Resources

A student measures the heritability of maze-learning speed in a genetically heterogeneous population of deer mice (Peromyscus maniculatus) in an enriched laboratory habitat and determines H2=0.250H^2 = 0.250. The student hypothesizes: 'If we move all mice to a completely barren, perfectly identical, automated testing environment where all cages, diets, temperatures, and handling protocols are strictly uniform, the environmental variance (VEV_E) will decrease toward zero, and therefore heritability (H2H^2) must drop toward zero because the environment is less supportive.' Evaluate this hypothesis: (a) State whether the student's predicted direction of change for H2H^2 is correct or incorrect. (b) If uniform housing reduces VEV_E from 18.0 units218.0\text{ units}^2 to 2.00 units22.00\text{ units}^2 while genetic variance remains constant at VG=6.00 units2V_G = 6.00\text{ units}^2 (Cov(G,E)=0Cov(G,E)=0), calculate the new value of H2H^2. Round to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Incorrect; reducing VEV_E increases H2H^2; (b) New H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

Steps

Part (a): Evaluating the Direction of Change in Heritability

Broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) measures the proportion of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) in a population that is attributable to genetic variance (VGV_G):

H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}

where:

  • VGV_G is the genetic variance,
  • VEV_E is the environmental variance,
  • VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E when genotype-environment covariance (Cov(G,E)\text{Cov}(G,E)) is zero.

Because VEV_E appears in the denominator, decreasing VEV_E while keeping VGV_G constant decreases the total phenotypic variance (VPV_P). As the denominator shrinks, the fraction VGVP\frac{V_G}{V_P} becomes larger, meaning H2H^2 increases toward 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%).

  • Common Pitfall: Heritability does not measure how "favorable" or "supportive" an environment is for a trait, nor does it measure the absolute degree of genetic control over an individual's behavior. Instead, it measures the fraction of variation among individuals caused by genetic differences. When everyone experiences identical environmental conditions, any remaining behavioral differences among individuals must be primarily due to their genes.

Therefore, the student's prediction that heritability will drop is incorrect; reducing VEV_E actually increases H2H^2.


Part (b): Calculating the New Heritability (H2H^2)

  1. Identify the given values:

    • New environmental variance: VE=2.00 units2V_E = 2.00\text{ units}^2
    • Genetic variance: VG=6.00 units2V_G = 6.00\text{ units}^2
  2. Calculate the new total phenotypic variance (VPV_P): VP=VG+VE=6.00 units2+2.00 units2=8.00 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 6.00\text{ units}^2 + 2.00\text{ units}^2 = 8.00\text{ units}^2
  3. Compute the new heritability (H2H^2): H2=VGVP=6.008.00=0.750H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00} = 0.750

The new broad-sense heritability of maze-learning speed under uniform conditions is 0.7500.750 (or 75.0%75.0\%).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets heritability as an intrinsic measure of environmental quality or thinks heritability is proportional to environmental variance, leading them to agree that H² decreases and to mistakenly compute H² as V_E / (V_G + V_E).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    As environmental variation decreases, heritability decreases because the barren environment reduces phenotypic expression.

    Correct

    Incorrect; as VEV_E decreases while VGV_G remains constant, heritability (H2=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}) increases.

    Heritability measures the proportion of phenotypic variation caused by genetic differences, not environmental quality. When the environment is made uniform (VE→0V_E \to 0), almost all remaining phenotypic differences between individuals are due to genetic differences, so heritability increases.

  2. Step 2

    VP=6.00+2.00=8.00V_P = 6.00 + 2.00 = 8.00

  3. Step 3

    H2=2.00/8.00=0.250H^2 = 2.00 / 8.00 = 0.250

    Correct

    H2=VGVP=6.008.00=0.750H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00} = 0.750

    You placed environmental variance (VE=2.00V_E = 2.00) in the numerator instead of genetic variance (VG=6.00V_G = 6.00). Broad-sense heritability is defined as H2=VGVPH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total phenotypic variance as VP=VG+VE=8.00 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 8.00\text{ units}^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Variance Ratio in Heritability Formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined heritability as the fraction of variance explained by environmental variance (VEVP\frac{V_E}{V_P}) rather than genetic variance (VGVP\frac{V_G}{V_P}), which also led to the misconception that heritability tracks environmental quality rather than genetic proportion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heritability Definition
  • Broad-sense heritability is H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}, where genetic variance is always in the numerator.

  • Check that your numerator represents genetic variance (VGV_G) and not environmental variance (VEV_E).

Effect of Environmental Uniformity
  • As VEV_E decreases, the denominator VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E decreases, which causes the fraction VGVP\frac{V_G}{V_P} to increase toward 1.01.0.

  • Remember that equalizing the environment leaves genetic differences as the primary source of variation, raising heritability.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. H2=VGVP=6.008.00H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00}

  2. H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

Final answer

(a) Incorrect; reducing VEV_E increases H2H^2; (b) New H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the conceptual definition of broad-sense heritability as the proportion of phenotypic variance due to genetic factors: H2=VG/VPH^2 = V_G / V_P.

  • Practice predicting how changing either VGV_G or VEV_E influences heritability using fractions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses broad-sense heritability with the ratio of genetic variance to environmental variance (V_G / V_E) instead of phenotypic variance (V_G / V_P).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Heritability increases when environmental variance decreases because genetic differences account for a larger fraction of the variation.

  2. Step 2

    H2=VGVEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_E}

    Correct

    H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}

    Broad-sense heritability is defined as the proportion of total phenotypic variance attributable to genetic variance, not the ratio of genetic variance to environmental variance.

  3. Step 3

    H2=6.002.00=3.00H^2 = \frac{6.00}{2.00} = 3.00

    Correct

    H2=6.006.00+2.00=6.008.00=0.750H^2 = \frac{6.00}{6.00 + 2.00} = \frac{6.00}{8.00} = 0.750

    Because you used VEV_E instead of VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E in the denominator, you calculated 3.003.00 instead of 0.7500.750. Heritability represents a proportion and must fall between 00 and 11.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly reasoned that reducing environmental differences causes genetic differences to explain a larger share of phenotypic variation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variance Ratio Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing heritability as an odds ratio of genetic to environmental variance (VG/VEV_G / V_E) rather than a proportion of total phenotypic variance (VG/VPV_G / V_P).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Heritability as a Proportion
  • Broad-sense heritability (H2H^2) is the fraction of total phenotypic variance (VPV_P) explained by genetic variance (VGV_G): H2=VGVP=VGVG+VEH^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E}.

  • Always verify that the denominator is total variance (VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E) and that your final value satisfies 0≤H2≤10 \le H^2 \le 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total phenotypic variance: VP=VG+VE=6.00+2.00=8.00 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 6.00 + 2.00 = 8.00\text{ units}^2.

  2. Substitute into the heritability formula: H2=VGVP=6.008.00H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00}.

  3. Simplify to three significant figures: H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750.

Final answer

(a) Incorrect; reducing VEV_E increases H2H^2; (b) New H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the variance partition equation VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  • Practice calculating heritability from component variances, always ensuring the result lies between 00 and 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits genetic variance from the denominator when computing phenotypic variance, dividing V_G by only the initial or change in variance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Incorrect \n Heritability increases as environmental variation is minimized.

  2. Step 2

    VP=18.0−2.00=16.00V_P = 18.0 - 2.00 = 16.00

    Correct

    VP=VG+VE=6.00+2.00=8.00 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 6.00 + 2.00 = 8.00\text{ units}^2

    You calculated the change in environmental variance (18.0−2.00=16.0018.0 - 2.00 = 16.00) rather than the new total phenotypic variance. Total phenotypic variance is the sum of genetic and environmental variance, VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  3. Step 3

    H2=6.00/16.00=0.375H^2 = 6.00 / 16.00 = 0.375

    Correct

    H2=VGVP=6.008.00=0.750H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00} = 0.750

    Your division step followed your calculated VPV_P, but substituting the correct phenotypic variance of 8.008.00 yields H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly concluded that the student's prediction was incorrect because lowering environmental variance raises heritability.

You knew to divide genetic variance VGV_G by total phenotypic variance VPV_P to find H2H^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Phenotypic Variance Miscalculation

You subtracted the new VEV_E from the old VEV_E instead of adding VGV_G and the new VEV_E to find the new VPV_P.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the magnitude of environmental variance reduction (ΔVE\Delta V_E) with the new state's total phenotypic variance (VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Formula for Phenotypic Variance
  • When genotype-environment covariance is zero, total phenotypic variance is the sum of genetic and environmental variances: VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  • Always compute VPV_P using the current values of VGV_G and VEV_E, rather than taking the difference between past and present values of VEV_E.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the new conditions: VG=6.00 units2V_G = 6.00\text{ units}^2 and VE=2.00 units2V_E = 2.00\text{ units}^2.

  2. Calculate the new total phenotypic variance: VP=VG+VE=6.00+2.00=8.00 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 6.00 + 2.00 = 8.00\text{ units}^2.

  3. Calculate broad-sense heritability: H2=VGVP=6.008.00=0.750H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{6.00}{8.00} = 0.750.

Final answer

(a) Incorrect; reducing VEV_E increases H2H^2; (b) New H2=0.750H^2 = 0.750

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the additive relationship between variance components: VP=VG+VEV_P = V_G + V_E.

  • Practice separating 'change in a variance parameter' (ΔV\Delta V) from the 'state value of the variance parameter' (VV).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A population of fruit flies has VG=4.0 units2V_G = 4.0\text{ units}^2 and VE=12.0 units2V_E = 12.0\text{ units}^2 for flight duration (Cov(G,E)=0Cov(G,E)=0). Calculate the broad-sense heritability H2H^2.

Answer

VP=VG+VE=4.0+12.0=16.0 units2V_P = V_G + V_E = 4.0 + 12.0 = 16.0\text{ units}^2. Therefore, H2=VGVP=4.016.0=0.250H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_P} = \frac{4.0}{16.0} = 0.250 (or 25.0%25.0\%).

02

In a plant breeding experiment, initial variances for seed mass are VG=10.0 units2V_G = 10.0\text{ units}^2 and VE=30.0 units2V_E = 30.0\text{ units}^2. By moving plants into controlled growth chambers, environmental variance is reduced by half to VE=15.0 units2V_E = 15.0\text{ units}^2 while VGV_G remains unchanged. Calculate the new heritability and state whether it increased or decreased.

Answer

New VP=10.0+15.0=25.0 units2V_P = 10.0 + 15.0 = 25.0\text{ units}^2. New H2=10.025.0=0.400H^2 = \frac{10.0}{25.0} = 0.400. Since the initial H2=10.040.0=0.250H^2 = \frac{10.0}{40.0} = 0.250, heritability increased.

03

A researcher clones a single genetically identical strain of bacteria (VG=0V_G = 0) and measures metabolic rate across diverse nutrient broth conditions (VE=8.5 units2V_E = 8.5\text{ units}^2). What is the heritability H2H^2 of metabolic rate in this population? Explain what happens to H2H^2 if the broth conditions are made completely uniform.

Answer

H2=VGVG+VE=00+8.5=0H^2 = \frac{V_G}{V_G + V_E} = \frac{0}{0 + 8.5} = 0. If broth conditions are made uniform (VE→0V_E \to 0), phenotypic variance becomes 00, and heritability remains 00 (undefined or zero) because there are no genetic differences (VG=0V_G = 0) among individuals.

Loading workspace…