Resources
A diploid eukaryotic cell () carries a heterozygous genotype at a specific autosomal locus. (a) State the exact number of copies of allele and allele present in the cell at mitotic metaphase following semi-conservative replication in phase. (b) During anaphase, identical sister chromatids segregate toward opposite poles. If nondisjunction of the single chromosome pair carrying this locus occurs such that both sister chromatids move to pole 1 and zero move to pole 2, determine the total chromosome number and the specific allele copies ( and/or ) received by daughter cell 1 and daughter cell 2 at cytokinesis.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) copies of allele and copies of allele ; (b) Daughter cell 1: chromosomes with either copies of and copy of (or copy of and copies of , depending on which chromatid pair missegregated); Daughter cell 2: chromosomes with copy of (or copy of ).
Steps
Part (a): Allele Copies at Mitotic Metaphase
-
Baseline diploid state in phase:
- A diploid cell () has homologous chromosome pairs.
- Being heterozygous () at an autosomal locus means one homologous chromosome carries allele , and the other homologous chromosome carries allele .
- Thus, in , there is copy of and copy of .
-
Effect of semi-conservative DNA replication in phase:
- During phase, each individual chromosome is replicated to form two genetically identical sister chromatids joined at the centromere.
- The chromosome carrying allele replicates into two sister chromatids, each carrying allele ( copies of ).
- The homologous chromosome carrying allele replicates into two sister chromatids, each carrying allele ( copies of ).
-
Conclusion for metaphase:
- Chromatids remain joined until anaphase begins.
- Therefore, at metaphase, the cell contains copies of allele and copies of allele .
Part (b): Consequences of Mitotic Nondisjunction
-
Normal segregation vs. nondisjunction:
- Under normal conditions, every replicated chromosome splits its two sister chromatids so that chromatid moves to pole 1 and moves to pole 2. Each daughter cell receives individual chromosomes (one and one ).
- In this event, nondisjunction occurs in one replicated chromosome (one pair of sister chromatids fails to separate), while all other replicated chromosomes segregate normally:
- The normally segregating chromosomes contribute chromatids to pole 1 and chromatids to pole 2.
-
Tracking chromosome numbers:
- Pole 1 / Daughter cell 1: Receives normally segregated chromosomes plus both () unseparated sister chromatids:
- Pole 2 / Daughter cell 2: Receives normally segregated chromosomes plus zero () chromatids of the missegregated chromosome:
-
Tracking allele distribution:
- The nondisjunction could involve either the chromosome carrying or the chromosome carrying :
- Case 1 (chromosome carrying undergoes nondisjunction):
- Both chromatids with allele migrate to pole 1; zero go to pole 2.
- The homologous chromosome carrying segregates normally ( copy to pole 1, copy to pole 2).
- Daughter cell 1: copies of and copy of .
- Daughter cell 2: copies of and copy of (only copy of ).
- Case 2 (chromosome carrying undergoes nondisjunction):
- Both chromatids with allele migrate to pole 1; zero go to pole 2.
- The homologous chromosome carrying segregates normally ( copy to pole 1, copy to pole 2).
- Daughter cell 1: copy of and copies of .
- Daughter cell 2: copy of and copies of (only copy of ).
- Case 1 (chromosome carrying undergoes nondisjunction):
- The nondisjunction could involve either the chromosome carrying or the chromosome carrying :
Typical errors
01 The student confuses mitotic nondisjunction of sister chromatids with meiotic nondisjunction of homologous chromosomes, assuming all four chromatids of the homologous pair segregate together to one pole.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
G1 cell has copy of and copy of . After phase replication: copies of and copies of .
- Step 2
Daughter cell receives both homologs: chromosomes. Daughter cell receives: chromosomes.
CorrectDaughter cell : chromosomes (); Daughter cell : chromosomes ()
In mitosis, homologous chromosomes do not pair up or segregate as bivalents. Nondisjunction occurs in one individual replicated chromosome when its two sister chromatids fail to separate. The other chromosomes segregate normally, so daughter cell receives chromosomes and daughter cell receives chromosomes.
- Step 3
Daughter cell receives two copies of and two copies of (). Daughter cell receives zero copies of and zero copies of .
CorrectDaughter cell : copies of and copy of (or copy of and copies of ); Daughter cell : copy of and copies of (or copy of and copies of )
Because only one replicated chromosome underwent nondisjunction, the homologous partner segregated its sister chromatids normally. Thus, both daughter cells still receive one copy of the normally segregating homolog's allele.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly tracked DNA replication through phase to determine metaphase allele copy numbers.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that homologous chromosomes pair up and both missegregate together during mitosis, yielding and chromosomes instead of and .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused mitotic nondisjunction of sister chromatids with meiotic nondisjunction of homologous chromosomes. In mitosis, homologous chromosomes align independently and do not pair or segregate together; a nondisjunction event affects sister chromatids of an individual replicated chromosome.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Mitotic chromosome alignment
In mitosis, homologous chromosomes align independently at the metaphase plate rather than pairing into tetrads/bivalents.
Always treat each replicated chromosome and its sister chromatids as an independent segregation unit during mitosis.
- Aneuploidy calculation from single mitotic nondisjunction
When one pair of sister chromatids fails to separate in mitosis, the resulting daughter cells are and .
Add extra chromatid to one daughter cell and subtract from the other relative to the normal diploid number .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn a diploid cell with , chromosomes segregate their sister chromatids normally ( chromatid to each pole).
One replicated chromosome undergoes nondisjunction: both of its sister chromatids move to pole 1, and move to pole 2.
Pole 1 receives chromosomes; Pole 2 receives chromosomes.
If the missegregated chromosome carries allele , daughter cell 1 receives copies of plus normally segregated copy of , while daughter cell 2 receives copies of and copy of (and vice versa if the chromosome carrying missegregates).
(a) copies of allele and copies of allele ; (b) Daughter cell 1: chromosomes with either copies of and copy of (or copy of and copies of ); Daughter cell 2: chromosomes with copy of (or copy of ).
02 The student fails to account for the other 11 normally segregating chromosomes and counts the total chromosome number as only the chromosomes involved in the nondisjunction event.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Allele copies: , Allele copies:
- Step 2
Daughter cell 1 receives chromosomes with allele copies and . ⟹ Daughter cell receives chromosome with allele copy .
CorrectDaughter cell 1: chromosomes () with copies of and copy of (or copy of and copies of ). ⟹ Daughter cell 2: chromosomes () with copy of (or copy of ).
You isolated the single missegregating chromosome pair and forgot to include the remaining normally segregating chromosomes. Since the diploid cell has , normal segregation of the other replicated chromosomes sends chromatids to each pole, giving totals of chromosomes for daughter cell 1 and chromosomes for daughter cell 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the duplicated allele copies present after phase replication.
You correctly identified that daughter cell 1 receives both replicated chromatids of one allele plus one chromatid of the homologous allele, while daughter cell 2 receives only the other homolog's chromatid.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou counted only the specific chromosomes involved in the nondisjunction event ( and ) rather than adding them to the baseline set of normally separating chromosomes ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the localized nondisjunction of a single chromosome with the total chromosome complement of the entire cell, forgetting that all other pairs of sister chromatids still disjoin normally into both daughter cells.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Baseline Diploid Segregation Check
In a cell with chromosomes, nondisjunction of replicated chromosome leaves all other pairs (or replicated chromosomes) separating normally: each pole receives individual chromatids from the normal set.
Always write down the baseline contribution from normally segregating chromosomes first: to each pole.
- Aneuploidy Sum Check
A single mitotic nondisjunction produces daughter cells with and total chromosomes.
Check that your daughter cell chromosome totals equal chromatids total ( total separated chromatids).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationA diploid cell with has replicated chromosomes at metaphase ( sister chromatids total).
During anaphase, of the chromosomes segregate normally, sending chromatids to pole 1 and chromatids to pole 2.
The single chromosome carrying allele fails to separate its sister chromatids, sending both () chromatids to pole 1 and none () to pole 2. The chromosome carrying allele separates normally ( chromatid to pole 1, to pole 2).
Sum the total chromosomes for each daughter cell: Daughter cell 1 receives chromosomes (alleles ); Daughter cell 2 receives chromosomes (allele ).
Daughter cell 1 receives chromosomes with copies of allele and copy of allele (or vice versa if allele missegregated); Daughter cell 2 receives chromosomes with copy of allele (or copy of allele ).
Lock it in
Do homologous chromosomes pair up (synapse) during mitotic metaphase?
No. In mitosis, each replicated chromosome aligns individually and independently at the metaphase plate; pairing into bivalents occurs only in meiosis I.
Similar question
A diploid cell () with genotype at an autosomal locus undergoes normal mitosis. How many chromosomes and how many copies of alleles and does each daughter cell receive at the completion of cytokinesis?
Answer
Each daughter cell receives chromosomes, with copy of allele and copy of allele . Key step: In normal mitosis, sister chromatids of every replicated chromosome separate equally to opposite poles.
A cell with is heterozygous . During mitotic anaphase, sister chromatid nondisjunction occurs exclusively for the chromosome carrying allele , such that both chromatids migrate to daughter cell 1. State the total chromosome number and the exact genotype/copy count of and in daughter cell 1 and daughter cell 2.
Answer
Daughter cell 1 has chromosomes () with copy of and copies of . Daughter cell 2 has chromosomes () with copy of and copies of . Key step: The -bearing chromosome segregates normally ( copy to each cell), while the -bearing chromosome sends both chromatids to cell 1 and none to cell 2.
Explain the difference in genetic outcome between nondisjunction of chromosome pair 21 in meiosis I versus nondisjunction of chromosome 21 in a post-zygotic mitotic division of a human embryo ().
Answer
Meiotic I nondisjunction affects gametes: homologous chromosomes fail to separate, producing gametes with both parental homologs () or neither (), affecting all cells of the resulting zygote. Mitotic nondisjunction affects only the clonal descendants of that single embryonic cell, creating genetic mosaicism where some somatic cells are trisomic ( chromosomes) and some are monosomic ( chromosomes), while normal cells remain diploid ().