Resources
An unknown main-group metal cation and a halide anion combine to form a neutral binary ionic solid with empirical formula . The isolated cation has an identical ground-state electron configuration to the noble gas argon (, ), and the halide anion has an identical ground-state electron configuration to the noble gas krypton (, ). Work backward to identify: (a) the identity and atomic number of the neutral metal , (b) the identity and atomic number of the neutral nonmetal , and (c) the total number of valence electrons lost by one atom of to attain its stable octet configuration.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Because the formula is and is a halide forming , the cation must be (). The neutral metal atom has electrons, which is calcium (, ). (b) The anion has electrons, meaning the neutral halogen atom has electrons, which is bromine (, ). (c) One neutral atom of loses exactly valence electrons (from the subshell) to form .
Steps
Determine the Charge of the Metal Cation
An ionic compound is electrically neutral, meaning the sum of positive and negative charges in its formula unit must equal zero.
- The formula unit is , containing one cation and two anions.
- Each halide anion carries a single negative charge:
- To balance this, the single metal cation must carry a charge:
Thus, the metal cation is .
Identify the Metal
- The cation has an identical ground-state electron configuration to argon (), which has an atomic number of . Therefore, possesses electrons.
- A charge indicates that the neutral metal atom lost electrons during ionization:
- For any neutral atom, the number of protons (atomic number, ) equals the number of electrons. Therefore, .
- The element with atomic number is calcium ().
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the electron count of the ion with the atomic number of the neutral element. Cations form by losing electrons, so you must add the magnitude of the charge back to find the neutral atom's atomic number.
Identify the Nonmetal Halide
- The halide anion is isoelectronic with krypton (), which has an atomic number of . Therefore, possesses electrons.
- A charge indicates that the neutral halogen atom gained electron to form the halide ion:
- The atomic number corresponds to bromine ().
Determine the Valence Electrons Lost by
- The neutral calcium atom (, ) has the electron configuration:
- To achieve the stable, closed-shell octet configuration of argon (), one neutral atom of loses its valence electrons from the subshell, forming .
Typical errors
01 The student subtracts the positive charge from the noble gas electron count instead of adding it when determining the neutral metal's atomic number.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
When an atom forms a positive ion (cation), it loses electrons. To find the atomic number of the neutral atom from its cation, you must add the lost electrons back: , which corresponds to calcium (), not sulfur ().
- Step 3
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the chemical formula and the charge of the halide to establish that the metal cation is .
You correctly subtracted electron from the anion's electron count to find the neutral halogen's atomic number (, ).
You correctly deduced that forming the ion requires losing valence electrons.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the sign of the electron transfer when converting from a cation back to a neutral atom. A cation carries a positive charge because electrons are negatively charged; forming requires losing electrons, meaning the neutral parent atom has .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Cation vs. Neutral Atom Electron Count
For any ion, . Therefore, the atomic number of the neutral atom is .
When working backward from a cation , always add to the ion's electron count to determine the neutral atom's atomic number.
- Chemical Sanity Check
Main-group metals form cations and lie on the left side of the periodic table, whereas nonmetals form anions and lie on the right.
Check that your calculated produces a metal. Obtaining (sulfur, a nonmetal) is an immediate cue that the charge was subtracted rather than added.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that a neutral atom loses electrons to form a positive cation: .
Add the lost electrons back to the electrons of : .
Locate element on the periodic table to identify neutral metal as calcium ().
(a) Calcium (, ); (b) Bromine (, ); (c) valence electrons.
02 The student confuses the subscript of the halide in MX₂ with the magnitude of the anion's charge, treating X as having a 2- charge.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Assume has charge , so balances
Correctis a halide () with charge . For a neutral formula unit : , so the cation is .
The problem specifies that is a halide anion, denoted as , which always carries a charge. The subscript in indicates that there are two halide ions per formula unit, not that each individual anion has a charge.
- Step 2
has electrons Metal is titanium (),
Correcthas electrons Metal is calcium (),
Your method of adding the lost electrons back to the noble-gas core was mathematically sound, but because it relied on the incorrect charge, it produced titanium instead of calcium. Notice also that titanium is a transition metal, whereas the prompt specified a main-group metal.
- Step 3
has electrons Nonmetal is selenium (),
Correcthas electrons Nonmetal is bromine (),
You correctly subtracted gained electrons from the noble-gas electron count to find the neutral atom, but substituting instead of yielded selenium instead of bromine.
- Step 4
Valence electrons lost by
CorrectValence electrons lost by
Because the correct cation is , one neutral calcium atom loses its valence electrons from the subshell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a cation's neutral atomic number equals its ionic electron count plus the magnitude of its positive charge.
You correctly recognized that an anion's neutral atomic number equals its ionic electron count minus the magnitude of its negative charge.
You balanced the total positive and negative charges to achieve overall electrical neutrality.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed the halide has a charge rather than a charge.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the formula subscript in with the individual ionic charge of the anion , overlooking the prompt's definition of as a halide anion .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Differentiate Subscripts from Ionic Charges
In an ionic formula , the subscripts and count the number of ions per formula unit; they do not dictate the intrinsic charge of a single ion.
Always verify the standard group charge of familiar species (e.g., Group 17 halides are always ) before setting up the charge-balance equation.
- Charge Neutrality Equation
For a neutral compound , .
Substitute the known individual ion charge into the equation and solve for the unknown charge, rather than modifying known charges.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that each halide ion is , possessing a charge.
Set up charge neutrality for : , identifying the cation as .
Calculate for : , which corresponds to the main-group metal calcium (, ).
Calculate for : , which corresponds to bromine (, ).
Determine valence electrons lost: () loses valence electrons to form .
(a) Calcium (, ); (b) Bromine (, ); (c) valence electrons
03 The student adds the extra electron to the noble gas electron count for an anion instead of subtracting it to find the neutral atom.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
An anion carries a negative charge because it gained an electron. When working backward to the neutral atom, you must subtract that gained electron (), which corresponds to bromine (), rather than adding an electron.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used charge neutrality with and to find the charge on .
You correctly added the lost electrons back to the cation's electron count to identify calcium ().
You correctly stated that calcium loses valence electrons during ionization.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou reversed the direction of electron transfer when converting an anion back to its neutral atom, adding an extra electron instead of subtracting the gained electron.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ion formation direction vs. backward calculation
Neutral atom . Therefore, .
Always verify that your result makes chemical sense: an anion formed from a halogen must be a nonmetal, whereas is rubidium, an alkali metal.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe halide ion has electrons (isoelectronic with ).
Because formed by gaining electron, the neutral atom possesses electrons.
Since the number of protons equals the number of electrons in a neutral atom, , which is bromine ().
(a) Calcium (, ); (b) Bromine (, ); (c) valence electrons
Lock it in
If a metal forms a cation that is isoelectronic with neon (), how many electrons and protons does the neutral metal atom have?
electrons and protons (, aluminum). Cations form by losing electrons, so the neutral atom has electrons.
Similar question
A metal cation and an oxide anion form the ionic compound . If is isoelectronic with neon (), determine the identity and atomic number of neutral metal , and state how many valence electrons it lost.
Answer
Neutral has electrons, so , which is aluminum (). It lost valence electrons (from the subshells).
A binary ionic compound has the formula . Anion is isoelectronic with argon (), and cation is isoelectronic with neon (). Identify elements and by name and atomic number.
Answer
For cation : neutral atom has electrons , sodium (). For anion : neutral atom has electrons , sulfur ().
A main-group metal reacts with nitrogen to form an ionic nitride . The isolated cation has an electron configuration of . Identify metal by its chemical symbol and atomic number , and write the full ground-state electron configuration of the neutral atom.
Answer
The nitride ion is , so for , (cation is ). The ion has electrons. Neutral has electrons, so , which is zinc (). Its neutral electron configuration is .