Resources

An elodea plant leaf cell initially in osmotic equilibrium has an intracellular osmolarity of 400 mOsm/L400\text{ mOsm/L}. An experimenter immerses the leaf into an open sucrose bath at 25∘C25^\circ\text{C} (298 K298\text{ K}) and observes that water exits the vacuole until the final protoplast volume stabilizes at exactly 80.0%80.0\% (0.8000.800) of its initial volume. Assuming the cell behaves as an ideal osmometer with negligible osmotically inactive volume and zero initial turgor pressure (P=0 MPaP = 0\text{ MPa}), calculate the final molar concentration of the external sucrose solution required to achieve this specific equilibrium volume.

Answer and steps

Final answer

0.500 M0.500\text{ M}

Steps

01

Understand the Ideal Osmometer Relationship

An ideal osmometer with negligible osmotically inactive volume obeys the principle of conservation of intracellular solute particles. Because solutes inside the cell cannot freely permeate the plasma membrane, the total number of osmotically active moles of solute (nn) remains constant:

n=CiVi=CfVfn = C_i V_i = C_f V_f

where:

  • CiC_i is the initial intracellular osmolarity,
  • ViV_i is the initial protoplast volume,
  • CfC_f is the final intracellular osmolarity,
  • VfV_f is the final protoplast volume.
02

Determine the Final Intracellular Osmolarity

The problem states that initial turgor pressure is zero (P=0 MPaP = 0\text{ MPa}), meaning the cell begins at incipient plasmolysis. As water exits the cell and the protoplast shrinks further, turgor pressure remains zero (P=0 MPaP = 0\text{ MPa}). Therefore, osmotic equilibrium depends solely on solute concentration.

Given that Vf=0.800 ViV_f = 0.800 \, V_i and Ci=400 mOsm/L=0.400 Osm/LC_i = 400\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.400\text{ Osm/L}:

Cf=Ci(ViVf)=0.400 Osm/L0.800=0.500 Osm/LC_f = C_i \left(\frac{V_i}{V_f}\right) = \frac{0.400\text{ Osm/L}}{0.800} = 0.500\text{ Osm/L}

03

Relate Intracellular Osmolarity to External Sucrose Molarity

At osmotic equilibrium, the net flow of water across the semipermeable membrane ceases when the water potential inside the cell equals the water potential outside the cell:

Ψinside=Ψoutside\Psi_{\text{inside}} = \Psi_{\text{outside}}

With zero turgor pressure inside and an open bath outside at atmospheric pressure (P=0P = 0):

Ψs(inside)=Ψs(outside)  ⟹  Osmolarityinside=Osmolarityoutside=0.500 Osm/L\Psi_s(\text{inside}) = \Psi_s(\text{outside}) \implies \text{Osmolarity}_{\text{inside}} = \text{Osmolarity}_{\text{outside}} = 0.500\text{ Osm/L}

Sucrose is a non-electrolyte and does not dissociate in aqueous solution, so its van 't Hoff factor is i=1i = 1:

Osmolarity=i⋅M=1⋅M\text{Osmolarity} = i \cdot M = 1 \cdot M

Msucrose=0.500 MM_{\text{sucrose}} = 0.500\text{ M}

Common Pitfall: Do not assume the cell develops negative turgor pressure that counteracts water loss. In plant cells undergoing plasmolysis, the plasma membrane detaches from the cell wall, keeping hydrostatic pressure equal to atmospheric pressure (P=0P = 0) throughout protoplast shrinkage.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student multiplies the initial osmolarity by the volume fraction instead of dividing by it, mistakenly assuming concentration scales proportionally with volume rather than inversely.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Cf=Ci∗VfVi  ⟹  Cf=400 mOsm/L∗0.800=320 mOsm/LC_f = C_i * \frac{V_f}{V_i} \implies C_f = 400\text{ mOsm/L} * 0.800 = 320\text{ mOsm/L}

    Correct

    CiVi=CfVf  ⟹  Cf=Ci(ViVf)=400 mOsm/L0.800=500 mOsm/LC_i V_i = C_f V_f \implies C_f = C_i \left(\frac{V_i}{V_f}\right) = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.800} = 500\text{ mOsm/L}

    Because intracellular solute particles are trapped inside the cell, the number of moles of solute is conserved (n=CiVi=CfVfn = C_i V_i = C_f V_f). When water leaves and the volume decreases, the internal solution becomes more concentrated, so you must divide by the volume ratio VfVi\frac{V_f}{V_i} rather than multiply by it.

  2. Step 2

    Sucrose does not dissociate, so i=1\text{Sucrose does not dissociate, so } i = 1

  3. Step 3

    Molar concentration=320 mM=0.320 M\text{Molar concentration} = 320\text{ mM} = 0.320\text{ M}

    Correct

    M=Cfi=500 mOsm/L1=500 mM=0.500 MM = \frac{C_f}{i} = \frac{500\text{ mOsm/L}}{1} = 500\text{ mM} = 0.500\text{ M}

    Your conversion from osmolarity to molarity followed logically from your previous calculation, but it inherited the numerical error from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that sucrose is a non-ionizing solute with a van 't Hoff factor of i=1i = 1.

You recognized that at osmotic equilibrium without turgor pressure, external solution concentration matches internal osmolarity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportionality inverted in dilution/concentration relation

You set Cf=Ci⋅(Vf/Vi)C_f = C_i \cdot (V_f / V_i) instead of Cf=Ci⋅(Vi/Vf)C_f = C_i \cdot (V_i / V_f), effectively treating concentration as directly proportional to volume.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing direct and inverse proportionality when solute amount is conserved: as solvent volume shrinks, solute concentration must increase (C=n/VC = n / V), meaning Cf=Ci/(Vf/Vi)C_f = C_i / (V_f / V_i).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Sanity Check
  • When water leaves a compartment while solute stays inside, the remaining solution must become more concentrated, never more dilute.

  • Always verify that if Vf<ViV_f < V_i, then Cf>CiC_f > C_i before proceeding to downstream steps.

Solute Conservation Equation
  • Solute conservation requires C1V1=C2V2C_1 V_1 = C_2 V_2.

  • Rearrange algebraically before plugging in numbers: C2=C1⋅V1V2=C1V2/V1C_2 = C_1 \cdot \frac{V_1}{V_2} = \frac{C_1}{V_2 / V_1}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply solute conservation: CiVi=CfVfC_i V_i = C_f V_f.

  2. Solve for final intracellular osmolarity: Cf=CiViVf=400 mOsm/L0.800=500 mOsm/LC_f = \frac{C_i V_i}{V_f} = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.800} = 500\text{ mOsm/L}.

  3. Equate external osmolarity to final internal osmolarity: Osmolarityext=500 mOsm/L=0.500 Osm/L\text{Osmolarity}_{\text{ext}} = 500\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.500\text{ Osm/L}.

  4. Convert osmolarity to molarity using i=1i = 1: Msucrose=0.500 Osm/L1=0.500 MM_{\text{sucrose}} = \frac{0.500\text{ Osm/L}}{1} = 0.500\text{ M}.

Final answer

0.500 M0.500\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the relationship C1V1=C2V2C_1 V_1 = C_2 V_2 for closed-solute systems.

  • Practice checking whether your calculated concentration increases when volume decreases.

  • Work through osmotic shrinkage and swelling problems involving electrolyte solutes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the correct final osmolarity of 500 mOsm/L but assumes sucrose dissociates like a binary salt with i = 2, resulting in halving the required molar concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Cf⋅Vf=Ci⋅Vi  ⟹  Cf=400 mOsm/L0.800=500 mOsm/LC_f \cdot V_f = C_i \cdot V_i \implies C_f = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.800} = 500\text{ mOsm/L}

  2. Step 2

    For sucrose, assume dissociation factor i=2i = 2

    Correct

    For sucrose (a non-electrolyte), the van 't Hoff factor is i=1i = 1.

    Sucrose (C12H22O11\text{C}_{12}\text{H}_{22}\text{O}_{11}) is a covalently bonded sugar molecule and does not dissociate into separate ions in water. Its van 't Hoff factor is i=1i = 1, not i=2i = 2.

  3. Step 3

    Molar concentration=500 mOsm/L2=250 mM=0.250 M\text{Molar concentration} = \frac{500\text{ mOsm/L}}{2} = 250\text{ mM} = 0.250\text{ M}

    Correct

    Molar concentration=500 mOsm/L1=500 mM=0.500 M\text{Molar concentration} = \frac{500\text{ mOsm/L}}{1} = 500\text{ mM} = 0.500\text{ M}

    Because your dissociation factor was set to i=2i = 2, your final molar concentration was halved from the correct value of 0.500 M0.500\text{ M}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the ideal osmometer relation to calculate that protoplast shrinkage to 80.0%80.0\% raises internal osmolarity to 500 mOsm/L500\text{ mOsm/L}.

You correctly identified that the external solution must match the cell's equilibrium osmolarity when turgor pressure is zero.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect van 't Hoff factor for non-electrolyte

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated a molecular disaccharide (sucrose) with a binary ionic salt (such as NaCl\text{NaCl}), mistakenly assigning it a van 't Hoff factor of i=2i = 2 instead of i=1i = 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electrolyte vs. Non-electrolyte Classification
  • Molecules with only covalent bonds like sugars (sucrose, glucose) do not ionize in water (i=1i = 1). Salts dissociating into two ions (like NaCl\text{NaCl}) have i=2i = 2.

  • Always identify the chemical nature of the solute before converting between osmolarity and molarity.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify sucrose as a non-electrolyte: i=1i = 1.

  2. Relate osmolarity to molarity: Osmolarity=i⋅M=1⋅M\text{Osmolarity} = i \cdot M = 1 \cdot M.

  3. Calculate final molarity: M=500 mOsm/L1=500 mM=0.500 MM = \frac{500\text{ mOsm/L}}{1} = 500\text{ mM} = 0.500\text{ M}.

Final answer

0.500 M0.500\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review common biological osmoprotectants and solutes (glucose, sucrose, glycerol) to reinforce that neutral organic compounds have i=1i = 1.

  • Double-check solute dissociation properties before dividing or multiplying by a van 't Hoff factor.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the change in volume (20% or 0.200) and uses it directly in place of the final volume in the dilution formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔV=1.000−0.800=0.200\Delta V = 1.000 - 0.800 = 0.200

  2. Step 2

    Cf=400 mOsm/L0.200=2000 mOsm/LC_f = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.200} = 2000\text{ mOsm/L}

    Correct

    Cf=Ci(ViVf)=400 mOsm/L0.800=500 mOsm/LC_f = C_i \left(\frac{V_i}{V_f}\right) = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.800} = 500\text{ mOsm/L}

    You substituted the lost volume fraction (ΔV=0.200\Delta V = 0.200) into the denominator instead of the remaining final volume fraction (Vf=0.800V_f = 0.800). Solute conservation dictates CiVi=CfVfC_i V_i = C_f V_f, so CfC_f depends on the final volume VfV_f containing those solutes.

  3. Step 3

    Sucrose i=1\text{Sucrose } i = 1

  4. Step 4

    Molar concentration=2.00 M\text{Molar concentration} = 2.00\text{ M}

    Correct

    M=Cfi=500 mOsm/L1000 mOsm/Osm=0.500 MM = \frac{C_f}{i} = \frac{500\text{ mOsm/L}}{1000\text{ mOsm/Osm}} = 0.500\text{ M}

    Your conversion from milliosmoles per liter to molar concentration was performed correctly using your value from Step 2, but the final numerical value is affected by the earlier volume substitution error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that sucrose is a non-dissociating solute with i=1i = 1.

You understood that cell shrinkage increases intracellular osmolarity according to an inverse concentration-volume relationship.

You converted units properly between mOsm/L\text{mOsm/L} and M\text{M}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable confusion: substituted volume change for final volume

You calculated the volume decrement ΔV=0.200\Delta V = 0.200 and mistakenly placed it in the denominator of the conservation equation in place of the final volume Vf=0.800V_f = 0.800.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the quantity of volume lost (ΔV\Delta V) with the remaining volume of solution (VfV_f) that holds the trapped intracellular solutes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Solute Conservation Principle
  • For an ideal osmometer with impermeable solutes: n=CiVi=CfVfn = C_i V_i = C_f V_f.

  • Always set the denominator of Cf=CiViVfC_f = \frac{C_i V_i}{V_f} to the actual remaining volume VfV_f, never to ΔV\Delta V.

Physical Reality Check
  • When a cell shrinks moderately (e.g., from 1.001.00 to 0.800.80 volume), concentration increases moderately (by 1/0.80=1.25×1/0.80 = 1.25\times).

  • Check whether your calculated concentration matches the scale of shrinking: a 20%20\% volume loss cannot cause a 5×5\times increase in concentration.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the final protoplast volume fraction Vf/Vi=0.800V_f / V_i = 0.800 into the solute conservation formula: Cf=CiVf/Vi=400 mOsm/L0.800=500 mOsm/LC_f = \frac{C_i}{V_f / V_i} = \frac{400\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.800} = 500\text{ mOsm/L}.

  2. Equate external osmolarity to final intracellular osmolarity at equilibrium (P=0 MPaP = 0\text{ MPa}): Osmolarityout=500 mOsm/L=0.500 Osm/L\text{Osmolarity}_{\text{out}} = 500\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.500\text{ Osm/L}.

  3. Relate external osmolarity to molarity for sucrose (i=1i = 1): M=Osmolarityi=0.500 Osm/L1=0.500 MM = \frac{\text{Osmolarity}}{i} = \frac{0.500\text{ Osm/L}}{1} = 0.500\text{ M}.

Final answer

0.500 M0.500\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • In osmotic equilibrium problems, explicitly write out Vf=0.800ViV_f = 0.800 V_i before substituting into CiVi=CfVfC_i V_i = C_f V_f.

  • Perform a quick mental check: if volume decreases to 80%80\%, concentration should increase by 1/0.8=125%1/0.8 = 125\%, leading to 400×1.25=500 mOsm/L400 \times 1.25 = 500\text{ mOsm/L}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A red blood cell behaving as an ideal osmometer has an initial intracellular osmolarity of 300 mOsm/L300\text{ mOsm/L}. It is placed in a concentrated sucrose solution (i=1i = 1) and shrinks until its volume is 75.0%75.0\% of the initial volume. Assuming zero hydrostatic pressure difference, calculate the molar concentration of the external sucrose solution at equilibrium.

Answer

0.400 M0.400\text{ M}. By solute conservation, Cf=CiVf/Vi=300 mOsm/L0.750=400 mOsm/L=0.400 Osm/LC_f = \frac{C_i}{V_f / V_i} = \frac{300\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.750} = 400\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.400\text{ Osm/L}. For sucrose (i=1i = 1), M=0.400 MM = 0.400\text{ M}.

02

An elodea protoplast at incipient plasmolysis (P=0P = 0) has an internal osmolarity of 450 mOsm/L450\text{ mOsm/L}. It is immersed in an external NaCl\ce{NaCl} solution (assume ideal dissociation, i=2i = 2). At equilibrium, the protoplast volume stabilizes at 60.0%60.0\% of its initial volume. Calculate the molarity of the external NaCl\ce{NaCl} solution.

Answer

0.375 M0.375\text{ M}. Final internal osmolarity is Cf=450 mOsm/L0.600=750 mOsm/L=0.750 Osm/LC_f = \frac{450\text{ mOsm/L}}{0.600} = 750\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.750\text{ Osm/L}. At equilibrium, external osmolarity equals 0.750 Osm/L0.750\text{ Osm/L}. Since NaCl\ce{NaCl} yields i=2i = 2 particles, MNaCl=0.750 Osm/L2=0.375 MM_{\ce{NaCl}} = \frac{0.750\text{ Osm/L}}{2} = 0.375\text{ M}.

03

A plant protoplast has an initial osmolar concentration of 350 mOsm/L350\text{ mOsm/L} and a total volume of 100 pL100\text{ pL}, of which 20 pL20\text{ pL} is osmotically inactive volume (VbV_b). The cell is placed in an open sucrose bath (i=1i = 1) until its total protoplast volume shrinks to 60 pL60\text{ pL}. If turgor pressure remains zero throughout, find the molarity of the external sucrose bath at equilibrium.

Answer

0.700 M0.700\text{ M}. Only the osmotically active volume changes: initial active volume is Va,i=100−20=80 pLV_{a,i} = 100 - 20 = 80\text{ pL}, and final active volume is Va,f=60−20=40 pLV_{a,f} = 60 - 20 = 40\text{ pL}. Solute conservation gives Cf=Ci(Va,iVa,f)=350 mOsm/L×(8040)=700 mOsm/L=0.700 Osm/LC_f = C_i \left(\frac{V_{a,i}}{V_{a,f}}\right) = 350\text{ mOsm/L} \times \left(\frac{80}{40}\right) = 700\text{ mOsm/L} = 0.700\text{ Osm/L}. Since i=1i = 1, M=0.700 MM = 0.700\text{ M}.

Loading workspace…