Resources
A spontaneously aborted fetus undergoes cytogenetic analysis following a missed abortion at weeks of gestation. Chromosome analysis reveals three complete, non-mosaic haploid sets () of chromosomes comprising total chromosomes with a sex-chromosome complement of (). Calculate: (a) the total number of autosomes present in this karyotype, (b) the total number of telomeres present in each cell during mitotic G2 phase, and (c) distinguish this polyploid condition from an aneuploid condition such as standard trisomy () in terms of relative genomic stoichiometry and primary reproductive etiology.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) autosomes (); (b) telomeres (); (c) Genomic stoichiometry: Triploidy represents a proportional increase of the entire genome () maintaining balanced gene dosage across all chromosomes, whereas aneuploidy () causes an unbalanced disruption in dosage for only one specific chromosome; Primary etiology: Triploidy typically results from dispermy (fertilization of one normal haploid ovum by two sperm) or failure of a meiotic division (diploid gamete), whereas aneuploidy arises from nondisjunction of a single homologous pair or sister chromatid pair.
Steps
(a) Calculating the Total Number of Autosomes
- Understand standard chromosomal composition: A normal human haploid set () consists of chromosomes: autosomes and sex chromosome.
- Apply to a triploid karyotype ():
- Since there are three complete haploid sets, each autosomal pair is replaced by a triplet:
- Alternatively, subtract the given sex chromosomes (, which is chromosomes) from the total chromosome count:
(b) Calculating the Total Number of Telomeres in Mitotic Phase
- Chromatid structure after DNA replication:
- During the phase of the cell cycle, every chromosome undergoes semiconservative replication to form two identical sister chromatids joined at a common centromere.
- By mitotic phase, DNA replication is complete. Each of the chromosomes consists of sister chromatids.
- Telomeres per chromosome:
- A single linear, double-stranded DNA molecule (one chromatid) has two free ends, each capped by a telomere.
- Therefore, one replicated chromosome (comprising chromatids) possesses:
- Total telomere count:
Common Pitfall: Forgetting that cells in phase have already duplicated their DNA. In an unreplicated () cell, each chromosome has only telomeres (), but in , the number doubles to .
(c) Distinguishing Triploidy () from Aneuploidy ()
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that DNA replicates prior to the G2 phase and calculates telomeres based on unreplicated G1 chromosomes (2 telomeres per chromosome instead of 4).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Cells in mitotic phase have completed DNA replication during phase. Each of the chromosomes is composed of two sister chromatids, with each chromatid having two telomeres (giving telomeres per replicated chromosome).
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the autosomal complement by subtracting the sex chromosomes from the total count.
You clearly articulated how triploidy preserves relative genomic stoichiometry while trisomy creates an unbalanced gene dosage.
You correctly identified dispermy as the primary etiology of triploidy and meiotic nondisjunction as the cause of trisomy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou calculated the telomere count assuming each chromosome is an unreplicated single DNA molecule with only telomeres.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the cell cycle state specified in the prompt: by mitotic phase, semiconservative DNA replication in phase has already doubled the number of chromatids, so each chromosome has telomeres rather than .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Cell Cycle Stage
In , chromosomes are unreplicated ( double-stranded DNA molecule per chromosome telomeres). In and early mitosis, chromosomes are replicated into sister chromatids ( DNA molecules telomeres).
Whenever a problem specifies , prophase, or metaphase, multiply the chromosome count by telomeres (or chromatids telomeres).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that DNA replication occurs in phase, which precedes phase.
Each of the chromosomes in consists of sister chromatids joined at a centromere.
Each sister chromatid is a linear double-stranded DNA duplex terminated by telomeres, yielding telomeres per replicated chromosome.
Multiply the total chromosome count by : .
(a) autosomes; (b) telomeres; (c) Triploidy maintains balanced relative gene dosage ( uniform increase) and arises mainly via dispermy, whereas standard trisomy causes an unbalanced gene dosage of a single chromosome and arises via nondisjunction.
02 The student subtracts two sex chromosomes instead of three by assuming the normal diploid sex-chromosome complement (XX or XY), arriving at 67 autosomes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Sex chromosomes = 2 ⟹ Autosomes = 69 - 2 = 67
Correct(or )
You assumed a typical diploid complement of sex chromosomes. In a triploid karyotype, there are sex chromosomes (two and one ), which leaves autosomes.
- Step 2
In G2 phase, each of the 69 chromosomes has replicated into 2 sister chromatids. ⟹ Total chromatids = 69 × 2 = 138 ⟹ Each chromatid has 2 telomeres, so total telomeres = 138 × 2 = 276
- Step 3
Stoichiometry: Triploidy maintains balanced stoichiometry because every autosome and sex chromosome set is increased equally, whereas trisomy introduces an asymmetric 3:2 imbalance. ⟹ Etiology: Triploidy commonly results from fertilization of an egg by two sperm, whereas trisomy results from meiotic nondisjunction during gametogenesis.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly accounted for chromatid doubling during S phase and calculated the G2 telomere count.
You clearly explained how polyploidy preserves relative gene dosage while aneuploidy creates unbalanced genomic stoichiometry.
You correctly identified dispermy as a major cause of triploidy and nondisjunction as the cause of trisomy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou subtracted instead of for the sex chromosomes despite the prompt specifying an complement.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisHabitually applying the normal diploid rule of two sex chromosomes per cell without adjusting for the triploid sex-chromosome complement specified by the karyotype nomenclature.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count Sex Chromosomes Directly from Karyotype Notation
In cytogenetic nomenclature (such as or ), every listed letter in the sex-chromosome suffix represents an individual sex chromosome.
Read the sex-chromosome string literally and count its length () rather than assuming the default diploid count of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the sex chromosomes listed in the karyotype: corresponds to sex chromosomes ( chromosomes and chromosome).
Subtract the sex chromosomes from the total chromosome number: autosomes (or multiply the haploid autosome count by : ).
(a) 66 autosomes; (b) 276 telomeres; (c) Triploidy maintains balanced gene stoichiometry across all chromosomes and primarily arises from dispermy or meiotic non-reduction, whereas aneuploidy disrupts gene dosage via single-chromosome nondisjunction.
03 The student misattributes the primary mechanism of triploidy to meiotic nondisjunction of all chromosomes rather than dispermy or failure of meiotic cytokinesis.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Triploidy primarily arises from dispermy (simultaneous fertilization of a single haploid ovum by two sperm, ) or meiotic non-reduction producing a diploid gamete. In contrast, standard trisomy arises from the nondisjunction of a single homologous or sister chromatid pair during meiosis.
Triploidy is not typically caused by a synchronized failure of all chromosome pairs to separate during maternal meiosis. Instead, its most frequent cause is dispermy (polyspermy involving two sperm fertilizing one egg), followed by fertilization involving a diploid gamete resulting from complete meiotic non-reduction or failure of cytokinesis.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the autosome count by subtracting the sex chromosomes from the triploid total.
You accounted for post-replicative chromatid doubling to determine the exact telomere count in phase.
You accurately contrasted balanced whole-genome stoichiometry in polyploidy with localized gene dosage imbalance in aneuploidy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the mechanism of single-chromosome nondisjunction (which causes aneuploidy) with the fertilization and cell-division failures (dispermy or complete meiotic non-reduction) that produce an entire extra haploid complement in polyploidy.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Aneuploidy vs. Polyploidy Origins
Aneuploidy () arises from nondisjunction of individual chromosome pairs. Polyploidy () arises from extra gametes (dispermy) or complete meiotic/mitotic division failure, never independent nondisjunction across all pairs.
When asked for the etiology of triploidy, list dispermy () first, followed by fertilization involving an unreduced diploid gamete.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that nondisjunction is a chromosome-specific segregation error that affects one or a few homologous pairs or sister chromatids.
For an entire additional haploid set () to enter a zygote, either an egg is fertilized by two separate sperm simultaneously (dispermy, causing of human triploidy cases), or one gamete fails meiotic cytokinesis/reduction and remains diploid ().
Contrast this with trisomy (), which is caused by classical meiotic nondisjunction of a single chromosome pair, most often during maternal Meiosis I.
(a) autosomes; (b) telomeres; (c) Stoichiometry: Triploidy maintains balanced relative gene dosage across the whole genome ( scaling), whereas trisomy disrupts relative dosage specifically for one chromosome; Etiology: Triploidy is primarily caused by dispermy (fertilization of one ovum by two sperm) or a diploid gamete from complete meiotic failure, whereas trisomy is caused by nondisjunction of a single chromosome pair.
Lock it in
How many telomeres are present on a single eukaryotic chromosome in mitotic G1 phase versus mitotic G2 phase?
G1: 2 telomeres (1 unreplicated DNA molecule). G2: 4 telomeres (2 sister chromatids, each with 2 ends capped by telomeres).
Similar question
A cell from an individual with Down syndrome () enters mitotic phase. Calculate: (a) the total number of sister chromatids, and (b) the total number of telomeres present in the cell.
Answer
(a) sister chromatids (); (b) telomeres (, or telomeres per chromatid).
An organism has a normal diploid complement of . A tetraploid mutant () of this species is examined. Calculate: (a) the number of telomeres in a cell at phase, and (b) the number of telomeres in a cell at mitotic prophase.
Answer
(a) telomeres ( telomeres each in unreplicated ); (b) telomeres ( telomeres each in prophase).
A human primary oocyte is arrested at prophase I of meiosis. Assuming normal diploid chromosome number (): (a) How many total centromeres, sister chromatids, and telomeres are present? (b) If this oocyte undergoes nondisjunction of chromosome 21 during Meiosis I, state the chromosome and telomere numbers in the two resulting secondary oocytes/polar bodies at metaphase II.
Answer
(a) centromeres, sister chromatids, and telomeres (); (b) One daughter cell has replicated chromosomes ( telomeres), while the other has replicated chromosomes ( telomeres).