Resources

A population of alpine ungulates (N=800N = 800) inhabits a mountain valley. Over one winter, the population experiences two concurrent mortality factors: an abiotic blizzard (a density-independent disturbance) that directly kills 30%30\% of the individuals across the valley, and a subsequent shortage of lichen forage (a density-dependent factor). The per capita winter starvation rate among survivors of the blizzard is given by s(Npost)=Npost2,000s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{N_{\text{post}}}{2{,}000}, where NpostN_{\text{post}} is the population size immediately following the blizzard. (a) Calculate the number of individuals surviving the blizzard (NpostN_{\text{post}}) and the number of individuals that subsequently starve. (b) Calculate the effective overall percentage mortality caused by the density-dependent factor relative to the original population of 800800.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Individuals surviving the blizzard: Npost=800×(1−0.30)=560 ungulatesN_{\text{post}} = 800 \times (1 - 0.30) = 560\text{ ungulates}. The per capita starvation rate is s(560)=5602,000=0.280s(560) = \frac{560}{2{,}000} = 0.280 (28.0%28.0\%). Number of starving individuals: 560×0.280=156.8≈157 ungulates560 \times 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}. (b) Effective density-dependent mortality relative to original population: 156.8800×100%=19.6%\frac{156.8}{800} \times 100\% = 19.6\% (final survivors =560−156.8=403.2≈403 ungulates= 560 - 156.8 = 403.2 \approx 403\text{ ungulates}).

Steps

Part (a): Survivors of the Blizzard and Mortality from Starvation

  1. Calculate the post-blizzard population (NpostN_{\text{post}}): A blizzard is a density-independent factor because it removes a fixed fraction of the population regardless of its density. With a direct mortality rate of 30%30\%, the fraction of individuals surviving is: 1−0.30=0.701 - 0.30 = 0.70 Applying this to the initial population of N=800N = 800: Npost=800⋅(1−0.30)=800⋅0.70=560 ungulatesN_{\text{post}} = 800 \cdot (1 - 0.30) = 800 \cdot 0.70 = 560\text{ ungulates}
  2. Determine the per capita starvation rate: Forage shortage is a density-dependent factor because the mortality rate depends on the surviving population density. The per capita starvation rate function is: s(Npost)=Npost2,000s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{N_{\text{post}}}{2{,}000} Substitute Npost=560N_{\text{post}} = 560: s(560)=5602,000=0.280(28.0%)s(560) = \frac{560}{2{,}000} = 0.280\quad (28.0\%)
  3. Calculate the number of individuals that starve: Multiply the surviving population by the per capita starvation rate: Starvation deaths=560⋅0.280=156.8≈157 ungulates\text{Starvation deaths} = 560 \cdot 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}

Part (b): Effective Overall Mortality from the Density-Dependent Factor

To determine the effective percentage mortality of the density-dependent factor relative to the original population of N=800N = 800, divide the number of starvation deaths by the initial population size:

Effective mortality=156.8800⋅100%=19.6%\text{Effective mortality} = \frac{156.8}{800} \cdot 100\% = 19.6\%

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the per capita rate within the surviving subgroup (28.0%28.0\%) with the overall mortality impact on the initial population (19.6%19.6\%). The density-dependent factor acts only on the post-disturbance cohort (560560 individuals), so its impact relative to the original population size is scaled down by the proportion that survived the density-independent event (0.70⋅28.0%=19.6%0.70 \cdot 28.0\% = 19.6\%).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the starvation rate and number of starving individuals using the initial population size N = 800 instead of the post-blizzard population size N_post = 560.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Npost=800×(1−0.30)=560N_{\text{post}} = 800 \times (1 - 0.30) = 560

  2. Step 2

    S=8002,000=0.40S = \frac{800}{2{,}000} = 0.40

    Correct

    s(Npost)=5602,000=0.280s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{560}{2{,}000} = 0.280

    The problem defines the starvation rate as a function of the survivors (NpostN_{\text{post}}), not the original population. You substituted N=800N = 800 instead of Npost=560N_{\text{post}} = 560 into the starvation function s(Npost)=Npost2,000s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{N_{\text{post}}}{2{,}000}.

  3. Step 3

    Starved=800×0.40=320\text{Starved} = 800 \times 0.40 = 320

    Correct

    Starved=560×0.280=156.8≈157\text{Starved} = 560 \times 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157

    Because this density-dependent mortality occurred after the blizzard, it only acts upon the surviving cohort of 560560 individuals. Using your previous values propagated the error.

  4. Step 4

    Mortality percentage=(320800)×100%=40%\text{Mortality percentage} = \left(\frac{320}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 40\%

    Correct

    Mortality percentage=(156.8800)×100%=19.6%\text{Mortality percentage} = \left(\frac{156.8}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 19.6\%

    Your formula for effective mortality relative to the initial population was set up correctly, but it evaluates to 19.6%19.6\% once the correct number of starved individuals (156.8156.8) is used.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the post-blizzard population size as 560560 ungulates.

You recognized that calculating the effective overall percentage requires dividing deaths by the original population size of 800800.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Cohort Evaluation for Density-Dependent Factor

You substituted the initial population N=800N = 800 into s(Npost)s(N_{\text{post}}) instead of your calculated post-blizzard population Npost=560N_{\text{post}} = 560.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating sequential population cohorts when applying density-dependent rates. Density-dependent factors operate on the active, current population density present at the time the factor acts, not on historical or pre-disturbance population numbers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Active Cohort
  • Density-dependent mortality rates depend strictly on the population density remaining when the factor acts.

  • Check chronological sequence: after an initial disturbance removes individuals, evaluate subsequent density-dependent functions using NpostN_{\text{post}}, not initial NN.

Distinguish Cohort Rate from Total Population Impact
  • A per capita rate within a surviving subgroup (ss) is multiplied by that subgroup size (NpostN_{\text{post}}) to find absolute deaths.

  • Calculate absolute deaths as Npost×s(Npost)N_{\text{post}} \times s(N_{\text{post}}), then express those deaths over initial NN to find overall mortality percentage.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. s(Npost)=5602,000=0.280s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{560}{2{,}000} = 0.280 (28.0%28.0\%)

  2. Number starving=560×0.280=156.8≈157 ungulates\text{Number starving} = 560 \times 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}

  3. Effective overall mortality=(156.8800)×100%=19.6%\text{Effective overall mortality} = \left(\frac{156.8}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 19.6\%

Final answer

(a) Npost=560 ungulatesN_{\text{post}} = 560\text{ ungulates}; starvation deaths =156.8≈157 ungulates= 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}. (b) Effective density-dependent mortality =19.6%= 19.6\%.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always draw a simple timeline or flowchart of population cohorts to track which population size is present when each mortality factor occurs.

  • When a rate formula states a variable such as s(Npost)s(N_{\text{post}}), explicitly substitute the variable's corresponding value (560560) rather than the starting population size (800800).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student multiplies the per capita starvation rate by the initial population of 800 rather than applying it to the 560 blizzard survivors.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Npost=800×0.70=560N_{\text{post}} = 800 \times 0.70 = 560

  2. Step 2

    s(560)=5602,000=0.28s(560) = \frac{560}{2{,}000} = 0.28

  3. Step 3

    Starved=800×0.28=224\text{Starved} = 800 \times 0.28 = 224

    Correct

    Starved=560×0.280=156.8≈157\text{Starved} = 560 \times 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157

    The subsequent forage shortage acts only on the individuals that survived the blizzard (Npost=560N_{\text{post}} = 560), not the original 800800 individuals.

  4. Step 4

    Mortality percentage=(224800)×100%=28%\text{Mortality percentage} = \left(\frac{224}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 28\%

    Correct

    Effective mortality=(156.8800)×100%=19.6%\text{Effective mortality} = \left(\frac{156.8}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 19.6\%

    Your formula structure dividing deaths by the original 800800 was appropriate, but using your previous value of 224224 deaths led to an inflated effective mortality rate of 28%28\% instead of 19.6%19.6\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a 30%30\% direct mortality leaves 70%70\% of the population alive.

You correctly substituted the post-disturbance population size into the density-dependent rate function s(Npost)s(N_{\text{post}}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cohort base misattribution in sequential mortality

You accidentally reverted to the initial population N=800N = 800 when multiplying by the per capita starvation rate.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated sequential mortality factors as acting independently on the entire initial population, overlooking that the second factor (starvation) can only act on the surviving cohort (Npost=560N_{\text{post}} = 560).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Active Cohort
  • When mortality events happen sequentially, subsequent factors act only on the survivors of earlier factors: Deaths2=Nsurviving×rate2\text{Deaths}_2 = N_{\text{surviving}} \times \text{rate}_2.

  • Always circle or write down the remaining cohort size before calculating deaths for the next event.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the post-blizzard cohort size by the per capita starvation rate: Starvation deaths=560×0.280=156.8≈157 ungulates\text{Starvation deaths} = 560 \times 0.280 = 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}.

  2. Calculate the effective mortality relative to the original population of 800800: 156.8800×100%=19.6%\frac{156.8}{800} \times 100\% = 19.6\%.

Final answer

(a) Npost=560 survivorsN_{\text{post}} = 560\text{ survivors}, 156.8≈157 starve156.8 \approx 157\text{ starve}; (b) Effective mortality =19.6%= 19.6\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Track sequential population changes using a step-by-step cohort flow diagram.

  • Distinguish between a per capita rate within a surviving subgroup and the effective rate relative to the original population.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 In part (b), the student calculates the density-dependent mortality percentage relative to the post-blizzard survivors (560) instead of the original population (800).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Npost=800×0.70=560N_{\text{post}} = 800 \times 0.70 = 560

  2. Step 2

    s(560)=560/2,000=0.28  ⟹  Starved=560×0.28=156.8s(560) = 560 / 2{,}000 = 0.28 \implies \text{Starved} = 560 \times 0.28 = 156.8

  3. Step 3

    Mortality percentage=28%\text{Mortality percentage} = 28\%

    Correct

    Effective mortality\text{Effective mortality} = 156.8800\frac{156.8}{800} ×\times 100% = 19.6%

    You evaluated the density-dependent mortality as a fraction of the post-blizzard cohort (28%28\%), but the question specifically asks for the mortality percentage relative to the original population of 800800.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly accounted for the density-independent disturbance to determine the post-blizzard population size.

You correctly evaluated the density-dependent per capita mortality function s(Npost)s(N_{\text{post}}).

You accurately computed the total number of individuals lost to winter starvation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Reference Base for Mortality Percentage

You reported the within-cohort per capita rate (28%28\%) rather than scaling it against the initial population base of 800800.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating a sequential subgroup's per capita mortality rate with the overall population-level impact. When multiple mortality events occur in sequence, the rate within a surviving subset must be normalized against the original starting population N0N_0 (0.70×28%=19.6%0.70 \times 28\% = 19.6\%, or 156.8800\frac{156.8}{800}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Reference Cohort
  • A subgroup mortality rate applies only to survivors at that stage, whereas total or effective mortality must be expressed relative to the specified starting population N0N_0.

  • Always check the denominator required by the prompt: divide total deaths from that cause by the original baseline population NinitialN_{\text{initial}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide the number of starvation deaths by the original population: 156.8800=0.196\frac{156.8}{800} = 0.196

  2. Convert the proportion to a percentage: 0.196×100%=19.6%0.196 \times 100\% = 19.6\%

Final answer

(a) Npost=560 ungulatesN_{\text{post}} = 560\text{ ungulates}; starvation deaths =156.8≈157 ungulates= 156.8 \approx 157\text{ ungulates}. (b) Effective density-dependent mortality =19.6%= 19.6\%.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how sequential mortality factors compound: total impact equals the survival rate of the first factor multiplied by the mortality rate of the second factor.

  • Practice identifying whether a question asks for a conditional (within-cohort) mortality rate or an unconditional (total population) mortality percentage.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A herd of 500500 caribou experiences an early autumn blizzard that kills 20%20\% of the individuals. During the following winter, deep snow limits food access, causing a per capita starvation rate of s(Npost)=Npost1,000s(N_{\text{post}}) = \frac{N_{\text{post}}}{1{,}000}, where NpostN_{\text{post}} is the number of survivors after the blizzard. Calculate: (a) the number of caribou that starve, and (b) the effective mortality percentage of the starvation event relative to the original population of 500500.

Answer

(a) Post-blizzard population: Npost=500×(1−0.20)=400N_{\text{post}} = 500 \times (1 - 0.20) = 400. Starvation rate: s(400)=4001,000=0.40s(400) = \frac{400}{1{,}000} = 0.40. Starvation deaths: 400×0.40=160 caribou400 \times 0.40 = 160\text{ caribou}. (b) Effective mortality relative to initial population: 160500×100%=32%\frac{160}{500} \times 100\% = 32\%.

02

A population of 1,2001{,}200 songbirds undergoes two sequential winter mortality events. First, a severe freeze (density-independent) eliminates 25%25\% of the flock. Second, a density-dependent respiratory pathogen spreads among the survivors with a mortality rate given by m(N)=0.10+N3,000m(N) = 0.10 + \frac{N}{3{,}000}. How many birds die from the pathogen, and what total percentage of the original 1,2001{,}200 birds survives both events?

Answer

Post-freeze population: Npost=1,200×0.75=900N_{\text{post}} = 1{,}200 \times 0.75 = 900. Pathogen mortality rate: m(900)=0.10+9003,000=0.10+0.30=0.40m(900) = 0.10 + \frac{900}{3{,}000} = 0.10 + 0.30 = 0.40 (40%40\%). Pathogen deaths: 900×0.40=360 birds900 \times 0.40 = 360\text{ birds}. Final survivors: 900−360=540 birds900 - 360 = 540\text{ birds}. Overall survival percentage: 5401,200×100%=45%\frac{540}{1{,}200} \times 100\% = 45\%.

03

In a trout stream, an initial cohort of 2,0002{,}000 fry experiences a flash flood (density-independent) with mortality rate dd, leaving N1N_1 survivors. Subsequently, competition for resting pools imposes density-dependent mortality of c(N1)=N14,000c(N_1) = \frac{N_1}{4{,}000}. If exactly 250250 fry die from pool competition, find the flood mortality rate dd.

Answer

Pool competition deaths: N1×c(N1)=N1×(N14,000)=N124,000=250N_1 \times c(N_1) = N_1 \times \left(\frac{N_1}{4{,}000}\right) = \frac{N_1^2}{4{,}000} = 250. Solving for N1N_1: N12=1,000,000  ⟹  N1=1,000N_1^2 = 1{,}000{,}000 \implies N_1 = 1{,}000. Since N1=2,000×(1−d)=1,000N_1 = 2{,}000 \times (1 - d) = 1{,}000, we have 1−d=0.501 - d = 0.50, so d=0.50d = 0.50 (50%50\%).

Loading workspace…