Resources

Researchers comparing cytochrome cc amino acid sequences across three modern amniote taxa find that Species A and Species B differ by 1212 amino acids, whereas Species A and Species C differ by 3636 amino acids. The lineage divergence between Species A and Species C has been established from the terrestrial fossil record at 300 million years ago (Mya)300\text{ million years ago (Mya)}. Assuming a strict molecular clock where the rate of neutral amino acid substitutions (rr) remains constant per million years along both divergent lineages, calculate the substitution rate per million years (rr) along a single lineage, and solve for the estimated divergence time (in Mya) between Species A and Species B.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Substitution rate along a single lineage: r=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}; Estimated divergence time between Species A and Species B: 100 Mya100\text{ Mya}.

Steps

01

Calibrate the Single-Lineage Substitution Rate (rr)

Understanding the Molecular Clock Model

A molecular clock assumes that neutral genetic differences (such as amino acid substitutions in conserved proteins like cytochrome cc) accumulate at an approximately constant rate over evolutionary time. When two lineages diverge from a common ancestor TT million years ago (Mya\text{Mya}), each lineage accumulates substitutions independently for time TT. Therefore, the total observed sequence divergence (DD) between two modern species represents the accumulation of changes across both branches: D=2⋅r⋅TD = 2 \cdot r \cdot T where:

  • DD is the number of amino acid differences between the two species.
  • rr is the substitution rate per lineage per million years.
  • TT is the time since divergence from their most recent common ancestor (Mya\text{Mya}).

We use the divergence between Species A and Species C, which is calibrated by the fossil record:

  • Observed amino acid differences: DA-C=36D_{\text{A-C}} = 36
  • Known divergence time: TA-C=300 MyaT_{\text{A-C}} = 300\text{ Mya}

The total lineage time elapsed along both paths since their common ancestor is:

2⋅TA-C=2⋅300 Mya=600 million lineage-years2 \cdot T_{\text{A-C}} = 2 \cdot 300\text{ Mya} = 600\text{ million lineage-years}

Solving for the substitution rate rr:

r=DA-C2⋅TA-C=36 substitutions600 million years=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = \frac{D_{\text{A-C}}}{2 \cdot T_{\text{A-C}}} = \frac{36\text{ substitutions}}{600\text{ million years}} = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}

Common Pitfall: Forgetting the factor of 22 in the denominator. Because divergence is measured between two surviving taxa, changes have accumulated independently along two separate branches since they split from their common ancestor.


02

Estimate the Divergence Time Between Species A and Species B

Now, apply the calibrated substitution rate r=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years} to the divergence between Species A and Species B:

  • Observed amino acid differences: DA-B=12D_{\text{A-B}} = 12

Rearranging the molecular clock equation to solve for the divergence time (TA-BT_{\text{A-B}}):

TA-B=DA-B2⋅rT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{2 \cdot r}

Substitute the values:

TA-B=122⋅0.0600=120.1200=100 MyaT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = \frac{12}{0.1200} = 100\text{ Mya}

Alternatively, using direct proportionality:

TA-BTA-C=DA-BDA-C  ⟹  TA-B=300 Mya⋅(1236)=300⋅13=100 Mya\frac{T_{\text{A-B}}}{T_{\text{A-C}}} = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{D_{\text{A-C}}} \implies T_{\text{A-B}} = 300\text{ Mya} \cdot \left(\frac{12}{36}\right) = 300 \cdot \frac{1}{3} = 100\text{ Mya}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores that sequence divergence accumulates independently along two lineages from a common ancestor, dividing differences by T instead of 2T to calculate rate and divergence time.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r=36300  ⟹  r=0.12 substitutions per million yearsr = \frac{36}{300} \implies r = 0.12\text{ substitutions per million years}

    Correct

    r=DA-C2⋅TA-C=362⋅300=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = \frac{D_{\text{A-C}}}{2 \cdot T_{\text{A-C}}} = \frac{36}{2 \cdot 300} = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}

    When comparing two extant species, mutations accumulate independently along both branches descending from their most recent common ancestor. The total time elapsed across both lineages is 2⋅T=2⋅300=600 million lineage-years2 \cdot T = 2 \cdot 300 = 600\text{ million lineage-years}, so the single-lineage rate is r=36600=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = \frac{36}{600} = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}.

  2. Step 2

    T=120.12  ⟹  T=100 MyaT = \frac{12}{0.12} \implies T = 100\text{ Mya}

    Correct

    TA-B=DA-B2r=122⋅0.0600=100 MyaT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{2r} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = 100\text{ Mya}

    Your final divergence time of 100 Mya100\text{ Mya} is numerically correct because omitting the factor of 22 in the rate equation canceled with omitting the factor of 22 in the time equation (T=DrT = \frac{D}{r}). Using the standard single-lineage formula, T=D2r=122⋅0.0600=100 MyaT = \frac{D}{2r} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = 100\text{ Mya}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that sequence divergence is directly proportional to divergence time under a strict molecular clock.

You accurately calculated the estimated divergence time between Species A and Species B as 100 Mya100\text{ Mya}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of two-lineage factor (2T)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated pairwise sequence differences as having accumulated along a single lineage over time TT, rather than along two independent divergent branches spanning a combined time of 2T2T.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for independent divergence along two lineages
  • For two extant taxa descending from a common ancestor TT million years ago, total divergence is D=2⋅r⋅TD = 2 \cdot r \cdot T.

  • Divide observed sequence differences by 2T2T (the total branch time) when solving for the single-lineage rate rr.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that Species A and Species C have evolved independently since their split 300 Mya300\text{ Mya}, giving a total branch time of 2×300=600 million lineage-years2 \times 300 = 600\text{ million lineage-years}.

  2. Calculate the single-lineage rate: r=DA-C2⋅TA-C=36600=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = \frac{D_{\text{A-C}}}{2 \cdot T_{\text{A-C}}} = \frac{36}{600} = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}.

  3. Apply this rate to solve for the divergence time between Species A and Species B: TA-B=DA-B2r=122⋅0.0600=100 MyaT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{2r} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = 100\text{ Mya}.

Final answer

Substitution rate along a single lineage: r=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}; Estimated divergence time: 100 Mya100\text{ Mya}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a simple phylogenetic tree before writing equations to clearly visualize both branches descending from the common ancestor.

  • Distinguish explicitly between the pairwise divergence rate (2r2r) and the single-lineage substitution rate (rr).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to divide the total elapsed branch time by 2 when calculating the divergence time between Species A and Species B, arriving at 200 Mya.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r=362⋅300  ⟹  r=36600=0.06 substitutions per million yearsr = \frac{36}{2 \cdot 300} \implies r = \frac{36}{600} = 0.06\text{ substitutions per million years}

  2. Step 2

    T=120.06  ⟹  T=200 MyaT = \frac{12}{0.06} \implies T = 200\text{ Mya}

    Correct

    T=DA-B2⋅r=122⋅0.0600=100 MyaT = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{2 \cdot r} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = 100\text{ Mya}

    You calculated the total evolutionary time across both lineages (2T=120.06=200 million years2T = \frac{12}{0.06} = 200\text{ million years}) rather than dividing by 22 to find the divergence time TT since their common ancestor.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the two-lineage formula to calculate the single-lineage substitution rate r=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of two-lineage factor

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot that observed sequence divergence between two extant species accumulates along two independent lineages, leading you to solve for total branch length (2T2T) rather than time since divergence (TT).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Two-lineage divergence equation
  • D=2⋅r⋅TD = 2 \cdot r \cdot T, where DD is observed divergence, rr is the single-lineage substitution rate, and TT is the divergence time since the common ancestor.

  • Always verify whether your formula solves for single-lineage time T=D2rT = \frac{D}{2r} or total elapsed branch time 2T=Dr2T = \frac{D}{r}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the molecular clock equation relating observed divergence to two independent lineages: DA-B=2⋅r⋅TA-BD_{\text{A-B}} = 2 \cdot r \cdot T_{\text{A-B}}

  2. Rearrange for divergence time: TA-B=DA-B2⋅rT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{D_{\text{A-B}}}{2 \cdot r}

  3. Substitute DA-B=12D_{\text{A-B}} = 12 and r=0.0600r = 0.0600: TA-B=122⋅0.0600=120.1200=100 MyaT_{\text{A-B}} = \frac{12}{2 \cdot 0.0600} = \frac{12}{0.1200} = 100\text{ Mya}

Final answer

r=0.0600 substitutions/lineage/million yearsr = 0.0600\text{ substitutions/lineage/million years}; TA-B=100 MyaT_{\text{A-B}} = 100\text{ Mya}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full formula D=2rTD = 2rT explicitly before rearranging it for unknown time TT.

  • Double-check that the calculated time represents the time to the common ancestor, not the sum of both branch lengths.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two bird species diverged from a common ancestor 40 Mya40\text{ Mya} and exhibit 1616 neutral nucleotide substitutions between them. Assuming a strict molecular clock, calculate the substitution rate per lineage per million years (rr).

Answer

r=0.20 substitutions/lineage/Myr = 0.20\text{ substitutions/lineage/My}. Total branch time across both lineages is 2×40 Mya=80 million years2 \times 40\text{ Mya} = 80\text{ million years}. Therefore, r=16 substitutions80 million years=0.20 substitutions/lineage/Myr = \frac{16\text{ substitutions}}{80\text{ million years}} = 0.20\text{ substitutions/lineage/My}.

02

A calibrated molecular clock for a mammalian gene yields a single-lineage substitution rate of r=0.015 substitutions/lineage/Myr = 0.015\text{ substitutions/lineage/My}. If two extant species differ by 1818 substitutions in this gene, how many million years ago did they diverge from their common ancestor?

Answer

600 Mya600\text{ Mya}. Using D=2rTD = 2rT, solve for time: T=D2r=182×0.015=180.030=600 MyaT = \frac{D}{2r} = \frac{18}{2 \times 0.015} = \frac{18}{0.030} = 600\text{ Mya}.

03

Species X and Species Y shared a common ancestor 120 Mya120\text{ Mya} and differ by 2424 amino acids in a conserved protein. A third taxon, Species Z, differs from Species X by 3030 amino acids in the same protein. Assuming a strict molecular clock, determine (a) the single-lineage substitution rate rr and (b) the divergence time between Species X and Species Z.

Answer

(a) r=0.100 substitutions/lineage/Myr = 0.100\text{ substitutions/lineage/My}; (b) T=150 MyaT = 150\text{ Mya}. Key steps: (a) r=DX-Y2⋅TX-Y=242×120=24240=0.100 substitutions/lineage/Myr = \frac{D_{\text{X-Y}}}{2 \cdot T_{\text{X-Y}}} = \frac{24}{2 \times 120} = \frac{24}{240} = 0.100\text{ substitutions/lineage/My}. (b) TX-Z=DX-Z2r=302×0.100=150 MyaT_{\text{X-Z}} = \frac{D_{\text{X-Z}}}{2r} = \frac{30}{2 \times 0.100} = 150\text{ Mya} (or via proportionality: 120×3024=150 Mya120 \times \frac{30}{24} = 150\text{ Mya}).

Loading workspace…