Resources

In an AP Biology laboratory investigation on population genetics and multiple alleles, students perform blood agglutination assays on a randomized sample of 200200 students to determine ABO blood phenotypes. The experimental counts are: 8282 individuals with Blood Type A, 2424 with Blood Type B, 1010 with Blood Type AB, and 8484 with Blood Type O. Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium with allele frequencies p=f(IA)p = f(I^A), q=f(IB)q = f(I^B), and r=f(i)r = f(i) such that p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1: (a) Calculate the sample frequency of the recessive allele rr, (b) calculate the allele frequencies pp and qq, and (c) determine the expected number of type AB individuals based on these derived frequencies.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) r=84200=0.42≈0.648r = \sqrt{\frac{84}{200}} = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648; (b) Since frequency of Type A ++ Type O is (p+r)2=82+84200=0.830(p + r)^2 = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = 0.830, p+r=0.830≈0.911p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911, yielding p=0.911−0.648=0.263p = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263; then q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089; (c) Expected frequency of Type AB is 2pq=2(0.263)(0.089)≈0.04682pq = 2(0.263)(0.089) \approx 0.0468, giving an expected count of 200×0.0468≈9.36200 \times 0.0468 \approx 9.36 individuals (or approximately 99 individuals).

Steps

Understanding the ABO System Under Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium

The ABO blood group system is governed by three alleles:

  • IAI^A with frequency pp
  • IBI^B with frequency qq
  • ii with frequency rr

These frequencies satisfy the relationship: p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1

Expanding the trinomial (p+q+r)2=1(p + q + r)^2 = 1 gives the expected genotype frequencies:

  • Type O (iiii): r2r^2
  • Type A (IAIA+IAiI^A I^A + I^A i): p2+2prp^2 + 2pr
  • Type B (IBIB+IBiI^B I^B + I^B i): q2+2qrq^2 + 2qr
  • Type AB (IAIBI^A I^B): 2pq2pq

The total sample size is N=200N = 200.


Step (a): Calculate the Frequency of the Recessive Allele (rr)

Phenotype O corresponds solely to the homozygous recessive genotype iiii. Therefore, its phenotypic frequency directly equals r2r^2: f(Type O)=84200=0.42f(\text{Type O}) = \frac{84}{200} = 0.42

Taking the square root gives rr: r=0.42≈0.648r = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648


Step (b): Calculate Allele Frequencies pp and qq

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is attempting to find pp by taking f(Type A)\sqrt{f(\text{Type A})}. Because the IAI^A allele is dominant to ii, individuals with blood type A include both homozygous individuals (p2p^2) and heterozygous individuals (2pr2pr).

To isolate pp, combine the frequencies of Type A and Type O: f(Type A)+f(Type O)=(p2+2pr)+r2=(p+r)2f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}) = (p^2 + 2pr) + r^2 = (p + r)^2

From the sample data: (p+r)2=82+84200=166200=0.830(p + r)^2 = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = \frac{166}{200} = 0.830

Take the square root of both sides: p+r=0.830≈0.911p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911

Now, solve for pp using the value of r≈0.648r \approx 0.648: p=(p+r)−r≈0.911−0.648=0.263p = (p + r) - r \approx 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263

Finally, solve for qq using p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1: q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089


Step (c): Determine the Expected Number of Type AB Individuals

Blood type AB corresponds to the codominant genotype IAIBI^A I^B, which occurs with expected frequency 2pq2pq: f(Type AB)=2pq=2⋅0.263⋅0.089≈0.0468f(\text{Type AB}) = 2pq = 2 \cdot 0.263 \cdot 0.089 \approx 0.0468

Multiply this frequency by the total population (N=200N = 200): Expected count=200⋅0.0468≈9.36\text{Expected count} = 200 \cdot 0.0468 \approx 9.36

Thus, approximately 9.369.36 individuals (or about 99 individuals) are expected to have blood type AB.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the frequency of type A as purely homozygous p² rather than p² + 2pr to find p.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Frequency of O=r2=84200=0.42  ⟹  r=0.42≈0.648\text{Frequency of O} = r^2 = \frac{84}{200} = 0.42 \implies r = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648

  2. Step 2

    Frequency of A=p2=82200=0.41  ⟹  p=0.41≈0.640\text{Frequency of A} = p^2 = \frac{82}{200} = 0.41 \implies p = \sqrt{0.41} \approx 0.640

    Correct

    (p+r)2=f(Type A)+f(Type O)=82+84200=0.830  ⟹  p+r=0.830≈0.911  ⟹  p=0.911−0.648=0.263(p + r)^2 = f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}) = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = 0.830 \implies p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911 \implies p = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263

    Because allele IAI^A is dominant to ii, blood type A consists of both IAIAI^A I^A (p2p^2) and IAiI^A i (2pr2pr), meaning f(Type A)=p2+2prf(\text{Type A}) = p^2 + 2pr, not p2p^2. Taking the square root of f(Type A)f(\text{Type A}) directly ignores heterozygous individuals.

  3. Step 3

    q=1−p−r=1−0.640−0.648=−0.288q = 1 - p - r = 1 - 0.640 - 0.648 = -0.288

    Correct

    q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089

    You correctly applied the relation p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1, but your calculation inherited the incorrect value of pp, yielding an impossible negative allele frequency.

  4. Step 4

    Expected AB=2pq×200=2(0.640)(−0.288)×200=−73.7\text{Expected AB} = 2pq \times 200 = 2(0.640)(-0.288) \times 200 = -73.7

    Correct

    Expected AB=2pq×200=2(0.263)(0.089)×200≈9.36\text{Expected AB} = 2pq \times 200 = 2(0.263)(0.089) \times 200 \approx 9.36

    You applied the correct Hardy-Weinberg formula for the codominant phenotype AB (2pq×N2pq \times N), but the result was distorted by the earlier error in pp and qq.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that blood type O corresponds solely to the homozygous recessive genotype iiii (r2r^2).

You correctly solved for the recessive allele frequency rr by taking the square root of f(Type O)f(\text{Type O}).

You knew to use the population frequency constraint p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1 to solve for the third allele frequency.

You correctly identified that the expected frequency of codominant type AB is 2pq2pq.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Dominant Phenotypic Frequency with Pure Homozygote Frequency

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that individuals expressing the dominant A phenotype are exclusively homozygous IAIAI^A I^A (p2p^2), forgetting that complete dominance of IAI^A over ii means the A phenotype also includes heterozygous individuals IAiI^A i (2pr2pr). Combining Type A and Type O into (p+r)2=p2+2pr+r2(p + r)^2 = p^2 + 2pr + r^2 is required to isolate pp.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dominance in Multiple Alleles
  • A dominant phenotype reflects both homozygous (p2p^2) and heterozygous (2pr2pr) genotypes: f(Type A)=p2+2prf(\text{Type A}) = p^2 + 2pr.

  • Never compute p=f(Type A)p = \sqrt{f(\text{Type A})}. Instead, combine Type A and Type O to form (p+r)2=f(Type A)+f(Type O)(p + r)^2 = f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}), take the square root to get p+rp + r, and then subtract rr.

Biological Sanity Check
  • Allele frequencies must lie strictly between 00 and 11: 0≤p,q,r≤10 \le p, q, r \le 1.

  • If any allele frequency or expected individual count evaluates to a negative number, stop immediately and re-evaluate how the dominant phenotypic classes were partitioned.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine the phenotypic frequencies of Type A (p2+2prp^2 + 2pr) and Type O (r2r^2): (p+r)2=82+84200=166200=0.830(p + r)^2 = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = \frac{166}{200} = 0.830.

  2. Take the square root to obtain p+rp + r: p+r=0.830≈0.911p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911.

  3. Subtract r≈0.648r \approx 0.648 to find pp: p=0.911−0.648=0.263p = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263.

  4. Solve for qq using p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1: q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089.

  5. Calculate the expected number of AB individuals: 2pq×N=2(0.263)(0.089)×200≈9.362pq \times N = 2(0.263)(0.089) \times 200 \approx 9.36.

Final answer

(a) r≈0.648r \approx 0.648; (b) p≈0.263p \approx 0.263, q≈0.089q \approx 0.089; (c) Expected count of Type AB is approximately 9.369.36 (or about 99 individuals).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the trinomial expansion (p+q+r)2=p2+q2+r2+2pq+2pr+2qr(p + q + r)^2 = p^2 + q^2 + r^2 + 2pq + 2pr + 2qr and map each genotype to its corresponding blood phenotype.

  • Practice combining dominant phenotypes with the homozygous recessive phenotype to isolate binomial squares such as (p+r)2(p + r)^2 and (q+r)2(q + r)^2.

  • Always verify that all calculated frequencies are positive and sum to 1.01.0 before computing expected genotype counts.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student directly counts observed phenotype numbers as simple allele counts rather than accounting for dominant and recessive diploid genotypes under Hardy-Weinberg.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total alleles=2×200=400  ⟹  r=2×84400=168400=0.42\text{Total alleles} = 2 \times 200 = 400 \implies r = \frac{2 \times 84}{400} = \frac{168}{400} = 0.42

    Correct

    f(Type O)=r2=84200=0.42  ⟹  r=0.42≈0.648f(\text{Type O}) = r^2 = \frac{84}{200} = 0.42 \implies r = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648

    You calculated the phenotypic frequency of Type O (84/200=0.4284/200 = 0.42) and labeled it directly as the allele frequency rr. Under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, Type O is the homozygous recessive genotype (iiii), so its frequency represents r2r^2, requiring a square root to find rr.

  2. Step 2

    p=2×82+10400=174400=0.435  ⟹  q=2×24+10400=58400=0.145p = \frac{2 \times 82 + 10}{400} = \frac{174}{400} = 0.435 \implies q = \frac{2 \times 24 + 10}{400} = \frac{58}{400} = 0.145

    Correct

    (p+r)2=82+84200=0.830  ⟹  p+r=0.830≈0.911  ⟹  p=0.911−0.648=0.263  ⟹  q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089(p + r)^2 = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = 0.830 \implies p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911 \implies p = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263 \implies q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089

    You used direct gene counting by assuming every Type A individual has two IAI^A alleles and every Type B individual has two IBI^B alleles. Because IAI^A and IBI^B are completely dominant over ii, Type A consists of both IAIAI^A I^A (p2p^2) and IAiI^A i (2pr2pr), so you must solve for pp using (p+r)2=f(Type A)+f(Type O)(p + r)^2 = f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}).

  3. Step 3

    Expected AB frequency=2pq=2(0.435)(0.145)=0.12615  ⟹  Expected AB count=0.12615×200=25.23\text{Expected AB frequency} = 2pq = 2(0.435)(0.145) = 0.12615 \implies \text{Expected AB count} = 0.12615 \times 200 = 25.23

    Correct

    Expected AB count=2pq×200=2(0.263)(0.089)×200≈9.36\text{Expected AB count} = 2pq \times 200 = 2(0.263)(0.089) \times 200 \approx 9.36

    You correctly applied the Hardy-Weinberg expected heterozygote formula 2pq×N2pq \times N, but your final numerical result was affected by the incorrect allele frequencies from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total gene pool size as 2N=4002N = 400 alleles for 200200 diploid individuals.

You correctly identified that Type AB individuals are heterozygous IAIBI^A I^B and modeled their expected frequency as 2pq2pq.

You multiplied your calculated genotype frequency by the total population size to find the expected individual count.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Allele counting applied to dominant/recessive phenotypes

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated blood phenotypes as if every genotype were directly observable (codominance without dominance), confusing the phenotypic frequency of homozygous recessives (r2r^2) with the allele frequency (rr) and failing to account for the ii alleles masked inside heterozygous Type A (IAiI^A i) and Type B (IBiI^B i) individuals.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direct Counting vs. Hardy-Weinberg Estimation
  • Direct allele counting can only be used when every genotype produces a unique, distinct phenotype (such as strict codominance or incomplete dominance). When an allele is dominant, heterozygotes and homozygous dominants share the same phenotype.

  • Always check whether a phenotype hides a recessive allele before attempting to count alleles directly.

Finding Allele Frequencies with Multiple Alleles (ABO)
  • In the ABO system, f(Type O)=r2f(\text{Type O}) = r^2, giving r=f(O)r = \sqrt{f(\text{O})}. Similarly, combining Type A and Type O gives p2+2pr+r2=(p+r)2p^2 + 2pr + r^2 = (p + r)^2, so p=f(A)+f(O)−rp = \sqrt{f(\text{A}) + f(\text{O})} - r.

  • Group the recessive phenotype with the dominant phenotype to form a perfect square binomial before taking the square root.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the frequency of the homozygous recessive phenotype equal to r2r^2: r2=84200=0.42r^2 = \frac{84}{200} = 0.42, which gives r=0.42≈0.648r = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648.

  2. Combine the frequencies of Type A and Type O to isolate (p+r)2(p + r)^2: (p+r)2=82+84200=0.830(p + r)^2 = \frac{82 + 84}{200} = 0.830, so p+r=0.830≈0.911p + r = \sqrt{0.830} \approx 0.911.

  3. Solve for pp: p=(p+r)−r=0.911−0.648=0.263p = (p + r) - r = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263.

  4. Solve for qq using p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1: q=1−(p+r)=1−0.911=0.089q = 1 - (p + r) = 1 - 0.911 = 0.089.

  5. Calculate the expected number of Type AB individuals: Expected count=2pq×N=2(0.263)(0.089)×200≈9.36\text{Expected count} = 2pq \times N = 2(0.263)(0.089) \times 200 \approx 9.36 individuals.

Final answer

(a) r≈0.648r \approx 0.648, (b) p≈0.263p \approx 0.263 and q≈0.089q \approx 0.089, (c) approximately 9.369.36 individuals (or about 99 individuals)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between phenotypic frequency (r2r^2) and allele frequency (rr) when dominance is present.

  • Practice using the (p+r)2=f(Type A)+f(Type O)(p + r)^2 = f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}) binomial expansion to solve ABO blood group frequency problems.

  • Verify your calculated allele frequencies by checking that p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1 before computing expected genotype frequencies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets the factor of 2 in the heterozygous genotype frequency for AB, calculating pq instead of 2pq.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r2=84200=0.42  ⟹  r=0.42≈0.648r^2 = \frac{84}{200} = 0.42 \implies r = \sqrt{0.42} \approx 0.648

  2. Step 2

    (p+r)2=82+84200=166200=0.83  ⟹  p+r=0.83≈0.911  ⟹  p=0.911−0.648=0.263  ⟹  q=1−0.263−0.648=0.089(p+r)^2 = \frac{82+84}{200} = \frac{166}{200} = 0.83 \implies p+r = \sqrt{0.83} \approx 0.911 \implies p = 0.911 - 0.648 = 0.263 \implies q = 1 - 0.263 - 0.648 = 0.089

  3. Step 3

    Expected AB frequency=pq=0.263×0.089=0.0234  ⟹  Expected AB count=0.0234×200=4.68\text{Expected AB frequency} = pq = 0.263 \times 0.089 = 0.0234 \implies \text{Expected AB count} = 0.0234 \times 200 = 4.68

    Correct

    Expected AB frequency=2pq=2(0.263)(0.089)≈0.0468  ⟹  Expected AB count=0.0468×200≈9.36\text{Expected AB frequency} = 2pq = 2(0.263)(0.089) \approx 0.0468 \implies \text{Expected AB count} = 0.0468 \times 200 \approx 9.36

    You calculated the frequency of blood type AB as pqpq instead of 2pq2pq. Because type AB represents a heterozygous genotype (IAIBI^A I^B), individuals can inherit IAI^A from the egg and IBI^B from the sperm, or vice versa, requiring a coefficient of 22.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the phenotypic frequency of type O equals r2r^2 because it is the only homozygous recessive phenotype.

You successfully applied the identity (p+r)2=f(Type A)+f(Type O)(p+r)^2 = f(\text{Type A}) + f(\text{Type O}) to separate allele pp from the dominant/recessive mixture.

You accurately used the constraint p+q+r=1p + q + r = 1 to calculate qq.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Heterozygote Multiplier

You set the expected frequency of Type AB to pqpq instead of 2pq2pq.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Forgetting that codominant phenotypes (like blood type AB) represent heterozygous genotypes (IAIBI^A I^B), which follow the binomial/trinomial expansion term 2pq2pq reflecting two reciprocal parental combinations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Expansion Term for Heterozygotes
  • In any Hardy-Weinberg expansion (p+q+r)2=p2+q2+r2+2pq+2pr+2qr(p + q + r)^2 = p^2 + q^2 + r^2 + 2pq + 2pr + 2qr, every heterozygous genotype has a coefficient of 22.

  • Always write out the genotype symbol (here, IAIBI^A I^B) before substituting frequencies so you remember to include the factor of 22.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the expected genotype frequency for codominant Type AB: f(IAIB)=2pqf(I^A I^B) = 2pq.

  2. Substitute your calculated values for pp and qq: f(Type AB)=2×0.263×0.089≈0.04682f(\text{Type AB}) = 2 \times 0.263 \times 0.089 \approx 0.04682.

  3. Multiply the genotype frequency by the total sample size N=200N = 200: Expected count=200×0.04682≈9.36\text{Expected count} = 200 \times 0.04682 \approx 9.36 individuals.

Final answer

Expected number of Type AB individuals is ≈9.36\approx 9.36 (or about 99 individuals).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the expansion of (p+q+r)2=1(p+q+r)^2 = 1 to verify how homozygous terms (p2,q2,r2p^2, q^2, r^2) differ from heterozygous terms (2pq,2pr,2qr2pq, 2pr, 2qr).

  • Practice identifying the underlying genotypes for codominant and incomplete dominant phenotypes.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a population of 500500 people in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, 180180 have blood type O and 225225 have blood type A. What is the allele frequency of p=f(IA)p = f(I^A)?

Answer

r=180500=0.36=0.60r = \sqrt{\frac{180}{500}} = \sqrt{0.36} = 0.60. Next, (p+r)2=225+180500=405500=0.81(p + r)^2 = \frac{225 + 180}{500} = \frac{405}{500} = 0.81, so p+r=0.81=0.90p + r = \sqrt{0.81} = 0.90. Therefore, p=0.90−0.60=0.30p = 0.90 - 0.60 = 0.30.

02

In a sample of 1,0001{,}000 individuals, 490490 have blood type O, 320320 have blood type A, and 150150 have blood type B. Determine the frequency of the IBI^B allele (qq).

Answer

r=4901000=0.49=0.70r = \sqrt{\frac{490}{1000}} = \sqrt{0.49} = 0.70. Combining types B and O gives (q+r)2=150+4901000=0.64(q + r)^2 = \frac{150 + 490}{1000} = 0.64, so q+r=0.64=0.80q + r = \sqrt{0.64} = 0.80. Thus, q=0.80−0.70=0.10q = 0.80 - 0.70 = 0.10.

03

In a population under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, allele frequencies are p=f(IA)=0.20p = f(I^A) = 0.20, q=f(IB)=0.10q = f(I^B) = 0.10, and r=f(i)=0.70r = f(i) = 0.70. In a sample of 400400 individuals, what is the expected number of individuals with blood type B?

Answer

Type B includes genotypes IBIBI^B I^B (q2q^2) and IBiI^B i (2qr2qr). Expected frequency =q2+2qr=(0.10)2+2(0.10)(0.70)=0.01+0.14=0.15= q^2 + 2qr = (0.10)^2 + 2(0.10)(0.70) = 0.01 + 0.14 = 0.15. Expected count =400×0.15=60= 400 \times 0.15 = 60 individuals.

Loading workspace…