Resources

Behavioral geneticists evaluated territorial aggression scores in captive-bred song sparrows (Melospiza melodia). Under strictly controlled uniform laboratory housing, the environmental variance was minimized to VE=4.50 points2V_E = 4.50\text{ points}^2. Analysis of family pedigrees demonstrated that the broad-sense heritability for territorial song rate under these laboratory conditions is H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750. Assuming phenotypic variance is partitioned simply as VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E, calculate the underlying genetic variance (VGV_G) of the population. Round your answer to three significant figures with appropriate units.

Answer and steps

Final answer

VG=13.5 points2V_G = 13.5\text{ points}^2

Steps

01

Identify the relationship between variance components and heritability

In quantitative genetics, the total observable variation in a trait across a population is called phenotypic variance (VPV_P). When assuming no significant gene-by-environment interaction, phenotypic variance is partitioned into genetic variance (VGV_G) and environmental variance (VEV_E):

VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E

Broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) represents the proportion of total phenotypic variance attributable to genetic differences among individuals:

H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}


02

Rearrange the formula to solve for genetic variance (VGV_G)

Multiply both sides by (VG+VE)(V_G + V_E) to clear the denominator:

H2(VG+VE)=VGH^2(V_G + V_E) = V_G

Expand and gather all VGV_G terms on one side:

H2⋅VG+H2⋅VE=VGH^2 \cdot V_G + H^2 \cdot V_E = V_G

H2⋅VE=VG−H2⋅VGH^2 \cdot V_E = V_G - H^2 \cdot V_G

Factor out VGV_G:

H2⋅VE=VG(1−H2)H^2 \cdot V_E = V_G(1 - H^2)

Divide by (1−H2)(1 - H^2):

VG=H21−H2⋅VEV_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} \cdot V_E


03

Substitute the given values

We are given:

  • Environmental variance: VE=4.50 points2V_E = 4.50\text{ points}^2
  • Broad-sense heritability: H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

Substitute these values into the derived equation:

VG=0.7501−0.750⋅4.50 points2V_G = \frac{0.750}{1 - 0.750} \cdot 4.50\text{ points}^2

VG=0.7500.250⋅4.50 points2V_G = \frac{0.750}{0.250} \cdot 4.50\text{ points}^2

VG=3.00⋅4.50 points2=13.5 points2V_G = 3.00 \cdot 4.50\text{ points}^2 = 13.5\text{ points}^2


04

Common Pitfall to Avoid

  • Treating H2H^2 as a squared quantity to take the square root of: The symbol H2H^2 denotes broad-sense heritability as a single parameter (similarly, h2h^2 denotes narrow-sense heritability); do not square or take the square root of 0.7500.750.
  • Multiplying H2H^2 directly by VEV_E: H2H^2 is the fraction of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P), not environmental variance (VEV_E). Always account for VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly treats broad-sense heritability as the ratio of genetic variance to environmental variance rather than phenotypic variance, calculating V_G = H² × V_E = 3.38 points².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    H2=VGVE  ⟹  VG=H2×VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_E} \implies V_G = H^2 \times V_E

    Correct

    H2=VGVP=VGVG+VE  ⟹  VG=H21−H2VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E} \implies V_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} V_E

    Heritability measures the proportion of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) accounted for by genetic differences (VGV_G), not the ratio between genetic and environmental components.

  2. Step 2

    VG=0.750×4.50V_G = 0.750 \times 4.50

    Correct

    VG=0.7501−0.750×4.50=3.00×4.50V_G = \frac{0.750}{1 - 0.750} \times 4.50 = 3.00 \times 4.50

    You substituted the given numeric values correctly into your expression, but the calculation inherits the formula error from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    VG=3.38 points2V_G = 3.38\text{ points}^2

    Correct

    VG=13.5 points2V_G = 13.5\text{ points}^2

    Your final numeric product and units followed your earlier formula, but the true genetic variance is 13.5 points213.5\text{ points}^2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly treated H2H^2 as a single parameter value rather than squaring or taking the square root of 0.7500.750.

You retained the correct unit of variance (extpoints2 ext{points}^2) in your answer.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect heritability denominator

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the part-to-whole definition of heritability (VG/VPV_G / V_P) with a direct part-to-part ratio (VG/VEV_G / V_E). Because VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E, total phenotypic variation must be in the denominator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Heritability Relative to Phenotype
  • H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}, where VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E

  • Always write VPV_P as the denominator and expand it as VG+VEV_G + V_E when environmental variance is given.

Isolate the Target Variance Component
  • H2(VG+VE)=VG  ⟹  VG(1−H2)=H2VE  ⟹  VG=H21−H2VEH^2(V_G + V_E) = V_G \implies V_G(1 - H^2) = H^2 V_E \implies V_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} V_E

  • Group like terms for VGV_G on one side before substituting values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the definition of broad-sense heritability: H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}.

  2. Clear the denominator: H2(VG+VE)=VGH^2(V_G + V_E) = V_G.

  3. Rearrange and factor to isolate VGV_G: VG(1−H2)=H2VE  ⟹  VG=H21−H2VEV_G(1 - H^2) = H^2 V_E \implies V_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} V_E.

  4. Substitute H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750 and VE=4.50 points2V_E = 4.50\text{ points}^2: VG=0.7500.250×4.50=3.00×4.50=13.5 points2V_G = \frac{0.750}{0.250} \times 4.50 = 3.00 \times 4.50 = 13.5\text{ points}^2.

Final answer

VG=13.5 points2V_G = 13.5\text{ points}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice rearranging H2=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E} for VGV_G, VEV_E, and VPV_P before plugging in numbers.

  • Check that whenever H2>0.50H^2 > 0.50, VGV_G must be larger than VEV_E.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the genetic variance component with environmental variance by defining heritability as H² = V_E / V_P, calculating V_P = 6.00 points² and subtracting to find V_G = 1.50 points².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    H2=VEVP  ⟹  0.750=4.50VPH^2 = \frac{V_E}{V_P} \implies 0.750 = \frac{4.50}{V_P}

    Correct

    H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}

    You defined broad-sense heritability as the proportion of environmental variance over total phenotypic variance. Heritability specifically quantifies the proportion of phenotypic variation caused by genetic differences, so the numerator must be VGV_G, giving H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}.

  2. Step 2

    VP=4.500.750=6.00 points2V_P = \frac{4.50}{0.750} = 6.00\text{ points}^2

    Correct

    VP=VE1−H2=4.501−0.750=18.0 points2V_P = \frac{V_E}{1 - H^2} = \frac{4.50}{1 - 0.750} = 18.0\text{ points}^2

    Your algebraic isolation of VPV_P was carried out correctly, but the numerical result was affected by using VEV_E instead of VGV_G in the heritability definition.

  3. Step 3

    VG=VP−VE=6.00−4.50  ⟹  VG=1.50 points2V_G = V_P - V_E = 6.00 - 4.50 \implies V_G = 1.50\text{ points}^2

    Correct

    VG=H2⋅VP=0.750⋅18.0 points2=13.5 points2V_G = H^2 \cdot V_P = 0.750 \cdot 18.0\text{ points}^2 = 13.5\text{ points}^2

    You correctly applied the variance partitioning identity VG=VP−VEV_G = V_P - V_E, but using the incorrect VP=6.00 points2V_P = 6.00\text{ points}^2 led to 1.50 points21.50\text{ points}^2 instead of 13.5 points213.5\text{ points}^2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that total phenotypic variance partitions as VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

You performed accurate algebraic rearrangement and subtraction given your starting equation.

You included the correct squared units in your answers.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Definition swap between genetic and environmental variance

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated heritability (H2H^2) with the given numerical environmental variance value and wrote H2=VEVPH^2 = \frac{V_E}{V_P} rather than defining heritability by the genetic component, H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the Biological Meaning of Heritability
  • Heritability (H2H^2 or h2h^2) always measures the genetic proportion of phenotypic variance: H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}. The environmental proportion is 1−H2=VEVP1 - H^2 = \frac{V_E}{V_P}.

  • Before substituting numbers, write down H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} and verify that the numerator matches 'genetic' variation.

Express $V_G$ Directly from $V_E$ and $H^2$
  • Since VE=(1−H2)VPV_E = (1 - H^2)V_P and VG=H2VPV_G = H^2 V_P, their ratio is VGVE=H21−H2\frac{V_G}{V_E} = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2}, which gives VG=H21−H2VEV_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} V_E.

  • Check your final value: when heritability is high (H2>0.50H^2 > 0.50), VGV_G must be larger than VEV_E.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express broad-sense heritability in terms of variance components: H2=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}.

  2. Substitute the known values into the equation: 0.750=VGVG+4.500.750 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + 4.50}.

  3. Multiply both sides by (VG+4.50)(V_G + 4.50): 0.750(VG+4.50)=VG  ⟹  0.750VG+3.375=VG0.750(V_G + 4.50) = V_G \implies 0.750 V_G + 3.375 = V_G.

  4. Isolate VGV_G: (1−0.750)VG=3.375  ⟹  0.250VG=3.375  ⟹  VG=3.3750.250=13.5 points2(1 - 0.750)V_G = 3.375 \implies 0.250 V_G = 3.375 \implies V_G = \frac{3.375}{0.250} = 13.5\text{ points}^2.

Final answer

VG=13.5 points2V_G = 13.5\text{ points}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize that heritability (H2H^2) is always the genetic fraction: H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}.

  • Use the ratio shortcut VGVE=H21−H2\frac{V_G}{V_E} = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} whenever VEV_E is given and you need VGV_G.

  • Perform a quick sanity check: if H2=0.75H^2 = 0.75, genetics accounts for 75%75\% of total variation, so VGV_G must be three times larger than VEV_E.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student fails to distribute the heritability coefficient across the sum when clearing the denominator, writing V_G = 0.750 V_G + 4.50 and obtaining V_G = 18.0 points².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    H2=VGVG+VE  ⟹  0.750=VGVG+4.50H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E} \implies 0.750 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + 4.50}

  2. Step 2

    VG=0.750VG+4.50  ⟹  0.250VG=4.50V_G = 0.750 V_G + 4.50 \implies 0.250 V_G = 4.50

    Correct

    VG=0.750(VG+4.50)  ⟹  VG=0.750VG+3.375  ⟹  0.250VG=3.375V_G = 0.750(V_G + 4.50) \implies V_G = 0.750 V_G + 3.375 \implies 0.250 V_G = 3.375

    When you multiplied both sides by (VG+4.50)(V_G + 4.50), you forgot to distribute 0.7500.750 to the 4.504.50 term on the right side. The product should be 0.750×4.50=3.3750.750 \times 4.50 = 3.375, not 4.504.50.

  3. Step 3

    VG=18.0 points2V_G = 18.0\text{ points}^2

    Correct

    VG=3.3750.250=13.5 points2V_G = \frac{3.375}{0.250} = 13.5\text{ points}^2

    Your final division followed logically from your previous equation, but the result is incorrect due to the distribution error in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the broad-sense heritability formula H2=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}.

You substituted the given environmental variance and heritability into the equation accurately.

You correctly subtracted 0.750VG0.750 V_G from VGV_G to collect the variable terms on one side.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic distribution error when clearing fractions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted parentheses around the binomial denominator (VG+VE)(V_G + V_E) when multiplying both sides by (VG+4.50)(V_G + 4.50), leading to a failure to distribute the coefficient 0.7500.750 across both terms.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Parenthesize Binomial Denominators
  • Whenever you clear a multi-term denominator such as (A+B)(A + B), multiply the entire other side using parentheses: k(A+B)=kA+kBk(A + B) = kA + kB.

  • Write explicit parentheses around (VG+4.50)(V_G + 4.50) before multiplying by 0.7500.750.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply both sides by (VG+4.50)(V_G + 4.50): 0.750(VG+4.50)=VG0.750(V_G + 4.50) = V_G

  2. Distribute 0.7500.750: 0.750VG+3.375=VG0.750 V_G + 3.375 = V_G

  3. Subtract 0.750VG0.750 V_G from both sides: 3.375=0.250VG3.375 = 0.250 V_G

  4. Divide by 0.2500.250: VG=3.3750.250=13.5 points2V_G = \frac{3.375}{0.250} = 13.5\text{ points}^2

Final answer

VG=13.5 points2V_G = 13.5\text{ points}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write grouping parentheses around binomial denominators before multiplying across an equals sign.

  • Check your answer using the proportion: VP=VG+VE=13.5+4.50=18.0V_P = V_G + V_E = 13.5 + 4.50 = 18.0, and verify that 13.518.0=0.750\frac{13.5}{18.0} = 0.750.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a laboratory colony of fruit flies (Drosophila melanogaster), the environmental variance for geotaxis climbing speed is measured as VE=2.00 cm2/s2V_E = 2.00\text{ cm}^2/\text{s}^2. If broad-sense heritability is H2=0.600H^2 = 0.600, calculate the genetic variance (VGV_G). Round to three significant figures with units.

Answer

VG=3.00 cm2/s2V_G = 3.00\text{ cm}^2/\text{s}^2. Using VG=H21−H2VE=0.6001−0.600×2.00=0.6000.400×2.00=1.50×2.00=3.00 cm2/s2V_G = \frac{H^2}{1 - H^2} V_E = \frac{0.600}{1 - 0.600} \times 2.00 = \frac{0.600}{0.400} \times 2.00 = 1.50 \times 2.00 = 3.00\text{ cm}^2/\text{s}^2.

02

A research team studying exploratory behavior in mice finds a total phenotypic variance of VP=25.0 units2V_P = 25.0\text{ units}^2 under standard housing. If the broad-sense heritability is H2=0.400H^2 = 0.400, find both the genetic variance (VGV_G) and the environmental variance (VEV_E). Include units.

Answer

VG=10.0 units2V_G = 10.0\text{ units}^2 and VE=15.0 units2V_E = 15.0\text{ units}^2. From H2=VG/VPH^2 = V_G / V_P, VG=0.400×25.0=10.0 units2V_G = 0.400 \times 25.0 = 10.0\text{ units}^2. Then VE=VP−VG=25.0−10.0=15.0 units2V_E = V_P - V_G = 25.0 - 10.0 = 15.0\text{ units}^2.

03

In a wild population of deer mice, burrow-depth variance is partitioned as VG=18.0 cm2V_G = 18.0\text{ cm}^2 and VE=6.00 cm2V_E = 6.00\text{ cm}^2. If environmental variance is reduced by 50%50\% in a greenhouse while genetic variance remains constant, what is the new broad-sense heritability (H2H^2)?

Answer

H2=0.857H^2 = 0.857. The new environmental variance is VE′=0.50×6.00=3.00 cm2V_E' = 0.50 \times 6.00 = 3.00\text{ cm}^2. Total new phenotypic variance is VP′=18.0+3.00=21.0 cm2V_P' = 18.0 + 3.00 = 21.0\text{ cm}^2. Thus, H2=VGVP′=18.021.0≈0.857H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P'} = \frac{18.0}{21.0} \approx 0.857.

Loading workspace…