Resources
Using Coulomb's law and the ionic lattice model, compare the lattice energies of sodium fluoride () and magnesium oxide (). The internuclear separation (sum of ionic radii) is approximately for (, ) and for (, ). Explain which compound has a significantly higher melting point, and calculate the approximate theoretical ratio of the electrostatic lattice attraction of to using the simplified Coulombic potential energy relation .
Answer and steps
Final answer
has a significantly higher melting point than . The calculated electrostatic attraction ratio .
Steps
Apply Coulomb's Law to the Ionic Lattice Model
According to Coulomb's law, the electrostatic potential energy (and thus the lattice energy, ) holding oppositely charged ions together in a crystal lattice is directly proportional to the product of the ionic charges and inversely proportional to the internuclear distance:
where:
- and represent the charges of the cation and anion in units of elementary charge.
- is the equilibrium internuclear distance (separation between ionic centers).
Compare the Parameters for and
Both compounds adopt the same face-centered cubic (-type) crystal structure, making their Madelung constants and coordination geometries directly comparable:
-
For :
- Ion charges: () and (), so .
- Internuclear distance: .
-
For :
- Ion charges: () and (), so .
- Internuclear distance: .
Calculate the Ratio of Electrostatic Lattice Energies
Substitute the parameters into the ratio of the Coulombic lattice energies:
Simplify the fraction:
The electrostatic attraction in is roughly times greater than in . Notice that the primary contributor to this large difference is the fourfold increase in the charge factor ( versus ), supplemented slightly by the shorter interionic distance in .
Relate Lattice Energy to Melting Point
Melting an ionic solid requires breaking the strong electrostatic forces holding ions in fixed lattice positions:
- A significantly higher lattice energy means much more thermal kinetic energy is required to overcome the ionic attractions and disrupt the lattice.
- Because has a lattice energy over four times that of , has a significantly higher melting point () compared to ().
Common Pitfall: When comparing lattice energies, students often focus solely on ionic radii. While smaller ionic radius does increase lattice energy by decreasing , the product of the ionic charges has a far greater numerical impact and is typically the dominant factor.
Typical errors
01 The student sums the absolute ionic charges instead of multiplying them when applying Coulomb's law, leading to an incorrect charge factor and underestimated ratio.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
E_{} \propto _
CorrectCoulomb's law dictates that electrostatic potential energy is proportional to the product of the two interacting charges, , not their sum.
- Step 2
\ce{MgO}$$\text{, charge sum is } |+2| + |-2| = 4 r_0 = 212 \Longrightarrow \ce{NaF}$$\text{, charge sum is } |+1| + |-1| = 2 r_0 = 231
Correct\ce{MgO}$$\text{: } |z_+ z_-| = |(+2)(-2)| = 4, \ r_0 = 212 \Longrightarrow \ce{NaF}$$\text{: } |z_+ z_-| = |(+1)(-1)| = 1, \ r_0 = 231
Because you summed the charges, you assigned a charge factor of instead of the correct product .
- Step 3
\ce{MgO}$$\text{ has greater charge and smaller distance, so } \ce{MgO}$$\text{ has a significantly higher melting point.}
- Step 4
= = = = = 2.18
Correct= = 4 = 4.36
Your algebraic simplification was carried out accurately based on your values, but the carryover of the charge factor for halved the final ratio from to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly linked lattice energy directly to the melting point of ionic crystals.
You correctly identified the ionic charges and equilibrium internuclear distances for both compounds.
You correctly deduced that exhibits a higher melting point due to larger charges and smaller separation.
You executed the arithmetic and fraction reduction accurately according to your setup.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote an addition sign between the charges instead of multiplying them as .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the product of charges in Coulomb's law with an additive sum of charges, overlooking the fundamental physical principle that Coulombic potential energy scales as the product of the two interacting field sources.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coulombic Attraction Formula
Lattice energy scales with Coulombic electrostatic potential: .
Always multiply the magnitudes of cation and anion charges in the numerator; never add them.
- Comparing Charge Multipliers
A lattice has a charge multiplier of , whereas a lattice has a multiplier of .
Check that doubling the charge of both ions increases the charge factor fourfold (), not twofold ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState Coulomb's law using multiplication: .
Calculate the numerator for : .
Calculate the numerator for : .
Form the electrostatic ratio: .
has a significantly higher melting point than . The ratio of lattice attraction is approximately .
02 The student inverts the distance dependence by placing r₀ directly proportional rather than inversely proportional in the ratio, calculating (4 × 212) / (1 × 231).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
; has and smaller compared to with and . has much stronger Coulombic attraction and therefore a significantly higher melting point.
- Step 2Correct
Because lattice energy is inversely proportional to internuclear distance (), dividing by inverts the distance term: . You placed in the numerator instead.
- Step 3Correct
Your numerical division followed correctly from your formula setup, but it was affected by the inverted distance ratio in Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly stated the Coulombic proportionality relation for lattice energy.
You accurately determined the charge product and interionic distance for each compound.
You correctly concluded that has a significantly higher melting point.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen taking the ratio of two quantities that depend inversely on a variable ( where ), you multiplied each numerator directly by its corresponding distance rather than multiplying by the reciprocal of the denominator's distance.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ratio of Inverse Proportionalities
If , then .
Always write compound fractions explicitly before simplifying to ensure denominator quantities cross-multiply into opposite positions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the ratio of Coulombic potential energies as a complex fraction: .
Multiply by the reciprocal of the denominator: .
Compute the decimal value: .
has a significantly higher melting point, and the theoretical electrostatic attraction ratio is approximately .
03 The student considers only the internuclear distance r₀ and completely ignores the ionic charges |z₊ z₋|, yielding a ratio close to 1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Lattice energy depends on ionic size: smaller internuclear distance gives higher attraction. is less than . Because has a smaller internuclear distance, has a higher melting point.
Correct. Both ionic charge and internuclear distance contribute, but ionic charge is the primary factor: for compared to for , which combined with shorter makes 's lattice energy much higher and explains its significantly higher melting point.
You correctly concluded that has a higher melting point, but you attributed lattice energy solely to ionic size. In Coulomb's law, the product of the ionic charges is the primary driving factor.
- Step 2Correct
You set up the ratio using only the inverse of the internuclear distances and omitted the charge factor . Because and have charges of , their charge product is , whereas and have a charge product of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a smaller internuclear distance increases electrostatic attraction.
You correctly identified that has a higher melting point than .
You correctly set up the inverse relationship with distance when computing .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou focused entirely on ionic radii () and neglected the ionic charges ( and ) in the numerator of Coulomb's potential energy relation .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coulomb's Law for Ionic Lattices
, where both charges and distance must be included.
Always identify the charges of the cation and anion first to compute the charge product before considering ionic radii.
- Dominance of Ionic Charges
A change in ion charge (e.g., doubling from to ) quadruples the numerator, which almost always outweighs small percentage differences in ionic radii.
Compare first to determine the major magnitude change, then refine with the internuclear distance .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the ion charges: for , and , giving . For , and , giving .
Combine charge and distance factors using : .
Simplify the compound fraction: .
has a significantly higher melting point than primarily because the product of its ionic charges is four times greater ( vs. ) and its internuclear separation is shorter ( vs. ). The theoretical ratio of electrostatic attraction is approximately .
Lock it in
How does Coulomb's law relate the electrostatic attraction between ions to their charges and ?
. Electrostatic attraction is directly proportional to the PRODUCT of ionic charges, not their sum.
Similar question
Using , calculate the relative lattice attraction ratio of to , given and .
Answer
Ratio . Key steps: For , ; for , . Ratio .
Compare the theoretical lattice attractions of magnesium chloride (, , considering a pair) and sodium chloride (, ). What is the ratio of single-pair electrostatic attraction ?
Answer
Ratio . Key steps: For a contact pair, . For , . Ratio .
Two hypothetical rock-salt lattices, Compound A () and Compound B (), have internuclear separations of and , respectively. Compute the ratio of electrostatic lattice attraction .
Answer
Ratio . Key steps: For Compound A, . For Compound B, . Ratio .