Resources

A population of N=200N = 200 European starlings engages in communal anti-predator scanning while foraging in open pasture. In a solitary starling, the individual probability of detecting a stalking sparrowhawk within a critical response window is p0=0.15p_0 = 0.15. In a flock of size kk, starlings scan independently, such that the collective probability of at least one individual detecting the predator is Pdetect=1−(1−p0)kP_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - p_0)^k. Simultaneously, each starling reduces its individual vigilance scanning time from t0=4.0 s/mint_0 = 4.0\text{ s/min} down to tk=12.0k+0.50 s/mint_k = \frac{12.0}{k} + 0.50\text{ s/min}, allocating the saved time directly to foraging. Calculate: (a) the collective predator detection probability PdetectP_{\text{detect}} for a cooperative foraging subgroup of k=6k = 6 starlings, and (b) the percentage reduction in individual vigilance time for a starling in this k=6k = 6 flock compared to a solitary bird (t0t_0).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Pdetect=0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 0.623 (or 62.3%62.3\%); (b) Vigilance time reduction =37.5%= 37.5\% (from 4.0 s/min4.0\text{ s/min} down to 2.5 s/min2.5\text{ s/min}).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating Collective Predator Detection Probability

  1. Understand the Principle of Independent Detection ("Many-Eyes" Hypothesis): When starlings forage in a group, multiple individuals scan the surroundings independently. For a predator to remain undetected, every single individual in the group must fail to spot it.

    • The probability that an individual starling fails to detect the predator is: 1−p0=1−0.15=0.851 - p_0 = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85
  2. Calculate the Probability of Complete Detection Failure: For a subgroup of k=6k = 6 independent foragers, the probability that all 66 starlings fail to detect the predator is: (1−p0)k=(0.85)6(1 - p_0)^k = (0.85)^6 (0.85)6≈0.37715(0.85)^6 \approx 0.37715
  3. Compute the Collective Detection Probability (PdetectP_{\text{detect}}): The collective probability that at least one bird detects the predator is the complement of all birds failing: Pdetect=1−(1−p0)k=1−0.37715=0.62285≈0.623 (or 62.3%)P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - p_0)^k = 1 - 0.37715 = 0.62285 \approx 0.623 \text{ (or } 62.3\%\text{)}

Common Pitfall: Do not simply multiply k⋅p0k \cdot p_0 (6×0.15=0.906 \times 0.15 = 0.90). Probabilities of independent non-mutually exclusive events cannot be added directly, as this overcounts instances where multiple birds detect the threat simultaneously.


Part (b): Calculating the Percentage Reduction in Individual Vigilance Time

  1. Determine the Vigilance Time for a Starling in the Flock (tkt_k): Substitute k=6k = 6 into the given flock vigilance equation: t6=12.06+0.50=2.0+0.50=2.5 s/mint_6 = \frac{12.0}{6} + 0.50 = 2.0 + 0.50 = 2.5\text{ s/min}
  2. Calculate the Absolute and Percentage Reduction:

    • A solitary bird spends t0=4.0 s/mint_0 = 4.0\text{ s/min} on vigilance.
    • The absolute time saved is: Δt=t0−t6=4.0 s/min−2.5 s/min=1.5 s/min\Delta t = t_0 - t_6 = 4.0\text{ s/min} - 2.5\text{ s/min} = 1.5\text{ s/min}
    • The percentage reduction relative to the solitary baseline (t0t_0) is: Percentage Reduction=t0−t6t0×100%=1.54.0×100%=37.5%\text{Percentage Reduction} = \frac{t_0 - t_6}{t_0} \times 100\% = \frac{1.5}{4.0} \times 100\% = 37.5\%

Biological Insight: By forming a small cooperative group of 66, starlings more than quadruple their overall detection rate (from 15%15\% to 62.3%62.3\%) while simultaneously cutting individual vigilance effort by 37.5%37.5\%, allowing more time for feeding.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the flock subgroup size k with the total population size N and substitutes N = 200 into the detection probability formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pdetect=1−(1−0.15)200  ⟹  Pdetect=1−(0.85)200  ⟹  Pdetect=1−0.000000000000035=1.0P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - 0.15)^{200} \implies P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (0.85)^{200} \implies P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - 0.000000000000035 = 1.0

    Correct

    Pdetect=1−(1−0.15)6=1−(0.85)6≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - 0.15)^6 = 1 - (0.85)^6 \approx 0.623

    You substituted the total population size N=200N = 200 instead of the subgroup foraging group size k=6k = 6 into the collective detection formula.

  2. Step 2

    t6=12.0/6+0.50=2.50 s/min  ⟹  reduction=4.0−2.504.0×100%=37.5%t_6 = 12.0/6 + 0.50 = 2.50\text{ s/min} \implies \text{reduction} = \frac{4.0 - 2.50}{4.0} \times 100\% = 37.5\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the vigilance rate function with the subgroup flock size k=6k = 6.

You calculated the baseline percentage reduction accurately using the relative difference formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parameter substitution error

You accidentally inserted the total population size N=200N = 200 rather than the specified subgroup size k=6k = 6 into the detection formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing overall regional population size NN with the local foraging group size kk that actually participates in collective scanning.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Local Group vs. Total Population
  • Only individuals within direct sensory contact in the active foraging subgroup (kk) contribute to communal scanning, not the total population (NN).

  • Always verify which variable represents the interacting social group when setting up probability exponents.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the active foraging group size specified in the prompt: k=6k = 6.

  2. Compute the probability that a single bird fails to spot the predator: 1−p0=1−0.15=0.851 - p_0 = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85.

  3. Compute the probability that all 66 birds fail: (0.85)6≈0.37715(0.85)^6 \approx 0.37715.

  4. Calculate the complement for collective detection: Pdetect=1−0.37715=0.62285≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - 0.37715 = 0.62285 \approx 0.623.

Final answer

(a) Pdetect≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} \approx 0.623 (or 62.3%62.3\%); (b) Reduction =37.5%= 37.5\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check variable definitions before substituting numbers into power-law or probability formulas.

  • Verify whether an ecological model describes the whole population (NN) or an immediate interactive flock (kk).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies independent probability by simply multiplying the individual detection probability by the flock size instead of calculating the complementary failure probability.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pdetect=6×0.15  ⟹  Pdetect=0.90P_{\text{detect}} = 6 \times 0.15 \implies P_{\text{detect}} = 0.90

    Correct

    Pdetect=1−(1−0.15)6=1−(0.85)6≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - 0.15)^6 = 1 - (0.85)^6 \approx 0.623

    You calculated collective detection as k×p0k \times p_0. Because detection by each bird represents an independent, non-mutually exclusive event, probabilities cannot simply be added or multiplied by kk. Instead, calculate the probability that all birds fail to detect the predator, (1−p0)k(1 - p_0)^k, and take its complement: 1−(1−p0)k1 - (1 - p_0)^k.

  2. Step 2

    t6=12.0/6+0.50=2.50 s/mint_6 = 12.0 / 6 + 0.50 = 2.50\text{ s/min}

  3. Step 3

    reduction=(4.0−2.50)4.0×100%=37.5%\text{reduction} = \frac{(4.0 - 2.50)}{4.0} \times 100\% = 37.5\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the flock vigilance function for k=6k = 6.

You calculated the relative percentage reduction accurately using the solitary baseline.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear probability scaling error

No, this is a conceptual error regarding how independent probabilities combine.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the detection events across group members as mutually exclusive by scaling p0p_0 linearly (k⋅p0k \cdot p_0), which overcounts instances where multiple birds detect the predator simultaneously and ignores the complement rule for independent events.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
At Least One Event Occurs
  • For kk independent events with probability pp, P(≥1)=1−(1−p)kP(\ge 1) = 1 - (1 - p)^k.

  • Always compute the probability of collective failure first, (1−p)k(1 - p)^k, then subtract it from 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the probability that an individual fails to detect the predator: 1−p0=1−0.15=0.851 - p_0 = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85.

  2. Raise the failure probability to the power of the group size: (0.85)6≈0.37715(0.85)^6 \approx 0.37715.

  3. Subtract from 11 to find the collective probability of at least one detection: Pdetect=1−0.37715=0.62285≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - 0.37715 = 0.62285 \approx 0.623.

Final answer

(a) Pdetect≈0.623P_{\text{detect}} \approx 0.623 (or 62.3%62.3\%); (b) 37.5%37.5\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the complement rule for independent probabilities: P(at least one)=1−P(none)P(\text{at least one}) = 1 - P(\text{none}).

  • Notice that linear scaling (k⋅pk \cdot p) breaks down completely for larger groups because it can yield probabilities greater than 1.01.0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the remaining vigilance time as a percentage of the original time rather than calculating the percentage reduction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pdetect=1−(1−0.15)6  ⟹  Pdetect=1−(0.85)6  ⟹  Pdetect=1−0.377=0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - 0.15)^6 \implies P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (0.85)^6 \implies P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - 0.377 = 0.623

  2. Step 2

    t6=12.06+0.50=2.50 s/mint_6 = \frac{12.0}{6} + 0.50 = 2.50\text{ s/min}

  3. Step 3

    percentage reduction=(2.504.0)×100%=62.5%\text{percentage reduction} = \left(\frac{2.50}{4.0}\right) \times 100\% = 62.5\%

    Correct

    percentage reduction=4.0−2.504.0×100%=1.504.0×100%=37.5%\text{percentage reduction} = \frac{4.0 - 2.50}{4.0} \times 100\% = \frac{1.50}{4.0} \times 100\% = 37.5\%

    You divided the remaining vigilance time t6t_6 by the baseline t0t_0, which gives the remaining percentage (62.5%62.5\%) rather than the reduction relative to the original baseline.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the collective predator detection probability using the complement probability formula.

You accurately evaluated the vigilance time t6t_6 for an individual bird in a flock of six.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Remaining value instead of reduction

No

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You computed the ratio of the final value to the initial value (tk/t0t_k / t_0) instead of the relative decrease ([t0−tk]/t0[t_0 - t_k] / t_0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Percentage Reduction Formula
  • Percentage Reduction=Initial−FinalInitial×100%\text{Percentage Reduction} = \frac{\text{Initial} - \text{Final}}{\text{Initial}} \times 100\%

  • Always subtract the new value from the original baseline to get the absolute decrease before dividing by the initial baseline.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the absolute reduction in vigilance time: Δt=t0−t6=4.0 s/min−2.50 s/min=1.50 s/min\Delta t = t_0 - t_6 = 4.0\text{ s/min} - 2.50\text{ s/min} = 1.50\text{ s/min}.

  2. Express this reduction as a percentage of the original baseline: 1.504.0×100%=37.5%\frac{1.50}{4.0} \times 100\% = 37.5\%.

Final answer

(a) Pdetect=0.623P_{\text{detect}} = 0.623 (or 62.3%62.3\%); (b) Vigilance time reduction =37.5%= 37.5\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between 'remaining percentage' (tfinal/tinitialt_{\text{final}} / t_{\text{initial}}) and 'percentage reduction' ([tinitial−tfinal]/tinitial[t_{\text{initial}} - t_{\text{final}}] / t_{\text{initial}}).

  • Check that your final percentage answers align with the question prompt: if a value decreases slightly, the reduction must be well under 50%50\%.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A flock of k=4k = 4 wood pigeons feeds in a field. The solitary predator detection probability is p0=0.20p_0 = 0.20. What is the collective probability that at least one pigeon spots a hawk?

Answer

Pdetect=1−(1−0.20)4=1−(0.80)4=1−0.4096=0.5904P_{\text{detect}} = 1 - (1 - 0.20)^4 = 1 - (0.80)^4 = 1 - 0.4096 = 0.5904 (or 59.04%59.04\%).

02

In a herd of gazelles, individual scanning time per minute follows tk=18.0k+1.0 s/mint_k = \frac{18.0}{k} + 1.0\text{ s/min}. If a solitary gazelle spends t0=10.0 s/mint_0 = 10.0\text{ s/min} scanning, find the percentage reduction in scanning time for a gazelle in a subgroup of k=9k = 9.

Answer
  1. Compute flock vigilance: t9=18.09+1.0=2.0+1.0=3.0 s/mint_9 = \frac{18.0}{9} + 1.0 = 2.0 + 1.0 = 3.0\text{ s/min}.\n2. Calculate reduction: 10.0−3.010.0×100%=70.0%\frac{10.0 - 3.0}{10.0} \times 100\% = 70.0\%.
03

A shorebird species has solitary predator detection probability p0=0.10p_0 = 0.10. Determine the minimum subgroup flock size kk required so that the collective detection probability PdetectP_{\text{detect}} reaches at least 0.500.50 (50%50\%).

Answer
  1. Set up the inequality: 1−(1−0.10)k≥0.50  ⟹  (0.90)k≤0.501 - (1 - 0.10)^k \ge 0.50 \implies (0.90)^k \le 0.50.\n2. Take logarithms: kln⁡(0.90)≤ln⁡(0.50)  ⟹  k≥ln⁡(0.50)ln⁡(0.90)≈−0.69315−0.10536≈6.58k \ln(0.90) \le \ln(0.50) \implies k \ge \frac{\ln(0.50)}{\ln(0.90)} \approx \frac{-0.69315}{-0.10536} \approx 6.58.\n3. Round up to the next integer: k=7k = 7 birds.
Loading workspace…