Resources

Naturally occurring chlorine consists of two stable isotopes: 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} (isotopic mass 34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}, natural abundance 75.78%75.78\%) and 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} (isotopic mass 36.966 Da36.966\text{ Da}, natural abundance 24.22%24.22\%). A student expects the mass spectrum of pure dichloromethane, CH2Cl2\text{CH}_2\text{Cl}_2 (where C=12.000 Da\text{C} = 12.000\text{ Da} and H=1.008 Da\text{H} = 1.008\text{ Da}), to show a single molecular ion peak corresponding to the periodic table average molar mass of 84.93 g/mol84.93\text{ g/mol}. Explain why no single molecule has this exact mass, and calculate the exact molecular mass in g/mol\text{g/mol} (or Da\text{Da}) of the most abundant isotopologue of CH2Cl2\text{CH}_2\text{Cl}_2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

No individual molecule possesses the average molar mass because individual molecules contain discrete integer combinations of isotopes rather than fractional averages; Most abundant isotopologue (12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2): 83.954 g/mol83.954\text{ g/mol}

Steps

01

Why No Single Molecule Has the Average Molar Mass

The molar mass listed on the periodic table (approximately 84.93 g/mol84.93\text{ g/mol} for CHX2ClX2\ce{CH2Cl2}) is a weighted macroscopic average across a vast ensemble of molecules containing different isotopes in their natural abundances:

  • Individual molecules are composed of discrete atoms containing specific numbers of protons and neutrons. An atom of chlorine is either 35Cl^{35}\ce{Cl} (mass 34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}) or 37Cl^{37}\ce{Cl} (mass 36.966 Da36.966\text{ Da}).
  • There is no single chlorine atom with the "average" mass of 35.45 Da35.45\text{ Da}.
  • Consequently, each single CHX2ClX2\ce{CH2Cl2} molecule must contain one of three discrete pairs of chlorine isotopes:
    • X35X2235Cl−X35X2235Cl\ce{^{35}Cl}-\ce{^{35}Cl}
    • X35X2235Cl−X37X2237Cl\ce{^{35}Cl}-\ce{^{37}Cl}
    • X37X2237Cl−X37X2237Cl\ce{^{37}Cl}-\ce{^{37}Cl}

Because an individual molecule cannot contain a fractional portion of a neutron, no single molecule can possess the theoretical average mass of 84.93 g/mol84.93\text{ g/mol}.


02

Identifying the Most Abundant Isotopologue

The probability of each isotopologue depends on the natural abundance of each chlorine isotope:

  • Abundance of 35Cl=75.78%=0.7578^{35}\ce{Cl} = 75.78\% = 0.7578
  • Abundance of 37Cl=24.22%=0.2422^{37}\ce{Cl} = 24.22\% = 0.2422

For a molecule with two chlorine atoms:

  • Probability of X12X2212CX1X221HX2X35X2235ClX2=(0.7578)2≈0.5743 (57.43%)\ce{^{12}C^1H2^{35}Cl2} = (0.7578)^2 \approx 0.5743\text{ (}57.43\%\text{)}
  • Probability of X12X2212CX1X221HX2X35X2235ClX37X2237Cl=2⋅(0.7578)⋅(0.2422)≈0.3671 (36.71%)\ce{^{12}C^1H2^{35}Cl^{37}Cl} = 2 \cdot (0.7578) \cdot (0.2422) \approx 0.3671\text{ (}36.71\%\text{)}
  • Probability of X12X2212CX1X221HX2X37X2237ClX2=(0.2422)2≈0.0587 (5.87%)\ce{^{12}C^1H2^{37}Cl2} = (0.2422)^2 \approx 0.0587\text{ (}5.87\%\text{)}

The most abundant isotopologue is therefore X12X2212CX1X221HX2X35X2235ClX2\ce{^{12}C^1H2^{35}Cl2}.


03

Calculating the Exact Mass of the Most Abundant Isotopologue

Sum the exact isotopic masses of each constituent atom:

Mass of X12X2212C=12.000 Da\text{Mass of }\ce{^{12}C} = 12.000\text{ Da} Mass of two X1X221H=2⋅1.008 Da=2.016 Da\text{Mass of two }\ce{^1H} = 2 \cdot 1.008\text{ Da} = 2.016\text{ Da} Mass of two X35X2235Cl=2⋅34.969 Da=69.938 Da\text{Mass of two }\ce{^{35}Cl} = 2 \cdot 34.969\text{ Da} = 69.938\text{ Da}

Total Mass=12.000 Da+2.016 Da+69.938 Da=83.954 Da (or g/mol)\text{Total Mass} = 12.000\text{ Da} + 2.016\text{ Da} + 69.938\text{ Da} = 83.954\text{ Da}\text{ (or g/mol)}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the most abundant isotopologue with the mixed isotopologue containing one of each chlorine isotope, yielding 85.951 Da.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    84.93 g/mol is a statistical weighted average of isotopes in a bulk sample, but each molecule contains specific whole isotopes rather than average atoms.

  2. Step 2

    The most abundant form has one of each isotope, 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} and 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl}.

    Correct

    The most abundant isotopologue is 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2, because the probability of two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms is (0.7578)2≈0.5743(0.7578)^2 \approx 0.5743 (57.43%57.43\%) compared to 2(0.7578)(0.2422)≈0.36712(0.7578)(0.2422) \approx 0.3671 (36.71%36.71\%) for the mixed form.

    Because 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} is much more abundant (75.78%75.78\%) than 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} (24.22%24.22\%), the probability of drawing two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms is greater than drawing one of each. Therefore, the pure 35Cl2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 isotopologue is the most abundant.

  3. Step 3

    Mass=12.000+2(1.008)+34.969+36.966  ⟹  Mass=85.951 Da\text{Mass} = 12.000 + 2(1.008) + 34.969 + 36.966 \implies \text{Mass} = 85.951\text{ Da}

    Correct

    Mass=12.000+2(1.008)+2(34.969)=83.954 Da (or g/mol)\text{Mass} = 12.000 + 2(1.008) + 2(34.969) = 83.954\text{ Da (or g/mol)}

    Your arithmetic was accurate for the mixed isotopologue, but this calculation was affected by selecting the wrong isotopologue in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly articulated why individual molecules have discrete masses rather than the statistical average molar mass.

You correctly set up the mass summation formula using the provided exact isotopic masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isotopologue abundance misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that a molecule containing multiple isotopic positions is most abundant when it contains a mix of different isotopes, rather than calculating the binomial probabilities of the isotopic combinations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Binomial Probability for Isotopologues
  • For a molecule with nn identical halogen atoms and two isotopes with fractional abundances pp and qq, the relative abundance of having kk atoms of the first isotope is given by (nk)pkqn−k\binom{n}{k} p^k q^{n-k}.

  • Always compare (p)2(p)^2, 2pq2pq, and (q)2(q)^2 explicitly before declaring which isotopologue is the most abundant.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the probability of two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms: P(35Cl2)=(0.7578)2≈0.5743P(^{35}\text{Cl}_2) = (0.7578)^2 \approx 0.5743.

  2. Calculate the probability of one 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} and one 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl}: P(35Cl37Cl)=2×0.7578×0.2422≈0.3671P(^{35}\text{Cl}^{37}\text{Cl}) = 2 \times 0.7578 \times 0.2422 \approx 0.3671.

  3. Notice that 0.5743>0.36710.5743 > 0.3671, confirming 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 is the most abundant form.

  4. Sum the isotopic masses: 12.000+2(1.008)+2(34.969)=83.954 Da12.000 + 2(1.008) + 2(34.969) = 83.954\text{ Da}.

Final answer

The most abundant isotopologue is 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 with an exact mass of 83.954 Da83.954\text{ Da} (or g/mol\text{g/mol}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to write out the binomial expansion (p+q)n(p + q)^n when determining peak ratios in mass spectrometry.

  • Practice identifying the base peak isotopologue for molecules with multiple chlorine or bromine atoms before performing exact mass additions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies 37Cl as the most abundant isotope due to its larger mass number, calculating the mass of the 37Cl2 isotopologue as 87.948 Da.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    84.93 is an average across all molecules, whereas individual molecules contain specific isotopes.

  2. Step 2

    The most abundant isotopologue contains two 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} atoms.

    Correct

    The most abundant isotopologue is 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 because 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} has the higher natural abundance (75.78%75.78\% vs. 24.22%24.22\%).

    You selected 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} as the basis for the most abundant isotopologue. Because 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} has a natural abundance of 75.78%75.78\%, the pair 35Cl–35Cl^{35}\text{Cl}\text{--}^{35}\text{Cl} occurs with probability (0.7578)2≈57.4%(0.7578)^2 \approx 57.4\%, making 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 the most abundant species.

  3. Step 3

    Mass=12.000+2(1.008)+2(36.966)  ⟹  Mass=87.948 Da\text{Mass} = 12.000 + 2(1.008) + 2(36.966) \implies \text{Mass} = 87.948\text{ Da}

    Correct

    Mass=12.000+2(1.008)+2(34.969)=83.954 Da\text{Mass} = 12.000 + 2(1.008) + 2(34.969) = 83.954\text{ Da}

    Your arithmetic was executed correctly for the chosen formula, but the result is incorrect due to substituting the isotopic mass of 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} instead of 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly articulated the distinction between a macroscopic weighted-average molar mass and the discrete isotopic composition of an individual molecule.

You correctly set up the sum of atomic masses to compute the molecular mass of a specific isotopologue.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isotope Abundance Misidentification

You used the heavier isotope 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} instead of the more abundant isotope 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} when constructing the predominant isotopologue.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing isotopic mass number with natural abundance, or inadvertently picking the heavier isotope rather than comparing the given percentage abundances (75.78%75.78\% for 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} versus 24.22%24.22\% for 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compare Abundances First
  • The most abundant isotopologue of a molecule is formed predominantly by the individual isotopes that have the highest natural abundance.

  • Always check the given abundance percentages before picking an isotope: 75.78%>24.22%75.78\% > 24.22\%, so 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} dominates.

Verify Probabilities for Multi-Atom Systems
  • For a molecule with two identical halogen atoms, the probability of X2\text{X}_2 is p2p^2, where pp is the fractional abundance.

  • Calculate (0.7578)2≈0.574(0.7578)^2 \approx 0.574 for 35Cl2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 versus (0.2422)2≈0.059(0.2422)^2 \approx 0.059 for 37Cl2^{37}\text{Cl}_2 to confirm which species produces the highest peak.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the natural abundances: 35Cl=75.78%^{35}\text{Cl} = 75.78\% and 37Cl=24.22%^{37}\text{Cl} = 24.22\%. Therefore, 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} is the predominant isotope.

  2. Construct the most abundant isotopologue: 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2.

  3. Sum the exact isotopic masses: Mass=12.000 Da+2(1.008 Da)+2(34.969 Da)=12.000+2.016+69.938=83.954 Da\text{Mass} = 12.000\text{ Da} + 2(1.008\text{ Da}) + 2(34.969\text{ Da}) = 12.000 + 2.016 + 69.938 = 83.954\text{ Da}.

Final answer

Most abundant isotopologue (12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2): 83.954 Da (or g/mol)83.954\text{ Da}\text{ (or g/mol)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check isotopic abundance percentages before calculating molecular masses for mass spectrometry problems.

  • Practice computing relative peak intensities for molecules with multiple isotopic centers (e.g., binomial expansion p2+2pq+q2p^2 + 2pq + q^2).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student correctly selects two 35Cl atoms but uses the nominal mass numbers instead of the given isotopic masses, arriving at 84.016 Da.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    No single molecule has 84.93 g/mol84.93\text{ g/mol} because that value is an average of different isotopes, not an actual single molecular mass.

  2. Step 2

    Most abundant isotopologue has two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms.

  3. Step 3

    Mass\text{Mass} = 12.000 + 2(1.008) + 2(35)   ⟹  \implies Mass\text{Mass} = 84.016 Da\text{ Da}

    Correct

    Mass\text{Mass} = 12.000 Da\text{ Da} + 2(1.008 Da\text{ Da}) + 2(34.969 Da\text{ Da}) = 83.954 Da\text{ Da}

    You used the nominal integer mass number 3535 for chlorine instead of the provided accurate isotopic mass 34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}. Nominal mass numbers neglect nuclear binding energy and the mass difference between protons and neutrons.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly articulated why periodic table molar mass is an ensemble average rather than the physical mass of an individual molecule.

You correctly deduced that the most abundant isotopologue of dichloromethane incorporates two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms.

You set up the summation of atomic masses with the correct stoichiometric coefficients.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nominal mass vs. accurate isotopic mass

You wrote the rounded integer mass number 3535 for 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} rather than the given experimental isotopic mass of 34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing nominal mass number (AA, an integer count of nucleons) with exact isotopic mass (the precise measured mass in atomic mass units or Daltons, which includes the mass defect).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nominal Mass vs. Exact Isotopic Mass
  • Mass number A=Z+NA = Z + N is always an integer count of nucleons, whereas exact isotopic mass accounts for real subatomic masses and nuclear binding energy.

  • Always substitute the exact experimental mass given in the problem statement (e.g., 34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}) instead of rounding to the nucleon count AA.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the exact isotopic masses provided: 12C=12.000 Da^{12}\text{C} = 12.000\text{ Da}, 1H=1.008 Da^1\text{H} = 1.008\text{ Da}, and 35Cl=34.969 Da^{35}\text{Cl} = 34.969\text{ Da}.

  2. Sum the exact masses for 12C1H235Cl2^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{35}\text{Cl}_2: Mass=12.000 Da+2(1.008 Da)+2(34.969 Da)\text{Mass} = 12.000\text{ Da} + 2(1.008\text{ Da}) + 2(34.969\text{ Da}).

  3. Calculate the total: 12.000+2.016+69.938=83.954 Da12.000 + 2.016 + 69.938 = 83.954\text{ Da}.

Final answer

83.954\text{ Da}$$\text{ (or }$$\text{g/mol})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between mass number AA (integer) and accurate isotopic mass (real number with decimals).

  • Double-check that all numerical values supplied in the prompt text are transferred directly into your calculation without premature rounding.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Elemental chlorine gas, Cl2\text{Cl}_2, has two isotopes: 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} (34.969 Da34.969\text{ Da}, 75.78%75.78\%) and 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} (36.966 Da36.966\text{ Da}, 24.22%24.22\%). Identify the molecular formula of the most abundant isotopologue of Cl2\text{Cl}_2 and calculate its exact mass.

Answer

The most abundant isotopologue is 35Cl2^{35}\text{Cl}_2 (P=0.75782≈57.4%P = 0.7578^2 \approx 57.4\% vs. 36.7%36.7\% for mixed and 5.9%5.9\% for 37Cl2^{37}\text{Cl}_2). Exact mass = 2×34.969 Da=69.938 Da2 \times 34.969\text{ Da} = 69.938\text{ Da}.

02

For chloroform, CHCl3\text{CHCl}_3, using 12C=12.000 Da^{12}\text{C} = 12.000\text{ Da}, 1H=1.008 Da^1\text{H} = 1.008\text{ Da}, 35Cl=34.969 Da^{35}\text{Cl} = 34.969\text{ Da} (75.78%75.78\%), and 37Cl=36.966 Da^{37}\text{Cl} = 36.966\text{ Da} (24.22%24.22\%), calculate the probabilities of the isotopologues containing three 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} atoms versus two 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} and one 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} atom. State which one is the most abundant isotopologue.

Answer

P(35Cl3)=(0.7578)3≈0.435P(^{35}\text{Cl}_3) = (0.7578)^3 \approx 0.435 (43.5%43.5\%). P(35Cl237Cl)=3×(0.7578)2×(0.2422)≈0.417P(^{35}\text{Cl}_2^{37}\text{Cl}) = 3 \times (0.7578)^2 \times (0.2422) \approx 0.417 (41.7%41.7\%). The most abundant isotopologue is 12C1H35Cl3^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}^{35}\text{Cl}_3.

03

Consider dibromomethane, CH2Br2\text{CH}_2\text{Br}_2. Given 79Br=78.918 Da^{79}\text{Br} = 78.918\text{ Da} (50.69%50.69\%) and 81Br=80.916 Da^{81}\text{Br} = 80.916\text{ Da} (49.31%49.31\%), with 12C=12.000 Da^{12}\text{C} = 12.000\text{ Da} and 1H=1.008 Da^1\text{H} = 1.008\text{ Da}, determine which isotopologue is most abundant and calculate its exact mass.

Answer

P(79Br2)=0.50692≈0.257P(^{79}\text{Br}_2) = 0.5069^2 \approx 0.257; P(79Br81Br)=2(0.5069)(0.4931)≈0.500P(^{79}\text{Br}^{81}\text{Br}) = 2(0.5069)(0.4931) \approx 0.500; P(81Br2)=0.49312≈0.243P(^{81}\text{Br}_2) = 0.4931^2 \approx 0.243. The most abundant isotopologue is the mixed form 12C1H279Br81Br^{12}\text{C}^1\text{H}_2^{79}\text{Br}^{81}\text{Br}. Exact mass = 12.000+2(1.008)+78.918+80.916=173.850 Da12.000 + 2(1.008) + 78.918 + 80.916 = 173.850\text{ Da}.

Loading workspace…