Resources

A student attempts to write the net ionic equation for the reaction between solid nickel metal and aqueous iron(III) chloride, FeCl3 (aq)\text{FeCl}_3\,(\text{aq}). The student incorrectly cancels the spectator ions and writes: Ni (s)+Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + \text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + \text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}). (a) Identify the violation of conservation laws in the student's equation and explain the sign/charge balance trap. (b) Write the fully balanced, charge-conserving net ionic equation. (c) Write the net ionic equation if excess nickel completely reduces iron(III) all the way to metallic iron, Fe (s)\text{Fe}\,(\text{s}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The equation violates conservation of charge (reactant net charge is +3+3, while product net charge is +2+2=+4+2 + 2 = +4); (b) Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}); (c) 3Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→3Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe (s)3\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow 3\text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}\,(\text{s}).

Steps

Part (a): Identifying the Violation and the Charge Trap

Every valid chemical equation must obey two fundamental conservation laws:

  1. Conservation of Mass (Atom Balance): The number of atoms of each element must be identical on both sides of the equation.
  2. Conservation of Charge: The total electrical charge on the reactant side must equal the total electrical charge on the product side.

Looking at the student's proposed equation: Ni(s)+FeX3+(aq)→NiX2+(aq)+FeX2+(aq)\ce{Ni (s) + Fe^3+ (aq) -> Ni^2+ (aq) + Fe^2+ (aq)}

  • Atom count: 1 Ni1\text{ Ni} atom on each side, and 1 Fe1\text{ Fe} atom on each side. Atoms appear balanced.
  • Total charge on reactants: 0+(+3)=+30 + (+3) = +3.
  • Total charge on products: (+2)+(+2)=+4(+2) + (+2) = +4.

Because +3≠+4+3 \neq +4, the equation violates the conservation of charge.

The Common Trap: Learners often balance only atom counts and overlook that electrons transferred in oxidation must equal electrons gained in reduction:

  • Nickel is oxidized from 00 to +2+2 (loss of 2 e−2\text{ e}^-): Ni(s)→NiX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Ni (s) -> Ni^2+ (aq) + 2e^-}
  • Iron is reduced from +3+3 to +2+2 (gain of only 1 e−1\text{ e}^-): FeX3+(aq)+eX−→FeX2+(aq)\ce{Fe^3+ (aq) + e^- -> Fe^2+ (aq)}

Writing a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio creates a "free" electron out of nowhere, violating the conservation of charge.


Part (b): Balancing the Net Ionic Equation for Reduction to FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+}

To balance charge and electron transfer, multiply the reduction half-reaction by 22 so that the number of electrons gained matches the 2 e−2\text{ e}^- lost by nickel:

1×[Ni(s)→NiX2+(aq)+2 eX−]1 \times [\ce{Ni (s) -> Ni^2+ (aq) + 2e^-}] 2×[FeX3+(aq)+eX−→FeX2+(aq)]2 \times [\ce{Fe^3+ (aq) + e^- -> Fe^2+ (aq)}]

Adding the two half-reactions together cancels the 2 e−2\text{ e}^-: Ni(s)+2 FeX3+(aq)→NiX2+(aq)+2 FeX2+(aq)\ce{Ni (s) + 2Fe^3+ (aq) -> Ni^2+ (aq) + 2Fe^2+ (aq)}

  • Verification of Charge: Reactants: 0+2(+3)=+6\text{Reactants: } 0 + 2(+3) = +6 Products: (+2)+2(+2)=+6\text{Products: } (+2) + 2(+2) = +6 The equation is balanced in both mass and charge.

Part (c): Reduction of Iron(III) to Metallic Iron, Fe(s)\ce{Fe(s)}

When excess nickel reduces iron(III) completely to elemental iron, Fe(s)\ce{Fe(s)}:

  • Oxidation half-reaction: Ni(s)→NiX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Ni (s) -> Ni^2+ (aq) + 2e^-}
  • Reduction half-reaction: FeX3+(aq)+3 eX−→Fe(s)\ce{Fe^3+ (aq) + 3e^- -> Fe (s)}

To equalize the electrons transferred, find the least common multiple of 22 and 33, which is 66:

  • Multiply the nickel oxidation by 33 (6 e−6\text{ e}^- lost): 3Ni(s)→3 NiX2+(aq)+6 eX−3\ce{Ni (s) -> 3Ni^2+ (aq) + 6e^-}
  • Multiply the iron reduction by 22 (6 e−6\text{ e}^- gained): 2FeX3+(aq)+6 eX−→2 Fe(s)2\ce{Fe^3+ (aq) + 6e^- -> 2Fe (s)}

Combine the half-reactions to obtain the net ionic equation: 3 Ni(s)+2 FeX3+(aq)→3 NiX2+(aq)+2 Fe(s)\ce{3Ni (s) + 2Fe^3+ (aq) -> 3Ni^2+ (aq) + 2Fe (s)}

  • Verification of Charge: Reactants: 3(0)+2(+3)=+6\text{Reactants: } 3(0) + 2(+3) = +6 Products: 3(+2)+2(0)=+6\text{Products: } 3(+2) + 2(0) = +6

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student balances the total charge by multiplying the iron(III) ion instead of the iron(II) product, creating an equation that violates both mass balance and charge conservation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Reactants have charge +3+3 and products have charge +2++2=+4  ⟹  +2 + +2 = +4 \implies Charge is not conserved because the total charge on each side is different.

  2. Step 2

    Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + \text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq})

    Correct

    Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq})

    You correctly realized that two Fe3+\text{Fe}^{3+} ions are required to accept the two electrons lost by nickel, but you did not balance the iron on the product side. Without a coefficient of 22 in front of Fe2+\text{Fe}^{2+}, the equation has 2 Fe2\text{ Fe} on the left, 1 Fe1\text{ Fe} on the right, and charges of +6+6 versus +4+4.

  3. Step 3

    3Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→3Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe (s)3\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow 3\text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}\,(\text{s})

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately identified that the original equation violated the conservation of charge.

You correctly balanced both mass and charge when reducing iron(III) to solid iron in part (c).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unbalanced Product Ion in Redox Stoichiometry

You adjusted the reactant coefficient for the electron acceptor to 2Fe3+2\text{Fe}^{3+} but forgot to carry the factor of 22 to the reduced iron species Fe2+\text{Fe}^{2+} on the product side.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating electron-accounting coefficients as one-sided adjustments rather than multiplying the entire reduction half-reaction (extFe3++e−→Fe2+ ext{Fe}^{3+} + \text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{Fe}^{2+}) by 22.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Half-Reaction Multipliers Apply to Both Sides
  • When scaling a half-reaction to equalize transferred electrons, multiply every species—reactants, electrons, and products—by that factor.

  • Multiply Fe3++e−→Fe2+\text{Fe}^{3+} + \text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{Fe}^{2+} entirely by 22 to get 2Fe3++2e−→2Fe2+2\text{Fe}^{3+} + 2\text{e}^- \rightarrow 2\text{Fe}^{2+}.

Dual Conservation Check
  • Every net ionic equation must satisfy both atom conservation and total net charge conservation.

  • Always verify that total reactant charge equals total product charge before finishing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the oxidation half-reaction: Ni (s)→Ni2+ (aq)+2e−\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{e}^-.

  2. Write the reduction half-reaction: Fe3+ (aq)+e−→Fe2+ (aq)\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) + \text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}).

  3. Multiply the reduction half-reaction by 22: 2Fe3+ (aq)+2e−→2Fe2+ (aq)2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{e}^- \rightarrow 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}).

  4. Combine both half-reactions so the electrons cancel: Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}).

Final answer

Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out explicit half-reactions with electrons whenever you are balancing redox net ionic equations.

  • Always perform a final two-step check on your finished equation: count atoms of each element first, then sum the total formal charge on each side.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes complete reduction in part (c) still produces equal 1:1 molar stoichiometry for Ni and Fe, forgetting to equalize the 2-electron oxidation and 3-electron reduction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Charge is not conserved: reactant side has +3 and product side has +4. The number of electrons transferred does not balance even though atoms match 1:1.\text{Charge is not conserved: reactant side has }+3\text{ and product side has }+4.\text{ The number of electrons transferred does not balance even though atoms match }1:1.

  2. Step 2

    Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq})

  3. Step 3

    Ni (s)+Fe3+ (aq)→Ni2+ (aq)+Fe (s)\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + \text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + \text{Fe}\,(\text{s})

    Correct

    3Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→3Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe (s)3\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow 3\text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}\,(\text{s})

    Your equation balances the metal atoms 1:11:1, but the charges do not match (reactants are +3+3, products are +2+2). Because each Ni\text{Ni} loses 2 e−2\text{ e}^- and each Fe3+\text{Fe}^{3+} gains 3 e−3\text{ e}^-, you must balance through the lowest common multiple of electrons transferred (6 e−6\text{ e}^-).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the given reaction violated the law of conservation of charge.

You accurately balanced the net ionic equation for the reduction to iron(II) in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unbalanced Charge in Redox Net Ionic Equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You relied on a 1:1 atom ratio in part (c) without checking that the total electrons lost by the reducing agent must equal the total electrons gained by the oxidizing agent.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Balancing Half-Reactions by Electron Count
  • In any redox reaction, the total number of electrons lost in oxidation must equal the total number of electrons gained in reduction.

  • Write the two half-reactions with their electrons, find the least common multiple of electrons, and multiply each half-reaction accordingly before combining.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the oxidation half-reaction: Ni (s)→Ni2+ (aq)+2e−\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{e}^-.

  2. Write the reduction half-reaction: Fe3+ (aq)+3e−→Fe (s)\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) + 3\text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{Fe}\,(\text{s}).

  3. Find the least common multiple between 2 e−2\text{ e}^- and 3 e−3\text{ e}^-, which is 6 e−6\text{ e}^-.

  4. Multiply the oxidation half-reaction by 33 and the reduction half-reaction by 22: 3Ni (s)→3Ni2+ (aq)+6e−3\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) \rightarrow 3\text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 6\text{e}^- and 2Fe3+ (aq)+6e−→2Fe (s)2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) + 6\text{e}^- \rightarrow 2\text{Fe}\,(\text{s}).

  5. Add the half-reactions and cancel the 6 e−6\text{ e}^- on both sides.

Final answer

3Ni (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→3Ni2+ (aq)+2Fe (s)3\text{Ni}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow 3\text{Ni}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}\,(\text{s})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out both half-reactions including electrons when dealing with redox net ionic equations.

  • Verify both atom conservation and total net charge conservation on both sides before finalizing your equation.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Balance the following net ionic redox equation: Zn (s)+Ag+ (aq)→Zn2+ (aq)+Ag (s)\text{Zn}\,(\text{s}) + \text{Ag}^+\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Zn}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + \text{Ag}\,(\text{s}).

Answer

Zn (s)+2Ag+ (aq)→Zn2+ (aq)+2Ag (s)\text{Zn}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Ag}^+\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Zn}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Ag}\,(\text{s}). Zn\text{Zn} loses 2 e−2\,\text{e}^-, so 2 Ag+2\,\text{Ag}^+ ions are required to balance electrons and charge (+2+2 on each side).

02

Solid tin metal reacts with aqueous iron(III) ions to produce tin(II) ions and iron(II) ions. Write the balanced net ionic equation.

Answer

Sn (s)+2Fe3+ (aq)→Sn2+ (aq)+2Fe2+ (aq)\text{Sn}\,(\text{s}) + 2\text{Fe}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow \text{Sn}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) + 2\text{Fe}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}). Oxidation: Sn→Sn2++2e−\text{Sn} \rightarrow \text{Sn}^{2+} + 2\text{e}^-. Reduction: 2(Fe3++e−→Fe2+)2(\text{Fe}^{3+} + \text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{Fe}^{2+}). Summing gives net charge +6+6 on both sides.

03

Solid aluminum reacts with aqueous copper(II) sulfate. Write the fully balanced net ionic equation, showing mass and charge conservation.

Answer

2Al (s)+3Cu2+ (aq)→2Al3+ (aq)+3Cu (s)2\text{Al}\,(\text{s}) + 3\text{Cu}^{2+}\,(\text{aq}) \rightarrow 2\text{Al}^{3+}\,(\text{aq}) + 3\text{Cu}\,(\text{s}). Oxidation loses 3 e−3\,\text{e}^- (multiplied by 22 to give 6 e−6\,\text{e}^-), reduction gains 2 e−2\,\text{e}^- (multiplied by 33 to give 6 e−6\,\text{e}^-). Net charge on each side is +6+6.

Loading workspace…