Resources

An agronomist analyzes the evolutionary trade-offs in an alpine angiosperm population producing both asexual vegetative bulbils and sexual flowers. The resource cost per vegetative bulbil is casex=4.2 Jc_{\text{asex}} = 4.2\text{ J}, whereas the total resource expenditure per viable seed (including floral investment, pollen, and ovule provisioning) is csex=10.5 Jc_{\text{sex}} = 10.5\text{ J}. In a field plot with a total reproductive energy budget of E=840 JE = 840\text{ J}, 60%60\% of the energy is allocated to sexual seed production and 40%40\% is allocated to asexual bulbils. (a) Determine the number of seeds (NseedN_{\text{seed}}) and the number of bulbils (NbulbilN_{\text{bulbil}}) produced. (b) Calculate the ratio of bulbils to seeds produced (Nbulbil/NseedN_{\text{bulbil}} / N_{\text{seed}}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Nseed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}, Nbulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}; (b) Ratio NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67.

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Number of Seeds and Bulbils

  1. Calculate the energy allocated to each reproductive pathway:

    • Total available reproductive budget: E=840 JE = 840\text{ J}
    • Energy allocated to sexual reproduction (EsexE_{\text{sex}}): Esex=0.60⋅840 J=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J}
    • Energy allocated to asexual reproduction (EasexE_{\text{asex}}): Easex=0.40⋅840 J=336 JE_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J}
  2. Calculate the number of viable seeds produced (NseedN_{\text{seed}}):

    • The cost per viable seed is csex=10.5 Jc_{\text{sex}} = 10.5\text{ J}.
    • Dividing the sexual energy allocation by the cost per seed: Nseed=Esexcsex=504 J10.5 J/seed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = \frac{E_{\text{sex}}}{c_{\text{sex}}} = \frac{504\text{ J}}{10.5\text{ J/seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}
  3. Calculate the number of bulbils produced (NbulbilN_{\text{bulbil}}):

    • The cost per bulbil is casex=4.2 Jc_{\text{asex}} = 4.2\text{ J}.
    • Dividing the asexual energy allocation by the cost per bulbil: Nbulbil=Easexcasex=336 J4.2 J/bulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = \frac{E_{\text{asex}}}{c_{\text{asex}}} = \frac{336\text{ J}}{4.2\text{ J/bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}

Part (b): Calculating the Ratio of Bulbils to Seeds

  1. Set up the ratio of offspring numbers: NbulbilNseed=8048\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48}
  2. Simplify the fraction:

    • Dividing both numerator and denominator by their greatest common divisor (1616): 80÷1648÷16=53≈1.67\frac{80 \div 16}{48 \div 16} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

Key Biological Takeaway & Pitfall:

  • A common pitfall is assuming that because more total energy (60%60\%) was allocated to sexual reproduction, more seeds would be produced than bulbils. However, sexual reproduction involves higher ancillary costs (such as floral displays, nectar, and pollen production) leading to a significantly higher cost per offspring (10.5 J10.5\text{ J} vs. 4.2 J4.2\text{ J}). Consequently, fewer seeds are produced despite the higher overall energy investment.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student swaps the energy allocation percentages between sexual reproduction and asexual reproduction, leading to 32 seeds and 120 bulbils.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Esex=336 J  ⟹  Easex=0.60⋅840=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 336\text{ J} \implies E_{\text{asex}} = 0.60 \cdot 840 = 504\text{ J}

    Correct

    Esex=0.60⋅840 J=504 J  ⟹  Easex=0.40⋅840 J=336 JE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J} \implies E_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J}

    You assigned 40%40\% of the energy budget to sexual reproduction and 60%60\% to asexual reproduction, but the problem specifies that 60%60\% is allocated to sexual seed production and 40%40\% to asexual bulbils.

  2. Step 2

    Nseed=336/10.5=32  ⟹  Nbulbil=504/4.2=120N_{\text{seed}} = 336 / 10.5 = 32 \implies N_{\text{bulbil}} = 504 / 4.2 = 120

    Correct

    Nseed=504/10.5=48  ⟹  Nbulbil=336/4.2=80N_{\text{seed}} = 504 / 10.5 = 48 \implies N_{\text{bulbil}} = 336 / 4.2 = 80

    Your method of dividing allocated energy by cost per propagule was completely sound, but the counts were thrown off by the swapped energy values from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    NbulbilNseed=12032=3.75\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{120}{32} = 3.75

    Correct

    NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

    You correctly set up and simplified the ratio of bulbils to seeds using your calculated values, but the final numerical ratio reflects the initial percentage swap.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly divided each allocated energy total by the corresponding unit resource cost.

You set up the offspring ratio NbulbilNseed\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} with the correct terms in the numerator and denominator.

You carried out all arithmetic divisions accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable Assignment Swap

You swapped the two percentage allocations, pairing 40%40\% with sexual reproduction and 60%60\% with asexual reproduction instead of the reverse.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misaligning multi-component allocation data when mapping narrative percentages to their biological pathways.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Data Alignment Check
  • Always write down each reproductive pathway explicitly alongside its designated percentage before computing energy values: Epathway=(%pathway)⋅EtotalE_{\text{pathway}} = (\%_{\text{pathway}}) \cdot E_{\text{total}}.

  • Before calculating, write: Sexual=60%  ⟹  Esex=0.60⋅840 J=504 J\text{Sexual} = 60\% \implies E_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J}, and Asexual=40%  ⟹  Easex=0.40⋅840 J=336 J\text{Asexual} = 40\% \implies E_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate sexual energy: Esex=0.60⋅840 J=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J}.

  2. Calculate asexual energy: Easex=0.40⋅840 J=336 JE_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \cdot 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J}.

  3. Determine seed count: Nseed=504 J10.5 J/seed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = \frac{504\text{ J}}{10.5\text{ J/seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}.

  4. Determine bulbil count: Nbulbil=336 J4.2 J/bulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = \frac{336\text{ J}}{4.2\text{ J/bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}.

  5. Compute the offspring ratio: NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67.

Final answer

(a) Nseed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}, Nbulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}; (b) NbulbilNseed=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Annotate or circle percentages directly in the problem text alongside their specific category before writing down equations.

  • Double-check that the larger percentage (60%60\%) matches the pathway with the higher total investment mentioned in the prompt.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the ratio requested in part (b) by calculating seeds to bulbils instead of bulbils to seeds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Esex=0.60×840=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \times 840 = 504\text{ J}, Easex=0.40×840=336 JE_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \times 840 = 336\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    Nseed=50410.5=48N_{\text{seed}} = \frac{504}{10.5} = 48, Nbulbil=3364.2=80  ⟹  Nseed=48, Nbulbil=80N_{\text{bulbil}} = \frac{336}{4.2} = 80 \implies N_{\text{seed}} = 48,\, N_{\text{bulbil}} = 80

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=NseedNbulbil=4880  ⟹  Ratio=0.6\text{Ratio} = \frac{N_{\text{seed}}}{N_{\text{bulbil}}} = \frac{48}{80} \implies \text{Ratio} = 0.6

    Correct

    NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

    The problem asked for the ratio of bulbils to seeds (Nbulbil/NextseedN_{\text{bulbil}} / N_{ ext{seed}}), but you set up seeds over bulbils (Nseed/NbulbilN_{\text{seed}} / N_{\text{bulbil}}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately partitioned the total energy budget according to the given percentages.

You correctly used unit costs to calculate the exact quantities of seeds and bulbils produced.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Ratio

You set up the ratio upside down as seeds over bulbils rather than bulbils over seeds.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the ratio order with the order of parts introduced in part (a) or the standard convention of writing sexual reproduction first, rather than following the explicit phrasing 'ratio of bulbils to seeds' (Nbulbil/NseedN_{\text{bulbil}} / N_{\text{seed}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verbal Ratio Translation
  • The verbal expression 'ratio of AA to BB' always translates mathematically to AB\frac{A}{B}.

  • Always write out the variable names directly from the prompt text before substituting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the requested ratio: Ratio=NbulbilNseed\text{Ratio} = \frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}}.

  2. Substitute the values from part (a): 8048\frac{80}{48}.

  3. Simplify the fraction by dividing the numerator and denominator by 1616: 80÷1648÷16=53≈1.67\frac{80 \div 16}{48 \div 16} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67.

Final answer

NbulbilNseed=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the first quantity mentioned in 'ratio of X to Y' is placed in the numerator.

  • Verify your biological intuition: because bulbils are much cheaper per unit (4.2 J4.2\text{ J} vs. 10.5 J10.5\text{ J}), the plant produces more bulbils than seeds (80>4880 > 48), so the bulbil-to-seed ratio must be greater than 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides the total energy budget directly by the sum of unit costs instead of using the specified percentage allocations.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Ctotal=10.5+4.2=14.7 J  ⟹  N=84014.7=57.14  ⟹  Nseed=57, Nbulbil=57C_{\text{total}} = 10.5 + 4.2 = 14.7\text{ J} \implies N = \frac{840}{14.7} = 57.14 \implies N_{\text{seed}} = 57,\, N_{\text{bulbil}} = 57

    Correct

    Esex=0.60×840 J=504 J  ⟹  Nseed=50410.5=48 seedsE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \times 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{seed}} = \frac{504}{10.5} = 48\text{ seeds}; Easex=0.40×840 J=336 J  ⟹  Nbulbil=3364.2=80 bulbilsE_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \times 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{bulbil}} = \frac{336}{4.2} = 80\text{ bulbils}

    You summed the unit costs and divided the entire budget by that sum, which assumes an equal number of seeds and bulbils is produced. The problem specifies that the energy itself is split into separate pools (60%60\% sexual, 40%40\% asexual), so you must calculate the energy for each pathway first before dividing by the respective unit cost.

  2. Step 2

    NbulbilNseed=5757  ⟹  NbulbilNseed=1\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{57}{57} \implies \frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = 1

    Correct

    NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

    Your division step correctly formed the ratio NbulbilNseed\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}}, but your result was affected by the incorrect offspring counts calculated in part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the unit costs csex=10.5 Jc_{\text{sex}} = 10.5\text{ J} and casex=4.2 Jc_{\text{asex}} = 4.2\text{ J} from the problem statement.

You set up the ratio in part (b) with the correct numerator and denominator.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Budget Allocation Method Error

You divided the total energy budget by the sum of unit costs rather than splitting the energy by the given percentages.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reproductive budget as if seeds and bulbils were forced to be produced in a 1:11:1 numerical ratio, overlooking that the percentages (60%60\% and 40%40\%) constrain the energy pools, not the offspring counts.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Partition the Total Budget First
  • When a resource budget is allocated by fixed percentages, compute each sub-budget first: Ei=percentagei×EtotalE_i = \text{percentage}_i \times E_{\text{total}}.

  • Multiply 840 J840\text{ J} by 0.600.60 to find Esex=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 504\text{ J}, and by 0.400.40 to find Easex=336 JE_{\text{asex}} = 336\text{ J}.

Compute Offspring from Separate Pools
  • The count of each structure is determined independently by Ni=EiciN_i = \frac{E_i}{c_i}.

  • Divide EsexE_{\text{sex}} by csexc_{\text{sex}} (504/10.5=48504 / 10.5 = 48) and EasexE_{\text{asex}} by casexc_{\text{asex}} (336/4.2=80336 / 4.2 = 80).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the sexual energy allocation: Esex=0.60×840 J=504 JE_{\text{sex}} = 0.60 \times 840\text{ J} = 504\text{ J}.

  2. Determine the asexual energy allocation: Easex=0.40×840 J=336 JE_{\text{asex}} = 0.40 \times 840\text{ J} = 336\text{ J}.

  3. Calculate seed count: Nseed=504 J10.5 J/seed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = \frac{504\text{ J}}{10.5\text{ J/seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}.

  4. Calculate bulbil count: Nbulbil=336 J4.2 J/bulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = \frac{336\text{ J}}{4.2\text{ J/bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}.

  5. Calculate the ratio: NbulbilNseed=8048=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{80}{48} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67.

Final answer

(a) Nseed=48 seedsN_{\text{seed}} = 48\text{ seeds}, Nbulbil=80 bulbilsN_{\text{bulbil}} = 80\text{ bulbils}; (b) NbulbilNseed=53≈1.67\frac{N_{\text{bulbil}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.67

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check whether problem statements assign percentages to total energy or to offspring numbers.

  • Practice biological resource-allocation problems where different reproductive pathways have unequal unit costs.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A perennial herb has an annual reproductive budget of E=1200 JE = 1200\text{ J}. It allocates 70%70\% of this energy to sexual reproduction (seeds at csex=14 J/seedc_{\text{sex}} = 14\text{ J/seed}) and 30%30\% to asexual stolons (casex=6 J/stolonc_{\text{asex}} = 6\text{ J/stolon}). Determine the number of seeds and stolons produced, and find the ratio of stolons to seeds.

Answer

Esex=0.70⋅1200=840 J  ⟹  Nseed=84014=60 seedsE_{\text{sex}} = 0.70 \cdot 1200 = 840\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{seed}} = \frac{840}{14} = 60\text{ seeds}. Easex=0.30⋅1200=360 J  ⟹  Nstolon=3606=60 stolonsE_{\text{asex}} = 0.30 \cdot 1200 = 360\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{stolon}} = \frac{360}{6} = 60\text{ stolons}. Ratio NstolonNseed=6060=1\frac{N_{\text{stolon}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{60}{60} = 1.

02

An invasive plant species switches allocation based on disturbance. Under shaded conditions with a total budget of 1500 J1500\text{ J}, it invests 25%25\% into sexual flowers (csex=12.5 J/seedc_{\text{sex}} = 12.5\text{ J/seed}) and 75%75\% into vegetative rhizome buds (casex=5.0 J/budc_{\text{asex}} = 5.0\text{ J/bud}). Calculate: (a) NseedN_{\text{seed}}, (b) NbudN_{\text{bud}}, and (c) the ratio NbudNseed\frac{N_{\text{bud}}}{N_{\text{seed}}}.

Answer

(a) Esex=0.25⋅1500=375 J  ⟹  Nseed=37512.5=30 seedsE_{\text{sex}} = 0.25 \cdot 1500 = 375\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{seed}} = \frac{375}{12.5} = 30\text{ seeds}. (b) Easex=0.75⋅1500=1125 J  ⟹  Nbud=11255.0=225 budsE_{\text{asex}} = 0.75 \cdot 1500 = 1125\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{bud}} = \frac{1125}{5.0} = 225\text{ buds}. (c) NbudNseed=22530=7.5\frac{N_{\text{bud}}}{N_{\text{seed}}} = \frac{225}{30} = 7.5.

03

A population of wild lilies divides an energy pool E=2400 JE = 2400\text{ J} such that the ratio of energy allocated to sexual versus asexual reproduction is 3:13 : 1. If each seed requires csex=15 Jc_{\text{sex}} = 15\text{ J} and each vegetative bulblet requires casex=4 Jc_{\text{asex}} = 4\text{ J}, find the total number of propagules produced (Ntotal=Nseed+NbulbletN_{\text{total}} = N_{\text{seed}} + N_{\text{bulblet}}) and the fraction of total propagules that are asexual.

Answer

Esex=34⋅2400=1800 J  ⟹  Nseed=180015=120 seedsE_{\text{sex}} = \frac{3}{4} \cdot 2400 = 1800\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{seed}} = \frac{1800}{15} = 120\text{ seeds}. Easex=14⋅2400=600 J  ⟹  Nbulblet=6004=150 bulbletsE_{\text{asex}} = \frac{1}{4} \cdot 2400 = 600\text{ J} \implies N_{\text{bulblet}} = \frac{600}{4} = 150\text{ bulblets}. Ntotal=120+150=270 propagulesN_{\text{total}} = 120 + 150 = 270\text{ propagules}. Asexual fraction =150270=59≈0.556= \frac{150}{270} = \frac{5}{9} \approx 0.556 (55.6%55.6\%).

Loading workspace…