Resources

Naturally occurring magnesium consists of three stable isotopes: 24Mg^{24}\text{Mg} (23.985 amu23.985\text{ amu}, 78.99%78.99\%) and 25Mg^{25}\text{Mg} (24.986 amu24.986\text{ amu}, 10.00%10.00\%). The overall average atomic mass of magnesium is 24.305 amu24.305\text{ amu}. A chemist reacts a pure 1.500 g1.500\text{ g} sample of magnesium metal completely with excess hydrochloric acid according to the reaction Mg(s)+2HCl(aq)→MgCl2(aq)+H2(g)\text{Mg}(s) + 2\text{HCl}(aq) \rightarrow \text{MgCl}_2(aq) + \text{H}_2(g). First, determine the isotopic mass of the third isotope, 26Mg^{26}\text{Mg}, to four significant figures. Then, calculate the theoretical yield of hydrogen gas produced in moles to four significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Isotopic mass of 26Mg=25.98 amu^{26}\text{Mg} = 25.98\text{ amu}; Theoretical yield of H2=0.06172 mol\text{H}_2 = 0.06172\text{ mol}

Steps

Part 1: Determine the Isotopic Mass of 26Mg^{26}\ce{Mg}

  1. Find the percent abundance of 26Mg^{26}\ce{Mg}: The total abundance of all naturally occurring isotopes must sum to 100%100\%: Abundance of 26Mg=100.00%−78.99%−10.00%=11.01%\text{Abundance of }^{26}\ce{Mg} = 100.00\% - 78.99\% - 10.00\% = 11.01\% In fractional abundance, this is 0.11010.1101.
  2. Set up the weighted average atomic mass equation: The average atomic mass of an element is the sum of each isotope's mass multiplied by its fractional abundance: Average Atomic Mass=(fraction1⋅mass1)+(fraction2⋅mass2)+(fraction3⋅mass3)\text{Average Atomic Mass} = (\text{fraction}_1 \cdot \text{mass}_1) + (\text{fraction}_2 \cdot \text{mass}_2) + (\text{fraction}_3 \cdot \text{mass}_3)

    Substitute the given values: 24.305 amu=(0.7899⋅23.985 amu)+(0.1000⋅24.986 amu)+(0.1101⋅m26)24.305\text{ amu} = (0.7899 \cdot 23.985\text{ amu}) + (0.1000 \cdot 24.986\text{ amu}) + (0.1101 \cdot m_{26})

  3. Solve for the mass of 26Mg^{26}\ce{Mg} (m26m_{26}): 24.305=18.9458+2.4986+0.1101⋅m2624.305 = 18.9458 + 2.4986 + 0.1101 \cdot m_{26} 24.305=21.4444+0.1101⋅m2624.305 = 21.4444 + 0.1101 \cdot m_{26} 2.8606=0.1101⋅m262.8606 = 0.1101 \cdot m_{26} m26=2.86060.1101≈25.9823 amum_{26} = \frac{2.8606}{0.1101} \approx 25.9823\text{ amu}

    Rounding to four significant figures gives: Isotopic mass of 26Mg=25.98 amu\text{Isotopic mass of }^{26}\ce{Mg} = 25.98\text{ amu}


Part 2: Calculate the Theoretical Yield of Hydrogen Gas (HX2\ce{H2})

  1. Calculate the moles of magnesium reacted: To calculate moles of a natural sample, use the average atomic mass (24.305 g/mol24.305\text{ g/mol}), not the mass of any single isotope: nMg=massmolar mass=1.500 g24.305 g/mol≈0.0617157 moln_{\ce{Mg}} = \frac{\text{mass}}{\text{molar mass}} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{24.305\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.0617157\text{ mol}
  2. Use reaction stoichiometry to find moles of HX2\ce{H2}: According to the balanced equation: Mg(s)+2 HCl(aq)→MgClX2(aq)+HX2(g)\ce{Mg(s) + 2HCl(aq) -> MgCl2(aq) + H2(g)} The stoichiometric mole ratio between Mg\ce{Mg} and HX2\ce{H2} is 1:11:1.

    Therefore: nHX2=nMg⋅1 mol HX21 mol Mg=0.0617157 moln_{\ce{H2}} = n_{\ce{Mg}} \cdot \frac{1\text{ mol }\ce{H2}}{1\text{ mol }\ce{Mg}} = 0.0617157\text{ mol}

    Rounding to four significant figures gives: Theoretical yield of HX2=0.06172 mol\text{Theoretical yield of }\ce{H2} = 0.06172\text{ mol}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the isotopes as having equal abundance by calculating an unweighted arithmetic mean, resulting in an incorrect isotopic mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    23.985+24.986+m3=24.305  ⟹  48.971+m=72.915  ⟹  m=23.94 amu\frac{23.985 + 24.986 + m}{3} = 24.305 \implies 48.971 + m = 72.915 \implies m = 23.94\text{ amu}

    Correct

    (0.7899)(23.985 amu)+(0.1000)(24.986 amu)+(0.1101)m=24.305 amu  ⟹  m=25.98 amu(0.7899)(23.985\text{ amu}) + (0.1000)(24.986\text{ amu}) + (0.1101)m = 24.305\text{ amu} \implies m = 25.98\text{ amu}

    You divided the sum of the masses by 33, which assumes all three isotopes are equally abundant (33.3%33.3\% each). Because 24Mg^{24}\text{Mg} makes up nearly 79%79\% of all atoms, each isotope must be multiplied by its fractional abundance.

  2. Step 2

    Moles of Mg=1.500 g24.305 g/mol=0.061716 mol\text{Moles of Mg} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{24.305\text{ g/mol}} = 0.061716\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    Ratio of Mg to H2 is 1:1  ⟹  Theoretical yield of H2=0.06172 mol\text{Ratio of Mg to H}_2\text{ is } 1:1 \implies \text{Theoretical yield of H}_2 = 0.06172\text{ mol}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the molar mass of magnesium to convert mass to moles.

You used the balanced chemical equation to determine the 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio between Mg\text{Mg} and H2\text{H}_2.

You rounded your final theoretical yield properly to four significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted mean instead of weighted average atomic mass

No, this is a conceptual error rather than a slip because you explicitly divided the sum of the three masses by 3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated average atomic mass as a simple arithmetic average rather than a weighted average that accounts for unequal isotopic abundances.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Abundance Sum Check
  • The sum of all percent abundances must equal 100%100\% (or fractional abundances must sum to 1.001.00).

  • Always find the missing isotope's percent by subtracting the known percentages from 100%100\% before setting up the mass equation.

Weighted Average Setup
  • Average Atomic Mass=∑(fractional abundancei×isotopic massi)\text{Average Atomic Mass} = \sum (\text{fractional abundance}_i \times \text{isotopic mass}_i).

  • Multiply each individual isotopic mass by its decimal abundance; never divide by the total number of isotopes unless their abundances are identical.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the abundance of 26Mg^{26}\text{Mg}: 100.00%−78.99%−10.00%=11.01%100.00\% - 78.99\% - 10.00\% = 11.01\%, which corresponds to a decimal fraction of 0.11010.1101.

  2. Set up the weighted average expression: 24.305=(0.7899)(23.985)+(0.1000)(24.986)+(0.1101)(m)24.305 = (0.7899)(23.985) + (0.1000)(24.986) + (0.1101)(m).

  3. Multiply known terms: 24.305=18.94575+2.4986+0.1101m=21.44435+0.1101m24.305 = 18.94575 + 2.4986 + 0.1101m = 21.44435 + 0.1101m.

  4. Isolate mm: 0.1101m=24.305−21.44435=2.86065  ⟹  m=2.860650.1101≈25.9823 amu0.1101m = 24.305 - 21.44435 = 2.86065 \implies m = \frac{2.86065}{0.1101} \approx 25.9823\text{ amu}.

Final answer

Isotopic mass of 26Mg=25.98 amu^{26}\text{Mg} = 25.98\text{ amu}; Theoretical yield of H2=0.06172 mol\text{H}_2 = 0.06172\text{ mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice calculating average atomic mass using decimal fractions for each isotope.

  • Verify that your calculated isotopic mass makes physical sense compared to its mass number (e.g., 26Mg^{26}\text{Mg} should be close to 26 amu26\text{ amu}, not 23.94 amu23.94\text{ amu}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies the coefficient of 2 from HCl to the mole ratio between Mg and H₂, halving the theoretical yield of hydrogen gas.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Abundance of 26Mg=100.00%−78.99%−10.00%=11.01%  ⟹  24.305=(0.7899×23.985)+(0.1000×24.986)+(0.1101×m)  ⟹  24.305=21.4444+0.1101m  ⟹  m=25.98 amu\text{Abundance of }^{26}\text{Mg} = 100.00\% - 78.99\% - 10.00\% = 11.01\% \implies 24.305 = (0.7899 \times 23.985) + (0.1000 \times 24.986) + (0.1101 \times m) \implies 24.305 = 21.4444 + 0.1101m \implies m = 25.98\text{ amu}

  2. Step 2

    Moles of Mg=1.500 g24.305 g/mol=0.061716 mol\text{Moles of Mg} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{24.305\text{ g/mol}} = 0.061716\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    Theoretical yield of H2=0.061716 mol2=0.03086 mol\text{Theoretical yield of }\text{H}_2 = \frac{0.061716\text{ mol}}{2} = 0.03086\text{ mol}

    Correct

    nH2=0.061716 mol Mg×1 mol H21 mol Mg=0.06172 moln_{\text{H}_2} = 0.061716\text{ mol Mg} \times \frac{1\text{ mol H}_2}{1\text{ mol Mg}} = 0.06172\text{ mol}

    In the reaction Mg(s)+2HCl(aq)→MgCl2(aq)+H2(g)\text{Mg}(s) + 2\text{HCl}(aq) \rightarrow \text{MgCl}_2(aq) + \text{H}_2(g), the stoichiometric ratio between Mg\text{Mg} and H2\text{H}_2 is 1:11:1. You mistakenly applied the coefficient of 22 from HCl\text{HCl} to H2\text{H}_2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly subtracted the known isotope percentages from 100%100\% to find the abundance of 26Mg^{26}\text{Mg}.

You set up and solved the weighted average atomic mass equation with high numerical precision.

You correctly converted grams of natural magnesium to moles using its average atomic mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric Ratio Misassignment

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You transferred the coefficient of 22 belonging to the excess reactant HCl\text{HCl} into the mole ratio calculation between Mg\text{Mg} and H2\text{H}_2, which actually react in a 1:11:1 molar ratio.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Species in the Mole Ratio
  • Moles of B=Moles of A×coefficient of Bcoefficient of A\text{Moles of B} = \text{Moles of A} \times \frac{\text{coefficient of B}}{\text{coefficient of A}}

  • Always write out the dimensional analysis units with formulas (e.g., 1 mol H21 mol Mg\frac{1\text{ mol H}_2}{1\text{ mol Mg}}) rather than doing mental arithmetic on coefficients.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. nMg=0.0617157 moln_{\text{Mg}} = 0.0617157\text{ mol}

  2. nH2=0.0617157 mol Mg×1 mol H21 mol Mg=0.0617157 moln_{\text{H}_2} = 0.0617157\text{ mol Mg} \times \frac{1\text{ mol H}_2}{1\text{ mol Mg}} = 0.0617157\text{ mol}

  3. Theoretical yield of H2≈0.06172 mol\text{Theoretical yield of H}_2 \approx 0.06172\text{ mol}

Final answer

Isotopic mass of 26Mg=25.98 amu^{26}\text{Mg} = 25.98\text{ amu}; Theoretical yield of H2=0.06172 mol\text{H}_2 = 0.06172\text{ mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out complete conversion factors with chemical formulas included in the numerator and denominator.

  • Double-check that stoichiometric coefficients come directly from the two specific species being compared, ignoring spectator or excess species.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the mass of the major isotope ²⁴Mg instead of the average atomic mass of elemental magnesium when calculating moles of the sample.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Abundance of 26Mg=100.00%−78.99%−10.00%=11.01%  ⟹  24.305=(0.7899×23.985)+(0.1000×24.986)+(0.1101×m)  ⟹  24.305=21.4444+0.1101m  ⟹  m=25.98 amu\text{Abundance of }^{26}\text{Mg} = 100.00\% - 78.99\% - 10.00\% = 11.01\% \implies 24.305 = (0.7899 \times 23.985) + (0.1000 \times 24.986) + (0.1101 \times m) \implies 24.305 = 21.4444 + 0.1101m \implies m = 25.98\text{ amu}

  2. Step 2

    Moles of Mg=1.500 g23.985 g/mol=0.062539 mol\text{Moles of Mg} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{23.985\text{ g/mol}} = 0.062539\text{ mol}

    Correct

    nMg=1.500 g24.305 g/mol≈0.061716 moln_{\text{Mg}} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{24.305\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.061716\text{ mol}

    You used 23.985 g/mol23.985\text{ g/mol} (the isotopic mass of 24Mg^{24}\text{Mg}) as the molar mass. A naturally occurring sample of an element contains all its isotopes in their natural proportions, so you must use the weighted average atomic mass (24.305 g/mol24.305\text{ g/mol}) when converting grams to moles.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio of Mg to H2 is 1:1  ⟹  Theoretical yield of H2=0.06254 mol\text{Ratio of Mg to H}_2\text{ is } 1:1 \implies \text{Theoretical yield of H}_2 = 0.06254\text{ mol}

    Correct

    nH2=0.061716 mol×1 mol H21 mol Mg=0.06172 moln_{\text{H}_2} = 0.061716\text{ mol} \times \frac{1\text{ mol H}_2}{1\text{ mol Mg}} = 0.06172\text{ mol}

    Your stoichiometric mole ratio of 1:11:1 between Mg\text{Mg} and H2\text{H}_2 was correct, but the final yield was affected by the incorrect mole calculation in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the missing percent abundance of 26Mg^{26}\text{Mg} by subtracting the other isotopic abundances from 100%100\%.

You set up and evaluated the weighted average equation accurately to find m=25.98 amum = 25.98\text{ amu}.

You correctly recognized the 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio between Mg\text{Mg} and H2\text{H}_2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Used Isotope Mass Instead of Average Atomic Mass

You selected the mass of the most abundant isotope (23.985 g/mol23.985\text{ g/mol}) instead of the element's average atomic mass (24.305 g/mol24.305\text{ g/mol}) when calculating moles of magnesium.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating an individual isotope's mass with the macroscopic molar mass of a natural elemental sample. Macroscopic samples of naturally occurring elements are mixtures of all isotopes, so their molar mass is always the weighted average atomic mass from the periodic table.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Molar Mass Selection
  • For naturally occurring bulk elements, molar mass equals the weighted average atomic mass, never the mass of a single isotope.

  • Check whether the problem specifies a single pure isotope (e.g., 'pure 24Mg^{24}\text{Mg}') or bulk elemental magnesium; use the weighted average (24.305 g/mol24.305\text{ g/mol}) for bulk samples.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the moles of magnesium using the average atomic mass: nMg=1.500 g24.305 g/mol=0.0617157 moln_{\text{Mg}} = \frac{1.500\text{ g}}{24.305\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0617157\text{ mol}

  2. Apply the 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio from Mg(s)+2HCl(aq)→MgCl2(aq)+H2(g)\text{Mg}(s) + 2\text{HCl}(aq) \rightarrow \text{MgCl}_2(aq) + \text{H}_2(g): nH2=nMg=0.0617157 moln_{\text{H}_2} = n_{\text{Mg}} = 0.0617157\text{ mol}

  3. Round the theoretical yield of H2\text{H}_2 to four significant figures: 0.06172 mol0.06172\text{ mol}

Final answer

Isotopic mass of 26Mg=25.98 amu^{26}\text{Mg} = 25.98\text{ amu}; Theoretical yield of H2=0.06172 mol\text{H}_2 = 0.06172\text{ mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always look up or use the given average atomic mass whenever converting a bulk elemental sample between mass and moles.

  • Reserve specific isotopic masses strictly for nuclear reactions or mass spectrometry problems specifying an isotopically pure substance.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Naturally occurring chlorine consists of two stable isotopes: 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} (34.969 amu34.969\text{ amu}, 75.78%75.78\%) and 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} (36.966 amu36.966\text{ amu}, 24.22%24.22\%). Calculate the average atomic mass of chlorine to four significant figures.

Answer

35.45 amu35.45\text{ amu}. Calculation: (0.7578)(34.969 amu)+(0.2422)(36.966 amu)=26.4995+8.9532=35.4527 amu≈35.45 amu(0.7578)(34.969\text{ amu}) + (0.2422)(36.966\text{ amu}) = 26.4995 + 8.9532 = 35.4527\text{ amu} \approx 35.45\text{ amu}.

02

Silicon has three isotopes: 28Si^{28}\text{Si} (27.977 amu27.977\text{ amu}, 92.23%92.23\%), 29Si^{29}\text{Si} (28.976 amu28.976\text{ amu}, 4.68%4.68\%), and 30Si^{30}\text{Si}. If the average atomic mass of silicon is 28.086 amu28.086\text{ amu}, determine the isotopic mass of 30Si^{30}\text{Si} to four significant figures.

Answer

29.97 amu29.97\text{ amu}. Calculation: Abundance of 30Si=100.00%−92.23%−4.68%=3.09%^{30}\text{Si} = 100.00\% - 92.23\% - 4.68\% = 3.09\%. Equation: 28.086=(0.9223)(27.977)+(0.0468)(28.976)+(0.0309)(m)  ⟹  28.086=25.8032+1.3561+0.0309m  ⟹  0.0309m=0.9267  ⟹  m≈29.97 amu28.086 = (0.9223)(27.977) + (0.0468)(28.976) + (0.0309)(m) \implies 28.086 = 25.8032 + 1.3561 + 0.0309m \implies 0.0309m = 0.9267 \implies m \approx 29.97\text{ amu}.

03

A sample contains gallium isotopes 69Ga^{69}\text{Ga} (68.926 amu68.926\text{ amu}) and 71Ga^{71}\text{Ga} (70.925 amu70.925\text{ amu}). If the average atomic mass of gallium is 69.723 amu69.723\text{ amu}, find the percent abundance of 69Ga^{69}\text{Ga}. Then, determine how many moles of gallium atoms are present in a 4.881 g4.881\text{ g} sample of pure gallium.

Answer

60.13%60.13\% and 0.07000 mol0.07000\text{ mol}. Calculation: Let xx be the fraction of 69Ga^{69}\text{Ga}: 68.926x+70.925(1−x)=69.723  ⟹  −1.999x=−1.202  ⟹  x=0.601368.926x + 70.925(1-x) = 69.723 \implies -1.999x = -1.202 \implies x = 0.6013 (60.13%60.13\%). Moles in sample: n=4.881 g69.723 g/mol=0.07000 moln = \frac{4.881\text{ g}}{69.723\text{ g/mol}} = 0.07000\text{ mol}.

Loading workspace…