Resources
In a human family pedigree tracking a rare metabolic disorder across three generations, Individual (unaffected male) and Individual (unaffected female) have four biological children: Individual (affected female), Individual (unaffected male), Individual (unaffected female), and Individual (affected male). Neither parent exhibits symptoms of the disorder, and there is no prior family history in preceding generations. (a) Identify the most likely mode of inheritance (autosomal recessive, autosomal dominant, X-linked recessive, or X-linked dominant). (b) Assuming complete penetrance, calculate the exact probability that an unaffected offspring from this mating pair (such as Individual ) is a heterozygous carrier.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Autosomal recessive; (b) (or approximately )
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Mode of Inheritance
-
Rule out dominant inheritance:
- Both parents ( and ) are unaffected, yet they have affected children ( and ).
- A dominant trait (whether autosomal dominant or X-linked dominant) requires at least one parent to exhibit the phenotype for their biological offspring to inherit it (barring de novo mutation or incomplete penetrance, which are ruled out by the prompt). Therefore, the disorder must be recessive.
-
Differentiate between autosomal recessive and X-linked recessive:
- If the condition were X-linked recessive, an affected female () would have the genotype .
- She must inherit one chromosome from her mother and one chromosome from her father.
- Her father () has only one X chromosome and would therefore possess the genotype , meaning he must show the disease phenotype.
- However, the father () is unaffected (genotype ).
- This contradiction eliminates X-linked recessive inheritance.
Therefore, the most likely mode of inheritance is autosomal recessive.
Part (b): Calculating the Carrier Probability for an Unaffected Offspring
-
Deduce parental genotypes:
- Let represent the wild-type dominant allele and represent the recessive disease allele.
- Because affected individuals ( and ) are homozygous recessive (), each parent must contribute one recessive allele .
- Since both parents are phenotypically normal, each must be a heterozygous carrier:
-
Construct the cross outcomes:
- A standard monohybrid cross of two carriers () produces the following expected genotypic ratio in offspring:
-
Apply conditional probability:
- We are given that Individual is unaffected. This rules out the homozygous recessive genotype ().
- The remaining sample space of unaffected individuals consists of:
- homozygous dominant ()
- heterozygous carriers ()
- Total unaffected outcomes: .
- Calculate the probability:
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is calculating the probability of a carrier as . That probability applies prior to birth when the phenotype is unknown. Once an individual is known to be unaffected, the affected outcome () is eliminated from the denominator.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the trait as X-linked recessive by noticing that both an affected male and an affected female are born to unaffected parents, while overlooking that an affected female requires an affected father under X-linkage.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Unaffected parents have affected children, so the disorder is recessive.
- Step 2
Both male and female offspring are affected, showing sex-linked transmission from a carrier mother. ⟹ Mode of inheritance: X-linked recessive
CorrectAn affected female (, genotype ) requires an affected father (). Since father is unaffected, the trait cannot be X-linked recessive. Therefore, the mode of inheritance is autosomal recessive.
Under X-linked recessive inheritance, an affected female must inherit an affected chromosome from each parent. Since biological fathers pass their single X chromosome to all daughters, an affected female's father must be affected (). Because father is unaffected, X-linked recessive inheritance is ruled out.
- Step 3
Parents have genotypes and . ⟹ Offspring is an unaffected male with genotype . ⟹ A male cannot be a heterozygous carrier because males are hemizygous. ⟹ Probability of being a carrier = 0
CorrectParents are heterozygous carriers (). For an unaffected offspring (), the possible genotypes are . Thus, .
Your reasoning that males are hemizygous for X-linked traits was logically sound within your premise, but it was affected by misidentifying the trait as X-linked. Because the trait is autosomal recessive, both parents are , and any unaffected child has a probability of being a heterozygous carrier ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the disorder as recessive because unaffected parents produced affected children.
You demonstrated a clear understanding that human males are hemizygous for standard X-linked loci.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that having affected offspring of both sexes from a carrier mother points to X-linkage, without verifying the mandatory paternal genotype requirement: in X-linked recessive inheritance, every affected female must have an affected father.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule out X-linked recessive using affected females
In X-linked recessive inheritance, an affected female () must have an affected father () and at least a carrier mother ().
Whenever you see an affected daughter born to an unaffected father, immediately eliminate X-linked recessive inheritance.
- Conditional probability for unaffected offspring in autosomal crosses
A cross between two heterozygous carriers () yields offspring in the genotypic ratio .
When an offspring is confirmed to be phenotypically unaffected, eliminate from the sample space, leaving a carrier probability of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck the father-daughter pair: daughter is affected ( or ), but father is unaffected ( or ).
If the trait were X-linked recessive, daughter would require from her father, forcing him to be affected (). Contradiction!
Therefore, the mode of inheritance must be autosomal recessive.
Assign parental genotypes: both unaffected parents must be carriers () to produce affected children ().
Perform a Punnett square for : outcomes are , , and .
Restrict to the unaffected offspring space (eliminate ): 1 and 2 (total = 3).
Calculate carrier probability: .
(a) Autosomal recessive; (b) (or approximately )
02 The student calculates the carrier probability out of all possible offspring (2/4) rather than conditioning on the fact that the individual is known to be unaffected.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Unaffected parents have affected children, ruling out dominant inheritance. ⟹ An affected female has an unaffected father , ruling out X-linked recessive inheritance. ⟹ Mode of inheritance: autosomal recessive
- Step 2
Parents are carriers with genotypes . ⟹ Cross produces , , out of total offspring.
- Step 3Correct
You divided by all possible offspring combinations instead of conditioning on the known phenotype. Because Individual is known to be unaffected, the homozygous recessive genotype () is eliminated from the denominator, reducing the sample space to the unaffected possibilities ( and ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used pedigree inheritance rules to identify the disorder as autosomal recessive.
You correctly determined that both parents are heterozygous carriers ().
You correctly listed the four potential zygotic outcomes (, , ).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou calculated the unconditional probability of being a carrier at conception rather than restricting the sample space to unaffected individuals once the phenotype is established.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Reduce the Sample Space
When an individual's phenotype is already observed, eliminate genotypes incompatible with that phenotype from the total outcomes before forming the fraction.
Since Individual is unaffected, cross out . The new denominator is .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the condition: Individual is unaffected, meaning their genotype cannot be .
Determine the restricted sample space: and , giving possible outcomes.
Compute the conditional probability: .
(a) Autosomal recessive; (b)
Lock it in
What two mandatory family relationships must hold for an individual in an X-linked recessive pedigree?
- Every affected female () must have an affected father ().
- Every affected mother () must have 100% affected sons ().
Similar question
In a pedigree, an unaffected man and an unaffected woman have three children: an affected son, an unaffected son, and an unaffected daughter. Can this trait be X-linked recessive? What is the probability that the unaffected daughter is a carrier if the trait is X-linked recessive?
Answer
Yes, it can be X-linked recessive because an affected son () inherits from an unaffected carrier mother () and from an unaffected father (). The daughter inherits from the father and either or from the mother, giving a probability of (or 50%) of being a carrier.
A phenotypically normal couple has a child with cystic fibrosis (an autosomal recessive disorder). They subsequently have another child who does not show symptoms of cystic fibrosis. What is the probability that this second child is a carrier?
Answer
. Both parents are carriers (). Since the second child is phenotypically normal, the homozygous recessive genotype () is eliminated. Among the remaining viable genotypes (), exactly 2 out of 3 are carriers.
A woman who is a known carrier for hemophilia A (an X-linked recessive disorder, ) marries a man with hemophilia A (). (a) What proportion of their daughters are expected to be affected? (b) Given that a child born to this couple is male, what is the probability that he is affected?
Answer
(a) (or 50%). Daughters receive from the father and either (carrier) or (affected) from the mother. (b) (or 50%). Sons receive from the father and either (unaffected) or (affected) from the mother.