Resources
An evolutionary biologist reconstructs the phylogenetic relationships among five vertebrate taxa: hagfish (), perch (), salamander (), lizard (), and mouse (). Character state analysis indicates that the ancestral lineage lacks jaws, lungs, claws/nails, and fur (). Jaws evolved along the internode leading to taxa ; lungs evolved along the internode leading to taxa ; claws or nails evolved along the internode leading to taxa and ; and fur evolved exclusively in taxon . Identify the sister taxon to taxon (lizard), and state whether the grouping consisting of taxa and forms a monophyletic, paraphyletic, or polyphyletic clade.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Sister taxon to : Taxon (mouse); The grouping is monophyletic.
Steps
Map the Derived Characters to Construct the Phylogeny
To determine relationships among the five taxa, track the sequential evolution of shared derived traits (synapomorphies):
- Root and Outgroup (): The ancestral lineage has the state (lacks all four traits). Hagfish () retains all ancestral states and branches off first as the basal outgroup.
- Evolution of Jaws: Jaws evolved on the internode leading to taxa and .
- Evolution of Lungs: Lungs evolved after the branch leading to perch () split off, defining the lineage containing salamander (), lizard (), and mouse ().
- Evolution of Claws or Nails: Claws or nails evolved after salamander () diverged, uniting lizard () and mouse () into a shared branch.
- Evolution of Fur: Fur evolved solely along the terminal branch leading to mouse ().
The resulting nested topology is:
Identify the Sister Taxon to Taxon
- Definition: Sister taxa are pairs of terminal taxa or clades that diverge from an immediate common ancestor not shared with any other group.
- Taxon (lizard) and Taxon (mouse) share a unique most recent common ancestor that arose after claws/nails evolved. Because this node leads only to and , the sister taxon to taxon is Taxon (mouse).
Classify the Grouping
- Definition: A group is monophyletic (a true clade) if it includes the most recent common ancestor and all of its descendants.
- The most recent common ancestor of , , and is the ancestral lineage in which lungs evolved.
- All descendant lineages arising from that lunged ancestor are present in the set , with no descendant omitted (which would make it paraphyletic) and no outside lineage added (which would make it polyphyletic).
- Therefore, the grouping is monophyletic.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses monophyly with paraphyly by believing a group is incomplete if an exclusive derived character like fur differentiates one of the descendant taxa.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
and share the most recent common ancestor marked by claws/nails. Sister taxon to taxon : taxon
- Step 2
Taxa and share lungs from their common ancestor. Because evolved fur exclusively, the grouping is paraphyletic.
CorrectThe grouping forms a monophyletic group (clade).
An exclusive derived trait (autapomorphy) like fur in taxon does not make a clade paraphyletic. Because the grouping includes the common ancestor with lungs and all of its descendant lineages ( and ), it satisfies the definition of a monophyletic clade.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that taxa and share an immediate common ancestor defined by claws/nails.
You correctly concluded that taxon is the sister taxon to taxon .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou mistook an autapomorphy (fur in ) as a reason for paraphyly rather than checking whether all descendants of the common ancestor were included.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou misunderstood the phylogenetic definition of monophyly versus paraphyly. A group is monophyletic if it contains the most recent common ancestor and all of its descendants, regardless of any novel derived traits that evolve within terminal lineages. Paraphyly only occurs when one or more descendant lineages are excluded from the group.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule of Monophyly (One Cut Test)
A group of taxa is monophyletic if and only if you can sever the ancestral branch leading to them with a single cut and detach exactly that set of taxa.
Find the most recent common ancestor of and (the branch where lungs evolved) and trace every branch arising from that node. Since every descendant lineage () is in the group and none is left out, classify the group as monophyletic.
- Definition of Paraphyly
A grouping is paraphyletic if it includes a common ancestor but leaves out at least one of its descendant lineages (e.g., grouping while excluding ).
Check if any descendant of the ancestral node is missing from your set; if no descendant is excluded, the grouping cannot be paraphyletic.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify all descendants arising from the ancestral node where lungs evolved: the lineages lead to (salamander), (lizard), and (mouse).
Compare this set of descendants with the specified grouping . All descendant taxa are present, and no descendants are excluded.
Conclude that because the group contains the most recent common ancestor and all of its descendants, it is monophyletic.
Sister taxon to : Taxon (mouse); The grouping is monophyletic.
02 The student misinterprets sister taxa as adjacent terminal leaves in an unresolved or sequential list, identifying taxon C as the sister taxon to D instead of identifying the clade sharing the most recent node.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Jaws lead to , lungs lead to , and claws lead to .
- Step 2
Sister taxon to taxon : taxon
CorrectSister taxon to taxon : taxon (mouse)
Taxa and share the most recent common ancestor because claws/nails evolved exclusively on the branch leading to both of them. Therefore, taxon is the sister taxon to taxon , not taxon .
- Step 3
Taxa , and include the common ancestor in which lungs evolved and all descendants. Grouping of taxa , and : monophyletic
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified how each shared derived trait maps to nested subsets of taxa.
You correctly explained and classified the grouping of taxa and as monophyletic.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou likely read the sequence of taxa linearly along the internodes ( followed by ) rather than identifying the two terminal taxa ( and ) that share the most exclusive common ancestral node.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Finding Sister Taxa
Sister taxa share a most recent common ancestor with each other that is not shared by any other taxon.
Locate the most derived internal node leading to the taxon of interest and trace all direct terminal branches arising from that same node.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the most recent node shared by taxon : claws/nails evolved on the lineage leading specifically to taxa and .
Because taxa and diverge from this immediate shared node without any intervening lineages, they are sister taxa to each other.
Sister taxon to taxon : Taxon (mouse); Grouping : monophyletic
Lock it in
What is the defining condition for a group of taxa to be considered monophyletic (a clade)?
It must include the most recent common ancestor and ALL of its descendants. Memory cue: Monophyletic = ancestor + complete family.
Similar question
A phylogenetic tree has topology . Classify the following two groupings as monophyletic, paraphyletic, or polyphyletic: (1) ; (2) .
Answer
(1) Monophyletic: includes the ancestor where the clade originates and all four descendant taxa. (2) Paraphyletic: includes the ancestor of and , but excludes descendant taxon .
In a vertebrate cladogram, mammals evolved endothermy and hair, while birds evolved endothermy and feathers from within reptiles. If we create a group called 'Traditional Reptiles' consisting of turtles, lizards, and crocodiles, but excluding birds, what kind of group is this, and why?
Answer
Paraphyletic. The most recent common ancestor of turtles, lizards, and crocodiles is also the ancestor of birds; omitting birds leaves out a descendant lineage.
Consider five taxa with tree topology . An investigator groups taxa together because they all share a specialized ecological role, while taxon is omitted. Name the phylogenetic classification of and state what single change would make it monophyletic.
Answer
The grouping is paraphyletic because it omits descendant . Adding taxon to form includes all descendants of their common ancestor, making the group monophyletic.