Resources

A horticulturalist collects N=400N = 400 seeds from a self-incompatible perennial shrub (Salix sp.). In this species, sexual reproduction produces seeds, while asexual reproduction occurs via broken twig fragmentation. Genetic screening of the resulting seedlings reveals that 340340 individuals show distinct recombinant multi-locus microsatellite genotypes, while the remaining 6060 seeds resulted from apomixis (asexual diploid seed formation bypassing meiosis and syngamy). Assuming a stable environmental regime where the field germination rate of sexual seeds is gsex=0.85g_{\text{sex}} = 0.85 and of apomictic seeds is gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95, calculate the initial total number of apomictic ovules that must have been fertilized or induced if 5757 viable asexually derived seedlings emerge.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Initial number of apomictic seeds/ovules =570.95=60 seeds= \frac{57}{0.95} = 60\text{ seeds}.

Steps

Understanding the Relationship Between Seeds and Seedlings

When seeds undergo germination, the number of successfully emerged seedlings (SS) depends directly on the initial number of seeds planted or produced (NN) and their specific germination rate (gg):

S=N⋅gS = N \cdot g

In this scenario, seeds arise through two distinct pathways:

  • Sexual reproduction: Yields recombinant seedlings with a germination rate of gsex=0.85g_{\text{sex}} = 0.85.
  • Apomixis (asexual seed formation): Bypasses meiosis and syngamy to produce clonal seeds with a higher germination rate of gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95.

Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Identify the Given Values for Apomictic Reproduction:

    • Number of emerged apomictic seedlings: Sapom=57S_{\text{apom}} = 57
    • Germination efficiency of apomictic seeds: gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95
  2. Set up the Equation to Find the Initial Seed/Ovule Count (NapomN_{\text{apom}}): Sapom=Napom⋅gapomS_{\text{apom}} = N_{\text{apom}} \cdot g_{\text{apom}}
  3. Rearrange to Solve for NapomN_{\text{apom}}: Napom=SapomgapomN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}}
  4. Compute the Value: Napom=570.95=60 seedsN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60\text{ seeds}

Verification and Common Pitfalls

  • Consistency Check: The problem states that 6060 of the 400400 screened seeds originated via apomixis. The calculation confirms that exactly 6060 apomictic seeds with a 95%95\% germination rate yield 60⋅0.95=5760 \cdot 0.95 = 57 viable seedlings.
  • Pitfall to Avoid: Do not use the sexual germination rate (gsex=0.85g_{\text{sex}} = 0.85) or total seed count (N=400N = 400) for this calculation. Because the two reproductive modes exhibit different developmental efficiencies, each pathway's germination rate must be applied exclusively to its corresponding subpopulation.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student multiplies the number of emerging seedlings by the germination rate instead of dividing by it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Napom=57×0.95  ⟹  Napom=54.15≈54 ovulesN_{\text{apom}} = 57 \times 0.95 \implies N_{\text{apom}} = 54.15 \approx 54\text{ ovules}

    Correct

    Napom=570.95=60 ovulesN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60\text{ ovules}

    You multiplied the number of emerged seedlings by the germination rate instead of dividing by it. Because germination represents the fraction of seeds that successfully sprout (S=N⋅gS = N \cdot g), finding the initial number of seeds/ovules requires dividing the seedling count by the germination efficiency: N=SgN = \frac{S}{g}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated the apomictic subpopulation data from the distractor values given for sexual reproduction.

You carried out the decimal arithmetic accurately based on your chosen operation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportion / rate inversion error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing forward calculation (starting seeds ×\times germination rate == seedlings) with inverse calculation (seedlings ÷\div germination rate == starting seeds). Because germination rates are between 00 and 11, multiplying resulted in fewer initial ovules (5454) than emerged seedlings (5757), which is biologically impossible.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Biological Yield
  • Seedlings=Initial Seeds×Germination Rate  ⟹  Initial Seeds=SeedlingsGermination Rate\text{Seedlings} = \text{Initial Seeds} \times \text{Germination Rate} \implies \text{Initial Seeds} = \frac{\text{Seedlings}}{\text{Germination Rate}}

  • Whenever working backward from emerged plants to initial ovules or seeds, divide by the germination efficiency so that the initial pool is larger than or equal to the final emerged count.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the fundamental rate relationship: Sapom=Napom⋅gapomS_{\text{apom}} = N_{\text{apom}} \cdot g_{\text{apom}}.

  2. Rearrange to solve for the initial ovule count: Napom=SapomgapomN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}}.

  3. Substitute the given values: Napom=570.95=60 ovulesN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60\text{ ovules}.

Final answer

60 ovules60\text{ ovules}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check your answer with a biological reality check: can 5454 initial seeds yield 5757 living seedlings?

  • Practice setting up rate equations algebraically (S=N⋅gS = N \cdot g) before substituting numerical values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the sexual seed germination rate (0.85) instead of the apomictic germination rate (0.95) to find the initial number of ovules.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    N_{apom\text{apom}} = 57 / 0.85_

    Correct

    N_{apom\text{apom}} = Sapomgapom\frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}} = 570.95\frac{57}{0.95}_

    You correctly recognized that the initial ovule number equals emerged seedlings divided by the germination rate. However, you used the sexual germination rate gsex=0.85g_{\text{sex}} = 0.85 instead of the apomictic germination rate gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95.

  2. Step 2

    N_{apom\text{apom}} ≈\approx 67.06 ≈\approx 67 ovules\text{ ovules}_

    Correct

    N_{apom\text{apom}} = 60 ovules\text{ ovules}_

    Your arithmetic on the numbers you selected was carried out accurately, but this final value is off because it carries over the incorrect germination rate from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the initial seed count is obtained by dividing the number of emerged seedlings by the germination rate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subpopulation Rate Mismatch

You selected the sexual seed germination rate (0.850.85) rather than the apomictic rate (0.950.95) given in the problem.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating two distinct developmental pathways in a mixed population leads to applying the wrong subgroup parameter when calculating lineage-specific counts.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Parameters to Subgroups
  • When a population consists of distinct cohorts (such as sexual vs. apomictic seeds), each subpopulation must be paired strictly with its own rate parameters.

  • Circle or label each reproductive pathway alongside its specific values (gsex=0.85g_{\text{sex}} = 0.85, gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95) before setting up the equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the apomictic parameters: Sapom=57S_{\text{apom}} = 57 and gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95.

  2. Set up the subpopulation equation: Napom=SapomgapomN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}}.

  3. Evaluate: Napom=570.95=60N_{\text{apom}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60.

Final answer

60 ovules

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always label given rates with clear subscripts representing each specific subpopulation before calculating.

  • Double-check your result against any total subgroup counts given in the problem text to verify consistency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the 57 seedlings as representing the 95% germination of the total pool of 400 seeds rather than the apomictic seeds alone.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total seeds=400  ⟹  Apomictic fraction=60400=0.15\text{Total seeds} = 400 \implies \text{Apomictic fraction} = \frac{60}{400} = 0.15

  2. Step 2

    Napom=400×0.95=380 ovulesN_{\text{apom}} = 400 \times 0.95 = 380\text{ ovules}

    Correct

    Napom=Sapomgapom=570.95=60 ovulesN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60\text{ ovules}

    You applied the apomictic germination rate to the entire collection of 400400 seeds and multiplied instead of dividing. To find the initial number of apomictic ovules/seeds that produced 5757 emerged seedlings, divide the number of emerged seedlings by the apomictic germination rate: 570.95=60\frac{57}{0.95} = 60.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly extracted the total seed count from the problem statement.

You accurately calculated the fraction of seeds produced via apomixis as 60400=0.15\frac{60}{400} = 0.15.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Subpopulation with Total Pool and Inverting Rate Relationship

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the total seed cohort (400400) with the specific subpopulation of apomictic seeds, and you multiplied a total pool by a germination percentage instead of working backward from emerged seedlings (S=N⋅g  ⟹  N=S/gS = N \cdot g \implies N = S / g).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolate Reproductive Subpopulations
  • In mixed reproductive cohorts, never apply a subpopulation-specific rate (gapomg_{\text{apom}} or gsexg_{\text{sex}}) to the pooled total (NtotalN_{\text{total}}).

  • Identify which specific subpopulation the rate applies to before calculating.

Distinguish Seed Inputs from Seedling Outputs
  • Seedlings (SS) represent successful germination from initial seeds (NN): S=N⋅gS = N \cdot g, so the initial seed count is N=SgN = \frac{S}{g}.

  • Divide the final seedling count by the germination efficiency to determine the required initial seed count.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the relationship between initial apomictic ovules (NapomN_{\text{apom}}), germination rate (gapomg_{\text{apom}}), and emerged seedlings (SapomS_{\text{apom}}): Sapom=Napom⋅gapomS_{\text{apom}} = N_{\text{apom}} \cdot g_{\text{apom}}.

  2. Rearrange the formula to solve for the initial ovule count: Napom=SapomgapomN_{\text{apom}} = \frac{S_{\text{apom}}}{g_{\text{apom}}}.

  3. Substitute Sapom=57S_{\text{apom}} = 57 and gapom=0.95g_{\text{apom}} = 0.95: Napom=570.95=60N_{\text{apom}} = \frac{57}{0.95} = 60.

Final answer

60 ovules60\text{ ovules}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to rearrange S=N⋅gS = N \cdot g to solve for the initial seed input NN when given the emerged output SS.

  • Practice partitioning mixed reproductive cohorts so you only apply specific rates to their matching subpopulations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A field biologist collects seeds from an apomictic grass species with a known germination rate of g=0.75g = 0.75. If a restoration plot requires 150150 viable seedlings to establish, how many apomictic seeds must be sown?

Answer

N=Sg=1500.75=200 seedsN = \frac{S}{g} = \frac{150}{0.75} = 200\text{ seeds}.

02

In an experimental nursery, a dioecious shrub produces both sexual and apomictic seeds. The sexual seeds have a field germination rate of gsex=0.60g_{\text{sex}} = 0.60, while apomictic seeds have gapom=0.80g_{\text{apom}} = 0.80. If the nursery needs 9090 sexually derived seedlings and 120120 apomictically derived seedlings, what is the total number of seeds that must be planted across both types?

Answer

Ntotal=Nsex+Napom=900.60+1200.80=150+150=300 seedsN_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{sex}} + N_{\text{apom}} = \frac{90}{0.60} + \frac{120}{0.80} = 150 + 150 = 300\text{ seeds}.

03

A population of 500500 harvested seeds contains a mixture of sexual seeds (80%80\%) and apomictic seeds (20%20\%). In a greenhouse trial, 272272 sexual seedlings emerge. Determine the germination rate of the sexual seeds (gsexg_{\text{sex}}), and calculate how many apomictic seedlings will emerge if their germination rate is 1.251.25 times higher than gsexg_{\text{sex}}.

Answer
  1. Sexual seed count: Nsex=500×0.80=400 seedsN_{\text{sex}} = 500 \times 0.80 = 400\text{ seeds}.
  2. Sexual germination rate: gsex=SsexNsex=272400=0.68g_{\text{sex}} = \frac{S_{\text{sex}}}{N_{\text{sex}}} = \frac{272}{400} = 0.68.
  3. Apomictic seed count: Napom=500×0.20=100 seedsN_{\text{apom}} = 500 \times 0.20 = 100\text{ seeds}.
  4. Apomictic germination rate: gapom=0.68×1.25=0.85g_{\text{apom}} = 0.68 \times 1.25 = 0.85.
  5. Apomictic seedlings emerged: Sapom=Napom⋅gapom=100×0.85=85 seedlingsS_{\text{apom}} = N_{\text{apom}} \cdot g_{\text{apom}} = 100 \times 0.85 = 85\text{ seedlings}.
Loading workspace…