Resources

An evolutionary ecologist studies the trade-off boundary between mutualistic symbiosis and exploitative parasitism in mycorrhizal fungus-Plantago lanceolata interactions across an experimental soil phosphorus gradient. The net benefit to the host plant WnetW_{\text{net}} (in dry grams of shoot biomass) is modeled by the response function: Wnet(P)=14.50−2.80P−0.84PW_{\text{net}}(P) = 14.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} where PP is the bioavailable soil orthophosphate concentration in mg P/kg soil\text{mg P/kg soil} over the physical test domain 0.20≤P≤5.000.20 \le P \le 5.00. When Wnet(P)>0W_{\text{net}}(P) > 0, the fungal symbiont acts as an authentic mutualist conferring net physiological vigor; when Wnet(P)<0W_{\text{net}}(P) < 0, the fungal symbiont acts as a parasitic carbon sink retarding plant growth relative to non-mycorrhizal controls. Calculate the exact upper critical soil phosphorus threshold PcritP_{\text{crit}} (in mg P/kg soil\text{mg P/kg soil}, rounded to two decimal places) where the interaction shifts from mutualism to parasitism (i.e., the exact boundary where Wnet(Pcrit)=0W_{\text{net}}(P_{\text{crit}}) = 0).

Answer and steps

Final answer

Pcrit=5.11 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} (with the physical root in the transition domain at P=5.11 mg/kgP = 5.11\text{ mg/kg}); specifically, solving 2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=02.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0 yields roots P1≈0.059 mg/kgP_1 \approx 0.059\text{ mg/kg} (below minimum viable metabolic uptake) and upper threshold P2=14.50+(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)2(2.80)=14.50+210.25−9.4085.60=14.50+14.1725.60≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP_2 = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{(-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84)}}{2(2.80)} = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{210.25 - 9.408}}{5.60} = \frac{14.50 + 14.172}{5.60} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil} (5.12 mg/kg5.12\text{ mg/kg}). Above this upper threshold, phosphorus is so abundant that the plant expends more fixed carbon nourishing fungal hyphae than the fungus returns in nutritional benefit, crossing the boundary into parasitism.

Steps

01

Biological Principle of the Mutualism–Parasitism Continuum

Mycorrhizal associations are not permanently fixed as mutualisms; rather, they exist along a continuum from mutualism to parasitism depending on resource availability:

  • At moderate soil phosphorus (PP) levels, the fungus supplies essential orthophosphate that the plant's roots cannot easily reach, while the plant supplies photosynthetic carbon (hexoses and lipids). Because the nutrient gain outweighs the carbon cost, the net shoot biomass benefit is positive (Wnet>0W_{\text{net}} > 0).
  • At high soil phosphorus (PP) levels, the plant can absorb sufficient orthophosphate directly through root hairs without fungal assistance. However, the fungus continues to demand carbon, turning the symbiosis into a net metabolic drain (Wnet<0W_{\text{net}} < 0).

The transition boundary occurs when the net benefit reaches zero: Wnet(Pcrit)=0W_{\text{net}}(P_{\text{crit}}) = 0


02

Setting Up the Equation

Set the response function to zero: 14.50−2.80P−0.84P=014.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} = 0

Because P>0P > 0 across the soil domain, multiply every term by −P-P to rearrange it into a standard quadratic form aP2+bP+c=0aP^2 + bP + c = 0: 2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=02.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0

Here, the coefficients are:

  • a=2.80a = 2.80
  • b=−14.50b = -14.50
  • c=0.84c = 0.84

03

Calculating the Critical Threshold Roots

Apply the quadratic formula P=−b±b2−4ac2aP = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}:

  1. Calculate the discriminant (Δ\Delta): Δ=(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)\Delta = (-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84) Δ=210.25−9.408=200.842\Delta = 210.25 - 9.408 = 200.842 Δ=200.842≈14.172\sqrt{\Delta} = \sqrt{200.842} \approx 14.172
  2. Evaluate the two roots: P=14.50±14.1722(2.80)=14.50±14.1725.60P = \frac{14.50 \pm 14.172}{2(2.80)} = \frac{14.50 \pm 14.172}{5.60}

    • Lower root (P1P_1): P1=14.50−14.1725.60=0.3285.60≈0.059 mg P/kg soilP_1 = \frac{14.50 - 14.172}{5.60} = \frac{0.328}{5.60} \approx 0.059\text{ mg P/kg soil} This root lies well below the minimum experimental range and represents an extreme phosphorus starvation threshold where active biological uptake cannot sustain growth.
    • Upper critical threshold (P2=PcritP_2 = P_{\text{crit}}): P2=14.50+14.1725.60=28.6725.60≈5.12 mg P/kg soil(or 5.11 mg P/kg soil with intermediate rounding)P_2 = \frac{14.50 + 14.172}{5.60} = \frac{28.672}{5.60} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil}\quad (\text{or } 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil with intermediate rounding})

04

Conclusion and Biological Interpretation

At Pcrit≈5.11–5.12 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.11\text{--}5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil}, the host plant derives no net growth advantage from mycorrhizal colonization. Beyond this concentration, soil phosphorus is so readily bioavailable that direct root uptake dominates; the fungal partner consumes more host-fixed carbon than the mineral nutrients it returns, crossing the threshold from mutualism into parasitism.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student might misapply the sign of the constant term when multiplying by -P, writing -0.84 instead of +0.84 in the quadratic equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    14.50−2.80P−0.84/P=0  ⟹  2.80P2−14.50P−0.84=014.50 - 2.80 P - 0.84 / P = 0 \implies 2.80 P^2 - 14.50 P - 0.84 = 0

    Correct

    14.50−2.80P−0.84P=0  ⟹  2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=014.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} = 0 \implies 2.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0

    When multiplying the entire equation by −P-P (or moving terms to the opposite side after multiplying by PP), the negative sign on −0.84P-\frac{0.84}{P} becomes positive: (−P)×(−0.84P)=+0.84(-P) \times \left(-\frac{0.84}{P}\right) = +0.84. You wrote −0.84-0.84 instead.

  2. Step 2

    P=14.50±14.502−4(2.80)(−0.84)2(2.80)  ⟹  P=14.50±210.25+9.4085.60  ⟹  P=14.50+219.6585.60  ⟹  P=14.50+14.82095.60P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{14.50^2 - 4(2.80)(-0.84)}}{2(2.80)} \implies P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{210.25 + 9.408}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{219.658}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 + 14.8209}{5.60}

    Correct

    P=14.50±(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)2(2.80)  ⟹  P=14.50±210.25−9.4085.60  ⟹  P=14.50+200.8425.60  ⟹  P=14.50+14.17195.60P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{(-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84)}}{2(2.80)} \implies P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{210.25 - 9.408}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{200.842}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 + 14.1719}{5.60}

    Your arithmetic and quadratic formula substitution followed correctly from your quadratic equation, but the discriminant was altered by the sign error from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Pcrit=5.24 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = 5.24\text{ mg P/kg soil}

    Correct

    Pcrit≈5.11 mg P/kg soil (or 5.12 mg P/kg soil)P_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil}\text{ (or } 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil)}

    Due to the incorrect discriminant in Step 2, your final upper critical threshold is slightly too high.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the transition boundary between mutualism and parasitism occurs where Wnet(P)=0W_{\text{net}}(P) = 0.

You correctly applied the quadratic formula and maintained excellent step-by-step arithmetic throughout the calculation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign distribution error when clearing algebraic fractions

You dropped the sign change on the constant term −0.84P-\frac{0.84}{P} when multiplying the equation by −P-P.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When clearing a rational term −cx-\frac{c}{x} by multiplying the entire equation by −x-x, remember that the product of two negatives is positive: (−x)⋅(−cx)=+c(-x) \cdot \left(-\frac{c}{x}\right) = +c. Doing this transformation in one mental step often causes the negative sign of the constant to be carried over erroneously.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Two-step equation clearing
  • Multiply by +P+P first, then multiply by −1-1 or transpose terms across the equals sign.

  • Write out (14.50)P−2.80P2−0.84=0(14.50)P - 2.80 P^2 - 0.84 = 0 as an explicit intermediate step before rearranging.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply 14.50−2.80P−0.84P=014.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} = 0 by PP: 14.50P−2.80P2−0.84=014.50 P - 2.80 P^2 - 0.84 = 0.

  2. Multiply by −1-1 to establish standard form aP2+bP+c=0a P^2 + b P + c = 0: 2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=02.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0.

  3. Compute the discriminant: Δ=(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)=210.25−9.408=200.842\Delta = (-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84) = 210.25 - 9.408 = 200.842.

  4. Take the square root: 200.842≈14.1719\sqrt{200.842} \approx 14.1719.

  5. Calculate the upper root: Pcrit=14.50+14.17195.60=28.67195.60≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = \frac{14.50 + 14.1719}{5.60} = \frac{28.6719}{5.60} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil} (or 5.11 mg P/kg soil5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} with intermediate rounding).

Final answer

Pcrit=5.11 mg P/kg soil (or 5.12 mg P/kg soil)P_{\text{crit}} = 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil}\text{ (or } 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice clearing denominators by writing out the multiplication by +x+x before changing signs.

  • Verify your quadratic constant's sign by mentally substituting a large positive value of PP back into the original expression.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student might take the derivative to find the maximum benefit instead of finding the zero crossing of W_net(P).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dWnetdP=−2.80+0.84P2=0\frac{dW_{\text{net}}}{dP} = -2.80 + \frac{0.84}{P^2} = 0

    Correct

    Wnet(P)=14.50−2.80P−0.84P=0W_{\text{net}}(P) = 14.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} = 0

    You set the derivative dWnetdP\frac{dW_{\text{net}}}{dP} equal to zero. That finds the phosphorus level where plant growth benefit is maximized, whereas the transition threshold between mutualism and parasitism occurs where net benefit equals zero, Wnet(P)=0W_{\text{net}}(P) = 0.

  2. Step 2

    0.84P2=2.80  ⟹  P2=0.842.80  ⟹  P2=0.30  ⟹  P=0.30\frac{0.84}{P^2} = 2.80 \implies P^2 = \frac{0.84}{2.80} \implies P^2 = 0.30 \implies P = \sqrt{0.30}

    Correct

    2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=0  ⟹  P=14.50±(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)2(2.80)2.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0 \implies P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{(-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84)}}{2(2.80)}

    You carried out your algebraic solving steps cleanly, but they follow from the incorrect starting equation.

  3. Step 3

    Pcrit=0.55 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = 0.55\text{ mg P/kg soil}

    Correct

    Pcrit≈5.11 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} (or 5.12 mg P/kg soil5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil})

    Your final numerical value corresponds to the optimal phosphorus level for maximum plant benefit rather than the boundary where the relationship becomes parasitic.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You computed the derivative of the reciprocal and linear terms accurately.

You solved the resulting power equation cleanly and evaluated the square root correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Optimization vs. zero-crossing confusion

You solved for the peak of the benefit curve instead of its root.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated a critical point of optimization (setting the first derivative dWdP=0\frac{dW}{dP} = 0) with a critical transition threshold between ecological states (setting the function value W(P)=0W(P) = 0). In ecological trade-off models, the boundary between mutualism (W>0W > 0) and parasitism (W<0W < 0) is defined by the zero-benefit crossing, not the maximum benefit point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Transition vs. Optimum
  • A regime boundary where an interaction shifts between net positive and net negative occurs at W(x)=0W(x) = 0, whereas an optimal condition occurs at W′(x)=0W'(x) = 0.

  • Always check whether the prompt asks for a threshold boundary (break-even zero) or an optimal maximum/minimum before taking derivatives.

Clear Denominators for Rational Equations
  • When solving A−Bx−Cx=0A - Bx - \frac{C}{x} = 0 for x>0x > 0, multiply by xx to convert it to a standard quadratic Bx2−Ax+C=0Bx^2 - Ax + C = 0.

  • Rearrange into standard quadratic form and apply the quadratic formula rather than isolating a single term.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the net benefit equal to zero: 14.50−2.80P−0.84P=014.50 - 2.80 P - \frac{0.84}{P} = 0.

  2. Multiply both sides by −P-P to arrange into standard quadratic form: 2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=02.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0.

  3. Compute the discriminant: Δ=(−14.50)2−4(2.80)(0.84)=210.25−9.408=200.842\Delta = (-14.50)^2 - 4(2.80)(0.84) = 210.25 - 9.408 = 200.842, so Δ≈14.172\sqrt{\Delta} \approx 14.172.

  4. Evaluate the upper physical root: P=14.50+14.1722(2.80)=28.6725.60≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP = \frac{14.50 + 14.172}{2(2.80)} = \frac{28.672}{5.60} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil} (or 5.11 mg P/kg soil5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} with intermediate rounding).

Final answer

Pcrit=5.11 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = 5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} (or 5.12 mg P/kg soil5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between finding an extreme value (calculus critical point, f′(x)=0f'(x) = 0) and finding a break-even threshold (algebraic root, f(x)=0f(x) = 0).

  • Practice solving rational response curves by clearing denominators to form standard quadratics.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student might compute the lower root corresponding to the minus sign instead of the upper critical threshold.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=0  ⟹  P=14.50±210.25−9.4085.602.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0 \implies P = \frac{14.50 \pm \sqrt{210.25 - 9.408}}{5.60}

  2. Step 2

    P=14.50−200.8425.60  ⟹  P=14.50−14.17195.60  ⟹  P=0.32815.60P = \frac{14.50 - \sqrt{200.842}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 - 14.1719}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{0.3281}{5.60}

    Correct

    P=14.50+200.8425.60  ⟹  P=14.50+14.17195.60  ⟹  P=28.67195.60P = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{200.842}}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{14.50 + 14.1719}{5.60} \implies P = \frac{28.6719}{5.60}

    You chose the negative sign branch (−-), which calculates the lower root. The question asks for the upper critical threshold, which corresponds to the addition branch (++).

  3. Step 3

    Pcrit=0.06 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} = 0.06\text{ mg P/kg soil}

    Correct

    Pcrit≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil}

    Because you evaluated the lower root, your final value of 0.06 mg P/kg soil0.06\text{ mg P/kg soil} represents the lower boundary rather than the requested upper critical threshold of 5.12 mg P/kg soil5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly multiplied by −P-P to set up the quadratic equation 2.80P2−14.50P+0.84=02.80 P^2 - 14.50 P + 0.84 = 0.

You accurately calculated the discriminant Δ=200.842\Delta = 200.842 and its square root ≈14.1719\approx 14.1719.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Root Selection Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the minus sign branch in the quadratic formula without comparing both physical roots against the question's explicit request for the upper critical threshold where excess phosphorus causes the fungal symbiont to become parasitic.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Both Quadratic Roots
  • Quadratic equations generally yield two distinct roots: P1=−b−Δ2aP_1 = \frac{-b - \sqrt{\Delta}}{2a} and P2=−b+Δ2aP_2 = \frac{-b + \sqrt{\Delta}}{2a}.

  • Always write down and evaluate both roots before choosing the one that fulfills the specific biological condition stated in the prompt.

Connect Roots to Biological Meaning
  • In the mutualism–parasitism continuum, the lower root marks the starvation boundary below which the plant cannot maintain the partnership, while the upper root marks the nutrient surplus boundary where direct uptake renders fungal colonization a net carbon cost.

  • Select the upper root (P2P_2) when analyzing parasitism induced by nutrient saturation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the upper root using the addition sign: Pcrit=14.50+200.8425.60P_{\text{crit}} = \frac{14.50 + \sqrt{200.842}}{5.60}

  2. Substitute the evaluated square root: Pcrit=14.50+14.17195.60=28.67195.60P_{\text{crit}} = \frac{14.50 + 14.1719}{5.60} = \frac{28.6719}{5.60}

  3. Divide and round to two decimal places: Pcrit≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil} (or 5.11 mg P/kg soil5.11\text{ mg P/kg soil} with intermediate rounding).

Final answer

Pcrit≈5.12 mg P/kg soilP_{\text{crit}} \approx 5.12\text{ mg P/kg soil}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check each root against the physical problem domain and verify whether the question asks for the minimum, lower, maximum, or upper threshold.

  • Interpret the ecological meaning of each root: low phosphorus starvation vs. high phosphorus nutrient saturation.

  • Practice selecting between quadratic roots in resource-allocation models across ecology.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A plant-rhizobia symbiosis provides net nitrogen benefit W(N)=10.0−2.0N−3.2NW(N) = 10.0 - 2.0 N - \frac{3.2}{N}, where NN is soil inorganic nitrogen in mg/kg\text{mg/kg}. Find the upper critical nitrogen threshold NcritN_{\text{crit}} where W(N)=0W(N) = 0.

Answer

Ncrit=4.64 mg/kgN_{\text{crit}} = 4.64\text{ mg/kg}. Setting 10.0−2.0N−3.2N=010.0 - 2.0N - \frac{3.2}{N} = 0 yields 2.0N2−10.0N+3.2=02.0 N^2 - 10.0 N + 3.2 = 0. Using the quadratic formula, N=10.0±100−25.64.0=10.0+74.44.0≈10.0+8.62554.0≈4.66 mg/kgN = \frac{10.0 \pm \sqrt{100 - 25.6}}{4.0} = \frac{10.0 + \sqrt{74.4}}{4.0} \approx \frac{10.0 + 8.6255}{4.0} \approx 4.66\text{ mg/kg} (or 4.64 mg/kg4.64\text{ mg/kg} if intermediate rounding is applied).

02

An endophyte-grass interaction has a net growth yield function Y(S)=18.0−1.5S−12.0SY(S) = 18.0 - 1.5 S - \frac{12.0}{S} across a salinity gradient SS. Find the critical salinity threshold ScritS_{\text{crit}} where the association switches from beneficial mutualism (Y>0Y > 0) to costly stress (Y<0Y < 0).

Answer

Scrit=11.29S_{\text{crit}} = 11.29. Multiplying by −S-S gives 1.5S2−18.0S+12.0=01.5 S^2 - 18.0 S + 12.0 = 0. The roots are S=18.0±324−723.0=18.0+2523.0≈18.0+15.87453.0≈11.29S = \frac{18.0 \pm \sqrt{324 - 72}}{3.0} = \frac{18.0 + \sqrt{252}}{3.0} \approx \frac{18.0 + 15.8745}{3.0} \approx 11.29.

03

A biocontrol model tracks net aphid defense benefit B(T)=8.50−0.75T−5.00T−1.25B(T) = 8.50 - 0.75 T - \frac{5.00}{T} - 1.25 where TT is temperature in ∘C^{\circ}\text{C}. Combine like terms first, then determine the upper threshold TcritT_{\text{crit}} where B(T)=0B(T) = 0.

Answer

Tcrit=8.91∘CT_{\text{crit}} = 8.91^{\circ}\text{C}. First combine constant terms: 7.25−0.75T−5.00T=07.25 - 0.75 T - \frac{5.00}{T} = 0. Multiply by −T-T to get 0.75T2−7.25T+5.00=00.75 T^2 - 7.25 T + 5.00 = 0. The upper root is T=7.25+7.252−4(0.75)(5.00)2(0.75)=7.25+52.5625−15.001.50=7.25+37.56251.50≈7.25+6.12881.50≈8.92∘CT = \frac{7.25 + \sqrt{7.25^2 - 4(0.75)(5.00)}}{2(0.75)} = \frac{7.25 + \sqrt{52.5625 - 15.00}}{1.50} = \frac{7.25 + \sqrt{37.5625}}{1.50} \approx \frac{7.25 + 6.1288}{1.50} \approx 8.92^{\circ}\text{C} (or 8.91∘C8.91^{\circ}\text{C} depending on rounding).

Loading workspace…