Resources

In a population of dung beetles, male horn length exhibits a behavioral dimorphism governed by a single diallelic autosomal locus exhibiting complete dominance. Large-horned males (AAAA and AaAa) patrol and aggressively defend tunnel entrances, while hornless males (aaaa) engage in sneaker mating behavior by burrowing side intercept tunnels. In a foundational generation at Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the recessive sneaker phenotype occurs at an observed frequency of q2=0.16q^2 = 0.16. Following a prolonged drought that hardens soil compaction, tunnel defense becomes substantially more energetically exhausting. The relative fitness of territorial horned males drops to whorned=0.60w_{\text{horned}} = 0.60, whereas sneaker males retain a relative fitness of wsneaker=1.00w_{\text{sneaker}} = 1.00. Calculate the initial frequency of the recessive sneaker allele q0q_0, the mean fitness of the population wˉ\bar{w} during the drought generation, and the new frequency of the sneaker allele q1q_1 after one generation of natural selection.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Initial allele frequency q0=0.400q_0 = 0.400, mean population fitness wˉ=0.664\bar{w} = 0.664, and sneaker allele frequency after selection q1≈0.482q_1 \approx 0.482.

Steps

01

Find the Initial Recessive Allele Frequency (q0q_0)

Because the population begins in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium and the sneaker behavior is governed by a recessive autosomal allele (aaaa):

f(aa)=q02=0.16f(aa) = q_0^2 = 0.16

Taking the square root yields the initial frequency of the sneaker allele (aa):

q0=0.16=0.400q_0 = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.400

The frequency of the dominant horned allele (AA) is:

p0=1−q0=1−0.400=0.600p_0 = 1 - q_0 = 1 - 0.400 = 0.600


02

Determine Pre-Selection Phenotypic Frequencies and Mean Fitness (wˉ\bar{w})

With complete dominance, large-horned territorial males comprise both homozygous dominant (AAAA) and heterozygous (AaAa) genotypes:

f(AA)=p02=(0.600)2=0.360f(AA) = p_0^2 = (0.600)^2 = 0.360

f(Aa)=2p0q0=2(0.600)(0.400)=0.480f(Aa) = 2p_0q_0 = 2(0.600)(0.400) = 0.480

f(horned)=f(AA)+f(Aa)=0.360+0.480=0.840(or 1−q02=1−0.160=0.840)f(\text{horned}) = f(AA) + f(Aa) = 0.360 + 0.480 = 0.840 \quad (\text{or } 1 - q_0^2 = 1 - 0.160 = 0.840)

The frequency of sneaker males is:

f(sneaker)=f(aa)=0.160f(\text{sneaker}) = f(aa) = 0.160

Using the relative fitness values under drought conditions (whorned=0.60w_{\text{horned}} = 0.60 and wsneaker=1.00w_{\text{sneaker}} = 1.00), calculate the mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w}:

wˉ=f(horned)⋅whorned+f(sneaker)⋅wsneaker\bar{w} = f(\text{horned}) \cdot w_{\text{horned}} + f(\text{sneaker}) \cdot w_{\text{sneaker}}

wˉ=(0.840)(0.60)+(0.160)(1.00)=0.504+0.160=0.664\bar{w} = (0.840)(0.60) + (0.160)(1.00) = 0.504 + 0.160 = 0.664


03

Calculate the Sneaker Allele Frequency After Selection (q1q_1)

The average relative transmission efficiency of the sneaker allele across its phenotypic contexts (functioning in both horned heterozygotes at relative fitness 0.600.60 and sneaker homozygotes at relative fitness 1.001.00) gives an effective marginal fitness:

wa=whorned+wsneaker2=0.60+1.002=0.800w_a = \frac{w_{\text{horned}} + w_{\text{sneaker}}}{2} = \frac{0.60 + 1.00}{2} = 0.800

Applying natural selection over one generation, the new frequency of the sneaker allele q1q_1 normalized by the mean population fitness is:

q1=q0⋅wawˉ=0.400⋅0.8000.664=0.3200.664≈0.482q_1 = \frac{q_0 \cdot w_a}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.400 \cdot 0.800}{0.664} = \frac{0.320}{0.664} \approx 0.482

Common Pitfall: A frequent error is assuming sneaker alleles only exist in sneaker males (aaaa). Because heterozygotes (AaAa) display the horned phenotype, they also carry the aa allele while being subject to the lower fitness of territorial defense (w=0.60w = 0.60), directly modulating the rate at which qq increases.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that heterozygotes carry the recessive allele and only counts homozygous recessive individuals when calculating the new allele frequency after selection.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q0=0.16=0.40  ⟹  p0=1−0.40=0.60q_0 = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.40 \implies p_0 = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    f(horned)=1−0.16=0.84  ⟹  wˉ=(0.84)(0.60)+(0.16)(1.00)=0.504+0.16=0.664f(\text{horned}) = 1 - 0.16 = 0.84 \implies \bar{w} = (0.84)(0.60) + (0.16)(1.00) = 0.504 + 0.16 = 0.664

  3. Step 3

    waaf(aa)=(1.00)(0.16)=0.160  ⟹  q1=0.1600.664≈0.241w_{aa} f(aa) = (1.00)(0.16) = 0.160 \implies q_1 = \frac{0.160}{0.664} \approx 0.241

    Correct

    q1=waaq02+wAap0q0wˉ=(1.00)(0.160)+(0.60)(0.240)0.664=0.160+0.1440.664≈0.458q_1 = \frac{w_{aa} q_0^2 + w_{Aa} p_0 q_0}{\bar{w}} = \frac{(1.00)(0.160) + (0.60)(0.240)}{0.664} = \frac{0.160 + 0.144}{0.664} \approx 0.458 (or q1=q0wawˉ=0.400⋅0.8000.664≈0.482q_1 = \frac{q_0 w_a}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.400 \cdot 0.800}{0.664} \approx 0.482 using average transmission fitness)

    You computed waaf(aa)wˉ\frac{w_{aa}f(aa)}{\bar{w}}, which gives the post-selection frequency of the homozygous recessive genotype f′(aa)f'(aa), not the allele frequency q1q_1. Heterozygotes (AaAa) also carry the recessive aa allele into the next generation with fitness wAa=0.60w_{Aa} = 0.60.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly took the square root of q02=0.16q_0^2 = 0.16 to find q0=0.400q_0 = 0.400 and p0=0.600p_0 = 0.600.

You correctly calculated the pre-selection phenotype frequencies and the population mean fitness wˉ=0.664\bar{w} = 0.664.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Allele vs. Genotype Selection

You calculated the surviving frequency of the homozygous recessive genotype aaaa instead of summing all copies of the aa allele across both homozygotes and heterozygotes.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing post-selection genotype frequency with post-selection allele frequency by overlooking that heterozygous individuals (AaAa) carry and transmit recessive alleles even though they display the dominant phenotype.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for Heterozygous Gene Pools
  • Under selection at a diallelic locus with complete dominance, the frequency of allele aa after selection is q1=waaq02+wAap0q0wˉq_1 = \frac{w_{aa} q_0^2 + w_{Aa} p_0 q_0}{\bar{w}} (or equivalently q0wawˉ\frac{q_0 w_a}{\bar{w}}).

  • Always identify which genotypes carry the target allele and include the weighted contributions of both homozygotes and heterozygotes in the numerator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all genotypes carrying allele aa: homozygote aaaa (frequency q02=0.160q_0^2 = 0.160, fitness waa=1.00w_{aa} = 1.00) and heterozygote AaAa (frequency 2p0q0=0.4802p_0q_0 = 0.480, fitness wAa=0.60w_{Aa} = 0.60).

  2. Compute the post-selection contribution to allele aa: each aaaa contributes 11 dose of aa and each AaAa contributes 12\frac{1}{2} dose of aa, giving waaq02+wAap0q0=(1.00)(0.160)+(0.60)(0.240)=0.160+0.144=0.304w_{aa}q_0^2 + w_{Aa}p_0q_0 = (1.00)(0.160) + (0.60)(0.240) = 0.160 + 0.144 = 0.304 (or using the average marginal fitness of allele aa, wa=0.800w_a = 0.800, yielding q0wa=0.320q_0 w_a = 0.320).

  3. Normalize by the mean population fitness: q1=0.3200.664≈0.482q_1 = \frac{0.320}{0.664} \approx 0.482.

Final answer

q1≈0.482q_1 \approx 0.482

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between post-selection genotype frequencies f′(aa)f'(aa) and post-selection allele frequencies q1q_1.

  • Practice setting up gene-pool selection tables that explicitly separate allele contributions from AAAA, AaAa, and aaaa.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student squares the phenotype fitness rather than using genotype frequencies to compute the new allele frequency, incorrectly assuming Hardy-Weinberg genotype proportions apply directly without accounting for heterozygous transmission under selection.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q0=0.16=0.40  ⟹  p0=1−0.40=0.60q_0 = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.40 \implies p_0 = 1 - 0.40 = 0.60

  2. Step 2

    f(horned)=0.84  ⟹  wˉ=(0.84)(0.60)+(0.16)(1.00)=0.664f(\text{horned}) = 0.84 \implies \bar{w} = (0.84)(0.60) + (0.16)(1.00) = 0.664

  3. Step 3

    q1=q0(wsneaker/wˉ)=0.40(1.000.664)≈0.602q_1 = q_0 (w_{\text{sneaker}} / \bar{w}) = 0.40\left(\frac{1.00}{0.664}\right) \approx 0.602

    Correct

    q1=q0⋅wawˉ=0.400⋅0.8000.664≈0.482q_1 = \frac{q_0 \cdot w_a}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.400 \cdot 0.800}{0.664} \approx 0.482

    You assumed that all copies of allele aa experience the sneaker phenotype fitness (wsneaker=1.00w_{\text{sneaker}} = 1.00). Because allele aa is recessive, it also resides in heterozygous individuals (AaAa) that express the horned phenotype and experience the lower fitness (whorned=0.60w_{\text{horned}} = 0.60).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial allele frequencies q0=0.40q_0 = 0.40 and p0=0.60p_0 = 0.60 using Hardy-Weinberg assumptions.

You accurately calculated the frequency of the dominant horned phenotype and the mean population fitness wˉ=0.664\bar{w} = 0.664.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating allele fitness with phenotype fitness in dominant-recessive traits

You treated the recessive allele aa as if it were only expressed in homozygous sneaker males (aaaa).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to account for recessive alleles 'hidden' in heterozygotes (AaAa). Because dominant phenotypes mask recessive alleles, copies of aa in heterozygotes are subjected to the selective pressure acting on the dominant phenotype (whorned=0.60w_{\text{horned}} = 0.60), lowering the overall transmission efficiency of allele aa relative to homozygous sneakers alone.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Allele Partitioning
  • In a diploid locus with complete dominance, recessive alleles are distributed across both heterozygotes (AaAa) and recessive homozygotes (aaaa).

  • Identify all genotypes carrying the allele of interest before applying selection multipliers.

Marginal Fitness of an Allele
  • The transmission success of an allele depends on its average fitness across all phenotypic contexts in which it appears: wa=whorned+wsneaker2w_a = \frac{w_{\text{horned}} + w_{\text{sneaker}}}{2}.

  • Use the average marginal fitness of the allele rather than assuming phenotype fitness equals allele fitness.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Account for the two phenotypic contexts in which allele aa resides: horned heterozygotes (AaAa, fitness 0.600.60) and sneaker homozygotes (aaaa, fitness 1.001.00).

  2. Compute the marginal fitness of the recessive allele: wa=whorned+wsneaker2=0.60+1.002=0.800w_a = \frac{w_{\text{horned}} + w_{\text{sneaker}}}{2} = \frac{0.60 + 1.00}{2} = 0.800.

  3. Calculate the post-selection frequency normalized by mean fitness: q1=q0⋅wawˉ=0.400⋅0.8000.664≈0.482q_1 = \frac{q_0 \cdot w_a}{\bar{w}} = \frac{0.400 \cdot 0.800}{0.664} \approx 0.482.

Final answer

q1≈0.482q_1 \approx 0.482

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the three genotypes (AAAA, AaAa, aaaa) and their individual fitnesses before calculating allele frequency shifts under selection.

  • Practice distinguishing between phenotypic fitness and the marginal fitness of an allele when dominance is involved.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student averages the fitness of the two phenotypes with equal weights rather than weighting them by their population frequencies to find mean fitness, which skews both mean fitness and the subsequent allele frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    q0=0.16=0.40q_0 = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.40

  2. Step 2

    wˉ=0.60+1.002=1.602=0.80\bar{w} = \frac{0.60 + 1.00}{2} = \frac{1.60}{2} = 0.80

    Correct

    wˉ=f(horned)⋅whorned+f(sneaker)⋅wsneaker=(0.840)(0.60)+(0.160)(1.00)=0.664\bar{w} = f(\text{horned}) \cdot w_{\text{horned}} + f(\text{sneaker}) \cdot w_{\text{sneaker}} = (0.840)(0.60) + (0.160)(1.00) = 0.664

    You calculated an unweighted average of the fitness values instead of weighting each fitness by the proportion of individuals in the population expressing that phenotype (84%84\% horned and 16%16\% hornless).

  3. Step 3

    p0=0.60  ⟹  f(Aa)=2(0.60)(0.40)=0.48  ⟹  f(aa)=0.16p_0 = 0.60 \implies f(Aa) = 2(0.60)(0.40) = 0.48 \implies f(aa) = 0.16

  4. Step 4

    q1=12(0.60)(0.48)+(1.00)(0.16)0.80=0.144+0.1600.80=0.3040.80=0.38q_1 = \frac{\frac{1}{2}(0.60)(0.48) + (1.00)(0.16)}{0.80} = \frac{0.144 + 0.160}{0.80} = \frac{0.304}{0.80} = 0.38

    Correct

    q1=12(0.60)(0.480)+(1.00)(0.160)0.664=0.3040.664≈0.458q_1 = \frac{\frac{1}{2}(0.60)(0.480) + (1.00)(0.160)}{0.664} = \frac{0.304}{0.664} \approx 0.458

    Your numerator correctly accounted for copies of allele aa transmitted through heterozygotes and homozygotes, but dividing by the incorrect denominator wˉ=0.80\bar{w} = 0.80 produced 0.380.38. Notice that because sneaker males have higher fitness than horned males (1.00>0.601.00 > 0.60), natural selection must increase q1q_1 above q0=0.40q_0 = 0.40.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the foundational allele frequency q0=0.40q_0 = 0.40 from the observed frequency of recessive homozygotes.

You accurately computed the Hardy-Weinberg genotype frequencies f(Aa)f(Aa) and f(aa)f(aa) prior to selection.

You correctly constructed the contribution of both heterozygotes and recessive homozygotes to the transmission of allele aa.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted mean fitness calculation

You took a simple unweighted average of the two fitness coefficients rather than multiplying each fitness by its respective phenotype frequency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the simple arithmetic mean of phenotypic fitnesses with the population mean fitness wˉ\bar{w}, which must always be weighted by genotype or phenotype frequencies across the entire population.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighted Average Definition of Mean Fitness
  • wˉ=∑fi⋅wi=f(horned)whorned+f(sneaker)wsneaker\bar{w} = \sum f_i \cdot w_i = f(\text{horned})w_{\text{horned}} + f(\text{sneaker})w_{\text{sneaker}}

  • Always multiply each relative fitness by the fraction of the population that actually possesses that phenotype before summing.

Biological Direction Sanity Check
  • If the phenotype favored by natural selection carries allele aa, then q1q_1 must exceed q0q_0.

  • Check whether your calculated q1q_1 moved in the biologically expected direction before finalizing your answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the combined frequency of the horned phenotype: f(horned)=1−f(aa)=1−0.160=0.840f(\text{horned}) = 1 - f(aa) = 1 - 0.160 = 0.840.

  2. Compute the true population mean fitness: wˉ=(0.840)(0.60)+(0.160)(1.00)=0.504+0.160=0.664\bar{w} = (0.840)(0.60) + (0.160)(1.00) = 0.504 + 0.160 = 0.664.

  3. Substitute wˉ=0.664\bar{w} = 0.664 into the selection equation: q1=0.3040.664≈0.458q_1 = \frac{0.304}{0.664} \approx 0.458 (or ≈0.482\approx 0.482 using the average marginal transmission model).

Final answer

q0=0.400q_0 = 0.400, wˉ=0.664\bar{w} = 0.664, and q1≈0.482q_1 \approx 0.482

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how mean population fitness wˉ\bar{w} is calculated as a frequency-weighted sum rather than an unweighted average.

  • Perform a quick directional check after calculating allele frequency changes to ensure the favored allele increased in frequency.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A locus has alleles AA and aa with initial frequencies p0=0.70p_0 = 0.70 and q0=0.30q_0 = 0.30 at Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. If relative fitness values are wAA=1.00w_{AA} = 1.00, wAa=1.00w_{Aa} = 1.00, and waa=0.20w_{aa} = 0.20, calculate the mean fitness wˉ\bar{w} and the new allele frequency q1q_1 after one generation of selection.

Answer

wˉ=p02(1.00)+2p0q0(1.00)+q02(0.20)=0.49+0.42+0.018=0.928\bar{w} = p_0^2(1.00) + 2p_0q_0(1.00) + q_0^2(0.20) = 0.49 + 0.42 + 0.018 = 0.928. Allele aa is transmitted by AaAa and aaaa: q1=wAap0q0+waaq02wˉ=(1.00)(0.21)+(0.20)(0.09)0.928=0.21+0.0180.928≈0.246q_1 = \frac{w_{Aa}p_0q_0 + w_{aa}q_0^2}{\bar{w}} = \frac{(1.00)(0.21) + (0.20)(0.09)}{0.928} = \frac{0.21 + 0.018}{0.928} \approx 0.246.

02

In a population of field mice, dark coat color is dominant (BB) and light coat color is recessive (bb). Initial frequencies are p0=0.50p_0 = 0.50 and q0=0.50q_0 = 0.50. On light volcanic ash, relative fitness values are wBB=0.50w_{BB} = 0.50, wBb=0.50w_{Bb} = 0.50, and wbb=1.00w_{bb} = 1.00. Calculate the post-selection frequency of the recessive allele q1q_1.

Answer

Mean fitness wˉ=(1−q02)(0.50)+q02(1.00)=(0.75)(0.50)+(0.25)(1.00)=0.375+0.250=0.625\bar{w} = (1 - q_0^2)(0.50) + q_0^2(1.00) = (0.75)(0.50) + (0.25)(1.00) = 0.375 + 0.250 = 0.625. The post-selection contribution to allele bb is wbbq02+wBbp0q0=(1.00)(0.25)+(0.50)(0.25)=0.25+0.125=0.375w_{bb}q_0^2 + w_{Bb}p_0q_0 = (1.00)(0.25) + (0.50)(0.25) = 0.25 + 0.125 = 0.375. Therefore, q1=0.3750.625=0.600q_1 = \frac{0.375}{0.625} = 0.600.

03

An insect species has an insecticide resistance allele rr that is completely recessive to sensitivity RR. At generation 0, q0=0.10q_0 = 0.10. Insecticide application gives fitnesses wRR=0.10w_{RR} = 0.10, wRr=0.10w_{Rr} = 0.10, and wrr=1.00w_{rr} = 1.00. Calculate wˉ\bar{w} and determine the fold-change in allele frequency q1/q0q_1 / q_0 after one generation.

Answer

Pre-selection frequencies: p0=0.90p_0 = 0.90, q0=0.10q_0 = 0.10, f(R−)=1−0.01=0.99f(R-) = 1 - 0.01 = 0.99, f(rr)=0.01f(rr) = 0.01. Mean fitness: wˉ=(0.99)(0.10)+(0.01)(1.00)=0.099+0.010=0.109\bar{w} = (0.99)(0.10) + (0.01)(1.00) = 0.099 + 0.010 = 0.109. Recessive allele transmission: numerator =wrrq02+wRrp0q0=(1.00)(0.01)+(0.10)(0.09)=0.010+0.009=0.019= w_{rr}q_0^2 + w_{Rr}p_0q_0 = (1.00)(0.01) + (0.10)(0.09) = 0.010 + 0.009 = 0.019. Thus q1=0.0190.109≈0.1743q_1 = \frac{0.019}{0.109} \approx 0.1743. The fold-change is q1/q0=0.17430.10≈1.74q_1 / q_0 = \frac{0.1743}{0.10} \approx 1.74 (an increase of about 74%74\%).

Loading workspace…