Resources

In isolated mitochondria metabolizing malate and glutamate, rotenone is added to achieve complete (100%100\%) stoichiometric inhibition of Complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase). Next, succinate is added in excess along with adequate ADP\text{ADP} and Pi\text{P}_i. State which electron carrier donates electrons downstream of the block, specify the entry complex into the electron transport chain, calculate the theoretical moles of ATP produced per mole of succinate oxidized to fumarate assuming 1 FADH2→1.5 ATP1\text{ FADH}_2 \to 1.5\text{ ATP}, and determine the net number of protons (H+\text{H}^+) pumped into the intermembrane space per pair of electrons transferred from succinate to 12O2\frac{1}{2}\text{O}_2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Electron carrier = FADH2\text{FADH}_2 (enzyme-bound E-FADH2\text{E-FADH}_2 of succinate dehydrogenase); Entry complex = Complex II (succinate-CoQ oxidoreductase); Theoretical ATP yield = 1.5 moles of ATP per mole of succinate1.5\text{ moles of ATP per mole of succinate}; Net protons pumped = 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ (0 H+0\text{ H}^+ from Complex II, 4 H+4\text{ H}^+ from Complex III, 2 H+2\text{ H}^+ from Complex IV).

Steps

01

Effect of Rotenone on Complex I

Rotenone is a specific, stoichiometric inhibitor of Complex I (NADH\text{NADH}:ubiquinone oxidoreductase). It prevents the transfer of electrons from iron-sulfur (Fe-S\text{Fe-S}) clusters of Complex I to ubiquinone (CoQ\text{CoQ} or Q\text{Q}). As a result, the oxidation of NADH\text{NADH} derived from malate and glutamate is completely blocked, arresting the electron transport chain downstream of Complex I when relying solely on NADH\text{NADH}-linked substrates.


02

Bypass via Succinate and Complex II

Adding succinate bypasses the Complex I block:

  • Enzyme and Entry Complex: Succinate dehydrogenase is a dual-function enzyme acting both in the citric acid cycle and as Complex II (succinate-CoQ\text{CoQ} oxidoreductase) of the electron transport chain.
  • Electron Carrier: Oxidation of succinate to fumarate reduces the enzyme-bound prosthetic group flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD\text{FAD}) to FADH2\text{FADH}_2 (specifically, enzyme-bound E-FADH2\text{E-FADH}_2).
  • Electron Flow: Electrons flow from succinate →FAD→Fe-S centers→ubiquinone (Q)\to \text{FAD} \to \text{Fe-S centers} \to \text{ubiquinone (Q)}, converting it to ubiquinol (QH2\text{QH}_2). Because ubiquinone operates downstream of Complex I, respiration and oxidative phosphorylation resume independently of the rotenone block.

03

Proton (H+\text{H}^+) Pumping Stoichiometry

As a pair of electrons (2e−2\text{e}^-) travels from succinate through ubiquinol to molecular oxygen (12OX2\frac{1}{2}\ce{O2}), the proton pumping across the inner mitochondrial membrane is as follows:

  • Complex II: Free energy change (ΔG∘′\Delta G^\circ{}') is insufficient to drive proton translocation; it pumps 0 H+0\text{ H}^+.
  • Complex III (cytochrome bc1bc_1 complex): Pumps 4 H+4\text{ H}^+ via the Q-cycle into the intermembrane space per pair of electrons.
  • Complex IV (cytochrome cc oxidase): Pumps 2 H+2\text{ H}^+ across the membrane as 2e−2\text{e}^- reduce 12OX2+2HX+→HX2O\frac{1}{2}\ce{O2} + 2\ce{H+} \to \ce{H2O}.

Net H+ pumped=0 H+(Complex II)+4 H+(Complex III)+2 H+(Complex IV)=6 H+\text{Net }\text{H}^+\text{ pumped} = 0\text{ H}^+ (\text{Complex II}) + 4\text{ H}^+ (\text{Complex III}) + 2\text{ H}^+ (\text{Complex IV}) = 6\text{ H}^+


04

Theoretical ATP Yield

Oxidation of 1 mole1\text{ mole} of succinate to fumarate generates 1 mole1\text{ mole} of FADH2\text{FADH}_2. Given that the theoretical P/O\text{P/O} ratio for FADH2\text{FADH}_2 oxidation is 1.51.5:

Theoretical ATP yield=1 mole succinate×1.5 moles ATP1 mole FADH2=1.5 moles of ATP\text{Theoretical ATP yield} = 1\text{ mole succinate} \times \frac{1.5\text{ moles ATP}}{1\text{ mole FADH}_2} = 1.5\text{ moles of ATP}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student might assume that Complex II directly pumps protons across the membrane like Complex I, erroneously calculating 10 protons pumped instead of 6.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ubiquinol (CoQH2)\text{Ubiquinol (CoQH}_2\text{)}

    Correct

    FADH2 (or enzyme-bound E-FADH2 of succinate dehydrogenase)\text{FADH}_2\text{ (or enzyme-bound E-FADH}_2\text{ of succinate dehydrogenase)}

    Succinate dehydrogenase oxidizes succinate to fumarate while reducing enzyme-bound FAD\text{FAD} to FADH2\text{FADH}_2. While ubiquinone subsequently receives these electrons to form ubiquinol, the immediate electron carrier generated by succinate oxidation is FADH2\text{FADH}_2.

  2. Step 2

    Complex II\text{Complex II}

  3. Step 3

    1 mol succinate→1 mol FADH2=1.5 mol ATP1\text{ mol succinate} \to 1\text{ mol FADH}_2 = 1.5\text{ mol ATP}

  4. Step 4

    Complex II pumps 4 H+  ⟹  Complex III pumps 4 H+ and Complex IV pumps 2 H+  ⟹  Total H+ pumped=4+4+2=10 H+\text{Complex II pumps } 4\text{ H}^+ \implies \text{Complex III pumps } 4\text{ H}^+ \text{ and Complex IV pumps } 2\text{ H}^+ \implies \text{Total H}^+ \text{ pumped} = 4 + 4 + 2 = 10\text{ H}^+

    Correct

    Complex II: 0 H+,  Complex III: 4 H+,  Complex IV: 2 H+  ⟹  Total H+ pumped=0+4+2=6 H+\text{Complex II: } 0\text{ H}^+,\; \text{Complex III: } 4\text{ H}^+,\; \text{Complex IV: } 2\text{ H}^+ \implies \text{Total H}^+ \text{ pumped} = 0 + 4 + 2 = 6\text{ H}^+

    Complex II does not span the entire inner mitochondrial membrane and the free energy change of electron transfer from succinate to ubiquinone is insufficient to drive proton translocation. Therefore, Complex II pumps 0 H+0\text{ H}^+, yielding a net total of 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ per electron pair.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that succinate oxidation enters the respiratory chain via Complex II.

You accurately calculated the ATP yield of 1.5 mol of ATP1.5\text{ mol of ATP} per mole of succinate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Proton pumping stoichiometry of Complex II

Assigning proton-pumping capacity to Complex II as if it were Complex I.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that all entry complexes of the electron transport chain pump protons equally (4 H+4\text{ H}^+). Unlike Complex I, Complex II (succinate dehydrogenase) has a much smaller standard reduction potential change (ΔE∘′\Delta E^\circ{}') between succinate/fumarate and CoQ\text{CoQ}, so it does not release enough free energy to translocate protons across the inner mitochondrial membrane.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Proton pumping per respiratory complex
  • For each pair of electrons (2e−2\text{e}^-): Complex I translocates 4 H+4\text{ H}^+, Complex II translocates 0 H+0\text{ H}^+, Complex III translocates 4 H+4\text{ H}^+, and Complex IV translocates 2 H+2\text{ H}^+.

  • Always verify whether an electron pair originates from NADH\text{NADH} (Complex I entry, total 10 H+10\text{ H}^+) or FADH2\text{FADH}_2/succinate (Complex II entry, total 6 H+6\text{ H}^+).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that Complex II translocates 0 H+0\text{ H}^+ across the inner membrane because ΔG∘′\Delta G^\circ{}' is insufficient.

  2. Sum the protons pumped by the downstream complexes along the pathway: 0 H+ (Complex II)+4 H+ (Complex III)+2 H+ (Complex IV)0\text{ H}^+\text{ (Complex II)} + 4\text{ H}^+\text{ (Complex III)} + 2\text{ H}^+\text{ (Complex IV)}.

  3. Calculate the net proton translocation: 0+4+2=6 H+0 + 4 + 2 = 6\text{ H}^+.

Final answer

Electron carrier: FADH2;  Entry complex: Complex II;  ATP yield: 1.5 moles of ATP;  Net H+ pumped: 6 H+\text{Electron carrier: } \text{FADH}_2;\; \text{Entry complex: Complex II};\; \text{ATP yield: } 1.5\text{ moles of ATP};\; \text{Net } \text{H}^+ \text{ pumped: } 6\text{ H}^+

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the structural and energetic differences between Complex I and Complex II that determine why only Complex I translocates protons.

  • Practice tracking electron flow and net proton pumping for different entry substrates such as glycerol-3-phosphate and fatty acyl-CoA.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student might use the traditional NADH stoichiometric ATP yield of 2.5 ATP per mole instead of the FADH2 pathway yield for succinate.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ubiquinol (CoQHX2)\text{Ubiquinol } (\ce{CoQH2})

    Correct

    FADH2\text{FADH}_2 (or enzyme-bound E-FADH2\text{E-FADH}_2 of succinate dehydrogenase)

    Succinate is oxidized by succinate dehydrogenase to reduce its prosthetic group FAD\text{FAD} to FADH2\text{FADH}_2, which directly donates electrons into the chain downstream of the rotenone block. Ubiquinol receives electrons from Complex II rather than donating them from succinate oxidation.

  2. Step 2

    Complex II\text{Complex II}

  3. Step 3

    1 mol succinate yields 2.5 mol ATP1\text{ mol succinate yields } 2.5\text{ mol ATP}

    Correct

    1.5 moles of ATP per mole of succinate1.5\text{ moles of ATP per mole of succinate}

    Oxidation of 1 mole1\text{ mole} of succinate generates 1 mole1\text{ mole} of FADH2\text{FADH}_2. Applying the given conversion of 1 FADH2→1.5 ATP1\text{ FADH}_2 \to 1.5\text{ ATP}, the theoretical yield is 1.5 mol ATP1.5\text{ mol ATP}, not the standard 2.5 mol ATP2.5\text{ mol ATP} associated with NADH\text{NADH}.

  4. Step 4

    Complex II pumps 0 H+,Complex III pumps 4 H+,Complex IV pumps 2 H+  ⟹  Total H+ pumped=0+4+2=6 H+\text{Complex II pumps } 0\text{ H}^+, \text{Complex III pumps } 4\text{ H}^+, \text{Complex IV pumps } 2\text{ H}^+ \implies \text{Total } \text{H}^+ \text{ pumped} = 0 + 4 + 2 = 6\text{ H}^+

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Complex II as the entry point for electrons when Complex I is inhibited.

You accurately identified the proton pumping contribution of each complex downstream of Complex I.

You correctly summed the proton contributions to find that 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ are pumped into the intermembrane space per pair of electrons.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Substrate-Specific ATP Stoichiometry and Electron Carrier Confusion

You knew that ubiquinol participates in downstream transport, but you substituted it for the primary prosthetic carrier FADH2\text{FADH}_2 and defaulted to the NADH\text{NADH} ATP yield of 2.52.5.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the electron carrier generated by succinate oxidation (enzyme-bound FADH2\text{FADH}_2) with the mobile carrier ubiquinol, and you applied the general 2.5 ATP/NADH2.5\text{ ATP}/\text{NADH} ratio instead of mapping succinate directly to FADH2\text{FADH}_2 at 1.5 ATP1.5\text{ ATP}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Link substrate to its prosthetic carrier
  • Succinate dehydrogenase uses an enzyme-bound FAD\text{FAD} cofactor, producing FADH2\text{FADH}_2 upon oxidizing succinate to fumarate.

  • Always track the primary cofactor reduced during substrate dehydrogenation before downstream mobile pool transfer.

Match ATP yield to the entry point
  • Electrons entering via FADH2\text{FADH}_2 bypass Complex I (pumping 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ total), resulting in a theoretical yield of 1.5 ATP1.5\text{ ATP}, whereas NADH\text{NADH} enters at Complex I (pumping 10 H+10\text{ H}^+ total) yielding 2.5 ATP2.5\text{ ATP}.

  • Check whether the pathway enters via Complex I or Complex II to select 2.52.5 vs 1.5 ATP/pair of electrons1.5\text{ ATP/pair of electrons}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Oxidation of 1 mol1\text{ mol} of succinate to fumarate reduces enzyme-bound FAD\text{FAD} to 1 mol1\text{ mol} of FADH2\text{FADH}_2 within Complex II.

  2. Multiply the moles of FADH2\text{FADH}_2 by the given ratio: 1 mol succinate×1.5 mol ATP1 mol FADH2=1.5 mol ATP1\text{ mol succinate} \times \frac{1.5\text{ mol ATP}}{1\text{ mol }\text{FADH}_2} = 1.5\text{ mol ATP}.

Final answer

Electron carrier = FADH2\text{FADH}_2; Entry complex = Complex II; Theoretical ATP yield = 1.5 mol ATP1.5\text{ mol ATP}; Net H+\text{H}^+ pumped = 6 H+6\text{ H}^+.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between enzyme-bound prosthetic groups (like FAD/FADH2\text{FAD}/\text{FADH}_2 in Complex II) and mobile lipid-soluble carriers (ubiquinol).

  • Practice calculating theoretical ATP yields directly from proton pumping stoichiometry (10 H+10\text{ H}^+ for NADH\text{NADH} vs 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ for FADH2\text{FADH}_2).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student might incorrectly identify cytochrome c rather than ubiquinol as the primary carrier donating electrons downstream of the rotenone block.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Cytochrome c

    Correct

    FADH2\text{FADH}_2 (or ubiquinol / QH2\text{QH}_2)

    Rotenone blocks Complex I, arresting electron transfer from NADH\text{NADH} to ubiquinone. When succinate is added, succinate dehydrogenase oxidizes succinate by transferring electrons to enzyme-bound FAD\text{FAD} to form FADH2\text{FADH}_2, which then reduces ubiquinone (CoQ) downstream of the block. Cytochrome cc functions further downstream between Complex III and Complex IV.

  2. Step 2

    Complex II

  3. Step 3

    1 mol succinate→1 mol FADH2=1.5 mol ATP1\text{ mol succinate} \to 1\text{ mol FADH}_2 = 1.5\text{ mol ATP}

  4. Step 4

    Complex II pumps 0 H+0\text{ H}^+, Complex III pumps 4 H+4\text{ H}^+, Complex IV pumps 2 H+  ⟹  Total H+ pumped=6 H+2\text{ H}^+ \implies \text{Total }\text{H}^+\text{ pumped} = 6\text{ H}^+

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Complex II as the entry complex that bypasses the Complex I block.

You correctly calculated the theoretical ATP yield per mole of succinate oxidized.

You accounted for the individual and net proton translocation across Complexes II, III, and IV.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect electron carrier downstream of respiratory inhibition

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the immediate mobile or prosthetic electron carriers that feed electrons directly into the ubiquinone pool (FADH2\text{FADH}_2 within Complex II) with downstream mobile electron shuttles operating between Complexes III and IV (cytochrome cc).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace the Entry Point of the Added Substrate
  • Oxidation of succinate to fumarate is directly coupled to the reduction of enzyme-bound FAD→FADH2\text{FAD} \to \text{FADH}_2 inside Complex II.

  • Always identify the direct prosthetic cofactor reduced by the substrate before following electrons downstream to ubiquinone (Q).

Distinguish Mobile Electron Carriers
  • Ubiquinone (Q/QH2\text{QH}_2) collects electrons from both Complex I and Complex II, while cytochrome cc only transfers electrons from Complex III to Complex IV.

  • Check the sequence of electron transport: Complex I/II→Q→Complex III→Cyt c→Complex IV→OX2\text{Complex I/II} \to \text{Q} \to \text{Complex III} \to \text{Cyt } c \to \text{Complex IV} \to \ce{O2}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the cofactor directly reduced upon succinate oxidation: Succinate+E-FAD→Fumarate+E-FADH2\text{Succinate} + \text{E-FAD} \to \text{Fumarate} + \text{E-FADH}_2.

  2. Confirm that electrons from E-FADH2\text{E-FADH}_2 enter the ubiquinone pool through iron-sulfur clusters in Complex II, bypassing the rotenone block at Complex I.

Final answer

Electron carrier: FADH2\text{FADH}_2 (or ubiquinol/QH2\text{QH}_2); Entry complex: Complex II; ATP yield: 1.5 mol1.5\text{ mol}; Net protons pumped: 6 H+6\text{ H}^+

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the order of electron carriers and complexes in the mitochondrial inner membrane: NADH→Complex I→Q\text{NADH} \to \text{Complex I} \to \text{Q}, Succinate→Complex II (FAD)→Q\text{Succinate} \to \text{Complex II (FAD)} \to \text{Q}, Q→Complex III→cytochrome c→Complex IV\text{Q} \to \text{Complex III} \to \text{cytochrome } c \to \text{Complex IV}.

  • Practice tracing the impact of specific respiratory inhibitors (rotenone, antimycin A, cyanide) to determine which components remain reduced versus oxidized.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In the presence of amytal (a Complex I inhibitor), mitochondria are supplied with ascorbate and TMPD, which donate electrons directly to cytochrome cc. Determine the number of protons pumped into the intermembrane space per pair of electrons transferred to 12O2\frac{1}{2}\text{O}_2.

Answer

2 H+2\text{ H}^+. Electrons donated to cytochrome cc enter directly at Complex IV, completely bypassing Complexes I, II, and III. Complex IV translocates 2 H+2\text{ H}^+ per pair of electrons reducing 12O2\frac{1}{2}\text{O}_2 to H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}.

02

Mitochondrial glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase oxidizes cytoplasmic glycerol-3-phosphate to dihydroxyacetone phosphate, transferring electrons to membrane-bound FAD\text{FAD} and then directly into the ubiquinone (Q\text{Q}) pool. Calculate the net number of protons pumped across the inner membrane per mole of glycerol-3-phosphate oxidized by oxygen.

Answer

6 H+6\text{ H}^+. The electrons enter the respiratory chain at the ubiquinone pool, bypassing Complex I. The electrons then travel through Complex III (4 H+4\text{ H}^+ pumped) and Complex IV (2 H+2\text{ H}^+ pumped), yielding a total of 0+4+2=6 H+0 + 4 + 2 = 6\text{ H}^+.

03

Assuming a standard mitochondrial c-ring\text{c-ring} requiring 8 H+8\text{ H}^+ per full rotation plus 1 H+1\text{ H}^+ per ATP for phosphate transport (yielding 3 ATP3\text{ ATP} per 11 H+11\text{ H}^+), calculate the theoretical ATP yield per pair of electrons entering via (a) NADH\text{NADH} and (b) succinate.

Answer

(a) 1011×3≈2.73 ATP\frac{10}{11} \times 3 \approx 2.73\text{ ATP} per NADH\text{NADH} (since 10 H+10\text{ H}^+ are pumped). (b) 611×3≈1.64 ATP\frac{6}{11} \times 3 \approx 1.64\text{ ATP} per succinate (since 6 H+6\text{ H}^+ are pumped). Key step: Divide total H+\text{H}^+ pumped (1010 or 66) by 11 H+3 ATP=3.67 H+/ATP\frac{11\text{ H}^+}{3\text{ ATP}} = 3.67\text{ H}^+/\text{ATP}.

Loading workspace…