Resources
A diploid mammalian somatic cell has a total chromosome number of and contains an initial nuclear DNA content of during the early phase. Trace the chromosome count, chromatid count, and total nuclear DNA mass (in ) through the following consecutive stages: (a) phase, (b) metaphase of mitosis, and (c) telophase immediately prior to cytokinesis (within a single binucleated cell before cleavage furrow completion).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) phase: chromosomes, sister chromatids, DNA; (b) Metaphase: chromosomes, sister chromatids, DNA; (c) Telophase (single cell before cytokinesis): individual chromosomes ( per forming nucleus), chromatids, total DNA ( per nucleus).
Steps
Phase
Foundational Rules for Cell Cycle Tracking
- Counting Chromosomes vs. Chromatids:
- Chromosome count: Count the number of functional centromeres. A chromosome can be unreplicated (one double-stranded DNA molecule) or replicated (two identical sister chromatids joined by a single centromere).
- Chromatid count: A chromatid exists only when sister chromatids are physically held together at a shared centromere. Once sister chromatids separate at anaphase, each is immediately classified as an independent daughter chromosome (chromatid count drops to zero).
- DNA Content (-value):
- Early phase represents the baseline diploid value ().
- During the S phase (synthesis), DNA replicates completely, doubling the mass to . The DNA mass remains until cytokinesis physically partitions the cytoplasm into two daughter cells.
Step-by-Step Stage Breakdown
- Event: Occurs after complete DNA replication in S phase and before entry into mitosis.
- Chromosome count: The centromeres have not divided, so the number of chromosomes remains .
- Chromatid count: Each replicated chromosome consists of sister chromatids:
- Total DNA mass: Duplicated in S phase:
Metaphase of Mitosis
- Event: Replicated chromosomes condense and align along the metaphase plate. Centromeres remain intact.
- Chromosome count: Still defined by intact centromeres, so there are .
- Chromatid count: Chromatid pairs are still attached, totaling .
- Total DNA mass: Remains unchanged at .
Telophase Prior to Cytokinesis (Single Cell)
- Event: In anaphase, sister chromatids separated at their centromeres into individual daughter chromosomes and moved to opposite poles. In telophase, nuclear envelopes re-form around each set of chromosomes, but the cleavage furrow has not yet completed cytoplasmic division.
- Chromosome count: Because each former chromatid is now an independent chromosome with its own centromere, the total chromosome count within this single binucleated cell doubles:
- Chromatid count: Because sister chromatids are no longer joined, the chromatid count is .
- Total DNA mass: Since the single cell still contains all the DNA, total DNA content is ( per nucleus).
Common Pitfall: A common error is assuming that the chromosome count doubles in S phase or that chromosome division reduces total DNA before cytokinesis. Remember: DNA mass doubles during S phase, whereas chromosome number temporarily doubles inside the cell only during anaphase and telophase due to centromere cleavage, returning to per cell only after cytokinesis completes.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses chromosome number with chromatid number during interphase, believing that DNA replication in S phase doubles the chromosome count to 92.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Replication doubles chromosomes: Chromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
CorrectChromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
You correctly determined that DNA replication doubles the DNA mass to and produces sister chromatids. However, chromosome count is determined by the number of functional centromeres. Because sister chromatids remain joined at shared centromeres during , the cell still contains chromosomes.
- Step 2
Chromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
CorrectChromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
You correctly kept the chromatid count and DNA content unchanged from , but the chromosome count remains incorrect because it carried over the misconception from part (a).
- Step 3
Sister chromatids separate into daughter nuclei: Chromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
CorrectChromosomes = , Chromatids = , DNA content =
You correctly recognized that chromatid count drops to once sister chromatids separate and that total DNA mass remains before cytokinesis. However, separating sister chromatids yields exactly individual daughter chromosomes ( at each pole), not .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated that DNA content doubles to following S phase and remains in the single cell until cytokinesis.
You correctly understood that sister chromatids separate completely by telophase, leaving chromatids.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated chromosome count with DNA copy/chromatid count, assuming that DNA replication in S phase doubles the chromosome count from to , which subsequently led you to double to upon anaphase separation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Centromere Rule for Chromosomes
One functional centromere equals one chromosome, regardless of whether it consists of one unduplicated chromatid or two duplicated sister chromatids.
Always count centromeres to find chromosome number; do not increase chromosome count when DNA replicates in S phase.
- Chromatid to Chromosome Transition
When sister chromatids disjoin at anaphase, each chromatid becomes an independent chromosome with its own centromere.
The number of newly formed chromosomes equals the number of separated chromatids ( chromatids become individual chromosomes).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn phase, count centromeres: replicated chromosomes, each having sister chromatids ( chromatids total), with DNA mass .
In metaphase, chromosomes remain aligned as pairs of sister chromatids: chromosomes, chromatids, and DNA.
In telophase prior to cytokinesis, the separated sister chromatids are now individual chromosomes ( per forming nucleus), with chromatids and total DNA.
(a) chromosomes, chromatids, DNA; (b) chromosomes, chromatids, DNA; (c) chromosomes, chromatids, DNA.
02 The student treats telophase as already divided into two daughter cells, reporting the values per daughter nucleus (46 chromosomes and 6.4 pg DNA) rather than the totals within the single binucleated cell.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
= 46 = 0 = 6.4
Correct, ,
You correctly recognized that chromatids separate into individual chromosomes (leaving sister chromatids). However, the prompt asked for the totals within the single cell before cytokinesis is completed. Because the cell has not yet physically divided into two separate daughter cells, all individual chromosomes ( per pole) and all of DNA are still inside that single cell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately tracked the doubling of DNA mass from to after replication.
You correctly calculated that each replicated chromosome consists of sister chromatids during and metaphase.
You correctly recognized that sister chromatids separate at anaphase, so no chromatid pairs remain in telophase.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeReporting values per nucleus rather than per cell prior to cytokinesis.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated karyokinesis (division of the nucleus) with cytokinesis (division of the cytoplasm/cell). Until cytokinesis physically pinches the cell into two distinct daughter cells, the entire cell remains a single membrane-bound compartment containing double the normal chromosome count () and double the baseline DNA content ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the physical boundary being measured
During anaphase and telophase before cytokinesis completes, a single cell is binucleated and holds both sets of separated genetic material.
Always check whether the prompt asks for values 'per cell' or 'per nucleus/daughter cell'.
- Count functional centromeres
When sister chromatids split at anaphase, each becomes an independent chromosome with its own centromere.
Multiply the original diploid chromosome number by when counting total chromosomes inside a cell during anaphase and telophase ( chromosomes).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the physical stage: Anaphase separated sister chromatids into distinct daughter chromosomes.
In telophase prior to cytokinesis, the cell has two forming nuclei inside one common cytoplasm: .
Because chromatids are no longer joined at a shared centromere, there are .
Since no cellular division has partitioned the cytoplasm yet, the total nuclear DNA mass in the cell remains ( per nucleus).
(c) Telophase (single cell): chromosomes, chromatids, DNA
03 The student assumes that separated sister chromatids in telophase are still called chromatids until cytokinesis completes, incorrectly concluding there are 46 chromosomes and 92 chromatids.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Chromosomes = 46, Chromatids = 92, DNA content =
- Step 2
Chromosomes = 46, Chromatids = 92, DNA content =
- Step 3
Sister Chromatids have not yet decondensed into new cells ⟹ Chromosomes = 46, Chromatids = 92, DNA content =
CorrectChromosomes = ( per forming nucleus), Chromatids = , DNA mass = ( per forming nucleus)
At anaphase, sister chromatids separate at their centromeres. From that instant onward, each separated strand is counted as an independent daughter chromosome with its own centromere. Therefore, within the single cell before cytokinesis completes, there are individual chromosomes and chromatids.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly doubled the nuclear DNA mass during S phase to obtain .
You maintained the accurate count of chromosomes and chromatids through and metaphase.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated physical cytoplasmic division (cytokinesis) with the separation of sister chromatids (centromere division). Chromosome count is defined by the number of independent centromeres; once anaphase separates sister chromatids, the term 'chromatid' drops to zero and the chromosome number within that single cell temporarily doubles to .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Centromere Rule for Counting Chromosomes
1 centromere = 1 chromosome. Whether it has one DNA duplex (unreplicated) or two (replicated), count centromeres.
Always determine chromosome number by counting independent centromeres rather than total DNA strands.
- Definition of a Chromatid
A chromatid only exists while physically joined to its sister at a shared centromere.
Set the chromatid count to as soon as anaphase centromere cleavage occurs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that centromeres divide at the onset of anaphase, separating the sister chromatids into independent daughter chromosomes.
Because cytokinesis has not yet partitioned the cytoplasm, all chromosomes remain inside this single cell ( at each pole).
Because none of the chromosomes remain joined as sister pairs, the chromatid count becomes .
The total DNA mass in the undivided cell remains ( partitioned to each reforming nucleus).
(a) : chromosomes, chromatids, DNA; (b) Metaphase: chromosomes, chromatids, DNA; (c) Telophase: chromosomes, chromatids, DNA.
Lock it in
How do you determine the total chromosome number in a eukaryotic cell?
Count the number of centromeres. Whether composed of one chromatid or two sister chromatids, one centromere equals one chromosome.
Similar question
A diploid organism has chromosomes and an early DNA content of . What are the chromosome count, chromatid count, and total DNA mass in a somatic cell during prophase of mitosis?
Answer
chromosomes, chromatids, and DNA. Key steps: DNA replicates during S phase, doubling DNA content to and producing sister chromatids per chromosome (). Centromeres have not divided, so chromosome number remains .
For the same organism (, DNA mass ), state the chromosome number, chromatid count, and total DNA content in a single cell during anaphase.
Answer
chromosomes, chromatids, and DNA. Key steps: Centromeres split simultaneously in anaphase, converting each of the sister chromatids into an independent daughter chromosome (). Chromatid count becomes . Cytokinesis has not occurred, so total DNA remains .
A researcher analyzes a binucleated cell prior to cytokinesis and measures total chromosomes and of nuclear DNA. Deduce the baseline diploid chromosome number () and early DNA content () for this species.
Answer
chromosomes and early DNA content . Key steps: Before cytokinesis in telophase, the single cell contains two nuclei, each housing one complete diploid set ( chromosomes per nucleus, so ). Total replicated DNA () will partition evenly into two daughter cells, giving in early .