Resources
A college biology laboratory conducts a multi-generational selection experiment on antibiotic resistance in Escherichia coli. Students plate wild-type cells onto an agar plate containing streptomycin (). Exactly colonies emerge after . To distinguish between directed adaptation in individuals versus selection of pre-existing variants in populations, a Fluctuation Test (Luria-Delbrück design) is executed: Tube A consists of one large broth culture divided onto plates, yielding low variance among plates (). Set B consists of independent separate cultures, yielding high variance among plates (, ). (a) Calculate the variance-to-mean ratio (index of dispersion, ) for Set A and Set B. (b) State whether these experimental findings support Lamarckian physiological adaptation of individual cells or Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing mutations, and justify why.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For Tube A, ; For Set B, ; (b) The significant fluctuation () supports population-level selection of pre-existing spontaneous mutations. If individual cells adapted in direct response to the antibiotic, mutations would occur with equal probability after plating, yielding a Poisson distribution (). Instead, mutations occurred spontaneously at variable times in the ancestral population prior to antibiotic exposure.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating the Index of Dispersion
The index of dispersion (variance-to-mean ratio), denoted as , measures the degree of clustering or fluctuation in count data:
- For Tube A (Single bulk culture sampled across plates): Given and :
- For Set B ( independent individual cultures): Given and :
Part (b): Evaluating the Evolutionary Mechanism
The results strongly support the Darwinian model of population-level selection of pre-existing spontaneous mutations, rather than Lamarckian directed physiological adaptation.
Biological and Statistical Basis:
- The Directed Adaptation (Lamarckian) Hypothesis: If exposure to streptomycin induced resistant mutations directly in individual surviving bacteria on the plate, every plated cell would possess an equal, independent probability of mutating after plating. The number of resistant colonies per plate would follow a Poisson distribution, where the variance equals the mean (, or ) in both Set A and Set B.
-
The Spontaneous Mutation (Darwinian) Hypothesis: If mutations occur randomly and spontaneously during population growth before antibiotic exposure, the timing of a mutation event dictates the final number of resistant descendants:
- A mutation occurring early in culture growth produces a massive burst of resistant offspring ("jackpot" culture).
- A mutation occurring late (or not at all) produces few or zero resistant cells.
Because Tube A samples one mixed population, sampling variation is small (). In contrast, the independent cultures of Set B exhibit dramatic differences between cultures depending on whether and when random mutations arose before plating, leading to a massive variance ().
This confirms that antibiotics do not direct mutations in individual cells; rather, antibiotic exposure acts as a selective filter on genetic variation that already existed within the ancestral bacterial population.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the interpretations of low and high variance, wrongly assuming that high variance in individual cultures implies individual adaptive responses to the antibiotic.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You concluded that high variance reflects individual cells adapting differently after exposure. In reality, if individual cells adapted in direct response to the antibiotic, every plated cell would have an independent, constant probability of adapting on the plate, producing a Poisson distribution where variance equals the mean (). The massive variance () occurs because spontaneous mutations arose at random generations in ancestral cultures prior to antibiotic exposure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the formula for the variance-to-mean ratio to compute the index of dispersion for both sets.
You noticed that Set B exhibited substantial variance compared to Set A.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted variation between culture plates as varying physiological responses of individual cells, rather than recognizing that high variance across independent lineages is the hallmark of spontaneous pre-existing mutations dividing into clonal 'jackpot' populations prior to selection.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Induced Adaptation vs. Pre-existing Mutation Distributions
If exposure induces mutations directly in individuals on the plate, events are independent and rare after plating, yielding a Poisson distribution (, ). If mutations arise spontaneously before exposure, lineage replication causes huge fluctuation (, ).
Always connect to independent post-plating induction and to pre-exposure clonal expansion of random mutations.
- Evolution Acts on Populations, Not Individuals
Individual bacteria do not dynamically invent antibiotic resistance upon sensing an antibiotic; rather, selection filters differential survival among pre-existing genetic variants in a population.
Attribute resistance emergence to population-level differential reproduction of cells that already possessed random mutations prior to antibiotic treatment.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the variance-to-mean ratios: matches a random Poisson process, whereas shows extreme fluctuation.
Determine the physical source of high variance: In Set B, an early mutation in a culture tube replicates exponentially into a massive cluster of resistant cells ('jackpot'), while cultures with late or zero mutations yield few or none.
Conclude that because jackpot cultures require mutations to occur generations before streptomycin contact, resistance is Darwinian selection of pre-existing mutations in populations, not Lamarckian adaptation of individuals.
(a) , ; (b) The data support Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing spontaneous mutations because the extreme variance () results from mutations arising at variable times during population growth prior to antibiotic exposure.
02 The student inverts the index of dispersion formula as mean over variance, producing erroneous dispersion values.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Set A: Set B:
CorrectYou inverted the formula for the index of dispersion (variance-to-mean ratio). The problem defines the index as (variance divided by mean), not mean divided by variance. While Set A coincidentally produced because , Set B should evaluate to .
- Step 2
Supports Darwinian population-level selection. Mutations arose before antibiotic exposure, producing high fluctuation in mutant numbers across independent cultures.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the high fluctuation across independent cultures indicates pre-existing spontaneous mutations rather than directed physiological adaptation.
You correctly identified that evolution by natural selection acts on pre-existing variation in populations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeInverting the variance-to-mean ratio as instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou swapped the numerator and denominator of the variance-to-mean ratio, confusing the index of dispersion with its reciprocal.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Variance-to-Mean Ratio Definition
The index of dispersion compares variance to the mean: .
Always verify that variance () is placed in the numerator and sample mean () in the denominator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite down the index of dispersion formula: .
Substitute the values for Set A: .
Substitute the values for Set B: .
(a) , ; (b) Supports Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing mutations because high fluctuation () indicates mutations occurred randomly prior to antibiotic plating.
03 The student misinterprets the similar mean counts between Set A and Set B as evidence that mutation rates depend on directed exposure rather than recognizing the significance of variance.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Set A: ; Set B:
- Step 2
Supports Lamarckian physiological adaptation. Because the mean number of resistant colonies is nearly identical ( vs ), the antibiotic induces resistance at a constant rate upon contact.
CorrectThe results support Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing mutations because Set B exhibits extreme fluctuation (), showing that mutations occurred spontaneously at variable times prior to antibiotic exposure.
You focused on the similar mean values rather than the variance. In a fluctuation test, directed adaptation predicts a Poisson distribution where variance equals the mean () across independent cultures. The massive variance () reflects 'jackpot' cultures where mutations arose early during division before plating, proving resistance variants pre-existed in the population.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the formula for the index of dispersion to compute and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated whether the mean colony counts were similar instead of analyzing the variance-to-mean ratio (fluctuation) between independent cultures, overlooking that high variance indicates pre-existing mutations that arose before selective exposure.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate the Variance, Not Just the Mean
In the Luria-Delbrück fluctuation test, similar means are expected because the average mutation rate is the same; the critical diagnostic variable is whether the variance equals the mean () or far exceeds it ().
Check the dispersion index (): if , the data reflect jackpot events from random pre-plating mutations.
- Distinguish Directed Adaptation from Pre-Existing Variation
Directed physiological adaptation means cells mutate only after contact with the selective agent, giving each cell an equal, independent chance to mutate (). Pre-existing spontaneous mutations arise at random generations during population growth, creating huge fluctuations ().
Attribute high fluctuation () to Darwinian selection of pre-existing genetic variants in the population.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationObserve that Set B has an index of dispersion , which is much greater than .
Recall that if resistance were induced after antibiotic contact, the count of resistant colonies would follow a Poisson distribution () in both sets.
Recognize that the extreme variance in Set B arises from random spontaneous mutations occurring at different generations prior to plating, producing occasional 'jackpot' cultures.
Conclude that antibiotic resistance evolves via Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing spontaneous mutations, not directed individual adaptation.
(a) , ; (b) The findings support Darwinian population-level selection of pre-existing mutations because the large variance in Set B () indicates random mutations arose prior to antibiotic exposure.
Lock it in
In a Luria-Delbrück fluctuation test, what statistical distribution is expected if antibiotics induce individual cells to adapt after plating?
A Poisson distribution (, ), because each cell would have an equal, independent probability of mutating upon exposure.
Similar question
A researcher repeats the fluctuation test with a new bactericidal compound. A single bulk culture sampled onto 10 plates yields and . Ten independent separate cultures yield and . Calculate the dispersion index for the independent cultures and identify which evolutionary hypothesis these data support.
Answer
. Because (), the resistant colonies follow a Poisson distribution. This outcome would support directed (induced) physiological adaptation upon exposure, because mutations occurred with equal probability per cell only after plating.
In a classic Luria-Delbrück experiment with 20 separate cultures, 16 cultures produce between 0 and 2 resistant colonies, 3 cultures produce 5 to 8 colonies, and 1 culture produces 142 colonies. Explain the biological origin of the single culture with 142 colonies and why this phenomenon is termed a 'jackpot'.
Answer
A random spontaneous mutation occurred early in the growth phase of that single culture tube, many generations before antibiotic plating. Because all daughter cells inherited the resistant allele, exponential division produced a massive burst (142 cells) of resistant mutants prior to antibiotic contact, creating a statistical 'jackpot'.
Explain why replica plating (Lederberg experiment) provides complementary spatial evidence to the fluctuation test that mutations arise prior to selection.
Answer
In replica plating, identical spatial patterns of resistant colonies appear at the exact same physical coordinates across multiple replica plates stamped from a master plate grown in the absence of antibiotic. This proves that clones were already genetically resistant at those specific positions before encountering the selective agent.