Resources
In Drosophila melanogaster, larval foraging path length is influenced by the foraging (for) locus, where the rover allele () is dominant over the sitter allele (). In a baseline well-fed environment, homozygous rovers () travel an average path length of with standard deviation , while homozygous sitters () travel an average of with . When larvae are subjected to severe nutrient deprivation during early development, the mean path length of rovers increases to , whereas the mean path length of sitters remains nearly unchanged at . (a) State whether the differential phenotypic response across environments represents phenotypic plasticity, a genotype-by-environment () interaction, or both. (b) Calculate the absolute change in phenotypic divergence () between the two genotypes induced by nutrient deprivation. Express your numerical value to two decimal places.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Both phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction; (b)
Steps
Part (a): Identifying the Behavioral Phenotype Concepts
-
Phenotypic Plasticity:
- Definition: Phenotypic plasticity refers to the capacity of a single genotype to produce different phenotypes under varying environmental conditions.
- Application: When exposed to nutrient deprivation, homozygous rovers () change their mean foraging path length from to (and sitters change slightly from to ). Because an organism's phenotype shifts in response to an environmental change, phenotypic plasticity is demonstrated.
-
Genotype-by-Environment () Interaction:
- Definition: A interaction occurs when distinct genotypes respond differently to changes in the environment, represented graphically by non-parallel reaction norms (slopes that differ).
- Application:
- Rovers exhibit a substantial increase in path length:
- Sitters exhibit minimal change: Because the environmental effect is conditional on the genotype, this demonstrates a interaction.
Therefore, the response represents both phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction.
Part (b): Calculating the Change in Phenotypic Divergence
-
Determine the phenotypic shift for each genotype:
- For rovers:
- For sitters:
- Calculate the absolute difference between these shifts:
(Alternative check: The initial divergence in the well-fed condition is , and the divergence under nutrient deprivation is . The change in phenotypic divergence is .)
Typical errors
01 The student conflates phenotypic plasticity with a G × E interaction, assuming that because different genotypes respond differently across environments, it only qualifies as G × E interaction rather than both.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Genotype-by-environment () interaction. This is because rovers change by while sitters change by only , so the effect of environment depends on genotype.
CorrectBoth phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction.
You correctly reasoned that genotypes responding differently across environments indicates a interaction. However, because a single genotype (such as rovers) changes its phenotypic expression from to across environments, phenotypic plasticity is also demonstrated.
- Step 2
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that unequal environmental shifts between genotypes demonstrate a genotype-by-environment () interaction.
You accurately calculated the change in mean path length for both rovers and sitters.
You correctly computed the absolute difference in divergence as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated phenotypic plasticity and genotype-by-environment () interaction as mutually exclusive categories. Phenotypic plasticity is the general capacity of an individual genotype to alter its phenotype across environments. When two genotypes exhibit different degrees or patterns of plasticity (non-parallel reaction norms), a interaction exists on top of phenotypic plasticity.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check for Within-Genotype Plasticity
If at least one genotype shifts its mean phenotype in response to an environmental change, phenotypic plasticity is present.
Examine the reaction norm of each genotype individually: if slope , plasticity exists.
- Check for Between-Genotype G x E Interaction
A interaction occurs when the reaction norms of different genotypes are non-parallel (their slopes or responses differ).
Compare the response slopes: if , a interaction is present alongside plasticity.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationObserve that homozygous rovers alter their foraging path length from to when nutrients are restricted.
Recognize that an organism altering its phenotype in response to environmental conditions meets the definition of phenotypic plasticity.
Combine both observations: the presence of non-parallel plastic responses means the system demonstrates both phenotypic plasticity and a interaction.
(a) Both phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction; (b)
02 The student calculates phenotypic divergence in each environment and adds them together instead of calculating the magnitude of change in divergence.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Both. Rovers change their phenotype in response to nutrient deprivation showing plasticity, and the two genotypes respond with different magnitudes showing a interaction.
- Step 2
- Step 3
| {} + {}| = |2.70 + 0.20| = 2.90
Correct| {} - {}| = |2.70 - 0.20| = 2.50
You added the two shifts instead of taking their difference. The change in divergence measures how much further apart the two reaction norms become, which requires subtracting one shift from the other.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the scenario displays both phenotypic plasticity and a interaction.
You clearly explained the biological rationale for both concepts.
You accurately calculated the individual phenotypic changes () for each genotype.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote a plus sign instead of a minus sign when calculating the change in divergence, summing the environmental responses instead of subtracting them.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating total combined phenotypic change across genotypes with the change in divergence (the difference between the two genotypes' responses).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Change in Divergence
Divergence refers to the gap or difference between genotypes: .
Always subtract the two genotype shifts when evaluating changes in divergence or reaction norm slopes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubtract from : .
Evaluate the absolute difference: .
(a) Both phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction; (b)
03 The student confuses the change in divergence between genotypes across environments with the phenotypic difference between genotypes in the nutrient-deprived environment alone.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Both. Individual genotypes alter path length showing phenotypic plasticity, and the disparity in reaction norms between rovers and sitters demonstrates .
- Step 2
Phenotypic divergence under nutrient deprivation:
CorrectYou calculated the absolute divergence between the two genotypes in the nutrient-deprived condition alone () rather than the change in divergence relative to the baseline well-fed condition ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly distinguished between individual phenotypic plasticity and the differential reaction norms that define a interaction.
You correctly identified and subtracted the two genotype means in the nutrient-deprived environment.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted 'change in phenotypic divergence' as the absolute difference between genotypes in the altered environment, overlooking the baseline divergence in the well-fed environment.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Change Across Environments
The change in phenotypic divergence between two genotypes across environments equals the difference between their environmental shifts: .
Always compute the response to the environmental change for each genotype separately before taking the difference between genotypes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the change in path length for rovers: .
Calculate the change in path length for sitters: .
Find the absolute difference between these changes: .
(a) Both phenotypic plasticity and a genotype-by-environment () interaction; (b)
Lock it in
What is phenotypic plasticity, and can it co-occur with a genotype-by-environment () interaction?
Yes. Phenotypic plasticity is the ability of a single genotype to produce different phenotypes in different environments. A interaction simply means that different genotypes exhibit different plastic responses (non-parallel reaction norms).
Similar question
In Arabidopsis thaliana, genotype A flowers at days in long-day conditions and days in short-day conditions. Genotype B flowers at days in long-day conditions and days in short-day conditions. Does this phenotypic change represent phenotypic plasticity, a interaction, or both?
Answer
Phenotypic plasticity only. For both genotypes, the flowering time shifts by ( and ). Because both genotypes change phenotype across environments, plasticity is present. However, because their response magnitudes are identical (slopes are parallel), there is no interaction.
Two strains of maize are grown under normal water and severe drought conditions. Under normal water, Strain 1 yields and Strain 2 yields . Under drought, Strain 1 yields and Strain 2 yields . (a) Identify whether this demonstrates phenotypic plasticity, a interaction, or both. (b) Calculate the absolute difference in yield reduction between the two strains.
Answer
(a) Both phenotypic plasticity and a interaction. (b) . Key steps: , . Both genotypes change yield across environments (plasticity), and their reductions differ (, crossing reaction norms), demonstrating a interaction. Absolute difference: .
A behavioral biologist measures aggression scores in two clones of fish across low-density and high-density tanks. Clone 1 has a score of in low density and in high density. Clone 2 has a score of in low density and in high density. Does Clone 1 exhibit phenotypic plasticity? Does the experiment as a whole demonstrate a interaction?
Answer
Clone 1 does not exhibit phenotypic plasticity (score remains constant at , slope is zero). However, the experiment as a whole demonstrates both phenotypic plasticity (since Clone 2 is plastic, changing from to ) and a interaction (the two reaction norms have different slopes, vs. ).