Resources

In a crater lake, cichlid fish undergo sympatric speciation driven simultaneously by sensory drive (prezygotic) and microhabitat resource partitioning (ecological selection). At water depth z=2.0 mz = 2.0\text{ m}, light penetration favors blue-sensitive opsin alleles (LWS450LWS^{450}), while at depth z=18.0 mz = 18.0\text{ m}, ambient light is red-shifted (LWS570LWS^{570}). In an enclosure experiment across intermediate depths, an initial cohort of 200200 heterozygous F1F_1 hybrids (LWS450/LWS570LWS^{450}/LWS^{570}) is released alongside 200200 pure blue morphs and 200200 pure red morphs. Over a 1212-month predation trial, surviving counts are recorded: 164164 blue morphs, 158158 red morphs, and 5252 hybrid morphs. In a parallel laboratory flume, female mate choice assays show that blue females select conspecific blue males over hybrid males in 8888 out of 100100 trials. Calculate: (a) the relative fitness of the hybrids (whybridw_{\text{hybrid}}) relative to the most fit parental morph, and (b) the percentage of sexual isolation preference displayed by conspecific females against hybrids.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) whybrid=0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.317; (b) 88.0%88.0\% preference for conspecifics (or an isolation index of 0.7600.760 against hybrids).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Relative Fitness of Hybrids (whybridw_{\text{hybrid}})

1. Determine absolute survival rates (viabilities)

Each group begins with an equal initial cohort of N0=200N_0 = 200 individuals:

  • Survival rate of blue morphs: Sblue=164200=0.82S_{\text{blue}} = \frac{164}{200} = 0.82
  • Survival rate of red morphs: Sred=158200=0.79S_{\text{red}} = \frac{158}{200} = 0.79
  • Survival rate of hybrid morphs: Shybrid=52200=0.26S_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{52}{200} = 0.26

2. Calculate relative fitness (ww)

Relative fitness (ww) is standardized by dividing the survival rate of a given phenotype by the survival rate of the most fit phenotype in the environment. Here, the pure blue morph exhibits the highest survival (Sblue=0.82S_{\text{blue}} = 0.82, or wblue=1.0w_{\text{blue}} = 1.0):

whybrid=ShybridSmax=ShybridSblue=0.260.82=52164≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{S_{\text{hybrid}}}{S_{\text{max}}} = \frac{S_{\text{hybrid}}}{S_{\text{blue}}} = \frac{0.26}{0.82} = \frac{52}{164} \approx 0.317

Common Pitfall: Standardizing by the average parental survival or dividing by the initial population size rather than scaling against the highest-performing reference morph (SmaxS_{\text{max}}).


Part (b): Quantifying Premating Sexual Isolation

1. Direct mate choice percentage

In two-choice trials between a conspecific mate and a hybrid mate:

  • Number of trials where blue females choose conspecific blue males: Nblue=88N_{\text{blue}} = 88
  • Number of trials where blue females choose hybrid males: Nhybrid=100−88=12N_{\text{hybrid}} = 100 - 88 = 12
  • Total trials: Ntotal=100N_{\text{total}} = 100

The direct percentage of trials favoring conspecifics is: Conspecific Preference=88100×100%=88.0%\text{Conspecific Preference} = \frac{88}{100} \times 100\% = 88.0\%

2. Sexual Isolation Index (IPSII_{\text{PSI}})

Speciation and population genetics studies frequently quantify sexual isolation using a standardized behavioral isolation index ranging from −1-1 (complete disassortative mating) through 00 (random mating) to +1+1 (complete assortative isolation):

I=Nconspecific−NhybridNconspecific+Nhybrid=88−1288+12=76100=0.760I = \frac{N_{\text{conspecific}} - N_{\text{hybrid}}}{N_{\text{conspecific}} + N_{\text{hybrid}}} = \frac{88 - 12}{88 + 12} = \frac{76}{100} = 0.760

Both metrics demonstrate strong prezygotic isolation reinforcing the disruptive postzygotic selection observed against intermediate hybrids.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the relative fitness of hybrids relative to the total cohort or average of parents rather than dividing by the most fit parental morph.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Blue survival=164200=0.82  ⟹  Red survival=158200=0.79\text{Blue survival} = \frac{164}{200} = 0.82 \implies \text{Red survival} = \frac{158}{200} = 0.79

  2. Step 2

    Average parental survival=0.82+0.792=0.805  ⟹  whybrid=0.260.805≈0.323\text{Average parental survival} = \frac{0.82 + 0.79}{2} = 0.805 \implies w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{0.26}{0.805} \approx 0.323

    Correct

    whybrid=ShybridSmax=0.260.82=52164≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{S_{\text{hybrid}}}{S_{\text{max}}} = \frac{0.26}{0.82} = \frac{52}{164} \approx 0.317

    You divided the hybrid survival rate by the average survival of the two parental morphs. In population genetics, relative fitness is scaled against the fittest reference genotype or phenotype (wmax⁡=1.0w_{\max} = 1.0), which here is the blue morph (Sblue=0.82S_{\text{blue}} = 0.82).

  3. Step 3

    Conspecific choices against hybrids=88100  ⟹  Percentage preference=88%\text{Conspecific choices against hybrids} = \frac{88}{100} \implies \text{Percentage preference} = 88\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the individual survival proportions for each morph from the initial cohort sizes.

You correctly identified that the hybrid survival rate was 0.260.26.

You accurately calculated the mate choice percentage of 88%88\% from the laboratory flume data.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Standardizing by average instead of maximum fitness

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You averaged the parental survival rates (0.8050.805) to use as the denominator for relative fitness instead of identifying the single most fit parental morph (Sblue=0.82S_{\text{blue}} = 0.82) as instructed by standard population genetics convention and the problem prompt.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identifying the Reference Phenotype for Relative Fitness
  • Relative fitness (ww) sets the most fit phenotype to w=1.0w = 1.0, calculating every other group as wi=SiSmax⁡w_i = \frac{S_i}{S_{\max}}, not relative to the population mean or an unweighted parental average.

  • Scan all competing phenotypes to identify the highest survival rate (Smax⁡S_{\max}), and place only that maximum value in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the maximum survival rate among the parental morphs: Smax⁡=Sblue=0.82S_{\max} = S_{\text{blue}} = 0.82.

  2. Set the relative fitness ratio using Smax⁡S_{\max} in the denominator: whybrid=ShybridSmax⁡=0.260.82w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{S_{\text{hybrid}}}{S_{\max}} = \frac{0.26}{0.82}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: 52164≈0.317\frac{52}{164} \approx 0.317.

Final answer

(a) whybrid≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} \approx 0.317; (b) 88.0%88.0\% preference for conspecifics.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always check whether the prompt asks for fitness relative to the most fit morph (Smax⁡S_{\max}) or relative to mean population fitness (wˉ\bar{w}).

  • Practice distinguishing between absolute fitness (WW or survival rate SS) and standardized relative fitness (ww).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the preference against hybrids with the choice of hybrids, subtracting 88% from 100% to get 12%.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Blue survival=164200=0.82  ⟹  Hybrid survival=52200=0.26\text{Blue survival} = \frac{164}{200} = 0.82 \implies \text{Hybrid survival} = \frac{52}{200} = 0.26

  2. Step 2

    whybrid=0.260.82≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{0.26}{0.82} \approx 0.317

  3. Step 3

    Hybrid choices=100−88=12  ⟹  Percentage preference against hybrids=(12100)×100%=12%\text{Hybrid choices} = 100 - 88 = 12 \implies \text{Percentage preference against hybrids} = \left(\frac{12}{100}\right) \times 100\% = 12\%

    Correct

    Preference against hybrids=(88100)×100%=88.0%\text{Preference against hybrids} = \left(\frac{88}{100}\right) \times 100\% = 88.0\% (or sexual isolation index I=88−12100=0.760I = \frac{88 - 12}{100} = 0.760)

    You calculated the percentage of trials where females accepted/chose hybrids (12%12\%), but a preference against hybrids means rejecting hybrids in favor of conspecifics, which occurred in 8888 out of 100100 trials (88%88\%).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately identified the initial cohort size and calculated the survival rates for both morphs.

You standardized the hybrid fitness against the maximum parental fitness to obtain whybrid≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} \approx 0.317.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Complementary event confusion in behavioral preference

You solved for the frequency of hybrid selection (12%12\%) instead of the frequency of conspecific selection (88%88\%).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing a behavioral preference against a non-preferred mate with the proportion of trials where that non-preferred mate was chosen. Preferring conspecifics over hybrids means choosing the conspecific mate; thus, the 8888 choices for conspecific blue males represent the preference against hybrids.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the target behavior
  • A preference against phenotype BB in a two-choice assay between AA and BB corresponds to the proportion of choices favoring phenotype AA.

  • Check whether your final percentage reflects the trials where the non-target phenotype was avoided or rejected.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that females choosing conspecific blue males (8888 out of 100100 trials) represent the behavioral rejection or avoidance of hybrid males.

  2. Calculate the direct conspecific preference percentage: 88100×100%=88.0%\frac{88}{100} \times 100\% = 88.0\%.

  3. Alternatively, calculate the pair-wise sexual isolation index: IPSI=Nconspecific−NhybridNconspecific+Nhybrid=88−1288+12=0.760I_{\text{PSI}} = \frac{N_{\text{conspecific}} - N_{\text{hybrid}}}{N_{\text{conspecific}} + N_{\text{hybrid}}} = \frac{88 - 12}{88 + 12} = 0.760 (76.0%76.0\%).

Final answer

(a) whybrid≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} \approx 0.317; (b) 88.0%88.0\% preference for conspecifics (or an isolation index of 0.7600.760 against hybrids).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review two-choice mating assay terminology to ensure you associate 'preference against' with the frequency of choosing the alternative morph.

  • Practice interpreting reproductive isolation indices such as the Joint Isolation Index (IPSII_{\text{PSI}}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates relative fitness as the hybrid's proportion of all surviving individuals instead of normalizing by the fittest parental morph.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Total survivors=164+158+52=374  ⟹  whybrid=52374≈0.139\text{Total survivors} = 164 + 158 + 52 = 374 \implies w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{52}{374} \approx 0.139

    Correct

    whybrid=ShybridSmax=52164≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{S_{\text{hybrid}}}{S_{\text{max}}} = \frac{52}{164} \approx 0.317

    You calculated the post-selection frequency of hybrids among all survivors rather than their relative fitness. Relative fitness (ww) must be normalized by dividing the hybrid survival rate by the survival rate of the most fit morph, which is the blue morph (Sblue=164200S_{\text{blue}} = \frac{164}{200}).

  2. Step 2

    Conspecific preference=88100  ⟹  Preference percentage=88%\text{Conspecific preference} = \frac{88}{100} \implies \text{Preference percentage} = 88\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You summed the total number of surviving individuals correctly.

You correctly identified and computed the proportion of female mate choices favoring conspecific males as 88%88\%.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative Fitness Normalization Error

You divided the number of surviving hybrids by the total pool of surviving fish instead of dividing by the number of survivors in the fittest reference class.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused relative fitness (w=survival of morphsurvival of fittest morphw = \frac{\text{survival of morph}}{\text{survival of fittest morph}}) with relative abundance or genotype frequency after selection (survivors of morphtotal survivors\frac{\text{survivors of morph}}{\text{total survivors}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Scaling Relative Fitness
  • Relative fitness (ww) scales the absolute fitness (viability or reproductive output) of a phenotype against the highest absolute fitness in the cohort (wmax=1.0w_{\text{max}} = 1.0).

  • First find the absolute survival rate for each cohort (S=NsurvivingNinitialS = \frac{N_{\text{surviving}}}{N_{\text{initial}}}), identify the maximum rate (SmaxS_{\text{max}}), and compute wi=SiSmaxw_i = \frac{S_i}{S_{\text{max}}}.

Fitness vs. Genotype Frequency
  • Genotype frequency after selection is Ni∑N\frac{N_i}{\sum N}, whereas relative fitness is SiSmax\frac{S_i}{S_{\text{max}}}.

  • Ensure the denominator is the performance of the benchmark fittest morph, not the sum of all survivors across morphs.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the absolute survival rate of each morph: Sblue=164200=0.82S_{\text{blue}} = \frac{164}{200} = 0.82, Sred=158200=0.79S_{\text{red}} = \frac{158}{200} = 0.79, and Shybrid=52200=0.26S_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{52}{200} = 0.26.

  2. Identify the morph with the highest survival rate, which is the blue morph (Smax=Sblue=0.82S_{\text{max}} = S_{\text{blue}} = 0.82).

  3. Divide the survival rate of the hybrids by that of the fittest morph: whybrid=0.260.82=52164≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{0.26}{0.82} = \frac{52}{164} \approx 0.317.

Final answer

(a) whybrid≈0.317w_{\text{hybrid}} \approx 0.317; (b) 88%88\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between genotype frequency after selection and standard relative fitness (ww).

  • Practice calculating selection coefficients (s=1−ws = 1 - w) for disruptive selection against intermediate heterozygotes.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In an alpine plant transplant experiment, 100100 individuals each of lowland, highland, and F1F_1 hybrid morphs are planted in a mid-elevation ecotone. The number of survivors reaching reproductive maturity is 7575 lowland, 6060 highland, and 3030 hybrids. Calculate the relative fitness (whybridw_{\text{hybrid}}) of the hybrid relative to the most fit parental morph.

Answer

whybrid=0.40w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.40. Key steps: (1) Survival rates are Slowland=0.75S_{\text{lowland}} = 0.75, Shighland=0.60S_{\text{highland}} = 0.60, Shybrid=0.30S_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.30. (2) The most fit parental morph is lowland (Smax⁡=0.75S_{\max} = 0.75). (3) whybrid=0.300.75=0.40w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{0.30}{0.75} = 0.40.

02

In a study of disruptive selection in seedcracker finches, birds with small beaks have a survival rate of 0.640.64, birds with large beaks have a survival rate of 0.800.80, and intermediate-beaked morphs have a survival rate of 0.320.32. (a) Find the relative fitness of intermediate morphs (wintw_{\text{int}}) scaled to the most fit morph. (b) Calculate the selection coefficient (ss) acting against the intermediate morph, where s=1−ws = 1 - w.

Answer

(a) wint=0.40w_{\text{int}} = 0.40; (b) s=0.60s = 0.60. Key steps: (1) The highest survival is Smax⁡=0.80S_{\max} = 0.80 (large beaks). (2) wint=0.320.80=0.40w_{\text{int}} = \frac{0.32}{0.80} = 0.40. (3) Selection coefficient s=1−0.40=0.60s = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60.

03

Two host-adapted races of an herbivorous insect mate in a contact zone. The survival of race 1 on Host A is 0.700.70, and on Host B is 0.200.20. The survival of race 2 on Host A is 0.150.15, and on Host B is 0.850.85. Hybrids survive at 0.340.34 on Host A and 0.340.34 on Host B. If an equal mixture of both hosts exists in nature (equal weighting), determine: (1) the mean absolute survival for each race and the hybrid across both hosts, and (2) the relative fitness of the hybrid (whybridw_{\text{hybrid}}) relative to the fittest pure race overall.

Answer

(1) Mean survivals: Race 1 = 0.450.45, Race 2 = 0.500.50, Hybrid = 0.340.34; (2) whybrid=0.68w_{\text{hybrid}} = 0.68. Key steps: (1) Race 1 average survival =0.70+0.202=0.45= \frac{0.70 + 0.20}{2} = 0.45; Race 2 average survival =0.15+0.852=0.50= \frac{0.15 + 0.85}{2} = 0.50; Hybrid average survival =0.34+0.342=0.34= \frac{0.34 + 0.34}{2} = 0.34. (2) Fittest race overall is Race 2 (Smax⁡=0.50S_{\max} = 0.50). (3) whybrid=0.340.50=0.68w_{\text{hybrid}} = \frac{0.34}{0.50} = 0.68.

Loading workspace…