Resources

A common ecological intuition predicts that when two competing granivorous rodent species (Chaetodipus intermedius, Species 11, and Dipodomys merriami, Species 22) consume seeds of two sizes (small grass seeds and large shrub seeds), a sudden two-fold increase in the abundance of small seeds will always elevate the population densities of both competitors. In an experimental desert plot, the per-capita competitive suppression coefficient of Dipodomys on Chaetodipus is α=1.25\alpha = 1.25, and the carrying capacities in baseline conditions are K1=300 individualsK_1 = 300\text{ individuals} and K2=280 individualsK_2 = 280\text{ individuals}. A nutrient irrigation treatment specifically doubles the production of large seeds favored by Dipodomys, driving K2K_2 from 280280 up to K2′=420 individualsK_2' = 420\text{ individuals}, while the small seed carrying capacity K1K_1 remains strictly unchanged at 300300. Using the classic Lotka-Volterra coexistence criteria and isocline zero-intercepts: (1) Determine the equilibrium population size N^1\hat{N}_1 of Chaetodipus under baseline conditions assuming Dipodomys is at its single-species carrying capacity (N2=K2=280N_2 = K_2 = 280). (2) Demonstrate quantitatively what happens to the population of Chaetodipus when Dipodomys expands to N2′=K2′=420N_2' = K_2' = 420. (3) Name the ecological phenomenon whereby an increase in a shared resource leads to the counter-intuitive local extinction or severe suppression of a competitor.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(1) Baseline steady-state growth requirement for Species 11 gives N1=K1−αN2=300−(1.25)(280)=300−350=−50≤0N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2 = 300 - (1.25)(280) = 300 - 350 = -50 \le 0, meaning Chaetodipus is already under competitive pressure; if held at N2=200N_2 = 200, N^1=50\hat{N}_1 = 50, but at N2=280N_2 = 280, dN1dt<0\frac{dN_1}{dt} < 0, driving N^1→0 individuals\hat{N}_1 \to 0\text{ individuals}; (2) Following resource enrichment of Species 22, K1−αK2′=300−(1.25)(420)=300−525=−225<0K_1 - \alpha K_2' = 300 - (1.25)(420) = 300 - 525 = -225 < 0. Because the competitor's isocline shifts entirely above Chaetodipus's carrying capacity (K2′>K1α=3001.25=240K_2' > \frac{K_1}{\alpha} = \frac{300}{1.25} = 240), Chaetodipus is driven to complete competitive exclusion (N1=0N_1 = 0); (3) The phenomenon is the 'Paradox of Enrichment' mediating competitive exclusion (or apparent resource-mediated displacement).

Steps

01

Baseline Equilibrium Population Size (N^1\hat{N}_1)

In the classic Lotka-Volterra two-species competition model, the population growth rate of Species 11 (Chaetodipus intermedius) is given by:

dN1dt=r1N1(K1−N1−αN2K1)\frac{dN_1}{dt} = r_1 N_1 \left(\frac{K_1 - N_1 - \alpha N_2}{K_1}\right)

For Species 11 to maintain a non-zero steady-state population (dN1dt=0\frac{dN_1}{dt} = 0 with N1>0N_1 > 0), the population must satisfy the zero-growth isocline equation:

N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2

Substitute the baseline values (K1=300K_1 = 300, α=1.25\alpha = 1.25, and N2=K2=280N_2 = K_2 = 280):

N1=300−(1.25)(280)=300−350=−50N_1 = 300 - (1.25)(280) = 300 - 350 = -50

Because population sizes cannot be negative, a negative algebraic solution indicates that at N2=280N_2 = 280, the growth rate is strictly negative (dN1dt<0\frac{dN_1}{dt} < 0) for any N1>0N_1 > 0. For Species 11 to maintain a positive population density, the abundance of Species 22 must not exceed:

N2<K1α=3001.25=240 individualsN_2 < \frac{K_1}{\alpha} = \frac{300}{1.25} = 240\text{ individuals}

Because K2=280>240K_2 = 280 > 240, Species 22 at its carrying capacity suppresses Species 11 entirely:

N^1=0 individuals\hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}


02

Quantitative Effect of Resource Enrichment (K2′=420K_2' = 420)

When nutrient irrigation elevates the carrying capacity of Dipodomys to K2′=420K_2' = 420, its equilibrium population exerts an even greater per-capita competitive suppression:

K1−αK2′=300−(1.25)(420)=300−525=−225K_1 - \alpha K_2' = 300 - (1.25)(420) = 300 - 525 = -225

The deficit widens significantly from −50-50 to −225-225. Graphically, on a phase-plane diagram with N1N_1 on the vertical axis and N2N_2 on the horizontal axis:

  • The horizontal intercept of the Species 11 isocline is K1α=240\frac{K_1}{\alpha} = 240.
  • The horizontal intercept of the Species 22 isocline shifts from K2=280K_2 = 280 outward to K2′=420K_2' = 420.

Because K2′=420K_2' = 420 lies entirely to the right of K1α=240\frac{K_1}{\alpha} = 240, the Species 22 isocline completely envelops that of Species 11 along the N2N_2-axis. Species 22 unconditionally wins by competitive exclusion, driving Chaetodipus to complete extinction:

N1→0 individualsN_1 \to 0\text{ individuals}


03

Name of the Phenomenon

This outcome is known as the Paradox of Enrichment (specifically manifested here as resource-mediated competitive exclusion or indirect displacement). Although total ecosystem resource availability increases, the selective enrichment of the stronger competitor's favored resource enhances its numerical advantage and intensifies interspecific competition, ultimately causing the decline or local extinction of the subordinate competitor.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student performs the linear algebraic subtraction but forgets that biological populations cannot take negative values, reporting a negative number as the equilibrium population.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    N^1=K1−α∗N2  ⟹  N^1=300−1.25∗280  ⟹  N^1=300−350=−50 individuals\hat{N}_1 = K_1 - \alpha * N_2 \implies \hat{N}_1 = 300 - 1.25 * 280 \implies \hat{N}_1 = 300 - 350 = -50\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N1=K1−αN2=300−1.25(280)=−50  ⟹  N^1=0 individualsN_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2 = 300 - 1.25(280) = -50 \implies \hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}

    You correctly evaluated the linear algebraic expression to get −50-50. However, biological population sizes cannot be negative. When K1−αN2<0K_1 - \alpha N_2 < 0, the per-capita growth rate dN1dt\frac{dN_1}{dt} is strictly negative for any positive population, which drives the population to extinction (N^1=0\hat{N}_1 = 0).

  2. Step 2

    N^1′=K1−α∗N2′  ⟹  N^1′=300−1.25∗420  ⟹  N^1′=300−525=−225 individuals\hat{N}_1' = K_1 - \alpha * N_2' \implies \hat{N}_1' = 300 - 1.25 * 420 \implies \hat{N}_1' = 300 - 525 = -225\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N1=K1−αN2′=300−1.25(420)=−225  ⟹  N^1′=0 individualsN_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2' = 300 - 1.25(420) = -225 \implies \hat{N}_1' = 0\text{ individuals} (complete competitive exclusion)

    You accurately computed the algebraic difference as −225-225. Because this value is strictly less than zero (and K2′=420>K1α=240K_2' = 420 > \frac{K_1}{\alpha} = 240), the zero-growth isocline of Dipodomys lies entirely above that of Chaetodipus, resulting in competitive exclusion where N1→0N_1 \to 0 rather than a negative population size.

  3. Step 3

    Paradox of enrichment\text{Paradox of enrichment}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and applied the zero-growth isocline formula N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2.

You executed the multiplication and subtraction steps without arithmetic errors.

You correctly identified the Paradox of Enrichment as the counter-intuitive phenomenon.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Biological Non-Negativity Violation in Population Models

You treated the linear algebraic expression of the isocline as an unconstrained variable instead of imposing the biological boundary N≥0N \ge 0.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating purely algebraic solutions of dynamic models with ecologically feasible state variables. In differential equation population models, a negative isocline intercept indicates that the population growth rate dNdt\frac{dN}{dt} is negative everywhere in the positive quadrant, meaning the boundary equilibrium is extinction (N=0N = 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Biological Domain Constraint
  • Population densities and counts must satisfy Ni(t)≥0N_i(t) \ge 0 for all species ii.

  • Whenever an isocline equation yields Ki−αijNj<0K_i - \alpha_{ij} N_j < 0, interpret the result as a population in decline toward Ni=0N_i = 0 rather than a negative steady state.

Phase-Plane Graphical Check
  • If competitor jj's carrying capacity satisfies Kj>KiαijK_j > \frac{K_i}{\alpha_{ij}}, competitor jj competitively excludes species ii.

  • Check whether the competitor's abundance exceeds the species' resource-equivalent capacity; if it does, set the final equilibrium to 00.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the isocline threshold: K1−αN2=300−(1.25)(280)=−50K_1 - \alpha N_2 = 300 - (1.25)(280) = -50.

  2. Recognize that because −50<0-50 < 0, dN1dt<0\frac{dN_1}{dt} < 0 whenever N1>0N_1 > 0, so the population declines to zero.

  3. Repeat the threshold evaluation for enriched conditions: K1−αK2′=300−(1.25)(420)=−225<0K_1 - \alpha K_2' = 300 - (1.25)(420) = -225 < 0, which solidifies competitive exclusion (N1=0N_1 = 0).

Final answer

(1) N^1=0 individuals\hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}; (2) Chaetodipus is driven to complete extinction/competitive exclusion (N1=0 individualsN_1 = 0\text{ individuals}); (3) Paradox of Enrichment.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Lotka-Volterra phase-plane diagrams to see how zero-growth isoclines create vector fields bounded by the axes N1=0N_1 = 0 and N2=0N_2 = 0.

  • Practice interpreting negative algebraic values in biological rate equations as indicators of population decline toward extinction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides by the competition coefficient instead of multiplying by it when calculating the competitive impact of Species 2 on Species 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    N^1=K1−N2α  ⟹  N^1=300−2801.25  ⟹  N^1=300−224=76 individuals\hat{N}_1 = \frac{K_1 - N_2}{\alpha} \implies \hat{N}_1 = 300 - \frac{280}{1.25} \implies \hat{N}_1 = 300 - 224 = 76\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N^1=K1−αN2=300−(1.25)(280)=300−350=−50  ⟹  N^1=0 individuals\hat{N}_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2 = 300 - (1.25)(280) = 300 - 350 = -50 \implies \hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}

    In the Lotka-Volterra competition model, each individual of Species 22 exerts a competitive impact equal to α\alpha individuals of Species 11. The zero-growth isocline is N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2, not K1−N2αK_1 - \frac{N_2}{\alpha}. Because 300−(1.25)(280)=−50<0300 - (1.25)(280) = -50 < 0, Species 11 is already driven to extinction (N^1=0\hat{N}_1 = 0) under baseline conditions.

  2. Step 2

    N^1′=K1−N2′α  ⟹  N^1′=300−4201.25  ⟹  N^1′=300−336=−36, so N^1′=0 individuals (extinction)\hat{N}_1' = \frac{K_1 - N_2'}{\alpha} \implies \hat{N}_1' = 300 - \frac{420}{1.25} \implies \hat{N}_1' = 300 - 336 = -36\text{, so } \hat{N}_1' = 0\text{ individuals (extinction)}

    Correct

    N^1′=K1−αN2′=300−(1.25)(420)=300−525=−225≤0  ⟹  N^1′=0 individuals\hat{N}_1' = K_1 - \alpha N_2' = 300 - (1.25)(420) = 300 - 525 = -225 \le 0 \implies \hat{N}_1' = 0\text{ individuals}

    You correctly recognized that a negative steady-state value implies biological extinction (N1=0N_1 = 0). However, this calculation inherited the formula error from Step 1 where N2′N_2' was divided by α\alpha rather than multiplied by it.

  3. Step 3

    Paradox of enrichment\text{Paradox of enrichment}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that an algebraically negative population equilibrium corresponds biologically to competitive exclusion and zero individuals.

You correctly named the ecological phenomenon as the paradox of enrichment.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted competition coefficient operation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You divided by the competition coefficient α\alpha instead of multiplying N2N_2 by α\alpha when setting up the Lotka-Volterra zero-growth isocline N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lotka-Volterra Isocline Formulation
  • For Species 11, the zero-growth isocline is K1−N1−αN2=0K_1 - N_1 - \alpha N_2 = 0, which rearranges to N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2.

  • Always multiply the abundance of the competing species (N2N_2) by its per-capita suppression coefficient (α\alpha) before subtracting from carrying capacity (K1K_1).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the growth rate of Species 11 to zero: dN1dt=r1N1(K1−N1−αN2K1)=0\frac{dN_1}{dt} = r_1 N_1 \left(\frac{K_1 - N_1 - \alpha N_2}{K_1}\right) = 0.

  2. Solve for the isocline: N1=K1−αN2N_1 = K_1 - \alpha N_2.

  3. Substitute baseline parameters: N1=300−(1.25)(280)=300−350=−50N_1 = 300 - (1.25)(280) = 300 - 350 = -50.

  4. Interpret biological boundaries: because a population cannot be negative, dN1dt<0\frac{dN_1}{dt} < 0 whenever N2=280>K1α=240N_2 = 280 > \frac{K_1}{\alpha} = 240, so N^1=0 individuals\hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}.

Final answer

(1) N^1=0 individuals\hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ individuals}; (2) N^1′=0 individuals\hat{N}_1' = 0\text{ individuals} (competitive exclusion with deficit −225-225); (3) Paradox of enrichment

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical meaning of the competition coefficient α\alpha: each individual of Species 22 consumes resources equivalent to α\alpha individuals of Species 11, so its total equivalent footprint is α×N2\alpha \times N_2.

  • Practice sketching state-space phase planes with axes N1N_1 and N2N_2, labeling the axis intercepts (K1,0)(K_1, 0) and (0,K1α)(0, \frac{K_1}{\alpha}) to reinforce where multiplication versus division occurs.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two competing plant species share light resources. For Species A, carrying capacity is KA=120 stems/m2K_A = 120\text{ stems/m}^2 and the competitive effect of Species B on Species A is α=0.8\alpha = 0.8. If Species B is established at its carrying capacity of KB=180 stems/m2K_B = 180\text{ stems/m}^2, determine the steady-state density N^A\hat{N}_A of Species A.

Answer

N^A=0 stems/m2\hat{N}_A = 0\text{ stems/m}^2. Applying the isocline condition gives NA=KA−αKB=120−0.8(180)=120−144=−24N_A = K_A - \alpha K_B = 120 - 0.8(180) = 120 - 144 = -24. Because densities cannot be negative, Species A experiences negative growth everywhere and is excluded (NA=0N_A = 0).

02

In an aquatic microcosm, zooplankton Species 1 (K1=500 individuals/LK_1 = 500\text{ individuals/L}) competes with Species 2 (K2=400 individuals/LK_2 = 400\text{ individuals/L}) with competition coefficients α12=1.2\alpha_{12} = 1.2 and α21=0.6\alpha_{21} = 0.6. Determine which species wins by competitive exclusion and find the final equilibrium densities (N^1,N^2)(\hat{N}_1, \hat{N}_2).

Answer

Species 2 wins; (N^1=0,N^2=400 individuals/L)(\hat{N}_1 = 0, \hat{N}_2 = 400\text{ individuals/L}). Compare the axis intercepts: K1α12=5001.2≈416.7>K2=400\frac{K_1}{\alpha_{12}} = \frac{500}{1.2} \approx 416.7 > K_2 = 400 along the N2N_2-axis, but K1=500<K2α21=4000.6≈666.7K_1 = 500 < \frac{K_2}{\alpha_{21}} = \frac{400}{0.6} \approx 666.7 along the N1N_1-axis. Thus, the isocline for Species 2 lies entirely outside that of Species 1, driving Species 1 to extinction (N1=0N_1 = 0) while Species 2 reaches K2=400K_2 = 400.

03

An algal species with K1=250 cells/mLK_1 = 250\text{ cells/mL} competes with a cyanobacterium with K2=200 cells/mLK_2 = 200\text{ cells/mL}. The interaction coefficient is α=1.5\alpha = 1.5. A nutrient addition increases K2K_2 to K2′=300 cells/mLK_2' = 300\text{ cells/mL} while K1K_1 remains 250250. Show how this enrichment alters the outcome from coexistence/exclusion thresholds, and state the initial and final equilibrium values of N^1\hat{N}_1 when Species 2 is at carrying capacity.

Answer

Initial N^1=0 cells/mL\hat{N}_1 = 0\text{ cells/mL}; Final N^1′=0 cells/mL\hat{N}_1' = 0\text{ cells/mL}. In baseline conditions, K1−αK2=250−1.5(200)=250−300=−50<0K_1 - \alpha K_2 = 250 - 1.5(200) = 250 - 300 = -50 < 0, so N^1=0\hat{N}_1 = 0. After enrichment, K1−αK2′=250−1.5(300)=250−450=−200<0K_1 - \alpha K_2' = 250 - 1.5(300) = 250 - 450 = -200 < 0, further strengthening the competitive exclusion of Species 1 (N1=0N_1 = 0) and illustrating the Paradox of Enrichment.

Loading workspace…