Resources
A saturated solution of silver sulfate, , is at dynamic equilibrium with solid precipitate at (). A student predicts that adding of solid sodium nitrate, , will cause additional to precipitate due to Le Chatelier's principle. Evaluate this prediction using chemical equilibrium principles and the ionic strength/common-ion concept. Furthermore, determine quantitatively what happens to the solubility of if is added instead, by calculating the molar solubility of in pure water versus in .
Answer and steps
Final answer
The student's prediction is incorrect: and are spectator ions that do not participate in the equilibrium (the diverse-ion/salt effect slightly increases solubility rather than causing precipitation). Molar solubility in pure water is , whereas in , the common ion suppresses solubility to .
Steps
Evaluate the Student's Prediction (Effect of Adding )
The dissolution equilibrium for silver sulfate is:
When solid sodium nitrate () dissolves, it dissociates completely into and ions:
- Common-ion consideration: Neither nor is part of the equilibrium expression (). Therefore, there is no common ion to shift the equilibrium to the left via Le Chatelier's principle.
- Ionic strength and diverse-ion (salt) effect: Introducing inert ions increases the ionic strength of the solution. The ionic atmosphere screens the electrostatic attraction between dissolved and ions, decreasing their activity coefficients (). To maintain the thermodynamic equilibrium constant, more solid dissolves rather than precipitating.
Conclusion: The student's prediction is incorrect. Adding will not cause precipitation; instead, it slightly increases the solubility of .
Calculate the Molar Solubility of in Pure Water
Let represent the molar solubility of in pure water in units of ().
From stoichiometry:
Substitute these concentrations into the solubility product expression:
Given :
Calculate the Molar Solubility in
When dissolved in a solution already containing , the silver ion is a common ion.
fully dissociates to provide an initial concentration .
Let be the new molar solubility of :
Substitute these into the expression:
Assuming :
Comparison and Pitfall Note
- In pure water, the molar solubility is .
- In the presence of , the molar solubility is reduced to due to the common-ion effect.
- Common Pitfall: Conflating inert electrolytes (like ) with common-ion sources (like ). An electrolyte only reduces solubility via Le Chatelier's principle if it supplies an ion already present in the equilibrium expression.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies NaNO3 as causing a common-ion effect and falsely concludes that increased ionic strength causes precipitation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
dissociates into and . Neither ion is a common ion, but adding ions increases total concentration. Le Chatelier's principle shifts the reaction left toward precipitate to reduce total ions. Therefore, the student's prediction that more precipitates is correct.
CorrectNeither nor appears in the solubility expression , so the reaction quotient is unaffected by their presence. Furthermore, adding an inert electrolyte increases ionic strength, screening the charges of and and lowering their activity coefficients (), which slightly increases solubility (the salt effect). Therefore, the prediction is incorrect.
You correctly noted that neither nor is a common ion, but Le Chatelier's principle does not shift a solution equilibrium simply to reduce total spectator ion concentration. Instead, increasing ionic strength decreases ion activities and slightly increases solubility rather than causing precipitation.
- Step 2
- Step 3
In , . Solubility decreases in due to the common-ion effect.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly formulated the solubility product expression and accurately calculated the solubility in pure water as .
You correctly identified as a common ion from and calculated the reduced solubility as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated total ionic concentration with the concentrations of active equilibrium species, assuming Le Chatelier's principle shifts an aqueous dissolution equilibrium to reduce non-participating spectator ions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check species in the equilibrium expression
Only chemical species present in the reaction quotient can directly shift an equilibrium via Le Chatelier's principle.
Write out and verify whether the added ions are part of the expression.
- Evaluate ionic strength (diverse-ion effect)
Adding an inert electrolyte increases ionic strength, which stabilizes dissolved ions through ionic atmospheres and slightly increases solubility.
Identify inert salts (like ) as spectators that cause a mild increase in solubility, never precipitation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine if the added ions appear in the equilibrium: . The ions from are and , neither of which appears in .
Assess the effect on : Because and remain unchanged initially, , so no precipitation occurs via Le Chatelier's principle.
Apply the diverse-ion effect: Increased ionic strength lowers the activity coefficients of and , slightly increasing the solubility of .
The student's prediction is incorrect: and are spectator ions that do not shift the equilibrium toward precipitation (the diverse-ion effect slightly increases solubility). Molar solubility in pure water is , whereas in , the common ion suppresses solubility to .
02 The student forgets the stoichiometric coefficient of 2 when writing the Ksp expression in pure water, using s^2 instead of 4s^3.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student is incorrect because and are inert ions and do not share a common ion with . Adding increases ionic strength, lowering activity coefficients and increasing solubility via the diverse-ion effect.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly wrote the dissolution equation, but in the expression, the stoichiometric coefficient of for must appear both as an exponent on and as a factor in , yielding rather than .
- Step 3
0.050 3, [^+] = 0.050 K{sp} = (0.050)(s') = 1.4 10^{-5} s' = = 2.8 10^{-4}$
CorrectYou correctly recognized that supplies initial , but this calculation carried forward the missing square on , using instead of .
- Step 4
3.7 10^{-3} 2.8 10^{-4}.
Correct1.5 10^{-2} 5.6 10^{-3}.
Your qualitative conclusion that solubility decreases is correct, but the numerical values reflect the errors propagated from Steps 2 and 3.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly distinguished spectator ions from common ions and provided a thorough explanation of ionic strength and the diverse-ion effect.
You correctly balanced the dissolution equilibrium equation for silver sulfate.
You correctly identified silver ion as the common ion introduced by silver nitrate.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the stoichiometric ratio of silver sulfate as instead of when setting up the mass-action equilibrium law.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the rule that stoichiometric coefficients in a balanced chemical equation must become exponents in the equilibrium constant expression ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Writing $K_{sp}$ Expressions
For a salt , .
Always write out the general law of mass action with explicit exponents before substituting concentrations or variables.
- Expressing Ion Concentrations in Pure Water
When moles of dissolve per liter, and , making .
Ensure stoichiometric multipliers are applied inside the parentheses before raising to the power of the coefficient.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the complete mass-action expression: .
Substitute and to get .
Solve for in pure water: .
Substitute into the common-ion expression with : .
Solve for in : .
The molar solubility of is in pure water and decreases to in due to the common-ion effect.
03 The student squares the entire [Ag+] term including an extra factor of 2 (setting [Ag+] = 2(0.050)) when setting up the common-ion equilibrium.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The prediction is incorrect because contains neither nor . Increasing ionic strength decreases activity coefficients, which increases the solubility of .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Each formula unit of dissociates into only one ion, so . You incorrectly multiplied the concentration of the common ion by , confusing the subscript in with the dissociation of .
- Step 4Correct
Your algebraic solving and qualitative conclusion were carried out cleanly, but the numerical answer is off due to using from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly explained why adding an inert salt does not shift the equilibrium to precipitate solid via Le Chatelier's principle.
You correctly set up and solved the relationship for pure water.
You correctly squared the term in the expression.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou crossed out the correct initial concentration of and replaced it with .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the stoichiometric coefficient of in the insoluble salt's equilibrium () with the concentration of supplied by the soluble salt (). Stoichiometric multipliers apply only to terms derived from dissolving unknown solid (), not to fixed concentrations from completely dissociated 1:1 salts.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check the source formula of the common ion
For a strong electrolyte , .
Since has , a solution provides exactly , never .
- Separate initial concentration from stoichiometric shift
In equilibrium: . The stoichiometric factor belongs only to the dissolved change term ().
Write , then plug into the squared position in .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine initial silver ion concentration: .
Express equilibrium concentrations: , and .
Substitute into : .
Solve for : .
The molar solubility of in is .
Lock it in
Does adding an inert, non-reacting soluble salt (like ) to a saturated solution of a sparingly soluble salt cause precipitation via Le Chatelier's principle?
No. Le Chatelier's principle only applies to species in the equilibrium expression; inert ions increase ionic strength and slightly increase solubility (salt effect).
Similar question
A saturated solution of calcium fluoride, (), is at equilibrium with solid precipitate. Predict whether adding of solid will cause more to precipitate, dissolve, or remain unchanged, and explain your reasoning.
Answer
More will dissolve (solubility slightly increases). Key steps: and are inert ions not present in . Adding raises ionic strength, reducing activity coefficients and shielding dissolved ions, which favors further dissolution rather than precipitation.
Calculate the molar solubility of lead(II) iodide, (), in (a) pure water and (b) a solution.
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Key steps: In pure water, . In , , so .
Equal volumes of saturated solution and solution are mixed (assume no volume change on mixing). Explain two competing effects on : the physical dilution effect and the ionic strength effect. State whether additional precipitates or dissolves.
Answer
Additional dissolves. Key steps: (1) Dilution halves and , making , driving dissolution. (2) Adding raises ionic strength, further stabilizing ions via the salt effect. Both effects favor dissolution; no precipitation occurs.