Resources

To experimentally distinguish dynamic chemical equilibrium from a static unreactive state, an investigator prepares two systems at 298 K298\text{ K}: System A contains a stoichiometric mixture of H2(g)\text{H}_2(g) and O2(g)\text{O}_2(g) at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} in a sealed glass bulb without a catalyst. System B contains an equilibrated mixture of H2(g)\text{H}_2(g), I2(g)\text{I}_2(g), and HI(g)\text{HI}(g): H2(g)+I2(g)⇌2HI(g)\text{H}_2(g) + \text{I}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\text{HI}(g). In both systems, macroscopic pressures and gas compositions remain strictly invariant for months. (a) For System A, explain why macroscopic constancy reflects a kinetically frozen static state rather than dynamic equilibrium by referencing activation energy and reaction rates. (b) If deuterium gas (D2\text{D}_2) is spiked into both systems, predict the specific isotopic molecular species observed via mass spectrometry after 24 hours24\text{ hours} in System A versus System B.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) System A is kinetically trapped: the huge activation energy makes rfwd≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0 and rrev≈0r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0 (a static metastable state, not true equilibrium). (b) System A yields no isotopic scrambling: only unreacted D2\text{D}_2, H2\text{H}_2, and O2\text{O}_2 are detected. System B exhibits dynamic bidirectional exchange, producing mixed isotopic species including HD(g)\text{HD}(g) and DI(g)\text{DI}(g).

Steps

(a) Differentiating Kinetically Frozen Metastability from Dynamic Equilibrium

A system is at dynamic chemical equilibrium only when forward and reverse reactions proceed at non-zero, equal rates:

rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0

At true thermodynamic equilibrium, the chemical composition of a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen at 298 K298\text{ K} and 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} would overwhelmingly favor liquid water, because the standard Gibbs free energy change of formation is strongly negative (ΔG∘≪0\Delta G^\circ \ll 0):

2 HX2(g)+OX2(g)→2 HX2O(l)\ce{2H2(g) + O2(g) -> 2H2O(l)}

However, the reaction between HX2(g)\ce{H2(g)} and OX2(g)\ce{O2(g)} has an extremely high activation energy (EaE_{\text{a}}) at room temperature due to the very strong H−H\ce{H-H} and O=O\ce{O=O} covalent bonds. Because thermal energy (kBTk_{\text{B}}T) at 298 K298\text{ K} is insufficient to overcome this energy barrier without a spark or catalyst, virtually no molecules undergo reaction:

rfwd≈0andrrev≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0 \quad \text{and} \quad r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0

Because the rates are zero rather than equal and non-zero, the invariant composition in System A is not true dynamic equilibrium, but a kinetically trapped (metastable) or static non-reactive state.


(b) Isotopic Tracing Using Deuterium (DX2\ce{D2})

Isotopic labeling is an experimental technique used to test whether chemical bonds are actively breaking and reforming in a system:

  1. System A (Kinetically Frozen State):

    • Because rfwd≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0, no H−H\ce{H-H} or D−D\ce{D-D} bonds are cleaved, and no reaction occurs with OX2\ce{O2}.
    • No bond exchange or isotopic scrambling takes place.
    • Observed species: Only the unreacted parent gases are detected: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, and OX2\ce{O2}.
  2. System B (Dynamic Chemical Equilibrium):

    • System B is at true dynamic equilibrium:

      HX2(g)+IX2(g)⇌2 HI(g)\ce{H2(g) + I2(g) <=> 2HI(g)}

      where rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0.

    • Spiking with DX2\ce{D2} introduces a labeled reactant into an ongoing reversible cycle. The forward reaction consumes DX2\ce{D2} with IX2\ce{I2} to produce labeled deuterium iodide:

      DX2(g)+IX2(g)⇌2 DI(g)\ce{D2(g) + I2(g) <=> 2DI(g)}

    • In addition, the reverse breakdown of simultaneously formed or preexisting iodide species releases mixed dihydrogen:

      HI(g)+DI(g)⇌HD(g)+IX2(g)\ce{HI(g) + DI(g) <=> HD(g) + I2(g)}

    • Observed species: Due to continuous bond breaking and reformation, mass spectrometry detects mixed isotopic species, including HD(g)\ce{HD(g)} and DI(g)\ce{DI(g)}, alongside HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, IX2\ce{I2}, and HI\ce{HI}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets macroscopic constancy as proof of chemical equilibrium, erroneously claiming the forward and reverse rates are equal and non-zero rather than kinetically frozen at zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Because concentrations and pressure are constant, System A has reached dynamic equilibrium. The activation energy was overcome during initial mixing so rateforward=ratereverse>0\text{rate}_{\text{forward}} = \text{rate}_{\text{reverse}} > 0.

    Correct

    System A is in a kinetically frozen (metastable) static state. The activation energy (EaE_{\text{a}}) for breaking H−H\ce{H-H} and O=O\ce{O=O} bonds is far too high to be overcome at 298 K298\text{ K} without a catalyst or spark, meaning rfwd≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0 and rrev≈0r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0.

    Macroscopic constancy alone does not prove dynamic equilibrium. In System A, the reactions are not occurring at equal non-zero rates; rather, both forward and reverse rates are effectively zero due to a very high activation energy barrier.

  2. Step 2

    System A: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, HD\ce{HD}, OX2\ce{O2}, HX2O\ce{H2O}, DX2O\ce{D2O}, and HDO\ce{HDO} because dynamic equilibrium exchanges isotopes.

    Correct

    System A: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, and OX2\ce{O2}.

    Because this prediction followed from your earlier conclusion that System A is at dynamic equilibrium, you predicted isotopic scrambling. However, since the mixture is kinetically unreactive at 298 K298\text{ K}, no bonds break or reform, leaving only the unreacted parent gases.

  3. Step 3

    System B: HX2\ce{H2}, HD\ce{HD}, DX2\ce{D2}, IX2\ce{I2}, HI\ce{HI}, and DI\ce{DI}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that dynamic chemical equilibrium involves active bond breaking and reformation that produces scrambled isotopic species such as HD\ce{HD} and DI\ce{DI} in System B.

You accurately recalled that dynamic equilibrium requires equal, non-zero forward and reverse rates (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing static kinetic trapping with dynamic equilibrium

You assumed that merely mixing reactants at room temperature supplies enough thermal energy to overcome the activation energy barrier.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated constant macroscopic properties (pressure and concentration) as sufficient evidence of dynamic equilibrium, overlooking the possibility of a kinetically frozen state where reaction rates are zero.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dynamic vs. Static Constancy
  • A system with unchanging macroscopic properties can be either dynamically equilibrated (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0) or kinetically frozen/metastable (rfwd≈rrev≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0).

  • Check whether the activation energy is low enough for reactions to proceed at the specified temperature before concluding dynamic equilibrium.

Isotopic Labeling Test
  • An isotopic tracer like DX2\ce{D2} will only scramble into new molecules if bonds are actively breaking and reforming (r>0r > 0).

  • If a mixture is kinetically unreactive, list only the unreacted starting molecules and the added tracer without exchange products.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the activation energy of the 2 HX2+OX2→2 HX2O\ce{2H2 + O2 -> 2H2O} reaction at 298 K298\text{ K}: the strong covalent bonds give an extremely high EaE_{\text{a}}, so thermal collisions at room temperature cannot initiate reaction without a catalyst or ignition source.

  2. Deduce the rates: rfwd≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0 and rrev≈0r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0. Because the rates are zero rather than non-zero, System A is in a kinetically frozen static state.

  3. Apply the zero-rate condition to the DX2\ce{D2} spike in System A: with no bonds breaking, no reaction or isotopic exchange occurs, leaving only HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, and OX2\ce{O2}.

Final answer

(a) System A is a kinetically trapped static state because its high activation energy prevents reaction at 298 K298\text{ K} (rfwd≈rrev≈0r_{\text{fwd}} \approx r_{\text{rev}} \approx 0). (b) System A contains only HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, and OX2\ce{O2}; System B contains HX2\ce{H2}, HD\ce{HD}, DX2\ce{D2}, IX2\ce{I2}, HI\ce{HI}, and DI\ce{DI}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always verify whether a reaction mixture at constant pressure has actually initiated or is merely kinetically inhibited by a large EaE_{\text{a}}.

  • When working with isotopic tracing problems, confirm that bond cleavage is occurring before predicting scrambled products.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses dynamic equilibrium with a static 'completed' state, failing to recognize that ongoing forward and reverse reactions in System B scramble isotopes into mixed species such as HD and DI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    System A has a very high activation energy at 298 K298\text{ K}, so forward and reverse reaction rates are zero. Because neither reaction occurs, the system is kinetically frozen rather than in dynamic equilibrium.

  2. Step 2

    System A: HX2\ce{H2}, OX2\ce{O2}, and DX2\ce{D2} because no reaction occurs.

  3. Step 3

    System B: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, IX2\ce{I2}, and HI\ce{HI} only, because equilibrium is already reached so no new species can form.

    Correct

    System B: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, HD\ce{HD}, IX2\ce{I2}, HI\ce{HI}, and DI\ce{DI} due to ongoing forward and reverse reactions (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0).

    Dynamic equilibrium does not mean reactions have stopped. Forward and reverse reactions continue at equal, non-zero rates. The spiked DX2\ce{D2} reacts with IX2\ce{I2} to produce DI\ce{DI}, and subsequent reversible reactions generate mixed HD\ce{HD}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly linked high activation energy to zero reaction rates to define a kinetically frozen state.

You accurately deduced that no isotopic scrambling can occur in a non-reactive mixture.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Dynamic Equilibrium with Static Invariance

You assumed that because macroscopic concentrations are constant at equilibrium, microscopic bond breaking and formation have permanently stopped.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Equilibrium is dynamic (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0), meaning molecules continually react and exchange atoms. Introducing an isotopic label like DX2\ce{D2} participates in these active forward and reverse pathways, resulting in scrambled isotopic products such as HD\ce{HD} and DI\ce{DI}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dynamic vs. Static Rates
  • A static state has rfwd=rrev=0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} = 0; dynamic equilibrium has rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0.

  • Always verify whether microscopic bond breaking and reforming are actively taking place even if macroscopic concentrations do not change.

Isotopic Tracing in Reversible Reactions
  • Spiking an isotopic tracer into a dynamic equilibrium incorporates the isotope into all species participating in the forward and reverse reaction cycles.

  • Track elementary bond-cleavage and reformation steps to identify all resulting scrambled isotopologues.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that System B maintains active forward and reverse reaction pathways: HX2+IX2⇌2 HI\ce{H2 + I2 <=> 2HI} where rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0.

  2. React the added DX2\ce{D2} with existing IX2\ce{I2} via the forward pathway to form DI\ce{DI}: DX2+IX2⇌2 DI\ce{D2 + I2 <=> 2DI}.

  3. Combine reverse decomposition steps (e.g., HI+DI⇌HD+IX2\ce{HI + DI <=> HD + I2}) to produce mixed dihydrogen molecules, HD\ce{HD}.

  4. List all resulting molecular species detected in the mixture.

Final answer

System A: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, and OX2\ce{O2}. System B: HX2\ce{H2}, DX2\ce{D2}, HD\ce{HD}, IX2\ce{I2}, HI\ce{HI}, and DI\ce{DI}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the microscopic definition of dynamic chemical equilibrium (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0).

  • Practice tracing isotope distribution through forward and reverse reactions in equilibrium systems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sealed flask contains gaseous diamond-forming reactants (or solid diamond and graphite) at 298 K298\text{ K} and 1 atm1\text{ atm}. Diamond is thermodynamically unstable relative to graphite (ΔG∘<0\Delta G^\circ < 0), yet no conversion is observed over several years. Classify this state as dynamic equilibrium or kinetically trapped, and explain using activation energy and rates.

Answer

Kinetically trapped (metastable). The conversion of diamond to graphite requires breaking rigid, strong carbon–carbon covalent bonds, leading to an extremely high activation energy (EaE_{\text{a}}). Consequently, the conversion rate is virtually zero at 298 K298\text{ K} (r≈0r \approx 0), rather than opposing forward and reverse processes occurring at equal non-zero rates.

02

Two closed containers at 300 K300\text{ K} show constant pressure: Container 1 holds NX2(g)\ce{N2(g)} and HX2(g)\ce{H2(g)} without a catalyst; Container 2 holds NOX2(g)\ce{NO2(g)} and NX2OX4(g)\ce{N2O4(g)} at equilibrium (2 NOX2⇌NX2OX4\ce{2NO2 <=> N2O4}). A small amount of 15N^{15}\ce{N}-labeled ammonia (15NHX3^{15}\ce{NH3}) is injected into Container 1, and 15NOX2^{15}\ce{NO2} is injected into Container 2. In which container, if either, will isotopic exchange into other species occur within 1 hour? Identify the species formed.

Answer

Isotopic exchange occurs only in Container 2. Container 1 is kinetically frozen due to the enormous N≡N\ce{N#N} triple bond activation barrier without a catalyst, so 15NHX3^{15}\ce{NH3}, NX2\ce{N2}, and HX2\ce{H2} remain unreacted. In Container 2, dynamic equilibrium is active (rfwd=rrev>0r_{\text{fwd}} = r_{\text{rev}} > 0), so rapid reversible association/dissociation incorporates 15N^{15}\ce{N} into nitrogen tetroxide, forming 15NNOX4^{15}\ce{N}\ce{NO4} (or mixed-isotope NX2OX4\ce{N2O4}).

03

A researcher investigates the reaction AX2(g)+BX2(g)⇌2 AB(g)\ce{A2(g) + B2(g) <=> 2AB(g)}. Mixture X (unreactive without catalyst) and Mixture Y (equilibrated with catalyst) both show constant partial pressures of AX2\ce{A2} and BX2\ce{B2}. If an isotopically pure tracer AX2∗\ce{A^*_2} is added, derive the differential rate equation for the initial rate of appearance of the mixed species AAX∗\ce{AA^*} in terms of the forward rate constant kfwdk_{\text{fwd}} and reactant concentrations, and contrast its value between Mixture X and Mixture Y.

Answer

For a dynamic bimolecular exchange AX2∗+BX2→2 AX∗B\ce{A^*2 + B2 -> 2A^*B} followed by reversible exchange or direct scrambling, the rate of AAX∗\ce{AA^*} formation is directly proportional to the active forward exchange rate: (d[AAX∗]dt)0=2kexchange[AX2∗][AX2]\left(\frac{d[\ce{AA^*}]}{dt}\right)_0 = 2 k_{\text{exchange}} [\ce{A^*2}][\ce{A2}] (or via intermediate AB\ce{AB}). In Mixture Y, active forward and reverse reaction yields a positive rate (d[AAX∗]dt)0>0\left(\frac{d[\ce{AA^*}]}{dt}\right)_0 > 0. In Mixture X, because kfwd≈0k_{\text{fwd}} \approx 0 due to high EaE_{\text{a}} without catalyst, (d[AAX∗]dt)0=0\left(\frac{d[\ce{AA^*}]}{dt}\right)_0 = 0.

Loading workspace…