Resources
An environmental water quality laboratory receives a clear surface water sample containing dissolved calcium bicarbonate, , at a concentration of , along with suspended micro-particulate silica () at a concentration of (where in dilute aqueous solution). (a) Classify the untreated surface water sample as an element, a compound, a homogeneous mixture, or a heterogeneous mixture. (b) If the sample is passed through a membrane filter that removes of the suspended , classify the resulting filtrate. (c) Calculate the total mass in grams of pure dissolved in the sample, and determine whether this solute is an element or a compound.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The untreated surface water is a heterogeneous mixture (containing insoluble suspended solid particles dispersed in water). (b) The filtrate is a homogeneous mixture (a true aqueous solution of dissolved calcium and bicarbonate ions in water). (c) Total mass of dissolved ; is a compound composed of three different elements (calcium, carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen) chemically combined in fixed stoichiometric proportions.
Steps
Part (a): Classifying the Untreated Water Sample
-
Definitions of Matter Classes:
- A pure substance (element or compound) has a fixed, uniform chemical composition throughout.
- A mixture consists of two or more distinct substances physically combined rather than chemically bonded.
- A homogeneous mixture (solution) possesses a uniform composition and a single physical phase down to the molecular level.
- A heterogeneous mixture consists of physically distinct phases with non-uniform composition and visible boundaries or suspended particles.
-
Analysis of the Untreated Sample:
- The sample contains liquid water, dissolved ions from , and solid suspended micro-particles of .
- Because the solid silica particles () are insoluble and suspended rather than dissolved, the sample has distinct phases (solid particles dispersed in a liquid phase).
- Therefore, the untreated surface water is a heterogeneous mixture.
Part (b): Classifying the Filtrate
-
Effect of Filtration:
- Passing the sample through a membrane filter removes of the insoluble suspended micro-particulate .
- The resulting liquid (the filtrate) contains only water () and completely dissolved calcium and bicarbonate ions ( and ).
-
Classification:
- Because the dissolved ions are distributed uniformly at the molecular/ionic scale, the liquid exists entirely in a single phase with uniform properties throughout.
- A multi-component system existing as a single uniform phase is a solution, which is a homogeneous mixture.
Part (c): Calculating Solute Mass and Classifying the Solute
- Volume Conversion:
- Mass Calculation:
- Convert Mass to Grams:
-
Classifying the Solute ():
- An element consists of only one type of atom and cannot be broken down chemically into simpler substances.
- A compound consists of two or more different elements chemically combined in fixed stoichiometric proportions.
- Pure calcium bicarbonate, , contains four distinct chemical elements: calcium (), hydrogen (), carbon (), and oxygen (), chemically bonded in a fixed ratio of .
- Therefore, is a compound.
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse dissolved solutes with suspended solids. Dissolved particles exist as individual hydrated ions or molecules () that pass easily through membrane filters and do not settle, whereas suspended particles () create turbidity, scatter light, and can be mechanically filtered out.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the untreated water as a homogeneous mixture by focusing on its clear appearance and overlooking that suspended particles create a separate phase.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous mixture \n The sample is a clear liquid mixture of dissolved substances in water.
CorrectHeterogeneous mixture
Even though the sample appears clear to the eye, it contains suspended solid micro-particles of . Suspended particles represent a distinct solid phase dispersed within the liquid phase, which makes the untreated water a heterogeneous mixture rather than a solution.
- Step 2
Homogeneous mixture
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the filtered sample forms a single-phase homogeneous solution.
You accurately converted units and calculated the dissolved mass of as .
You correctly classified pure calcium bicarbonate as a compound composed of chemically bonded elements.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip was detected; your numerical arithmetic and unit conversions were completely correct.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on the macroscopic descriptor 'clear' to assume all components were dissolved solutes, overlooking that suspended micro-particles constitute a separate insoluble phase (a suspension) that makes the system heterogeneous.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Phase Boundaries vs. Dissolved Species
A homogeneous mixture must exist as a single uniform phase down to the molecular or ionic level. Insoluble or suspended particles form a separate phase.
Look specifically for keywords like 'suspended', 'particulate', 'precipitate', or 'colloid' in the problem statement, which indicate a multi-phase heterogeneous mixture regardless of macroscopic clarity.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify all components present in the untreated water: liquid water, dissolved and ions, and suspended solid particles.
Recognize that suspended solid particles are not dissolved and therefore constitute a distinct solid phase dispersed in the liquid.
Conclude that a mixture containing more than one physical phase is a heterogeneous mixture.
(a) Heterogeneous mixture; (b) Homogeneous mixture; (c) , compound
02 The student confuses a homogeneous mixture (solution) with a pure chemical compound because the filtered liquid appears uniform throughout.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Heterogeneous mixture ⟹ Suspended silica particles make it a two-phase mixture
- Step 2
ElementCompoundCorrectHomogeneous mixture
The filtrate contains dissolved uniformly distributed in liquid . Because it contains two distinct chemical substances physically combined into a single uniform phase, it is a solution (homogeneous mixture), not a single pure chemical compound.
- Step 3
V = 500.0 = 0.5000 m = 185 0.5000 = 92.5 = 0.0925
- Step 4
Compound
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the untreated water sample as a heterogeneous mixture due to the presence of suspended solid particles.
You converted the volume and concentration accurately to calculate the mass of dissolved solute in grams.
You correctly classified pure calcium bicarbonate as a chemical compound.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated a clear, uniform liquid containing dissolved ions and solvent as a single pure chemical substance rather than recognizing it as a physical solution (homogeneous mixture) composed of multiple distinct compounds.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pure Substance vs. Solution
A pure compound has a single fixed chemical formula (e.g., pure or pure ), whereas a homogeneous mixture (solution) consists of two or more distinct substances physically mixed uniformly in a single phase.
Ask yourself whether the clear liquid can be separated by physical means such as evaporation; if water evaporates to leave dissolved solid behind, it is a homogeneous mixture.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the components present in the filtrate after removing suspended : liquid water () and dissolved calcium bicarbonate ( and ions).
Check whether these substances are chemically bonded into a single new substance or physically mixed: they are physically mixed, with water molecules surrounding hydrated ions.
Determine the phase uniformity: the dissolved ions are distributed uniformly at the molecular scale, forming a single liquid phase.
Conclude that a uniform physical combination of two or more substances is a homogeneous mixture (solution).
Homogeneous mixture
03 The student fails to convert the volume from milliliters to liters or milligrams to grams, resulting in an answer that is off by a factor of 1000.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) Heterogeneous mixture Contains suspended solid particles and dissolved solute
- Step 2
b) Homogeneous mixture
- Step 3
c)
CorrectMultiplying concentration in by volume in yields mass in milligrams (), not grams (). You need to divide by to convert to .
- Step 4
d) Compound
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between heterogeneous mixtures, homogeneous mixtures, and chemical compounds.
You correctly converted the volume of the solution from to .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou carried the numerical value straight into grams instead of keeping the unit in milligrams and dividing by .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the unit attached to concentration () led to treating the calculated mass product directly as grams.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Track intermediate units explicitly
, not .
Always write down the units at each step: , then convert: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationMultiply concentration by volume: .
Convert milligrams to grams: .
Lock it in
What is the fundamental difference between a homogeneous mixture and a heterogeneous mixture?
A homogeneous mixture consists of a single uniform phase at the molecular level, while a heterogeneous mixture contains two or more distinct physical phases or visible boundaries.
Similar question
A laboratory preparation consists of of table sugar () thoroughly dissolved in of pure water at with no undissolved crystals remaining. (a) Classify this prepared liquid. (b) Classify pure sucrose itself as an element, compound, or mixture.
Answer
(a) Homogeneous mixture (a single-phase aqueous solution with uniform composition throughout). (b) Compound (sucrose consists of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen chemically bonded in a fixed atomic ratio).
An unopened bottle of sparkling mineral water contains dissolved carbon dioxide (), dissolved mineral salts, and liquid water under high pressure with no visible gas bubbles. When the cap is unscrewed, effervescence occurs and gas bubbles disperse throughout the liquid. Classify the system: (a) before opening, and (b) immediately after opening while bubbling.
Answer
(a) Before opening: Homogeneous mixture (all solutes are completely dissolved in a single liquid phase). (b) After opening: Heterogeneous mixture (a two-phase system consisting of gaseous bubbles dispersed throughout the aqueous liquid phase).
A wastewater sample contains dissolved zinc sulfate at a concentration of and an insoluble flocculant precipitate of . (a) Classify the raw wastewater. (b) Calculate the total mass in grams of pure zinc sulfate dissolved in the sample. (c) Classify the residue left behind on the filter paper after gravity filtration.
Answer
(a) Heterogeneous mixture (contains an insoluble solid precipitate dispersed in an aqueous solution). (b) of zinc sulfate. (c) The residue, , is an insoluble solid compound consisting of iron, oxygen, and hydrogen atoms chemically bonded in a fixed stoichiometric ratio.