Resources

An ecology and systematics lab standardizes ribosomal RNA sequencing to classify three newly isolated bacterial strains (S1,S2,S3S_1, S_2, S_3) alongside an outgroup (S0S_0). Across an alignment of 1,5001{,}500 aligned nucleotide positions, pairwise differences are tallied as follows: S0S_0 vs S1=45S_1 = 45 differences, S0S_0 vs S2=46S_2 = 46 differences, S0S_0 vs S3=45S_3 = 45 differences, S1S_1 vs S2=18S_2 = 18 differences, S1S_1 vs S3=32S_3 = 32 differences, and S2S_2 vs S3=30S_3 = 30 differences. Calculate the percent sequence identity between the two most closely related strains, identify that sister pair, and construct the nested cladistic parenthetical string showing the rooted phylogenetic topology of the three strains and the outgroup.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Sister pair: S1S_1 and S2S_2; Percent sequence identity =98.8%= 98.8\%; Rooted topology: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

Steps

01

Identify the most closely related pair (sister taxa)

In sequence-based phylogenetics, taxa sharing the smallest number of pairwise nucleotide differences have diverged most recently and are considered sister taxa. Comparing the differences among the ingroup strains:

  • S1 vs S2=18 differencesS_1\text{ vs }S_2 = 18\text{ differences}
  • S2 vs S3=30 differencesS_2\text{ vs }S_3 = 30\text{ differences}
  • S1 vs S3=32 differencesS_1\text{ vs }S_3 = 32\text{ differences}

The pair with the fewest sequence differences is S1S_1 and S2S_2 (1818 differences). Therefore, S1S_1 and S2S_2 form the sister pair.


02

Calculate the percent sequence identity for the sister pair

The total length of the aligned region is L=1,500 nucleotidesL = 1{,}500\text{ nucleotides}.

  1. Calculate the number of identical nucleotide sites: Identical sites=1,500−18=1,482\text{Identical sites} = 1{,}500 - 18 = 1{,}482
  2. Compute the percent sequence identity: Percent identity=(1,4821,500)×100%=0.988×100%=98.8%\text{Percent identity} = \left(\frac{1{,}482}{1{,}500}\right) \times 100\% = 0.988 \times 100\% = 98.8\%

03

Determine the rooted phylogenetic tree topology

  1. Clustering the ingroup:

    • S1S_1 and S2S_2 cluster first as the most closely related sister group: (S1,S2)(S_1, S_2).
    • S3S_3 is more similar to S1S_1 (3232 differences) and S2S_2 (3030 differences) than to the outgroup S0S_0 (4545 differences). Thus, S3S_3 joins the clade formed by S1S_1 and S2S_2: ((S1,S2),S3)((S_1, S_2), S_3)
  2. Rooting with the outgroup:

    • S0S_0 exhibits the highest number of differences to all ingroup strains (≈45–46\approx 45\text{--}46 differences), confirming its basal position outside the ingroup clade.
    • Adding S0S_0 as the outgroup at the root yields the nested cladistic parenthetical topology: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

Common Pitfall: When writing Newick-style tree strings, ensure internal clades are properly nested. Writing ((S1,S2),(S3,S0))((S_1, S_2), (S_3, S_0)) would incorrectly imply that S3S_3 and the outgroup S0S_0 form a derived monophyletic clade rather than S0S_0 branching outside all three ingroup strains.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student calculates percent sequence divergence instead of percent sequence identity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Minimum differences: S1 vs S2=18  ⟹  Sister pair: S1 and S2\text{Minimum differences: } S_1 \text{ vs } S_2 = 18 \implies \text{Sister pair: } S_1 \text{ and } S_2

  2. Step 2

    Percent sequence identity\text{Percent sequence identity} = (181,500)\left(\frac{18}{1{,}500}\right) ×\times 100% = 1.2%

    Correct

    Percent sequence identity\text{Percent sequence identity} = (1,500−181,500)\left(\frac{1{,}500 - 18}{1{,}500}\right) ×\times 100% = (1,4821,500)\left(\frac{1{,}482}{1{,}500}\right) ×\times 100% = 98.8%

    You divided the number of nucleotide differences by the total alignment length, which calculates percent sequence divergence (1.2%1.2\%) rather than percent sequence identity (100%−1.2%=98.8%100\% - 1.2\% = 98.8\%).

  3. Step 3

    (S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified S1S_1 and S2S_2 as the sister pair based on the lowest pairwise difference count.

You correctly constructed the nested parenthetical tree notation with the outgroup S0S_0 basal to the ingroup.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sequence Identity vs. Divergence Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated sequence divergence (the proportion of mismatched sites) with sequence identity (the proportion of identical sites), using the difference count directly in the numerator instead of subtracting it from the total alignment length.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Complementarity of Identity and Divergence
  • Percent Identity+Percent Divergence=100%\text{Percent Identity} + \text{Percent Divergence} = 100\%, where Identical Sites=Total Length−Differences\text{Identical Sites} = \text{Total Length} - \text{Differences}.

  • Always convert pairwise differences into identical positions ( L−D \,L - D\,) before computing percentage identity, or subtract the divergence percentage from 100%100\%.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the number of matching sites: 1,500−18=1,4821{,}500 - 18 = 1{,}482.

  2. Divide matching sites by the total alignment length and multiply by 100%100\%: (1,4821,500)×100%=98.8%\left(\frac{1{,}482}{1{,}500}\right) \times 100\% = 98.8\%.

Final answer

Sister pair: S1S_1 and S2S_2; Percent sequence identity =98.8%= 98.8\%; Rooted topology: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check that your calculated sequence identity reflects how similar the sequences are (typically a high percentage like >90%>90\% for closely related strains).

  • Review the distinction between pairwise sequence difference/divergence and pairwise sequence identity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student identifies the sister pair by looking for the largest number of differences rather than the smallest.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Differences: S1 vs S3=32S_1\text{ vs }S_3 = 32 ⟹\Longrightarrow Sister pair: S1 and S3S_1\text{ and }S_3

    Correct

    Sister pair: S1 and S2S_1\text{ and }S_2 (18 differences18\text{ differences})

    Taxa that diverged most recently share the fewest nucleotide differences. Among the ingroup comparisons (1818, 3030, and 3232), S1S_1 and S2S_2 have the lowest distance (1818), making them the sister pair.

  2. Step 2

    Percent sequence identity=1500−321500×100%=14681500×100%=97.87%\text{Percent sequence identity} = \frac{1500 - 32}{1500} \times 100\% = \frac{1468}{1500} \times 100\% = 97.87\%

    Correct

    Percent sequence identity=1500−181500×100%=14821500×100%=98.8%\text{Percent sequence identity} = \frac{1500 - 18}{1500} \times 100\% = \frac{1482}{1500} \times 100\% = 98.8\%

    Your mathematical calculation and percent identity formula were carried out accurately, but the value is affected because it evaluated the incorrectly chosen pair S1S_1 and S3S_3 instead of S1S_1 and S2S_2.

  3. Step 3

    (S0,((S1,S3),S2))(S_0, ((S_1, S_3), S_2))

    Correct

    (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

    Your tree syntax correctly placed the outgroup outside the nested ingroup clade, but the internal clade is affected by your initial choice of sister taxa.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the percent sequence identity calculation using the aligned sequence length.

You formatted the rooted cladistic parenthetical topology with proper nested parentheses and outgroup placement.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Distance Metric for Sister Taxa

You selected the pair with the maximum pairwise differences (3232) rather than the minimum (1818).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused pairwise sequence differences with sequence similarity, seeking the largest numeric difference when identifying the most closely related sister taxa. In distance-based phylogenetics, fewer mutations reflect more recent common ancestry.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distance vs. Similarity
  • Genetic distance (number of differences) is inversely related to evolutionary closeness; fewer differences mean closer kinship.

  • Always scan pairwise distance matrices for the minimum positive value among ingroup taxa to find the first sister clade.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the ingroup pairwise differences: S1 vs S2=18S_1\text{ vs }S_2 = 18, S2 vs S3=30S_2\text{ vs }S_3 = 30, S1 vs S3=32S_1\text{ vs }S_3 = 32. The smallest value is 1818, so S1S_1 and S2S_2 are sister taxa.

  2. Compute the identical sites between S1S_1 and S2S_2: 1,500−18=1,4821{,}500 - 18 = 1{,}482.

  3. Calculate percent identity: 1,4821,500×100%=98.8%\frac{1{,}482}{1{,}500} \times 100\% = 98.8\%.

  4. Cluster the sister pair (S1,S2)(S_1, S_2), add S3S_3 as the next closest branch, and root with outgroup S0S_0.

Final answer

Sister pair: S1S_1 and S2S_2; Percent sequence identity =98.8%= 98.8\%; Rooted topology: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review distance matrices by labeling whether values represent differences (distances) or identical matches (similarities) before clustering.

  • Practice converting small distance tables directly into Newick/cladistic parenthetical strings by finding the minimum value at each clustering step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student places the outgroup S0 inside the ingroup as sister to S3 instead of placing it outside the clade of all three ingroup strains.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Minimum differences: S1S_1 vs S2=18S_2 = 18   ⟹  \implies Sister pair: S1S_1 and S2S_2

  2. Step 2

    Percent sequence identity=(1500−18)/1500×100%=1482/1500×100%=98.8%\text{Percent sequence identity} = (1500 - 18) / 1500 \times 100\% = 1482 / 1500 \times 100\% = 98.8\%

  3. Step 3

    (((S1,S2),(S0,S3)))(((S_1, S_2), (S_0, S_3)))

    Correct

    (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

    You grouped the outgroup S0S_0 into a sister clade with S3S_3. Because S3S_3 is much closer to S1S_1 (3232 differences) and S2S_2 (3030 differences) than to S0S_0 (4545 differences), all three ingroup strains form a single clade ((S1,S2),S3)((S_1, S_2), S_3) with S0S_0 rooted entirely outside them.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified S1S_1 and S2S_2 as sister taxa by finding the minimum pairwise differences.

You set up and computed the percent sequence identity calculation perfectly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cladogram outgroup placement error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You paired the leftover ingroup taxon S3S_3 with the outgroup S0S_0 rather than grouping all ingroup members into a monophyletic clade before attaching the outgroup at the root.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ingroup Monophyly Rule
  • An outgroup by definition branches outside the clade formed by all ingroup taxa; it never forms a derived sister pair with an individual ingroup taxon.

  • Cluster all ingroup taxa hierarchically first based on shared sequence similarity, then attach the outgroup to root the entire tree.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Group the closest sister pair first: (S1,S2)(S_1, S_2).

  2. Compare the remaining ingroup taxon S3S_3 to the sister pair: S3S_3 shares 30–3230\text{--}32 differences with S1S_1 and S2S_2, but 4545 differences with the outgroup S0S_0. Thus, S3S_3 joins the clade: ((S1,S2),S3)((S_1, S_2), S_3).

  3. Place the outgroup S0S_0 at the basal root position outside the entire ingroup clade: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3)).

Final answer

Sister pair: S1S_1 and S2S_2; Percent sequence identity =98.8%= 98.8\%; Rooted topology: (S0,((S1,S2),S3))(S_0, ((S_1, S_2), S_3))

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how outgroups define tree polarity by remaining basal to the entire ingroup.

  • Practice building Newick parenthetical strings step-by-step from distance matrices.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two orthologous genes of length 800 bp800\text{ bp} differ by 1616 single-nucleotide substitutions. Calculate the percent sequence identity and percent sequence divergence.

Answer

Percent divergence=(16800)×100%=2.0%\text{Percent divergence} = \left(\frac{16}{800}\right) \times 100\% = 2.0\%; Percent identity=100%−2.0%=98.0%\text{Percent identity} = 100\% - 2.0\% = 98.0\% (or 784800×100%=98.0%\frac{784}{800} \times 100\% = 98.0\%).

02

An alignment of 2,000 bp2{,}000\text{ bp} among three strains (A,B,CA, B, C) reveals pairwise differences: A vs B=40A\text{ vs }B = 40, A vs C=120A\text{ vs }C = 120, and B vs C=110B\text{ vs }C = 110. Identify the sister pair and compute their percent sequence identity.

Answer

The sister pair is AA and BB (lowest difference count: 4040). Identical sites=2,000−40=1,960\text{Identical sites} = 2{,}000 - 40 = 1{,}960. Percent identity=(1,9602,000)×100%=98.0%\text{Percent identity} = \left(\frac{1{,}960}{2{,}000}\right) \times 100\% = 98.0\%.

03

Four species (W,X,Y,ZW, X, Y, Z) have a 1,200 bp1{,}200\text{ bp} gene alignment. An outgroup OO has ≈150\approx 150 differences to all four. Pairwise differences among the four are: W vs X=24W\text{ vs }X = 24, Y vs Z=12Y\text{ vs }Z = 12, and any pair between {W,X}\{W, X\} and {Y,Z}\{Y, Z\} has 80–8580\text{--}85 differences. Identify both sister pairs, compute the sequence identity for the most closely related pair, and write the rooted Newick tree.

Answer

Sister pairs: (Y,Z)(Y, Z) with 1212 differences and (W,X)(W, X) with 2424 differences. The most closely related pair is YY and ZZ with percent identity =(1,200−121,200)×100%=99.0%= \left(\frac{1{,}200 - 12}{1{,}200}\right) \times 100\% = 99.0\%. Rooted topology: (O,((W,X),(Y,Z)))(O, ((W, X), (Y, Z))).

Loading workspace…