Resources
In a hypothetical diploid organism, a developmental gene locus possesses distinct multiple alleles () in a large breeding population. If all possible pairings of distinct alleles display codominance while homozygotes produce pure-breeding states, derive a generalized mathematical formula in terms of for the total number of distinct possible diploid genotypes and the total number of distinct possible phenotypes. Evaluate both quantities as scales to alleles, and verify whether the number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Number of genotypes is ; under full codominance with zero dominance hierarchy, the number of phenotypes is also . For , both the total number of distinct genotypes and distinct phenotypes equal .
Steps
Derive the Formula for the Total Number of Genotypes
A diploid organism inherits two alleles for any given autosomal locus. For a locus with distinct alleles (), the possible diploid combinations fall into two categories:
- Homozygous genotypes: An individual inherits two copies of the same allele (). Because there are alleles, there are exactly:
- Heterozygous genotypes: An individual inherits two distinct alleles ( where ). The order of inheritance does not matter (e.g., is genetically identical to ). The number of ways to choose distinct alleles from is given by the combination formula:
Summing the two types gives the total number of distinct diploid genotypes:
(Alternative combinatorial view: Choosing 2 alleles with replacement from a set of gives .)
Derive the Formula for the Total Number of Phenotypes
In genetics, the relationship between genotype count and phenotype count depends on allele interactions:
- Complete Dominance (contrast): A dominant allele masks a recessive allele, so heterozygotes share the phenotype of homozygous dominant individuals, resulting in fewer phenotypes than genotypes.
- Codominance: Both alleles in a heterozygote are fully, independently, and simultaneously expressed without blending or masking.
Because all distinct allele pairs exhibit codominance:
- Each of the homozygous genotypes () produces its own unique, pure-breeding phenotype ( phenotypes).
- Each of the heterozygous genotypes () expresses both traits simultaneously, forming a distinct, identifiable phenotype that is different from either parental phenotype and different from every other heterozygous combination.
Consequently, there is a strict one-to-one correspondence between each distinct genotype and its resulting phenotype:
Evaluate for Alleles
Substitute into the derived formulas:
- Total Genotypes:
- Total Phenotypes:
Verification
Under a system of full codominance with zero dominance hierarchy, no heterozygous genotype is masked or phenotypic class collapsed. Therefore, the total number of distinct phenotypes is identical to the total number of distinct genotypes, both equaling .
Typical errors
01 The student treats heterozygotes as ordered pairs, failing to divide by 2 when counting genotypes, leading to an overcount of genotypes and phenotypes as n² and 36.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
, , giving
In a diploid organism, alleles at an autosomal locus are unordered combinations because is genetically identical to . Writing counts ordered permutations, which double-counts every distinct heterozygous pairing.
- Step 2Correct
Your biological deduction that codominance produces exactly one distinct phenotype per genotype is completely correct, but the resulting algebraic formula inherits the overcounted genotype expression from the previous step.
- Step 3Correct
,
Because your underlying formula was instead of , evaluating at yielded rather than the correct count of .
- Step 4Correct
Your conclusion that the two counts are equal is sound under codominance, but the specific total of reflects the earlier counting error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the number of homozygous genotypes as .
You correctly deduced that full codominance preserves a strict one-to-one mapping between diploid genotypes and phenotypes.
You correctly verified that the total number of distinct phenotypes must equal the total number of distinct genotypes under full codominance.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used the permutation formula instead of the combination formula when tallying heterozygous genotypes.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating alleles as ordered slots (parent 1 vs. parent 2) when counting unique individual genotypes, which overlooks that diploid genotypes like and represent the exact same genetic state.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unordered Allele Combinations
For an autosomal diploid locus, genotype order does not matter: .
Always count heterozygous pairings using combinations rather than permutations.
- Total Genotypes Formula
Total genotypes with alleles equals homozygotes plus heterozygotes: .
Check your formula with a small test case like , where the genotypes are (total 3, not ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount distinct heterozygotes as unordered pairs of distinct alleles: .
Add the homozygotes: .
Apply the codominant 1:1 phenotype-to-genotype mapping: .
Evaluate both formulas for : genotypes and phenotypes.
Total genotypes = ; Total phenotypes = ; for , both equal .
02 The student assumes a complete dominance hierarchy instead of codominance, concluding there are only n phenotypes rather than n(n + 1)/2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The problem specifies that all distinct allele pairings display codominance, not complete dominance. Under codominance, both alleles in every heterozygote are fully and simultaneously expressed, creating a unique phenotype for every heterozygous genotype rather than masking one allele.
- Step 3Correct
Because you used instead of for the phenotype formula, your evaluated phenotype count () and your final verification () were affected by the earlier misconception.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly partitioned diploid genotypes into homozygous () and heterozygous () classes.
You correctly combined algebraic fractions to derive for total genotypes.
You accurately calculated for genotypes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied a linear complete-dominance hierarchy () where each heterozygote collapses into the phenotype of the dominant allele, overlooking the problem statement's condition that all pairs exhibit codominance. In codominance, no allele is masked, so every heterozygous genotype forms its own distinct phenotypic class.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Phenotype Mapping Under Codominance
Under full codominance, every distinct genotype (both homozygous and heterozygous) yields a distinct, identifiable phenotype.
Check whether heterozygotes express both alleles simultaneously (codominance) or mask one allele (complete dominance) before calculating phenotype totals.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that each of the homozygotes produces a unique pure-breeding phenotype.
Recognize that under codominance, each of the heterozygotes simultaneously expresses both traits, producing a unique phenotype distinct from all homozygotes and other heterozygotes.
Add both classes to get .
Evaluate for : .
Verify: The number of phenotypes () equals the number of genotypes ().
Total genotypes: ; Total phenotypes: . For , both equal . Yes, the number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes.
03 The student forgets to add the n homozygous combinations, counting only the combinations of choosing 2 distinct alleles for both genotypes and phenotypes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Choosing alleles from gives the total genotypes
CorrectYou counted only the heterozygous pairings where two different alleles are chosen. A diploid organism can also inherit two identical alleles (), giving homozygous genotypes that must be added to the total.
- Step 2
Each distinct combination produces a unique codominant phenotype
CorrectYour biological logic that every distinct genotype yields a unique phenotype under codominance is completely sound, but your formula inherits the missing homozygous genotypes from Step 1.
- Step 3Correct
Substituting into your formula correctly executed the arithmetic for , but using the complete formula gives .
- Step 4
The number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes, both being
CorrectThe number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes, both being
You correctly concluded that the number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes under full codominance, though the numerical count is rather than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that under full codominance, every distinct diploid genotype produces a unique, identifiable phenotype.
You accurately recognized that heterozygous pairings correspond to the combination .
You correctly verified that the count of phenotypes equals the count of genotypes under complete codominance.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated forming a diploid genotype as choosing distinct alleles without replacement, overlooking that an individual can inherit identical alleles (), which requires combinations with replacement or adding homozygotes to heterozygotes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Partitioning Diploid Genotypes
Diploid genotypes at an -allele locus always split into homozygotes () and heterozygotes ( with ).
Always write .
- Genotype-to-Phenotype Mapping Under Codominance
In pure codominance, no allele is masked or recessive; therefore, every single genotype maps to a distinct phenotype in a strict ratio.
Check that your phenotype count matches your total genotype count, including the homozygous phenotypes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationA diploid locus with alleles allows both homozygous () and heterozygous () pairings.
Count the distinct homozygotes and the distinct heterozygotes.
Sum them to obtain total genotypes: .
Because all allele pairs show codominance, each distinct genotype generates a distinct phenotype, giving phenotypes.
Substitute : genotypes and phenotypes.
Total genotypes formula is ; total phenotypes formula is . For , both equal , and the number of phenotypes equals the number of genotypes.
Lock it in
For an autosomal locus with alleles in a diploid organism, why is the number of heterozygotes instead of ?
Genotype pairs are unordered ( is identical to ), requiring combinations to avoid double-counting.
Similar question
A gene locus has alleles exhibiting complete codominance. Calculate the number of distinct homozygous genotypes, heterozygous genotypes, and total distinct phenotypes.
Answer
Homozygotes = . Heterozygotes = . Total genotypes = . Under full codominance, phenotypes equal genotypes, so there are distinct phenotypes.
In a diploid plant species, flower color is controlled by a single gene with multiple alleles that follow a strict linear dominance hierarchy (). How many distinct genotypes and distinct phenotypes exist?
Answer
Total genotypes = . Under a strict linear dominance hierarchy, each allele determines one unique phenotype when paired with itself or any allele lower in the hierarchy, yielding exactly distinct phenotypes.
A diploid population has alleles at a locus where alleles are mutually codominant with each other, but all are completely dominant over a single null allele . Derive the total number of distinct genotypes and phenotypes.
Answer
Total genotypes = . Phenotypes: homozygous null () gives phenotype; the functional alleles produce pure phenotypes (each identical whether homozygous or heterozygous ); pairings between two different functional alleles produce distinct codominant phenotypes. Total phenotypes = .