Resources
Rank the following four molecular substances in order of increasing normal boiling point: methane (, molar mass ), propane (, molar mass ), dimethyl ether (, molar mass ), and ethanol (, molar mass ). Justify the ranking by identifying the dominant intermolecular force governing the condensed phase for each substance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
. Dominant forces: (weak London dispersion forces due to small polarizable electron cloud), (stronger London dispersion forces due to larger electron cloud), (dipole-dipole interactions from polar bonds), and (hydrogen bonding via the hydroxyl donor-acceptor network).
Steps
Identify the dominant intermolecular force for each molecule
To rank substances by normal boiling point, evaluate the relative strength of the intermolecular forces (IMFs) holding their molecules together in the liquid phase. Stronger attractions require greater thermal energy to overcome, leading to higher boiling points.
-
Methane (, ):
- is a symmetrical, nonpolar tetrahedral molecule.
- Its only intermolecular forces are London dispersion forces. Because it has very few electrons (small, tightly held electron cloud) and a low molar mass, its polarizability is extremely low, making its dispersion forces very weak.
-
Propane (, ):
- is a nonpolar alkane.
- Its dominant forces are also London dispersion forces. However, with a significantly larger electron cloud and larger surface area than , it is much more polarizable, resulting in much stronger dispersion forces than those in methane.
-
Dimethyl ether (, ):
- Due to the bent geometry around the central oxygen atom and the electronegativity difference between carbon and oxygen ( bonds), dimethyl ether possesses a net permanent dipole.
- Because no hydrogen atom is bonded directly to nitrogen, oxygen, or fluorine, it cannot donate hydrogen bonds to other ether molecules. Thus, its dominant cohesive forces are dipole-dipole interactions (supplemented by dispersion forces comparable to propane).
-
Ethanol (, ):
- Ethanol contains a polar hydroxyl group () where hydrogen is directly bonded to a highly electronegative oxygen atom.
- It acts as both a hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor, forming an extensive network of intermolecular hydrogen bonds. Hydrogen bonding is a particularly strong category of dipole-dipole attraction and substantially exceeds standard dipole-dipole and dispersion attractions for molecules of this size.
Compare strengths and rank the boiling points
- vs. : Both are nonpolar, but has a much larger, more polarizable electron cloud, so .
- vs. : Both have very similar molar masses () and comparable dispersion baselines, but dimethyl ether adds permanent dipole-dipole attractions, so .
- vs. : These two are constitutional isomers with identical molar mass (). The hydrogen bonding in ethanol is far stronger than the dipole-dipole forces in dimethyl ether, so .
Common Pitfall: When molecules have very similar molar masses (such as the isomers dimethyl ether and ethanol), dispersion forces are nearly equal. The difference in boiling point is determined entirely by specific polar interactions—here, hydrogen bonding versus ordinary dipole-dipole forces.
Conclusion
Ranking in order of increasing normal boiling point:
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies dimethyl ether as having hydrogen bonding because of the oxygen atom and hydrogen atoms in the formula, leading to an incorrect ranking where dimethyl ether is placed above or equal in strength to ethanol.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: nonpolar, London dispersion forces : nonpolar, London dispersion forces (larger molar mass than )
- Step 2
: contains and , exhibits hydrogen bonding
Correcthas polar bonds and a bent geometry, so its dominant intermolecular force is dipole-dipole attraction (it has no bonds to act as a hydrogen bond donor).
For a pure substance to exhibit hydrogen bonding, a hydrogen atom must be covalently bonded directly to a highly electronegative atom (, , or ). In dimethyl ether, all hydrogen atoms are bonded directly to carbon (), so pure dimethyl ether cannot donate hydrogen bonds.
- Step 3
: contains , exhibits hydrogen bonding
- Step 4
Ranking by intermolecular force strength and molar mass:
CorrectBecause dimethyl ether only exhibits dipole-dipole attractions while ethanol forms much stronger hydrogen bonds, ethanol has a significantly higher boiling point than dimethyl ether.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified London dispersion forces as the sole intermolecular force in both methane and propane.
You recognized that propane has stronger dispersion forces than methane due to its larger molar mass and electron cloud.
You correctly identified that the hydroxyl group in ethanol allows for hydrogen bonding.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that simply possessing both oxygen and hydrogen atoms anywhere in a chemical formula allows a pure liquid to form hydrogen bonds, overlooking the requirement that hydrogen must be covalently bonded directly to nitrogen, oxygen, or fluorine (, , or ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Structural Requirement for Hydrogen Bonding
A molecule can only act as a hydrogen-bond donor if hydrogen is directly bonded to , , or .
Always draw or inspect the Lewis structure to confirm whether an , , or bond exists before assigning hydrogen bonding to a pure substance.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConfirm the connectivity of dimethyl ether (): all hydrogens are attached to carbon, so it has polar bonds but no donor bonds.
Classify the dominant intermolecular force in dimethyl ether as dipole-dipole attractions.
Compare relative strengths: dispersion forces () < dipole-dipole () < hydrogen bonding ().
02 The student ranks substances strictly by molar mass rather than dominant intermolecular forces, incorrectly placing dimethyl ether before propane because propane's molar mass is lower.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Boiling point increases with increasing molar mass: Molar masses: (), (), (), ()
CorrectBoiling point is determined by the total strength of intermolecular forces (London dispersion, dipole-dipole, and hydrogen bonding), not molar mass alone.
You stated that boiling point increases with increasing molar mass. While higher molar mass generally increases polarizability and London dispersion forces among similar nonpolar molecules, boiling point across different substances is fundamentally governed by the types and strengths of their intermolecular forces.
- Step 2
: London dispersion forces () : London dispersion forces () : dipole-dipole forces () : hydrogen bonding ()
- Step 3
Ranking:
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the dominant intermolecular force for each of the four molecules.
You correctly determined the final ranking of normal boiling points.
You recognized that hydrogen bonding in ethanol produces a higher boiling point than dipole-dipole attractions in dimethyl ether despite identical molar masses.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou framed molar mass as the primary governing rule for boiling point rather than the hierarchy of intermolecular forces.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on molar mass as a direct measure of boiling point. Molar mass serves as a useful proxy for polarizability and London dispersion force strength only when comparing nonpolar species or homologous series; it cannot override stronger specific interactions like permanent dipole-dipole attractions and hydrogen bonding.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Intermolecular Force Hierarchy
For molecules of comparable size and molar mass, hydrogen bonding is generally stronger than dipole-dipole interactions, which are stronger than London dispersion forces.
Identify and compare the types of dominant intermolecular forces first before looking at molar mass.
- When to Use Molar Mass
Molar mass correlates with boiling point primarily through electron cloud size and polarizability within the same class of intermolecular forces.
Use molar mass only to compare dispersion forces between nonpolar substances (such as vs. ), not across different force categories.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationClassify the dominant intermolecular forces: nonpolar and exhibit only London dispersion forces; bent, polar exhibits dipole-dipole forces; and forms an extensive network of hydrogen bonds via its group.
Compare the nonpolar pair: has a larger electron cloud and greater polarizability than , giving it stronger dispersion forces and thus a higher boiling point ().
Compare similar-mass species: permanent dipole-dipole attractions in make its boiling point higher than the primarily dispersive attractions in , while the strong hydrogen-bonding network in requires the greatest thermal energy to disrupt.
03 The student confuses the relative strength of dipole-dipole forces with London dispersion forces, assuming all dispersion forces are strictly weaker regardless of size, or misjudging propane and dimethyl ether relative to each other.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: nonpolar, London dispersion forces : nonpolar, London dispersion forces : polar, dipole-dipole forces : hydrogen bonding
- Step 2
Propane has higher mass and dispersion forces than dimethyl ether dipole forces, giving ranking:
CorrectCompare substances of similar molar mass: propane () and dimethyl ether () have comparable dispersion baselines, but dimethyl ether adds permanent dipole-dipole attractions, meaning . The correct ranking is .
Propane () actually has a slightly lower molar mass than dimethyl ether (). Because their molar masses and electron counts are very close, their dispersion force strengths are comparable, but dimethyl ether additionally has permanent dipole-dipole attractions, giving it a higher boiling point than propane.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the polarity of each molecular substance.
You successfully determined the dominant intermolecular force for each molecule.
You correctly placed methane as the lowest boiling substance and ethanol as the highest.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou misstated that propane has a higher molar mass than dimethyl ether.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that dispersion forces in propane outweigh the dipole-dipole forces in dimethyl ether, overlooking that both molecules have nearly identical molar mass ( vs. ) and that polar interactions add significant cohesive energy when dispersion baselines are comparable.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Molar Mass Baseline Check
When comparing polar and nonpolar substances, first compare their molar masses and electron cloud sizes to establish whether dispersion forces are comparable.
Always verify given molar masses directly: propane () is slightly lighter than dimethyl ether (), not heavier.
- Comparing Molecules of Similar Size
For molecules with similar molar mass and size, dispersion forces are roughly equal, so permanent dipole-dipole attractions or hydrogen bonds result in a higher boiling point.
Rank the polar molecule higher than the nonpolar molecule whenever their molar masses are nearly identical.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the molar masses of propane () and dimethyl ether (). Because they are nearly equal, both have comparable London dispersion forces.
Add the effect of molecular polarity: dimethyl ether has permanent dipole-dipole attractions from its bent bonds, whereas propane is nonpolar.
Conclude that dimethyl ether has stronger overall intermolecular attractions than propane, so .
Lock it in
What specific covalent bond must be present for a pure molecular substance to engage in intermolecular hydrogen bonding?
An atom must be directly bonded to , , or (e.g., , , or ).
Similar question
Rank fluoromethane () and methanol () in order of increasing boiling point, and name the dominant intermolecular force for each pure substance.
Answer
. Fluoromethane has polar bonds but no bonds, so its dominant force is dipole-dipole attraction. Methanol contains an bond, giving it much stronger intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Consider three substances with similar molar masses: pentane (, ), diethyl ether (, ), and 1-butanol (, ). Rank them in order of increasing normal boiling point and explain your reasoning.
Answer
. Pentane is nonpolar (London dispersion forces only). Diethyl ether has permanent dipole-dipole interactions due to polar bonds. 1-butanol has an group forming strong intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
Explain why trimethylamine (, boiling point ) has a significantly lower boiling point than propylamine (, boiling point ), even though both are constitutional isomers with the formula .
Answer
Propylamine has two bonds directly attached to nitrogen, allowing molecules to form intermolecular hydrogen bonds. In trimethylamine, all three methyl groups are bonded to nitrogen with no bonds, restricting its intermolecular forces to weaker dipole-dipole attractions and dispersion forces.