Resources
In Escherichia coli, the operon regulates the transcription of genes required for lactose metabolism. Consider a wild-type bacterial culture grown in a medium containing a high concentration of glucose () and zero lactose. (a) Specify the conformational state and binding status of the Lac repressor () at the operator (). (b) Determine the intracellular level of cyclic adenosine monophosphate () and the binding state of the catabolite activator protein () to the -binding site. (c) Predict the relative transcription rate of the structural genes () as either high, basal/repressed, or completely absent.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) repressor is in its active conformation and bound to ; (b) is low, and the complex is inactive and unbound to the site; (c) Basal/repressed (near zero transcription).
Steps
Negative Control: Status of the Lac Repressor ()
The regulation of the lac operon in Escherichia coli is governed by dual control mechanisms: negative regulation by the Lac repressor () and positive regulation mediated by the catabolite activator protein (, also known as ) along with cyclic adenosine monophosphate ().
- Lactose Availability: Lactose is completely absent from the growth medium. Under normal conditions with lactose present, an isomer called allolactose forms and acts as an inducer by binding to the repressor and changing its conformation so it cannot bind DNA.
- Repressor State: Without lactose (and thus no allolactose), the homotetrameric repressor remains in its active, DNA-binding conformation.
- Binding at : The active repressor binds stably and tightly to the operator region (), creating a physical steric block immediately downstream of the promoter ().
Positive Control: Levels and Binding
- Glucose Effect (Catabolite Repression): Glucose is the preferred carbon and energy source for E. coli. High intracellular glucose concentrations () inhibit the enzyme adenylyl cyclase via the phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent phosphotransferase system (PTS).
- Intracellular : Because adenylyl cyclase activity is suppressed, intracellular levels of cyclic adenosine monophosphate () remain very low.
- Binding to the Site: Catabolite activator protein () requires binding with to adopt its active DNA-binding conformation. Since is low, the complex fails to form; therefore, remains inactive and unbound to the upstream -binding site, providing no recruitment or stabilization of RNA polymerase at the promoter.
Net Effect on the Transcription of
- Transcription Level: RNA polymerase cannot bind effectively due to the absence of the activator, and any transient binding is blocked from transcriptional elongation by the repressor bound at the operator.
- Basal/Repressed vs. Completely Absent: While transcription is strongly turned off, biological repression is not absolute. The repressor periodically dissociates for brief moments, allowing extremely rare, "leaky" transcription events necessary to produce the minute amounts of -galactosidase and permease needed to detect lactose if it later appears. Therefore, transcription is classified as basal/repressed (near zero transcription) rather than completely absent.
Summary of Answers:
- (a) The repressor is in its active conformation and bound to the operator ().
- (b) The intracellular is low, and remains inactive and unbound to the -binding site.
- (c) The transcription rate of is basal/repressed.
Typical errors
01 The student believes that repressor binding shuts off transcription entirely rather than allowing a low basal rate.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
No lactose means no allolactose inducer. Lac repressor is active and bound to the operator.
- Step 2
High glucose lowers cAMP levels. cAMP is low, so CAP is inactive and not bound to DNA.
- Step 3
Lac repressor physically blocks RNA polymerase completely. Transcription rate of lacZYA: completely absent
CorrectThe transcription rate of the structural genes () is basal/repressed (near zero transcription).
You treated repressor binding as an absolute shutoff. In reality, the repressor-operator binding exists in dynamic chemical equilibrium, occasionally dissociating for brief intervals to allow low-level basal ("leaky") transcription.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly analyzed the negative regulatory system by noting that the lack of allolactose keeps the repressor active and bound.
You correctly linked high glucose concentration to reduced intracellular and the inactive state of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou viewed transcriptional repression as a rigid, absolute on/off switch rather than a dynamic, reversible equilibrium where periodic repressor dissociation permits essential basal transcription.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Repression is Reversible, Not Absolute
Protein-DNA interactions are non-covalent and reversible; repressors undergo continuous association and dissociation.
Always characterize repressed prokaryotic operons as exhibiting 'basal' or 'leaky' transcription rather than 'zero' or 'completely absent' transcription.
- Physiological Necessity of Basal Expression
Cells require pre-existing permease to import lactose and -galactosidase to convert lactose into allolactose before full induction can ever happen.
Remember that if transcription were truly zero, the cell could never sense or respond to the sudden arrival of lactose.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that non-covalent binding between and is governed by a dynamic association-dissociation constant ().
Account for the transient moments when the repressor briefly dissociates from , allowing RNA polymerase to initiate rare transcription runs.
Classify the resulting transcription of as basal/repressed.
Basal/repressed (near zero transcription)
02 The student confuses the effect of glucose on cAMP and assumes high glucose produces high cAMP that activates CAP binding.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Lactose is absent, so repressor is active. Lac repressor is bound to .
- Step 2
Glucose is high, so intracellular cAMP is high. cAMP binds CAP, so CAP is bound to the CAP site.
CorrectIntracellular is low, so the complex fails to form and remains inactive and unbound to the site.
Glucose exerts catabolite repression by inhibiting adenylyl cyclase. Consequently, high glucose results in low intracellular , leaving inactive and unbound to DNA.
- Step 3
Repressor is bound at the operator. Transcription rate of lacZYA: basal/repressed
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the absence of lactose leaves the Lac repressor active and bound to the operator.
You accurately predicted that the transcription of is basal/repressed rather than completely absent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that high glucose increases intracellular , overlooking catabolite repression where glucose transport inhibits adenylyl cyclase, leading to an inverse relationship between glucose and .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Catabolite Repression Mechanism
High extracellular glucose inhibits adenylyl cyclase via the phosphotransferase system, decreasing intracellular .
Always pair high glucose with low , and low or absent glucose with elevated .
- CAP Activation Requirement
requires allosteric binding of to form the active DNA-binding complex.
Check whether is elevated before predicting binding at the promoter.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationHigh glucose () inhibits the activity of adenylyl cyclase, reducing intracellular to a minimum.
Without sufficient , remains in its inactive conformation and cannot bind to the upstream recognition site.
The lack of binding means RNA polymerase does not receive positive transcriptional activation.
(a) repressor is active and bound to ; (b) is low, and is inactive and unbound; (c) Transcription of is basal/repressed.
03 The student confuses the repressor with an activator and concludes that without lactose, the repressor cannot bind the operator.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
No lactose is present to activate the repressor. Lac repressor is inactive and not bound to the operator.
CorrectIn the absence of lactose (and allolactose), the repressor remains in its active, DNA-binding conformation and binds tightly to the operator ().
You treated lactose as an activator of the repressor. In inducible systems like the operon, the repressor protein is natively active on its own. When lactose is absent, no inducer (allolactose) binds to , so the repressor stays active and bound to .
- Step 2
High glucose results in low cAMP concentration. CAP is not bound to the CAP-binding site.
- Step 3
Without repressor and without CAP activation, RNA polymerase transcribes at a low level. Transcription rate of lacZYA : basal/repressed
CorrectBecause the active repressor is bound to (and is unbound), RNA polymerase is sterically blocked, resulting in a basal/repressed transcription rate.
Your final category selection is correct, but your justification was affected by Step 1 because the repressor is actually bound to the operator, causing repression.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that high glucose concentration lowers intracellular .
You correctly concluded that remains unbound to the promoter's -binding site.
You accurately identified that the overall expression level of is basal/repressed.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated lactose as a molecule that activates the repressor (like a co-repressor in a repressible operon), rather than an inducer that inactivates an inherently active repressor.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Default State of an Inducible Operon
In an inducible operon (), the repressor is synthesized in an active conformation by default and binds DNA unless an inducer binds to it.
Always check whether the ligand acts as an inducer (turns off the repressor) or a co-repressor (turns on the repressor).
- Role of Allolactose
Allolactose is an allosteric inhibitor (inducer) of ; binding causes a conformational change that lowers affinity for .
When lactose is absent, conclude that maintains high DNA affinity and blocks transcription at the operator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that the operon is an inducible operon, meaning the repressor is natively active.
In the absence of lactose, no allolactose is produced, so remains in its active conformation.
Active binds tightly to the operator (), sterically blocking RNA polymerase elongation.
Combine this with low (no activation) to confirm that transcription is held at a basal/repressed level.
(a) is active and bound to ; (b) is low and is unbound; (c) Basal/repressed.
Lock it in
Why is wild-type lac operon transcription in the absence of lactose described as 'basal' rather than 'completely off'?
Repressor-operator binding is a reversible equilibrium, so periodic transient dissociation allows occasional, leaky transcription runs.
Similar question
A culture of E. coli is grown in minimal medium containing lactose as the sole carbon source (zero glucose). Predict the status of the Lac repressor, the complex, and the resulting transcription level of .
Answer
The Lac repressor is inactive (bound by allolactose) and unbound to . Because glucose is absent, intracellular is high, forming the active complex that binds upstream of the promoter. Transcription of is high (fully induced).
A mutant E. coli strain possesses a 'super-repressor' allele () whose repressor product cannot bind allolactose but binds operator DNA with normal affinity. In a medium with both high glucose and high lactose, what is the transcription level of the lac operon?
Answer
Transcription remains at the basal/repressed level. Because the protein cannot bind allolactose, it remains bound to , keeping transcription tightly repressed despite the presence of lactose.
Consider an E. coli mutant with a promoter mutation in the operon that entirely abolishes RNA polymerase binding (). Contrast the molecular cause of zero transcription in this mutant with the basal transcription observed in an uninduced wild-type cell.
Answer
In the mutant, transcription is truly completely absent because RNA polymerase cannot bind the promoter under any circumstances. In uninduced wild-type cells, the promoter remains fully functional, and transcription occurs at a basal level whenever the repressor transiently dissociates.