Resources

An experimental ecology team investigates the Lotka-Volterra competition model between two diatom species, Synedra ulna (Species 11) and Asterionella formosa (Species 22), competing for dissolved silicate in a controlled aquatic mesocosm. The system is governed by the coupled differential equations: dN1dt=r1N1(K1−N1−αN2K1)\frac{dN_1}{dt} = r_1 N_1 \left( \frac{K_1 - N_1 - \alpha N_2}{K_1} \right) dN2dt=r2N2(K2−N2−βN1K2)\frac{dN_2}{dt} = r_2 N_2 \left( \frac{K_2 - N_2 - \beta N_1}{K_2} \right) The carrying capacities are determined to be K1=180 cells/mLK_1 = 180\text{ cells/mL} and K2=120 cells/mLK_2 = 120\text{ cells/mL}. The per-capita competitive effect of Asterionella on Synedra is α=0.75\alpha = 0.75. Rather than solving for the equilibrium population sizes, calculate the critical threshold value of the competition coefficient β\beta (the per-capita effect of Synedra on Asterionella) below which Synedra will definitively competitively exclude Asterionella regardless of initial starting population densities.

Answer and steps

Final answer

β<K2K1=120180=0.667\beta < \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{120}{180} = 0.667. For Synedra (Species 11) to stably and unconditionally exclude Asterionella (Species 22) from all non-zero initial conditions, the phase-plane geometry requires K1α>K2\frac{K_1}{\alpha} > K_2 (which is satisfied: 1800.75=240>120\frac{180}{0.75} = 240 > 120) and K1>K2βK_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta}, which rearranges to β<K2K1≈0.667\beta < \frac{K_2}{K_1} \approx 0.667.

Steps

01

Identify the Zero-Growth Isoclines

In the Lotka-Volterra two-species competition model, a species' population stops growing (dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0) along its zero-growth isocline:

  • Species 11 (Synedra ulna) isocline: K1−N1−αN2=0  ⟹  N1+αN2=K1K_1 - N_1 - \alpha N_2 = 0 \implies N_1 + \alpha N_2 = K_1

    • Horizontal axis intercept (N1N_1-axis, where N2=0N_2 = 0): N1=K1=180N_1 = K_1 = 180
    • Vertical axis intercept (N2N_2-axis, where N1=0N_1 = 0): N2=K1α=1800.75=240N_2 = \frac{K_1}{\alpha} = \frac{180}{0.75} = 240
  • Species 22 (Asterionella formosa) isocline: K2−N2−βN1=0  ⟹  βN1+N2=K2K_2 - N_2 - \beta N_1 = 0 \implies \beta N_1 + N_2 = K_2

    • Horizontal axis intercept (N1N_1-axis, where N2=0N_2 = 0): N1=K2βN_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}
    • Vertical axis intercept (N2N_2-axis, where N1=0N_1 = 0): N2=K2=120N_2 = K_2 = 120

02

Condition for Unconditional Competitive Exclusion by Species 11

For Species 11 to win and drive Species 22 to extinction regardless of initial densities, the isocline of Species 11 must lie strictly outside (further from the origin than) the isocline of Species 22 across the entire positive quadrant:

  1. Along the N2N_2-axis: K1α>K2\frac{K_1}{\alpha} > K_2 Substituting the known parameters: 240>120240 > 120 This condition is already satisfied.
  2. Along the N1N_1-axis: K1>K2βK_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta}

03

Calculate the Critical Value of β\beta

Rearranging the second inequality to solve for β\beta: β<K2K1\beta < \frac{K_2}{K_1}

Substitute the carrying capacities K1=180 cells/mLK_1 = 180\text{ cells/mL} and K2=120 cells/mLK_2 = 120\text{ cells/mL}: β<120180=23≈0.667\beta < \frac{120}{180} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

When β<0.667\beta < 0.667, the per-capita competitive impact of Synedra on Asterionella is weak enough relative to the ratio of their carrying capacities that the isocline of Synedra completely encloses the isocline of Asterionella. As a result, population trajectories from any non-zero starting state inexorably move toward the stable equilibrium (N1,N2)=(K1,0)=(180,0)(N_1, N_2) = (K_1, 0) = (180, 0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the ratio of carrying capacities when setting up the boundary condition on the N1 axis, calculating K1 / K2 instead of K2 / K1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    K1α=1800.75=240>120=K2\frac{K_1}{\alpha} = \frac{180}{0.75} = 240 > 120 = K_2

  2. Step 2

    β=K1K2=180120=1.5\beta = \frac{K_1}{K_2} = \frac{180}{120} = 1.5

    Correct

    β=K2K1=120180=23≈0.667\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{120}{180} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

    You inverted the ratio of carrying capacities. On the N1N_1-axis, setting the intercepts equal gives K1=K2βK_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}, which solves to β=K2K1=120180≈0.667\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{120}{180} \approx 0.667 rather than K1K2\frac{K_1}{K_2}.

  3. Step 3

    Critical threshold β=1.5\text{Critical threshold } \beta = 1.5

    Correct

    Critical threshold β=23≈0.667\text{Critical threshold } \beta = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

    Your final threshold value was directly affected by inverting the carrying capacity ratio in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the zero-growth isocline of Species 11 must lie outside that of Species 22 along the N2N_2-axis.

You accurately substituted the given carrying capacities and the competition coefficient α\alpha.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted carrying capacity ratio

You set β=K1K2\beta = \frac{K_1}{K_2} instead of solving K1=K2βK_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta} for β\beta.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the intercept expressions on the phase-plane axes leads to inverting the ratio of carrying capacities when deriving the critical boundary condition.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Deriving the $N_1$-Axis Intercept
  • For Species 22, the isocline equation is βN1+N2=K2\beta N_1 + N_2 = K_2. Setting N2=0N_2 = 0 gives N1=K2βN_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}.

  • Always write down the full isocline equation and explicitly set N2=0N_2 = 0 rather than recalling the quotient from memory.

Solving for the Competition Coefficient
  • Comparing the N1N_1-intercepts requires K1K_1 and K2β\frac{K_2}{\beta} at the boundary, which gives β=K2K1\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1}.

  • Rearrange K1=K2βK_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta} algebraically by multiplying both sides by β\beta and dividing by K1K_1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the N1N_1-axis intercepts for both species: Species 11 has intercept N1=K1N_1 = K_1, while Species 22 has intercept N1=K2βN_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}.

  2. Equate the two intercepts to find the critical boundary value: K1=K2βK_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}.

  3. Solve for β\beta: β=K2K1=120180=23≈0.667\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{120}{180} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667.

Final answer

β=23≈0.667\beta = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the phase plane with both axes labeled (N1N_1 and N2N_2) to visually confirm each isocline's intercepts.

  • Practice isolating parameters from the denominator of an intercept fraction rather than jumping directly to a ratio of carrying capacities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the roles of α and β by equating β to α rather than solving the isocline boundary condition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    K1=180K_1 = 180, K2=120K_2 = 120, α=0.75\alpha = 0.75

  2. Step 2

    Symmetric competition threshold requires β=α\text{Symmetric competition threshold requires } \beta = \alpha

    Correct

    K1>K2β  ⟹  β<K2K1K_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta} \implies \beta < \frac{K_2}{K_1}

    Competitive exclusion depends on the relative positions of the two zero-growth isoclines rather than parameter symmetry. For Species 11 to always exclude Species 22, its isocline must lie completely outside that of Species 22, requiring K1>K2βK_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta} along the N1N_1-axis.

  3. Step 3

    Critical threshold β=0.75\text{Critical threshold } \beta = 0.75

    Correct

    β<120180=23≈0.667\beta < \frac{120}{180} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

    Because of the incorrect assumption in the previous step, your final numerical value for β\beta was evaluated as α=0.75\alpha = 0.75 instead of K2K1≈0.667\frac{K_2}{K_1} \approx 0.667.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and recorded the carrying capacities K1=180K_1 = 180 and K2=120K_2 = 120.

You correctly noted the competition coefficient α=0.75\alpha = 0.75.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isocline Boundary Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the boundary between coexistence and competitive exclusion occurs when interspecific competition coefficients are equal (β=α\beta = \alpha), overlooking that carrying capacities scale the intercepts of the zero-growth isoclines along each axis.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isocline Dominance Condition
  • Species 11 wins unconditionally when its zero-growth isocline is strictly outside Species 22's isocline: K1α>K2\frac{K_1}{\alpha} > K_2 and K1>K2βK_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta}.

  • Always compare axis intercepts (K1K_1 vs. K2β\frac{K_2}{\beta} and K1α\frac{K_1}{\alpha} vs. K2K_2) rather than equating α\alpha and β\beta.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the condition where Species 11's isocline lies strictly further from the origin along the N1N_1-axis: K1>K2βK_1 > \frac{K_2}{\beta}.

  2. Rearrange the inequality for β\beta: β<K2K1\beta < \frac{K_2}{K_1}.

  3. Substitute the given carrying capacities: β<120180=23≈0.667\beta < \frac{120}{180} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667.

Final answer

β<23≈0.667\beta < \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.667

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the phase plane with N1N_1 on the horizontal axis and N2N_2 on the vertical axis, labeling all four intercepts.

  • Practice solving Lotka-Volterra boundary conditions when carrying capacities are unequal to reinforce how K1K_1 and K2K_2 scale the competitive impact.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two competing protozoan species follow Lotka-Volterra dynamics with carrying capacities K1=300 cells/mLK_1 = 300\text{ cells/mL} and K2=150 cells/mLK_2 = 150\text{ cells/mL}, and competitive effect α=0.5\alpha = 0.5. Determine the critical value of β\beta at which the N1N_1-intercepts of their zero-growth isoclines coincide.

Answer

β=0.5\beta = 0.5. Setting the N1N_1-intercepts equal gives K1=K2βK_1 = \frac{K_2}{\beta}, so β=K2K1=150300=0.5\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{150}{300} = 0.5.

02

In a competition experiment between two grass species, Species 11 has K1=400 g/m2K_1 = 400\text{ g/m}^2 and Species 22 has K2=500 g/m2K_2 = 500\text{ g/m}^2. The competition coefficient α=0.6\alpha = 0.6. Can Species 11 competitively exclude Species 22 unconditionally for any value of β\beta?

Answer

No. Unconditional exclusion by Species 11 requires K1α>K2\frac{K_1}{\alpha} > K_2 on the N2N_2-axis. Here, 4000.6≈666.7>500\frac{400}{0.6} \approx 666.7 > 500 is satisfied, but on the N1N_1-axis, exclusion requires matching or exceeding the intercept condition K1=400K_1 = 400 versus K2β\frac{K_2}{\beta}. While a critical β=K2K1=500400=1.25\beta = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{500}{400} = 1.25 exists, unconditional exclusion depends on both axes satisfying the geometry simultaneously.

03

Consider two competing beetle species where K1=250K_1 = 250 and K2=100K_2 = 100. Suppose α=0.8\alpha = 0.8 and β=0.35\beta = 0.35. Determine which species wins the competition or if they stably coexist.

Answer

Species 11 wins definitively. Evaluating the axis intercepts: on the N2N_2-axis, K1α=2500.8=312.5>K2=100\frac{K_1}{\alpha} = \frac{250}{0.8} = 312.5 > K_2 = 100. On the N1N_1-axis, the critical threshold is βcrit=K2K1=100250=0.4\beta_{\text{crit}} = \frac{K_2}{K_1} = \frac{100}{250} = 0.4. Because the isocline of Species 11 entirely encloses that of Species 22, Species 11 drives Species 22 to extinction.

Loading workspace…