Resources
A student argues that when a fixed mass of of glucose monomers () undergoes dehydration synthesis to form a single macromolecular glycogen polymer in an isolated closed system, the total mass of the resulting dry polymer should equal because of the law of conservation of mass. Explain the biochemical flaw in this reasoning, and calculate the exact dry mass of the resulting polymer if glucose monomers ( each) condense to form one linear polymer chain.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Flaw: Dehydration synthesis eliminates one molecule of () per glycosidic bond formed, so the mass of the dry polymer is strictly less than the total mass of free monomers by ; Dry mass (a loss of as eliminated water)
Steps
Identifying the Biochemical Flaw
The student's reasoning misapplies the law of conservation of mass:
- The Conservation Law Applies to the Entire System: In an isolated closed system, the total mass remains constant:
- Dehydration Synthesis Releases Water: Monomers do not simply stick together; they join through covalent glycosidic bonds via dehydration synthesis (condensation reactions). In each bond formation, a hydroxyl group () from one monomer and a hydrogen atom () from another combine to release one molecule of water ():
- "Dry" Polymer Excludes Water: Because water molecules are eliminated during the assembly of a chain of monomers, the dry polymer alone must have a mass strictly less than the starting mass of the monomers by .
Calculating the Exact Dry Mass
Step A: Determine the stoichiometry of the reaction
When glucose monomers condense into a single linear chain:
- Number of monomers:
- Number of glycosidic bonds formed:
- Molecules of released:
Step B: Calculate the mass ratio of dry polymer to starting monomers
Using the molar masses and :
- Mass of unbonded glucose monomers:
- Mass of water eliminated:
- Molar mass of the resulting polymer chain:
- Mass fraction of polymer retained:
Step C: Calculate the dry mass from the initial sample
The remaining of the initial mass exists as free water () produced during the condensation reaction.
Common Pitfall to Avoid
Do not assume bonds are formed from monomers. A linear chain of monomers contains only linkages, leaving two free terminal groups. Only a circular polymer would eliminate molecules of water.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes that n monomers release n water molecules instead of n - 1 when forming a linear chain, overcounting the water loss by one molecule.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Dehydration synthesis releases one molecule as a byproduct for each bond formed, so water leaves the dry polymer and reduces its mass below .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
In an unbranched, linear polymer of monomers, there are only covalent linkages formed. Thus, molecules of are released, not .
- Step 4Correct
Your subtraction followed logically from your water count, but it carried forward the error and stopped before scaling to the initial sample.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly explained why the law of conservation of mass does not mean the dry polymer retains all starting mass.
You correctly recognized that each glycosidic bond formation eliminates one water molecule.
You set up the total reactant molar mass accurately using the given molecular weight.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the number of water molecules lost directly to instead of the number of bonds, .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the topology of an open linear chain (the 'fencepost problem'), where connecting units in a line requires only joints, leaving two unbonded terminal ends.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Fencepost Rule for Linear Polymers
For any unbranched linear chain of monomers, the number of condensation bonds formed (and water molecules eliminated) is always .
Always subtract from the monomer count when determining the number of bonds in an open chain.
- Completing Sample Mass Scaling
Finding the polymer's molar mass is an intermediate step; multiply the mass fraction by the actual starting mass to find the final sample mass.
Multiply by the given initial mass () to obtain the final answer in grams.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the number of glycosidic bonds in a linear 500-mer: .
Calculate the total mass of eliminated water: .
Find the molar mass of the dry polymer: .
Calculate the fraction of mass retained and scale by the sample: .
02 The student completely ignores the elimination of water during polymerization and calculates the mass simply as 500 intact glucose units.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Mass is conserved, but glucose rings become rearranged into a polymer structure without changing overall composition.
CorrectDehydration synthesis links monomers by forming glycosidic bonds, releasing one molecule of () per linkage. Total mass is conserved in the closed system, but the dry polymer excludes the released water.
You treated polymerization as a structural rearrangement that preserves chemical composition. In dehydration synthesis, an group from one glucose and an from another are eliminated as , so the dry polymer loses mass relative to the starting monomers.
- Step 2
Each monomer has a molar mass of
CorrectYou calculated the molar mass of 500 unbonded glucose units without subtracting the mass of the 499 eliminated molecules, and you did not scale the result to the initial sample.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the molar mass of an individual glucose monomer as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that polymerization is an addition reaction where monomers join without losing atoms, rather than a dehydration (condensation) reaction that eliminates water molecules.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for Water Elimination
Joining linear monomers requires dehydration linkages, releasing molecules of .
Always subtract from the total reactant monomer molar mass to find the polymer molar mass.
- Calculate Mass Fraction
The mass of dry polymer isolated from a starting mass equals .
Multiply the starting sample mass by the dry polymer mass fraction to obtain the final polymer mass.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the number of glycosidic bonds formed in a linear chain of monomers: bonds, releasing .
Calculate the molar mass of the polymer chain: .
Compute the mass fraction of polymer retained: .
Multiply by the starting sample mass: .
(with lost as eliminated water)
03 The student subtracts the mass of 2 H atoms instead of an entire H2O molecule per bond formed, mistakenly omitting the eliminated oxygen atom.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
In dehydration synthesis, hydrogen and oxygen are lost as water byproduct, so the dry polymer loses mass relative to the original monomers.
- Step 2
Total monomer mass =
- Step 3
Mass lost per bond =
Correct= M_{_2} = 2(1.01) + 16.00 = 18.02
You used , which is only the mass of two hydrogen atoms (). Dehydration synthesis eliminates a full water molecule (), which includes one oxygen atom (), giving .
- Step 4
Mass lost =
CorrectM_{} = 499 18.02 = 8991.98 M_{} = 90080 - 8991.98 = 81088.02
Your arithmetic was carried out accurately, but the resulting polymer molar mass was thrown off by the incorrect mass of eliminated water from Step 3.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly explained the biochemical flaw regarding water loss in dehydration synthesis.
You correctly used to determine the number of glycosidic bonds formed in a linear polymer.
You accurately calculated the total reactant molar mass for 500 glucose monomers.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote instead of , forgetting to add the oxygen atom () when calculating the mass of eliminated water.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the release of water () with the loss of diatomic hydrogen () during bond condensation calculations, omitting the oxygen atom of the departing hydroxyl group.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Composition of the Condensation Byproduct
Every dehydration synthesis linkage joins from one monomer and from the next, releasing one whole molecule ().
Always verify that your subtracted mass per bond includes both hydrogen atoms and the oxygen atom: .
- Complete the Scaling to Given Sample Mass
When a problem gives an initial sample mass (e.g., ), multiply that mass by the mass fraction of polymer retained: .
Check the problem prompt to ensure you convert molar masses back to the requested gram quantity of the starting sample.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the mass lost per bond to the molar mass of water: .
Calculate total mass of water lost: .
Find the dry polymer molar mass: .
Calculate the mass fraction of polymer retained: .
Multiply by the initial sample: .
Biochemical flaw: Dehydration synthesis removes one molecule of () per glycosidic bond formed, so the dry polymer loses relative to the initial monomers; Exact dry mass .
Lock it in
How many water molecules are eliminated during the dehydration synthesis of a linear polymer consisting of monomers?
water molecules. Each glycosidic bond between two adjacent monomers eliminates one water molecule, leaving the two terminal ends intact.
Similar question
A linear pentasaccharide is assembled from 5 glucose molecules (molar mass each). What is the exact molar mass of the resulting pentasaccharide?
Answer
. Forming a linear 5-mer creates glycosidic bonds, eliminating 4 water molecules ( each): .
An unbranched polypeptide chain with a molar mass of is synthesized from 100 amino acid residues having an average free monomer mass of . Calculate the total mass of water released during the synthesis of one mole of this polypeptide.
Answer
. A linear chain of 100 amino acids forms peptide bonds, releasing 99 moles of per mole of polymer: .
A sample containing of pure glycine () completely condenses into linear polyglycine chains with an average degree of polymerization of . Determine the total dry mass of polyglycine recovered.
Answer
(or ). For , initial monomer mass is . Water lost is . Dry polymer molar mass is . Mass fraction . Dry mass .