the triple point pressure (P<Pt=0.40 atmP < P_t = 0.40\text{ atm}). Because the constant pressure is 1.00 atm>0.40 atm1.00\text{ atm} > 0.40\text{ atm}, the isobaric heating path traverses the liquid phase region, crossing the solid-liquid boundary into liquid.

  3. Step 3

    State at T1=100 K: solid; State at T2=300 K: gas\text{State at } T_1 = 100\text{ K: solid}; \text{ State at } T_2 = 300\text{ K: gas}

    Correct

    State at T2=300 K: liquid\text{State at } T_2 = 300\text{ K: liquid}

    Because you concluded that the substance sublimed directly into vapor, you identified the state at 300 K300\text{ K} as gas. At 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} and 300 K300\text{ K}, substance XX is between the melting boundary and the boiling boundary, so it is in the liquid state.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the substance begins in the solid phase at 100 K100\text{ K}.

You recognized that the triple point temperature (150 K150\text{ K}) represents a key reference mark during the heating process.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing isobaric heating above vs. below triple point pressure

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You focused entirely on the temperature crossing Tt=150 KT_t = 150\text{ K} while ignoring the role of pressure. Direct solid-to-gas sublimation only happens at pressures strictly below the triple point pressure (P<PtP < P_t). Because the pressure here is 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, which is greater than Pt=0.40 atmP_t = 0.40\text{ atm}, the isobaric line lies above the triple point and must enter the liquid region upon melting.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Locate the Operating Pressure Relative to $P_t$
  • If P<PtP < P_t, heating a solid leads to sublimation (solid →\to gas). If Pt<P<PcP_t < P < P_c, heating a solid leads to melting (solid →\to liquid) before eventual vaporization.

  • Compare the given pressure (1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}) with the triple point pressure (0.40 atm0.40\text{ atm}) before predicting phase transition paths.

Trace the Isobaric Path on a Sketch
  • On a P-TP\text{-}T phase diagram, constant-pressure heating corresponds to moving strictly horizontally from left to right at P=P0P = P_0.

  • Draw a horizontal line at P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}. Observe that it intersects the solid-liquid coexistence line first, entering the liquid region.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the constant pressure to the triple point pressure: P=1.00 atm>Pt=0.40 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} > P_t = 0.40\text{ atm}.

  2. Since P>PtP > P_t, the horizontal isobaric path lies above the triple point and passes through the liquid domain rather than bypassing it.

  3. Moving from T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K} to T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K} at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} crosses the solid-liquid equilibrium line at Tm≈150 KT_m \approx 150\text{ K}, causing melting (solid →\to liquid).

  4. Because T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K} is well below the boiling temperature at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} (the liquid-gas boundary extends up to the critical point at 420 K420\text{ K} and 65 atm65\text{ atm}), the sample remains liquid at 300 K300\text{ K}.

Final answer

Initial state at 100 K100\text{ K}: Solid; Final state at 300 K300\text{ K}: Liquid; Phase transition sequence: Melting (solid to liquid) only.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always check whether the operating pressure is above or below the triple point pressure PtP_t before determining phase transitions.

  • Sketch a quick P-TP\text{-}T phase diagram with the triple point and critical point to visually trace the isobaric horizontal line.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student assumes that substance X remains liquid at 300 K because they confuse the critical temperature (420 K) with the normal boiling point, concluding only melting occurs.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} is above Pt=0.40 atmP_t = 0.40\text{ atm}, so a liquid phase exists.   ⟹  \implies At T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K}, the sample is a solid.

  2. Step 2

    Boiling only occurs at the critical temperature Tc=420 KT_c = 420\text{ K}, so at 300 K300\text{ K} it has only melted.

    Correct

    Boiling occurs when the isobaric path crosses the liquid-vapor coexistence curve Pvap(T)P_{\text{vap}}(T). At P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}, the normal boiling point lies between Tt=150 KT_t = 150\text{ K} and Tc=420 KT_c = 420\text{ K} (well above 300 K300\text{ K} due to the logarithmic shape of the vapor pressure curve), meaning the liquid does not boil before 300 K300\text{ K}.

    Boiling does not occur only at the critical temperature. Vaporization occurs along the entire liquid-vapor boundary line from (Tt,Pt)(T_t, P_t) up to (Tc,Pc)(T_c, P_c). The critical point is simply where the liquid-gas boundary terminates and the two fluid phases become indistinguishable.

  3. Step 3

    Sequence of phase transitions: melting (solid to liquid)   ⟹  \implies State at T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K}: solid ; State at T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K}: liquid

    Correct

    Initial state at 100 K100\text{ K}: Solid; Final state at 300 K300\text{ K}: Liquid; Phase transition sequence: Melting (solid to liquid) only.

    Your final states and transition sequence match the correct answer, but this conclusion was reached through the mistaken assumption that boiling cannot occur below Tc=420 KT_c = 420\text{ K}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that a pressure of 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} is above the triple point pressure (0.40 atm0.40\text{ atm}), meaning a liquid phase exists.

You accurately determined that the substance is in the solid phase at T1=100 KT_1 = 100\text{ K}.

You correctly concluded that the substance undergoes melting to become a liquid.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Critical Temperature with Boiling Point

You assumed that boiling only takes place at the critical temperature Tc=420 KT_c = 420\text{ K}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the critical point—the thermodynamic endpoint where liquid and gas phases become a single supercritical fluid—with the liquid-gas phase transition temperature (boiling point), which varies continuously with pressure along the vaporization curve.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Liquid-Vapor Coexistence Curve
  • Boiling occurs at any temperature and pressure pair along the vaporization curve between (Tt,Pt)(T_t, P_t) and (Tc,Pc)(T_c, P_c), governed by the Clausius-Clapeyron relation.

  • To check if a liquid boils at an applied pressure PP, locate the temperature Tb(P)T_b(P) on the vaporization curve where vapor pressure equals PP, rather than comparing directly to TcT_c.

Definition of the Critical Point
  • The critical point (Tc,Pc)(T_c, P_c) marks the termination of the liquid-gas boundary line, above which distinct liquid and gas phases cease to exist.

  • Treat TcT_c as the highest temperature at which liquid and gas can coexist as separate phases, not as the required boiling temperature for all pressures.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that the boiling point TbT_b at a given pressure PP is the temperature on the liquid-vapor coexistence curve where the substance's equilibrium vapor pressure equals PP.

  2. Because P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} is relatively close to Pt=0.40 atmP_t = 0.40\text{ atm} compared to Pc=65 atmP_c = 65\text{ atm}, the vapor-pressure curve rises steeply toward higher pressures, placing the boiling point at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} comfortably above 300 K300\text{ K}.

  3. Because T2=300 KT_2 = 300\text{ K} lies between the melting curve (Tm≈150 KT_m \approx 150\text{ K}) and the vaporization curve (Tb>300 KT_b > 300\text{ K}), the sample melts and remains a liquid without boiling.

Final answer

Initial state at 100 K100\text{ K}: Solid; Final state at 300 K300\text{ K}: Liquid; Phase transition sequence: Melting (solid to liquid) only.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct meanings of triple point, boiling curve, and critical point on a P-TP\text{-}T phase diagram.

  • Practice tracing horizontal isobaric heating lines across the three coexistence curves (sublimation, fusion, vaporization).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pure substance has a triple point at (200 K,0.25 atm)(200\text{ K}, 0.25\text{ atm}) and a critical point at (500 K,40 atm)(500\text{ K}, 40\text{ atm}). A solid sample at 120 K120\text{ K} is heated isobarically at P=0.10 atmP = 0.10\text{ atm} to 300 K300\text{ K}. Identify the phase transition sequence and the final state.

Answer

Because P=0.10 atm<Pt=0.25 atmP = 0.10\text{ atm} < P_t = 0.25\text{ atm}, the isobaric path lies below the triple point. Heating crosses the sublimation curve directly from solid to gas. Transition sequence: Sublimation (solid to gas). Final state: Gas.

02

Carbon dioxide (CO2\text{CO}_2) has a triple point at −56.6∘C-56.6^\circ\text{C} and 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}. A cylinder of solid CO2\text{CO}_2 is maintained at a constant pressure of 10.0 atm10.0\text{ atm} and heated from −80∘C-80^\circ\text{C} to 0∘C0^\circ\text{C}. Describe the phase transition that occurs and state the final phase.

Answer

Since P=10.0 atm>Pt=5.11 atmP = 10.0\text{ atm} > P_t = 5.11\text{ atm}, liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 is stable. Heating from −80∘C-80^\circ\text{C} to 0∘C0^\circ\text{C} crosses the solid-liquid coexistence boundary. Phase transition: Melting (solid to liquid). Final phase: Liquid.

03

Substance YY has Tt=180 KT_t = 180\text{ K}, Pt=0.80 atmP_t = 0.80\text{ atm}, Tc=450 KT_c = 450\text{ K}, and Pc=50 atmP_c = 50\text{ atm}. A sample at 100 K100\text{ K} and 2.00 atm2.00\text{ atm} is heated isobarically all the way to 400 K400\text{ K}, crossing both the melting line at 182 K182\text{ K} and the boiling line at 350 K350\text{ K}. List the complete sequence of phase transitions and the state of matter in each temperature interval.

Answer

Since P=2.00 atmP = 2.00\text{ atm} lies between PtP_t and PcP_c, the sample traverses solid (100 K≤T<182 K100\text{ K} \le T < 182\text{ K}), melts at 182 K182\text{ K} (transition 1: melting, solid →\to liquid), exists as liquid (182 K<T<350 K182\text{ K} < T < 350\text{ K}), vaporizes at 350 K350\text{ K} (transition 2: boiling/vaporization, liquid →\to gas), and finishes as gas (350 K<T≤400 K350\text{ K} < T \le 400\text{ K}). Transition sequence: Melting, followed by boiling.

Loading workspace…