Resources
A student examines the following mRNA sequence: and concludes that because the codons and alternate, the resulting peptide must contain an alternating sequence of two different amino acids. Evaluate this claim by consulting the degeneracy of the standard genetic code (where and both encode Aspartate, ). Furthermore, determine the total number of hydrogen bonds formed between this -ribonucleotide mRNA transcript and the template DNA strand during active transcription, given that / pairs form hydrogen bonds and pairs form hydrogen bonds.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The student's claim is false due to genetic code degeneracy: both and specify Aspartate (), yielding the homopolymeric peptide . The -base mRNA contains pairs and pairs; thus, the total number of hydrogen bonds formed with the template DNA is .
Steps
Evaluating the Student's Claim
- Genetic Code Degeneracy: The genetic code is degenerate (redundant), meaning multiple synonymous codons can specify the exact same amino acid.
- Codon Translation:
- is the start codon encoding Methionine ().
- Both and are synonymous codons that specify Aspartate ().
- is a stop (nonsense) codon that does not encode an amino acid; it signals the termination of translation.
- Resulting Peptide: Translating the open reading frame yields: Because the alternating codons specify identical amino acid residues, the internal chain is composed entirely of repeating Aspartate residues rather than two alternating amino acids. Therefore, the student's claim is false.
Calculating Hydrogen Bonds with the Template DNA Strand
During transcription, RNA polymerase synthesizes mRNA complementary and antiparallel to the template DNA strand:
- Ribonucleotides and pair with template deoxyribonucleotides ( and , respectively) via hydrogen bonds.
- Ribonucleotides and pair with template deoxyribonucleotides ( and , respectively) via hydrogen bonds.
For this -ribonucleotide transcript paired to its complementary template:
- The transcript comprises base pairs (forming each).
- The transcript comprises base pairs (forming each).
Calculating the total number of hydrogen bonds:
Common Pitfall
A frequent error is assuming that different codons must code for distinct amino acids. Always account for wobble pairing and code degeneracy, where mutations or variations in the third codon position often produce silent changes that leave the primary peptide structure unaltered. Additionally, remember that stop codons terminate translation rather than incorporating an amino acid into the nascent polypeptide.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the degeneracy of the genetic code with unambiguous coding, assuming that distinct codons must code for distinct amino acids.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The claim is correct because each distinct codon specifies a unique amino acid. GAU and GAC have different sequences, so they must alternate two different amino acids in the peptide.
CorrectThe claim is false. The genetic code is degenerate (redundant), meaning multiple synonymous codons can code for the same amino acid. Since both and specify Aspartate (), the peptide contains consecutive residues rather than alternating amino acids.
You confused the unambiguous nature of the genetic code with its degeneracy. While each codon specifies only one amino acid (unambiguous), multiple distinct codons can specify the same amino acid (degenerate).
- Step 2
Base count in mRNA:
CorrectYour base tallies for the transcript were inaccurate, which caused your final hydrogen bond calculation to deviate from the correct total.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that / pairs form hydrogen bonds while pairs form hydrogen bonds.
You correctly structured the calculation as a weighted sum of base pairs multiplied by their respective hydrogen bond counts.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou miscounted the individual bases across the codons of the -nucleotide transcript.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the genetic code as a strictly one-to-one bijection between codons and amino acids, misunderstanding degeneracy to mean that different codon spellings must specify different amino acid residues.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Degeneracy vs. Unambiguity
The genetic code is degenerate (multiple codons one amino acid) and unambiguous (one codon only one amino acid).
Check whether different codons share the same amino acid assignment (synonymous codons) before concluding that primary protein sequence changes.
- Systematic Nucleotide Tallying
In an RNA-DNA hybrid, and pair via hydrogen bonds, whereas and pair via hydrogen bonds.
Count bases codon by codon or group them into and bins before multiplying by their bond numbers.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that both and encode Aspartate (), so alternating codons produce an identical run of residues; thus, the claim is false.
Tally the nucleotide composition of the -base mRNA transcript for base pairing with the template DNA.
Apply for each base pair and for each base pair: .
The claim is false due to genetic code degeneracy (both codons specify ); the total number of hydrogen bonds formed during transcription is .
02 The student reverses the hydrogen bond counts between base pairs, assigning 3 bonds to A-T/U-A pairs and 2 bonds to G-C pairs.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The claim is incorrect because the genetic code is degenerate. Both GAU and GAC code for aspartate, so the peptide contains identical Asp residues rather than alternating different amino acids.
- Step 2
Base count:
CorrectCount the base composition of the -nucleotide transcript : there are bases and bases.
You miscounted the ribonucleotides in the sequence. The transcript contains base pairs and base pairs when aligned with the template strand.
- Step 3
Number of and , each forming hydrogen bonds Number of and , each forming hydrogen bonds
Correctand pairs form hydrogen bonds each, whereas pairs form hydrogen bonds each: and .
You reversed the hydrogen bonding values between the base pairs. Adenine-uracil () pairs form hydrogen bonds, while guanine-cytosine () pairs form hydrogen bonds.
- Step 4
Total hydrogen bonds
CorrectAlthough your final arithmetic yielded , this occurred only because your swapped base counts and swapped hydrogen bond values cancelled each other out mathematically.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the genetic code exhibits degeneracy.
You accurately noted that both and specify the same amino acid, Aspartate.
You correctly concluded that the resulting peptide contains repeating Aspartate residues rather than alternating amino acids.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally assigned hydrogen bonds to pairs and hydrogen bonds to pairs.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the hydrogen-bonding capacities of complementary base pairs: remembering that pairs are stronger because they form hydrogen bonds, whereas and pairs form only .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Base-Pair Hydrogen Bond Rule
and pairs form hydrogen bonds; pairs form hydrogen bonds.
Use the mnemonic 'G-C has 3' or associate the three prongs of 'C' and 'G' curvature with bonds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the base counts from the mRNA transcript: bases and bases.
Apply the correct hydrogen bonding rules: bonds per pair and bonds per pair.
Compute the total hydrogen bonds: .
The claim is false due to genetic code degeneracy; the total number of hydrogen bonds is .
03 The student calculates hydrogen bonds only for the translated peptide coding region, omitting the stop codon UAA.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The claim is incorrect because of genetic code degeneracy. Since GAU and GAC both specify Asp, the sequence produces consecutive Asp residues rather than alternating amino acids.
- Step 2
Only consider the coding codons AUG GAU GAC GAU GAC (15 bases)
CorrectYou restricted your calculation to the translated region (15 bases), omitting the stop codon . Transcription is the synthesis of the entire mRNA transcript from the DNA template; stop codons terminate translation, but they are fully transcribed and base-pair with the template DNA.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that genetic code degeneracy allows multiple codons to encode the same amino acid.
You accurately paired base types with their respective hydrogen bond counts ( for and for ).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the boundary of translation with the boundary of transcription, incorrectly assuming that non-coding or termination signals like stop codons are not base-paired to the DNA template during RNA synthesis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Transcription scope vs. Translation scope
Transcription synthesizes the full RNA transcript (including start codons, coding regions, stop codons, and UTRs) complementary to template DNA. Stop codons only signal termination to ribosomes during translation.
When asked for base pairs or hydrogen bonds during transcription, include all ribonucleotides in the specified transcript length rather than stopping at the translated peptide region.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount all base pairs across the entire -base transcript: contains bases and bases.
Multiply each base pair type by its respective hydrogen bond count: and .
Sum the bond counts: .
46
Lock it in
What does it mean that the standard genetic code is 'degenerate' (redundant)?
Multiple distinct codons can specify the same amino acid (for example, both and specify Aspartate).
Similar question
A mRNA segment reads . Given that both and code for Glutamate (), describe the resulting peptide segment and determine the number of hydrogen bonds this -nucleotide segment forms with its template DNA strand.
Answer
The resulting peptide is a homopolymer of four Glutamate residues: , because and are synonymous codons. The -base segment contains 's and 's. pairs form H-bonds and pairs form H-bonds. Total H-bonds = .
An mRNA transcript is translated. and both encode Phenylalanine (). State the amino acid sequence produced and calculate the total hydrogen bonds formed between this transcript and its template DNA strand.
Answer
Translation gives (since is a stop codon that signals termination). Across the nucleotides, there are bases ( and in and ) and bases. Total H-bonds = .
A point mutation alters an mRNA codon from to , both of which specify Proline (). Explain why the primary structure of the protein is unchanged, and calculate the net change in hydrogen bonds formed with the template DNA strand during transcription.
Answer
Due to degeneracy at the third codon position (wobble position), the mutation is silent and still incorporates , leaving the primary structure identical. The base changes from (which pairs with template via H-bonds) to (which pairs with template via H-bonds). Net change = hydrogen bond.