Resources
A student tests the effect of adding an inert gas on the rate of the gas-phase reaction under two distinct conditions at constant temperature : Case A: Argon gas is injected into a rigid, closed container of fixed volume . Case B: Argon gas is injected into a flexible reaction vessel held at constant total pressure . Common student intuition suggests that in both cases, adding gas increases total system pressure, thereby increasing total collisions and accelerating the reaction rate. (a) Applying collision theory, state whether the reaction rate increases, decreases, or remains unchanged in Case A, and explain at the molecular level in terms of reactant collision frequency. (b) State whether the reaction rate increases, decreases, or remains unchanged in Case B, explaining in terms of reactant concentrations and collision frequency.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) In Case A, the reaction rate remains completely unchanged. Although Ar increases total pressure and total collision frequency, the volume is constant, so remains unchanged; collisions between and are chemically inert and do not alter the collision frequency between two molecules (); (b) In Case B, the reaction rate decreases. To maintain constant total pressure upon adding Ar, the volume must expand, which dilutes ; because the rate depends on collisions between reactant molecules (), the frequency of effective reactive collisions decreases.
Steps
Foundational Concept: Collision Theory and Reaction Rate
According to collision theory, the rate of a chemical reaction depends solely on the frequency of effective collisions between reactant molecules—collisions that possess energy greater than or equal to the activation energy () and proper molecular orientation:
where is the collision frequency per unit volume between reacting species, and is the fraction of collisions with sufficient energy and correct orientation. At a fixed temperature , remains constant. For the bimolecular elementary step or rate-determining collision between two molecules:
Collisions between a reactant molecule () and an inert gas atom () cannot lead to chemical transformation into and . Therefore, only the concentration of determines the rate of reaction.
Part (a): Case A — Rigid Container (Constant Volume )
- Effect on Concentration: Because the container is rigid, the volume is fixed. Adding does not change the amount of reactant moles, . Consequently, the molar concentration of the reactant remains unchanged:
- Effect on Collision Frequency and Rate: While the introduction of argon increases the total pressure and the overall number of gas-particle collisions ( and ), argon is chemically inert. The frequency of collisions between two molecules () depends solely on and temperature , both of which are constant.
- Conclusion: The reaction rate remains unchanged.
Common Pitfall: Believing that an increase in total pressure always increases reaction rate. An increase in pressure only increases the rate if it increases the partial pressure (or molar concentration) of the reactants.
Part (b): Case B — Flexible Vessel (Constant Total Pressure )
- Effect on Volume and Concentration: By Dalton's law and the ideal gas law: To maintain a constant total pressure when additional gas moles () are introduced at constant temperature , the volume of the flexible vessel must expand ().
- Effect on Collision Frequency and Rate: As the volume increases, the reactant is diluted: Because decreases, the average distance between molecules increases, directly reducing the frequency of collisions between reactant molecules:
- Conclusion: The reaction rate decreases.
Typical errors
01 The student believes that adding gas to a rigid container raises total pressure and overall collision frequency, wrongly assuming all collisions—including inert gas collisions—speed up the reaction.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Adding Ar to a fixed volume increases total pressure More gas molecules lead to a higher collision frequency Greater collision frequency causes more effective collisions Therefore, the reaction rate increases.
CorrectThe reaction rate remains unchanged. In a fixed volume , the concentration is constant. Although increases total collisions, collisions between and are chemically inert; the collision frequency between reactant molecules () is unchanged.
You correctly noted that total pressure and overall particle collisions increase, but reaction rate depends exclusively on the frequency of collisions between reactant molecules (). Collisions involving inert argon atoms do not possess reactive pathways and cannot form products.
- Step 2
In a flexible vessel at constant pressure, the volume must expand decreases because volume increases Lower concentration of reduces collisions between reactant molecules Therefore, the reaction rate decreases.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied the ideal gas relationship to determine that vessel volume must increase at constant total pressure.
You correctly linked the dilution of reactant concentration to a decrease in reactant-reactant collision frequency and reaction rate in Case B.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated total collision frequency with the frequency of effective collisions between reacting molecules, treating inert gas collisions as chemically active.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Reactant Concentration and Partial Pressure
Reaction rate depends only on the concentrations or partial pressures of the reacting species, not on total system pressure: .
Always evaluate whether the volume or moles of the actual reactants change before concluding how reaction rate is affected.
- Distinguish Inert Collisions from Reactive Collisions
Only collisions between reactant molecules with sufficient energy and correct orientation can lead to chemical change: .
Disregard collisions between reactants and spectator/inert species like noble gases when evaluating collision frequency in collision theory.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that volume and moles of reactant are both constant, so does not change.
Apply collision theory: the rate depends solely on bimolecular collisions between two reactant molecules, .
Recognize that while collisions occur, they cannot yield products because argon is chemically inert.
Conclude that because the frequency of reactant-reactant collisions is unchanged, the reaction rate remains unchanged.
(a) Remains unchanged; (b) Decreases.
02 The student assumes that because argon is chemically inert, it has no effect on reaction rate under any condition, overlooking the dilution caused by volume expansion at constant pressure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Volume is fixed, so moles of per unit volume is constant. Argon does not react with . Collision frequency between molecules remains unchanged. Therefore, the reaction rate remains unchanged.
- Step 2
Argon is an inert gas and does not take part in the reaction. Adding an unreactive gas does not change reactant properties. The collision frequency of reacting molecules is unaffected by inert gas.
CorrectAt constant total pressure in a flexible container, adding increases total moles of gas (). By the ideal gas law (), the volume must expand. This dilution lowers , thereby decreasing the collision frequency between molecules ().
You treated the chemical inertness of argon as meaning it has no physical effect on the system. Because the vessel has a flexible boundary at constant total pressure, adding gas forces the volume to expand, which decreases reactant concentration and lowers reactant collision frequency.
- Step 3
Therefore, the reaction rate remains unchanged.
CorrectTherefore, the reaction rate decreases.
Because your previous step missed the volume expansion and subsequent decrease in reactant collision frequency, your final conclusion for Case B was incorrect.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that inert gas atoms do not participate in reactive collisions.
You demonstrated that at fixed volume, reactant concentration remains constant and collision frequency between reactant molecules is unchanged.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that an inert gas cannot influence reaction rate under any condition, forgetting that under constant total pressure in a flexible container, adding more moles of gas forces the volume to expand, which dilutes the reactant species.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Boundary Condition Check
For a gas mixture, adding an inert gas at constant leaves reactant partial pressures and concentrations constant (), but adding an inert gas at constant forces volume to expand ().
Always identify whether the container is rigid (constant ) or flexible/piston-fitted (constant ) before evaluating concentration changes.
- Collision Frequency Dependence
Chemical reaction rate depends strictly on effective collisions between reactant molecules, with collision frequency proportional to reactant concentrations ().
Check how the volume change alters the concentration of the reactants before predicting the collision rate.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the ideal gas relationship for constant and : . Adding argon increases total moles, requiring the flexible vessel to expand ().
Calculate the effect on reactant concentration: , which decreases due to the expanded volume.
Apply collision theory: with fewer molecules per unit volume, the frequency of collisions between two molecules () decreases.
Conclude that with fewer reactant-reactant collisions per second, the overall reaction rate must decrease.
(a) Remains unchanged; (b) Decreases
Lock it in
Does adding an inert gas to a gas-phase reaction at constant volume change the reaction rate?
No, the rate remains unchanged. Volume is constant, so reactant concentrations and reactant-reactant collision frequencies are unaffected.
Similar question
An equimolar mixture of and reacts according to . Neon gas is added to the container at constant volume and temperature. Explain what happens to: (i) the total pressure, (ii) the partial pressure of , and (iii) the initial rate of reaction.
Answer
(i) Total pressure increases because additional gas moles are added to a fixed volume (). (ii) The partial pressure of remains unchanged because and neither , , nor changed. (iii) The reaction rate remains unchanged because the concentration of reactants and the frequency of collisions are unaffected by inert neon.
For the elementary reaction taking place in a piston-cylinder apparatus at constant temperature, argon is introduced while the piston moves freely to maintain a constant total pressure of . State whether the rate of production of increases, decreases, or remains the same, and justify your answer using collision theory.
Answer
The rate of production of decreases. To maintain constant total pressure upon adding argon, the piston must expand, increasing the total volume . This decreases the molar concentration of hydrogen iodide (). According to collision theory, the rate of a bimolecular collision is proportional to . Lower concentration reduces the collision frequency between molecules, thereby reducing the rate of effective reactive collisions.
A chemist claims: 'Compressing a reaction vessel by halving its volume speeds up a gas reaction because total pressure doubles. Therefore, doubling the total pressure by pumping in helium gas at fixed volume must also double the reaction rate.' Identify the flaw in this reasoning and contrast the two scenarios in terms of reactant molar concentrations.
Answer
The flaw is equating an increase in total pressure caused by volume reduction with an increase caused by adding an inert gas. Halving the volume doubles the concentration of all reactants (), which increases reactant-reactant collision frequency and accelerates the rate. In contrast, pumping in helium at fixed volume leaves the volume unchanged, so reactant concentrations () and reactant-reactant collision frequencies remain strictly constant, leaving the reaction rate unchanged.