Resources

Consider the long-term evolutionary fate of a slightly deleterious mutation bb in two finite, isolated populations of an endangered bird species. The wild-type allele is BB, and the mutation rate from B→bB \to b is μ=2.0×10−5\mu = 2.0 \times 10^{-5} per generation with negligible back-mutation. The selective disadvantage against homozygous mutant individuals is s=0.002s = 0.002 with additive fitness (wBB=1w_{BB} = 1, wBb=1−s2w_{Bb} = 1 - \frac{s}{2}, wbb=1−sw_{bb} = 1 - s). Population 1 is a continental sanctuary with effective population size Ne1=50,000N_{e1} = 50{,}000, while Population 2 is an island reserve with Ne2=50N_{e2} = 50. (a) Determine the deterministic mutation-selection equilibrium frequency q^det\hat{q}_{\text{det}} of allele bb in an infinite population under additive selection (where q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}, with h=0.5h = 0.5). (b) Evaluate the nearly neutral boundary product NesN_e s for both populations to determine whether genetic drift or natural selection dominates the dynamics of allele bb. (c) What is the asymptotic probability of ultimate fixation PfixP_{\text{fix}} of a newly arisen neutral-limit mutant allele in Population 2 if drift completely overwhelms selection?

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) q^det=μhs=2.0×10−5(0.5)(0.002)=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \frac{\mu}{hs} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{(0.5)(0.002)} = 0.020; (b) For Population 1, Ne1s=(50,000)(0.002)=100≫1N_{e1}s = (50{,}000)(0.002) = 100 \gg 1 (selection dominates); for Population 2, Ne2s=(50)(0.002)=0.10≪1N_{e2}s = (50)(0.002) = 0.10 \ll 1 (genetic drift dominates, rendering the allele effectively neutral); (c) Pfix=12Ne2=1100=0.010P_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{2N_{e2}} = \frac{1}{100} = 0.010 (or 1.0%1.0\%).

Steps

Part (a): Deterministic Mutation-Selection Equilibrium Frequency

In a very large (effectively infinite) population, deterministic evolutionary forces govern allele frequencies. When an allele is slightly deleterious and acts additively with dominance coefficient h=0.5h = 0.5, selection acts against heterozygotes with a fitness reduction of hshs. New mutant alleles enter the gene pool at rate μ\mu per generation.

At equilibrium, the rate of introducing new copies via mutation balances the rate of removal by selection: q^det≈μhs\hat{q}_{\text{det}} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}

Substitute the given values (μ=2.0×10−5\mu = 2.0 \times 10^{-5}, h=0.5h = 0.5, and s=0.002s = 0.002): q^det=2.0×10−5(0.5)(0.002)=2.0×10−51.0×10−3=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{(0.5)(0.002)} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{1.0 \times 10^{-3}} = 0.020

Pitfall: For fully recessive mutations (h=0h = 0), selection only acts against homozygotes, yielding q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}}. However, under additive gene action (h=0.5h = 0.5), selection acts on heterozygotes, making the linear approximation q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs} the appropriate formula.


Part (b): Evaluating the Relative Strength of Drift versus Selection

In finite populations, random sampling of gametes (genetic drift) introduces stochastic fluctuations in allele frequencies. The balance between deterministic selection and random drift is governed by the product NesN_e s (or 4Nes4N_e s):

  • If Nes≫1N_e s \gg 1, natural selection dictates allele dynamics, purging deleterious mutations efficiently.
  • If Nes≪1N_e s \ll 1, genetic drift overwhelms natural selection, and the allele behaves as effectively neutral.
  1. Population 1 (Continental sanctuary, Ne1=50,000N_{e1} = 50{,}000): Ne1s=(50,000)(0.002)=100N_{e1}s = (50{,}000)(0.002) = 100 Because 100≫1100 \gg 1, natural selection dominates. Allele frequencies will remain close to the deterministic mutation-selection equilibrium q^≈0.020\hat{q} \approx 0.020.
  2. Population 2 (Island reserve, Ne2=50N_{e2} = 50): Ne2s=(50)(0.002)=0.10N_{e2}s = (50)(0.002) = 0.10 Because 0.10≪10.10 \ll 1, genetic drift completely dominates over selection. Selection is too weak relative to random sampling error, causing allele bb to evolve as an effectively neutral variant.

Part (c): Fixation Probability in the Neutral Drift Limit

In a diploid population of size NeN_e, there are 2Ne2N_e total gene copies. A newly arisen mutation starts as a single copy in the population, so its initial frequency is: q0=12Neq_0 = \frac{1}{2N_e}

Under pure genetic drift (the neutral limit), every gene copy in the population has an equal chance of becoming the common ancestor of all future alleles. Therefore, the probability of ultimate fixation PfixP_{\text{fix}} of a neutral mutation equals its initial frequency: Pfix=12Ne2=12(50)=1100=0.010(1.0%)P_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{2N_{e2}} = \frac{1}{2(50)} = \frac{1}{100} = 0.010 \quad (1.0\%)

Although the mutation is deleterious in absolute terms, the severe bottleneck on the island allows drift to override selection, giving this harmful allele a non-zero 1.0%1.0\% probability of fixing across the entire population.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misremembers the equilibrium formula by using completely recessive selection √(μ/s) instead of additive selection μ/(hs), yielding q̂ = 0.1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q^det=μs=2.0×10−50.002=0.01=0.10\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} = \sqrt{\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.002}} = \sqrt{0.01} = 0.10

    Correct

    q^det≈μhs=2.0×10−5(0.5)(0.002)=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{det}} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{(0.5)(0.002)} = 0.020

    You applied the formula for a completely recessive allele, q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}}. Because the mutation has additive fitness with h=0.5h = 0.5, selection acts directly on heterozygotes, which requires q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}.

  2. Step 2

    Population 1: Ne1×s=50,000×0.002=100>1, selection dominatesPopulation 2: Ne2×s=50×0.002=0.1<1, genetic drift dominates\text{Population 1: } N_{e1} \times s = 50{,}000 \times 0.002 = 100 > 1\text{, selection dominates} \\ \text{Population 2: } N_{e2} \times s = 50 \times 0.002 = 0.1 < 1\text{, genetic drift dominates}

  3. Step 3

    Pfix=12×Ne2=1100=0.01P_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{2 \times N_{e2}} = \frac{1}{100} = 0.01

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the boundary product NesN_e s and identified the dominant evolutionary force for each population size.

You applied the correct initial-frequency identity Pfix=12NeP_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{2N_e} for a neutral allele in a finite diploid population.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Recessive vs. Additive Mutation-Selection Equilibrium

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the square-root equilibrium formula q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}}, which holds only when a deleterious allele is completely hidden in heterozygotes (h=0h = 0). When fitness is additive (h>0h > 0), selection acts against heterozygotes with selection coefficient hshs, leading to a linear balance q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dominance and Heterozygote Fitness
  • If 0<h≤10 < h \le 1, heterozygotes express the deleterious effect (w=1−hsw = 1 - hs), so equilibrium frequency is linear: q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}. If h=0h = 0 (completely recessive), selection only acts on homozygotes, so q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}}.

  • Always inspect the heterozygote fitness wBbw_{Bb} or dominance coefficient hh before picking the equilibrium formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the dominance coefficient: for additive fitness, h=0.5h = 0.5, so heterozygote disadvantage is hs=(0.5)(0.002)=0.001hs = (0.5)(0.002) = 0.001.

  2. Apply the linear balance formula q^det=μhs=2.0×10−50.001\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \frac{\mu}{hs} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.001}.

  3. Simplify the fraction: q^det=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = 0.020.

Final answer

q^det=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = 0.020

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between additive (h=0.5h = 0.5) and recessive (h=0h = 0) mutation-selection balance models.

  • Practice identifying whether selection acts against heterozygotes or strictly against homozygous mutants.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the factor of 2 in the denominator for diploid individuals, calculating fixation probability as 1/Ne = 0.02 instead of 1/(2Ne).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q^det=μh⋅s=2.0×10−50.5×0.002=0.02\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \frac{\mu}{h \cdot s} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.5 \times 0.002} = 0.02

  2. Step 2

    Population 1: \text{Population 1: } N_{e1} ⋅\cdot s = 50{,}000 ×\times 0.002 = 100,  selection dominates\text{ selection dominates} \ Population 2: \text{Population 2: } N_{e2} ⋅\cdot s = 50 ×\times 0.002 = 0.1,  genetic drift dominates\text{ genetic drift dominates}

  3. Step 3

    P_{fix\text{fix}} = 1Ne2\frac{1}{N_{e2}}   ⟹  \implies P_{fix\text{fix}} = 150\frac{1}{50} = 0.02

    Correct

    P_{fix\text{fix}} = 12Ne2\frac{1}{2N_{e2}} = 12(50)\frac{1}{2(50)} = 1100\frac{1}{100} = 0.010_

    Because birds are diploid organisms, an effective population size of Ne2=50N_{e2} = 50 contains 2Ne2=1002N_{e2} = 100 total gene copies. A single newly arisen mutant allele has an initial frequency of 12Ne2\frac{1}{2N_{e2}}, making its neutral fixation probability 0.0100.010 rather than 0.020.02.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the additive mutation-selection balance formula q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs} and found q^=0.02\hat{q} = 0.02.

You correctly evaluated NesN_e s for both populations to identify whether selection or drift predominates.

You recognized that neutral fixation probability equals the allele's initial frequency under drift.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diploid allele count omitted in fixation probability

You used the haploid fixation formula Pfix=1NeP_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{N_e} instead of accounting for both homologous chromosome copies in diploid birds.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the number of breeding individuals (NeN_e) with the total number of gene copies in the gene pool (2Ne2N_e) when converting a single mutational event into an initial allele frequency.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check ploidy of the gene pool
  • For a diploid autosomal locus with NeN_e individuals, the total gene pool size is 2Ne2N_e copies.

  • Always multiply the census or effective population size by the ploidy level (22 for diploids) before setting up initial allele frequencies.

Neutral fixation probability equivalence
  • Under pure genetic drift, every gene copy in the pool has an equal chance of fixing: Pfix=p0=12NeP_{\text{fix}} = p_0 = \frac{1}{2N_e}.

  • Verify that your starting numerator represents 11 mutant copy and the denominator represents all 2Ne2N_e homologous copies.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total number of autosomal gene copies: 2Ne2=2×50=1002N_{e2} = 2 \times 50 = 100.

  2. Set the initial frequency of a single newly arisen mutation: q0=12Ne2=1100q_0 = \frac{1}{2N_{e2}} = \frac{1}{100}.

  3. Apply the neutral drift fixation theorem: Pfix=q0=0.010P_{\text{fix}} = q_0 = 0.010.

Final answer

P_{fix\text{fix}} = 12Ne2\frac{1}{2N_{e2}} = 0.010  (or \text{ (or } 1.0%)\text{)}_

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between haploid (NN) and diploid (2N2N) gene pool sizes across population genetics formulas.

  • Solve problems comparing fixation probabilities for newly arisen alleles under drift versus positive selection (P≈2sP \approx 2s).

  • Practice identifying the ploidy level of the locus (autosomal vs. X-linked vs. mitochondrial) before setting up initial frequencies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the criterion for drift dominance, concluding that selection dominates whenever the product is greater than zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q^det=μh∗s=2.0×10−50.5×0.002=0.02\hat{q}_{\text{det}} = \frac{\mu}{h * s} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.5 \times 0.002} = 0.02

  2. Step 2

    Population 1: \text{Population 1: } N_{e_1} * s = 50{,}000 ×\times 0.002 = 100 > 0,  selection dominates\text{ selection dominates}_

  3. Step 3

    Population 2: \text{Population 2: } N_{e_2} * s = 50 ×\times 0.002 = 0.10 > 0,  selection dominates\text{ selection dominates}_

    Correct

    N_{e2}s = (50)(0.002) = 0.10 \ll 1   ⟹  \implies Genetic drift dominates (allele is effectively neutral)\text{Genetic drift dominates (allele is effectively neutral)}_

    In Population 2, Ne2s=0.10N_{e2}s = 0.10. The threshold for selection overcoming drift is Nes≫1N_e s \gg 1. Because 0.10≪10.10 \ll 1, random sampling error (drift) overwhelms selection, meaning allele bb behaves as effectively neutral.

  4. Step 4

    P_{fix\text{fix}} = 12∗Ne2\frac{1}{2 * N_{e_2}} = 12×50\frac{1}{2 \times 50} = 0.01_

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the mutation-selection equilibrium frequency for an additive allele.

You accurately computed the numerical products NesN_e s for both populations.

You correctly used the initial mutant frequency 12Ne\frac{1}{2N_e} to find the neutral fixation probability.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplied Drift-Selection Boundary Condition

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You tested whether Nes>0N_e s > 0 instead of evaluating whether NesN_e s is much greater than or much less than 1. Since effective population size NeN_e and selection coefficient ss are positive physical quantities, their product is always greater than 0. The true boundary between selection dominance and drift dominance occurs at Nes≈1N_e s \approx 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nearly Neutral Boundary Rule
  • Compare NesN_e s against 11, not 00. If Nes≫1N_e s \gg 1, natural selection dominates; if Nes≪1N_e s \ll 1, genetic drift dominates.

  • Always evaluate whether NesN_e s is significantly above or below 11 when determining whether an allele behaves neutrally or selectively.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate Population 1: Ne1s=(50,000)(0.002)=100N_{e1}s = (50{,}000)(0.002) = 100. Since 100≫1100 \gg 1, natural selection dominates.

  2. Evaluate Population 2: Ne2s=(50)(0.002)=0.10N_{e2}s = (50)(0.002) = 0.10. Since 0.10≪10.10 \ll 1, genetic drift dominates over selection, and the allele is effectively neutral.

Final answer

In Population 1, Ne1s=100≫1N_{e1}s = 100 \gg 1, so selection dominates. In Population 2, Ne2s=0.10≪1N_{e2}s = 0.10 \ll 1, so genetic drift dominates.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Ohta's nearly neutral theory to see why Nes≈1N_e s \approx 1 represents the threshold where random drift balances deterministic selection.

  • Practice checking whether values of NesN_e s fall in the drift-dominated regime (Nes<1N_e s < 1) or the selection-dominated regime (Nes>1N_e s > 1).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A deleterious mutation has rate μ=4.0×10−6\mu = 4.0 \times 10^{-6} and selective disadvantage s=0.04s = 0.04. If gene action is partially dominant with h=0.1h = 0.1, determine its deterministic mutation-selection equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q}.

Answer

q^=μhs=4.0×10−6(0.1)(0.04)=4.0×10−64.0×10−3=1.0×10−3=0.0010\hat{q} = \frac{\mu}{hs} = \frac{4.0 \times 10^{-6}}{(0.1)(0.04)} = \frac{4.0 \times 10^{-6}}{4.0 \times 10^{-3}} = 1.0 \times 10^{-3} = 0.0010.

02

An isolated population of endangered mammals has an effective population size of Ne=200N_e = 200. A newly arisen slightly deleterious allele has selection coefficient s=0.001s = 0.001. Determine whether drift or selection dominates, and calculate the allele's fixation probability if it is treated as effectively neutral.

Answer

Nes=(200)(0.001)=0.2<1N_e s = (200)(0.001) = 0.2 < 1, so genetic drift dominates over selection (the allele is effectively neutral). In the neutral limit, Pfix=12Ne=1400=0.0025P_{\text{fix}} = \frac{1}{2N_e} = \frac{1}{400} = 0.0025 (or 0.25%0.25\%).

03

For a deleterious allele with μ=1.0×10−4\mu = 1.0 \times 10^{-4} and s=0.01s = 0.01, compare the deterministic equilibrium frequency under completely recessive action (h=0h = 0) versus additive action (h=0.5h = 0.5). Explain why the recessive equilibrium frequency is significantly higher.

Answer

For completely recessive: q^rec=μs=1.0×10−40.01=0.10\hat{q}_{\text{rec}} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} = \sqrt{\frac{1.0 \times 10^{-4}}{0.01}} = 0.10. For additive: q^add=μhs=1.0×10−4(0.5)(0.01)=0.020\hat{q}_{\text{add}} = \frac{\mu}{hs} = \frac{1.0 \times 10^{-4}}{(0.5)(0.01)} = 0.020. The recessive equilibrium frequency is much higher because rare deleterious alleles reside almost exclusively in heterozygotes, where completely recessive alleles are entirely shielded from natural selection.

Loading workspace…