Resources

A population of zooplankton (Daphnia magnaDaphnia\ magna) in a controlled limnology mesocosm experiences density-dependent logistic growth with carrying capacity K=2,400 individualsK = 2{,}400\text{ individuals} and intrinsic growth rate r=0.450 day−1r = 0.450\text{ day}^{-1}. Simultaneously, a constant environmental harvesting pressure (predation by introduced juvenile planktivorous fish) removes individuals at a steady rate of H=135 individuals⋅day−1H = 135\text{ individuals}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}, leading to the coupled dynamics model dNdt=rN(1−NK)−H\frac{dN}{dt} = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H. Find the two equilibrium population sizes N1∗N_1^* and N2∗N_2^* (N1∗<N2∗N_1^* < N_2^*) where dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0, and identify which equilibrium is locally stable.

Answer and steps

Final answer

N1∗=351 individualsN_1^* = 351\text{ individuals} (unstable threshold); N2∗=2,049 individualsN_2^* = 2{,}049\text{ individuals} (stable equilibrium)

Steps

01

Setting Up the Equilibrium Condition

An ecological population reaches an equilibrium (steady state) when the rate of population change is zero: dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0

Using the given rate equation for logistic growth subject to constant-rate harvesting: rN(1−NK)−H=0rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0

Substitute the given parameter values (r=0.450 day−1r = 0.450\text{ day}^{-1}, K=2,400 individualsK = 2{,}400\text{ individuals}, and H=135 individuals⋅day−1H = 135\text{ individuals}\cdot\text{day}^{-1}): 0.450N(1−N2,400)−135=00.450N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2{,}400}\right) - 135 = 0


02

Solving for the Equilibrium Population Sizes

First, divide the entire equation by r=0.450r = 0.450: N(1−N2,400)−1350.450=0N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2{,}400}\right) - \frac{135}{0.450} = 0

N−N22,400−300=0N - \frac{N^2}{2{,}400} - 300 = 0

Multiply through by −2,400-2{,}400 to clear the denominator and rewrite in standard quadratic form aN2+bN+c=0aN^2 + bN + c = 0: N2−2,400N+720,000=0N^2 - 2{,}400N + 720{,}000 = 0

Apply the quadratic formula, N=−b±b2−4ac2aN = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}: b2−4ac=(−2,400)2−4(1)(720,000)=5,760,000−2,880,000=2,880,000b^2 - 4ac = (-2{,}400)^2 - 4(1)(720{,}000) = 5{,}760{,}000 - 2{,}880{,}000 = 2{,}880{,}000

2,880,000≈1,697.056\sqrt{2{,}880{,}000} \approx 1{,}697.056

Now, compute the two roots: N=2,400±1,697.0562=1,200±848.528N = \frac{2{,}400 \pm 1{,}697.056}{2} = 1{,}200 \pm 848.528

  • Lower equilibrium: N1∗=1,200−848.528≈351 individualsN_1^* = 1{,}200 - 848.528 \approx 351\text{ individuals}
  • Upper equilibrium: N2∗=1,200+848.528≈2,049 individualsN_2^* = 1{,}200 + 848.528 \approx 2{,}049\text{ individuals}

03

Evaluating Local Stability

To determine stability, evaluate the derivative of the net growth function f(N)=dNdtf(N) = \frac{dN}{dt} with respect to population size NN: f(N)=rN−rKN2−Hf(N) = rN - \frac{r}{K}N^2 - H

f′(N)=dfdN=r−2rKN=r(1−2NK)f'(N) = \frac{df}{dN} = r - \frac{2r}{K}N = r\left(1 - \frac{2N}{K}\right)

An equilibrium point N∗N^* is:

  • Locally stable if f′(N∗)<0f'(N^*) < 0, because any small disturbance is countered by a restoring rate of change.
  • Unstable if f′(N∗)>0f'(N^*) > 0, because a disturbance causes the population to move further away from the equilibrium.

Notice that the derivative changes sign at the maximum sustainable yield point, N=K2=1,200N = \frac{K}{2} = 1{,}200:

  • At N1∗≈351N_1^* \approx 351: f′(351)=0.450(1−2⋅3512,400)=0.450(1−0.2925)=+0.318 day−1>0f'(351) = 0.450\left(1 - \frac{2 \cdot 351}{2{,}400}\right) = 0.450(1 - 0.2925) = +0.318\text{ day}^{-1} > 0 Since f′(N1∗)>0f'(N_1^*) > 0, N1∗N_1^* is an unstable threshold (an extinction boundary: if N<N1∗N < N_1^*, dNdt<0\frac{dN}{dt} < 0 and the population collapses to zero).
  • At N2∗≈2,049N_2^* \approx 2{,}049: f′(2,049)=0.450(1−2⋅2,0492,400)=0.450(1−1.7075)=−0.318 day−1<0f'(2{,}049) = 0.450\left(1 - \frac{2 \cdot 2{,}049}{2{,}400}\right) = 0.450(1 - 1.7075) = -0.318\text{ day}^{-1} < 0 Since f′(N2∗)<0f'(N_2^*) < 0, N2∗N_2^* is a locally stable equilibrium (the population recovers toward N2∗N_2^* after minor disturbances).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student forgets to divide the constant harvesting rate H by the coefficient of N² when simplifying the quadratic equation to standard form, obtaining incorrect equilibrium values.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dNdt=0.45N(1−N2400)−135=0  ⟹  0.0001875N2−0.45N+135=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.45N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2400}\right) - 135 = 0 \implies 0.0001875 N^2 - 0.45 N + 135 = 0

  2. Step 2

    N2−2400N+135=0N^2 - 2400 N + 135 = 0

    Correct

    N2−2400N+720000=0N^2 - 2400 N + 720000 = 0

    When dividing the entire equation by the leading coefficient 0.00018750.0001875, you divided the first two terms but forgot to divide the constant term 135135 by 0.00018750.0001875, which equals 720,000720{,}000.

  3. Step 3

    N=2400±5760000−5402  ⟹  N1∗=0.06 individuals,  N2∗=2399.94 individualsN = \frac{2400 \pm \sqrt{5760000 - 540}}{2} \implies N_1^* = 0.06\text{ individuals},\; N_2^* = 2399.94\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N=2400±28800002  ⟹  N1∗≈351 individuals,  N2∗≈2049 individualsN = \frac{2400 \pm \sqrt{2880000}}{2} \implies N_1^* \approx 351\text{ individuals},\; N_2^* \approx 2049\text{ individuals}

    You applied the quadratic formula correctly to your equation, but the values were distorted by the missing division in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    f′(N)=0.45−2(0.45)N2400=0.45−0.000375N  ⟹  f′(2399.94)=−0.45<0  ⟹  N2∗ is locally stable.f'(N) = 0.45 - \frac{2(0.45)N}{2400} = 0.45 - 0.000375 N \implies f'(2399.94) = -0.45 < 0 \implies N_2^*\text{ is locally stable.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the equilibrium condition by setting dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.

You accurately computed the derivative f′(N)f'(N) to evaluate local stability.

You correctly identified that a negative derivative indicates a locally stable equilibrium point.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic transformation oversight

You forgot to divide the constant harvesting rate H=135H = 135 by the leading coefficient 0.00018750.0001875 when normalizing the quadratic equation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete distribution of division across all terms when converting a quadratic equation aN2+bN+c=0aN^2 + bN + c = 0 into monic form N2+baN+ca=0N^2 + \frac{b}{a}N + \frac{c}{a} = 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Divide every term by the leading coefficient
  • For any equation ax2+bx+c=0ax^2 + bx + c = 0, dividing by aa requires computing ax2a+bxa+ca=0\frac{ax^2}{a} + \frac{bx}{a} + \frac{c}{a} = 0.

  • Always verify that the constant term cc is also divided by aa before applying the quadratic formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide 0.0001875N2−0.45N+135=00.0001875N^2 - 0.45N + 135 = 0 by 0.00018750.0001875 across every term: N2−0.450.0001875N+1350.0001875=0  ⟹  N2−2400N+720000=0N^2 - \frac{0.45}{0.0001875}N + \frac{135}{0.0001875} = 0 \implies N^2 - 2400N + 720000 = 0.

  2. Evaluate the discriminant: Δ=(−2400)2−4(1)(720000)=5760000−2880000=2880000\Delta = (-2400)^2 - 4(1)(720000) = 5760000 - 2880000 = 2880000.

  3. Solve for the roots using N=2400±28800002=1200±848.53N = \frac{2400 \pm \sqrt{2880000}}{2} = 1200 \pm 848.53, yielding N1∗≈351N_1^* \approx 351 and N2∗≈2049N_2^* \approx 2049.

Final answer

N1∗=351 individualsN_1^* = 351\text{ individuals} (unstable threshold); N2∗=2049 individualsN_2^* = 2049\text{ individuals} (stable equilibrium)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that when clearing or normalizing coefficients, every single term on both sides of the equals sign receives the operation.

  • Practice solving coupled logistic harvesting problems by factoring out rr first to keep numbers manageable.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student incorrectly assumes that the lower equilibrium is stable because it represents a smaller population with lower intraspecific competition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    0.45N(1−N2400)−135=0  ⟹  0.0001875N2−0.45N+135=0  ⟹  N2−2400N+720000=0  ⟹  N=2400±28800002=1200±848.53  ⟹  N1∗=351 individuals,  N2∗=2049 individuals0.45N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2400}\right) - 135 = 0 \implies 0.0001875N^2 - 0.45N + 135 = 0 \implies N^2 - 2400N + 720000 = 0 \implies N = \frac{2400 \pm \sqrt{2880000}}{2} = 1200 \pm 848.53 \implies N_1^* = 351\text{ individuals},\; N_2^* = 2049\text{ individuals}

  2. Step 2

    Lower population experiences less competition and resource limitation.   ⟹  N1∗\implies N_1^* is locally stable.

    Correct

    ddN(dNdt)=r(1−2NK)\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right) = r\left(1 - \frac{2N}{K}\right). Since f′(351)>0f'(351) > 0 and f′(2,049)<0f'(2{,}049) < 0, N2∗=2,049 individualsN_2^* = 2{,}049\text{ individuals} is locally stable and N1∗=351 individualsN_1^* = 351\text{ individuals} is unstable.

    Although intraspecific competition is lower at small population sizes, the constant harvest rate HH exceeds the reproductive capacity of the population whenever N<N1∗N < N_1^*, causing extinction. A state is locally stable only when ddN(dNdt)<0\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right) < 0, which occurs at the upper equilibrium N2∗=2,049 individualsN_2^* = 2{,}049\text{ individuals}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the biological parameters into the logistic harvesting model.

You performed accurate algebraic manipulation to formulate and solve the quadratic equation.

You correctly identified the two numerical equilibrium values N1∗=351N_1^* = 351 and N2∗=2,049N_2^* = 2{,}049.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equilibrium Stability Misidentification

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You evaluated stability using an intuitive biological heuristic (low density means low competition) instead of checking dynamic stability through the derivative of the net growth function or evaluating the sign of dNdt\frac{dN}{dt} on either side of the equilibria.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Local Stability Criterion
  • For a continuous single-variable model dNdt=f(N)\frac{dN}{dt} = f(N), an equilibrium point N∗N^* is locally stable if and only if f′(N∗)<0f'(N^*) < 0.

  • Differentiate f(N)=rN−rKN2−Hf(N) = rN - \frac{r}{K}N^2 - H with respect to NN to get f′(N)=r(1−2NK)f'(N) = r\left(1 - \frac{2N}{K}\right), then evaluate the sign at each equilibrium.

Harvesting Threshold vs. Attractor
  • Under constant harvesting, the lower equilibrium acts as an extinction threshold (unstable tipping point), while the upper equilibrium acts as the stable carrying-capacity-like attractor.

  • Check the net growth rate when NN falls slightly below the equilibrium: if N<N1∗N < N_1^*, harvesting exceeds reproduction, driving the population to zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate the net growth function f(N)=dNdt=0.45N−0.452,400N2−135f(N) = \frac{dN}{dt} = 0.45N - \frac{0.45}{2{,}400}N^2 - 135 with respect to NN: f′(N)=0.45−0.902,400N=0.45(1−N1,200)f'(N) = 0.45 - \frac{0.90}{2{,}400}N = 0.45\left(1 - \frac{N}{1{,}200}\right).

  2. Evaluate f′(N)f'(N) at the lower equilibrium: f′(351)=0.45(1−3511,200)≈+0.318>0f'(351) = 0.45\left(1 - \frac{351}{1{,}200}\right) \approx +0.318 > 0. Because the derivative is positive, any perturbation above 351351 grows toward N2∗N_2^* and any perturbation below 351351 collapses toward zero, making N1∗N_1^* an unstable threshold.

  3. Evaluate f′(N)f'(N) at the upper equilibrium: f′(2,049)=0.45(1−2,0491,200)≈−0.318<0f'(2{,}049) = 0.45\left(1 - \frac{2{,}049}{1{,}200}\right) \approx -0.318 < 0. Because the derivative is negative, the population returns to N2∗N_2^* after small disturbances, making N2∗N_2^* locally stable.

Final answer

N1∗=351 individualsN_1^* = 351\text{ individuals} (unstable threshold); N2∗=2,049 individualsN_2^* = 2{,}049\text{ individuals} (locally stable equilibrium)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice computing the derivative f′(N∗)=ddN(dNdt)∣N∗f'(N^*) = \left.\frac{d}{dN}\left(\frac{dN}{dt}\right)\right|_{N^*} whenever an ecology problem asks for local stability.

  • Draw a sign chart or phase-line diagram showing the direction of population change arrows (positive or negative dNdt\frac{dN}{dt}) across the intervals separated by the equilibria.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student neglects the constant harvesting term H when solving for equilibrium, equating only logistic growth to zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dNdt=0  ⟹  rN(1−NK)=0  ⟹  N(1−N2400)=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0 \implies rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) = 0 \implies N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2400}\right) = 0

    Correct

    dNdt=0  ⟹  rN(1−NK)−H=0  ⟹  0.450N(1−N2,400)−135=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0 \implies rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H = 0 \implies 0.450N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2{,}400}\right) - 135 = 0

    You set only the logistic production component to zero, leaving out the constant predation harvesting term −H-H given in the model dNdt=rN(1−NK)−H\frac{dN}{dt} = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H.

  2. Step 2

    N1∗=0 individuals,N2∗=2400 individualsN_1^* = 0\text{ individuals},\quad N_2^* = 2400\text{ individuals}

    Correct

    N1∗≈351 individuals,N2∗≈2,049 individualsN_1^* \approx 351\text{ individuals},\quad N_2^* \approx 2{,}049\text{ individuals}

    Because the harvesting term was omitted in the previous step, your roots reflect unharvested carrying capacity and zero rather than the roots of the quadratic equation N2−2,400N+720,000=0N^2 - 2{,}400N + 720{,}000 = 0.

  3. Step 3

    f′(N)=r−2rNK  ⟹  f′(2400)=0.45−2(0.45)=−0.45<0  ⟹  N2∗ is locally stablef'(N) = r - \frac{2rN}{K} \implies f'(2400) = 0.45 - 2(0.45) = -0.45 < 0 \implies N_2^*\text{ is locally stable}

    Correct

    f′(N)=r−2rNK  ⟹  f′(2,049)=0.450(1−2(2,049)2,400)≈−0.318<0  ⟹  N2∗≈2,049 is locally stablef'(N) = r - \frac{2rN}{K} \implies f'(2{,}049) = 0.450\left(1 - \frac{2(2{,}049)}{2{,}400}\right) \approx -0.318 < 0 \implies N_2^* \approx 2{,}049\text{ is locally stable}

    Your derivative formula f′(N)f'(N) is correct because the derivative of the constant HH is zero, and your stability criterion is sound. However, you evaluated the stability at N=2,400N = 2{,}400 instead of the true upper equilibrium N2∗≈2,049N_2^* \approx 2{,}049.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the equilibrium condition as dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.

You correctly computed the derivative f′(N)=r−2rNKf'(N) = r - \frac{2rN}{K} to assess local stability.

You correctly used the sign of f′(N∗)f'(N^*) to classify whether an equilibrium point is locally stable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of external removal term in differential rate equation

You equated only the intrinsic logistic growth expression to zero and left out the harvesting constant HH.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defaulted to standard unharvested logistic equilibrium points (N=0N=0 and N=KN=K) rather than balancing the full net rate of change dNdt=births−natural deaths−harvesting=0\frac{dN}{dt} = \text{births} - \text{natural deaths} - \text{harvesting} = 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Include All Forcing and Removal Terms
  • Equilibrium requires the total net rate dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0, which must include all additive terms such as harvesting, immigration, or stocking.

  • Always write down the full differential equation given in the prompt before setting it equal to zero.

Standard Quadratic Rearrangement
  • When constant removal is coupled with logistic growth, clearing fractions yields a quadratic equation of the form N2−KN+HKr=0N^2 - KN + \frac{HK}{r} = 0.

  • Solve for the two equilibria using the quadratic formula rather than factoring out NN directly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the full rate equation equal to zero: 0.450N(1−N2,400)−135=00.450N\left(1 - \frac{N}{2{,}400}\right) - 135 = 0.

  2. Divide by 0.4500.450: N−N22,400−300=0N - \frac{N^2}{2{,}400} - 300 = 0.

  3. Multiply by −2,400-2{,}400 to obtain standard form: N2−2,400N+720,000=0N^2 - 2{,}400N + 720{,}000 = 0.

  4. Apply the quadratic formula: N=2,400±(−2,400)2−4(1)(720,000)2=1,200±720,000≈1,200±848.5N = \frac{2{,}400 \pm \sqrt{(-2{,}400)^2 - 4(1)(720{,}000)}}{2} = 1{,}200 \pm \sqrt{720{,}000} \approx 1{,}200 \pm 848.5.

  5. Calculate the roots: N1∗≈351 individualsN_1^* \approx 351\text{ individuals} and N2∗≈2,049 individualsN_2^* \approx 2{,}049\text{ individuals}.

  6. Evaluate f′(N)=0.450(1−2N2,400)f'(N) = 0.450\left(1 - \frac{2N}{2{,}400}\right): at N1∗=351N_1^* = 351, f′(351)>0f'(351) > 0 (unstable); at N2∗=2,049N_2^* = 2{,}049, f′(2,049)<0f'(2{,}049) < 0 (locally stable).

Final answer

N1∗=351 individualsN_1^* = 351\text{ individuals} (unstable threshold); N2∗=2,049 individualsN_2^* = 2{,}049\text{ individuals} (locally stable equilibrium)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving logistic equations that include constant stocking (+S+S) or constant harvesting (−H-H).

  • Sketch phase-line diagrams for dNdt\frac{dN}{dt} versus NN to visualize how harvesting lowers the parabola and creates an extinction threshold.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A fish population grows logistically with K=1,000K = 1{,}000 and r=0.2 year−1r = 0.2\text{ year}^{-1}, and is harvested at a constant rate H=30 individuals⋅year−1H = 30\text{ individuals}\cdot\text{year}^{-1}. Write the standard quadratic equation N2+bN+c=0N^2 + bN + c = 0 for the equilibria and find both equilibrium values.

Answer

N2−1,000N+150,000=0N^2 - 1{,}000N + 150{,}000 = 0; Roots: N1∗≈184 individualsN_1^* \approx 184\text{ individuals}, N2∗≈816 individualsN_2^* \approx 816\text{ individuals}. Key step: divide all terms of 0.0002N2−0.2N+30=00.0002N^2 - 0.2N + 30 = 0 by 0.00020.0002, giving constant term 300.0002=150,000\frac{30}{0.0002} = 150{,}000.

02

For the population dynamic model dNdt=0.5N(1−N800)−50\frac{dN}{dt} = 0.5N\left(1 - \frac{N}{800}\right) - 50, determine the two equilibrium points and evaluate f′(N)f'(N) at each to identify which is stable and which is unstable.

Answer

Equilibria: N1∗≈117N_1^* \approx 117 and N2∗≈683N_2^* \approx 683. Derivative: f′(N)=0.5−0.00125Nf'(N) = 0.5 - 0.00125N. At N1∗=117N_1^* = 117, f′(117)>0f'(117) > 0 (unstable). At N2∗=683N_2^* = 683, f′(683)<0f'(683) < 0 (locally stable).

03

An endangered herbivore follows dNdt=rN(1−NK)−H\frac{dN}{dt} = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right) - H. Prove analytically that two distinct real equilibrium points exist only if the harvesting rate satisfies H<rK4H < \frac{rK}{4} (the maximum sustainable yield).

Answer

Rewriting rKN2−rN+H=0\frac{r}{K}N^2 - rN + H = 0 gives discriminant Δ=r2−4(rK)H=r2−4rHK\Delta = r^2 - 4\left(\frac{r}{K}\right)H = r^2 - \frac{4rH}{K}. For two distinct real equilibria, Δ>0  ⟹  r2>4rHK  ⟹  H<rK4\Delta > 0 \implies r^2 > \frac{4rH}{K} \implies H < \frac{rK}{4}.

Loading workspace…