Resources

A plant cell maintains a cytosolic pH\text{pH} of 7.207.20 and an apoplastic (cell wall space) pH\text{pH} of 5.505.50 across its plasma membrane at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}). The resting membrane potential is Vm=−120 mVV_m = -120\text{ mV} (inside negative). (a) Calculate the molar electrochemical driving force ΔGH+\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) for the passive inward flux of protons (H+\text{H}^+) from the apoplast into the cytosol. (b) In secondary active transport, an H+\text{H}^+:sucrose symporter couples the inward movement of 1 H+1\text{ H}^+ to the inward transport of 11 neutral sucrose molecule. If the apoplastic sucrose concentration is 0.20 mM0.20\text{ mM}, calculate the maximum cytosolic sucrose concentration [sucrose]cyt[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} (in mM\text{mM}) that can be accumulated by utilizing the energy of this proton gradient.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔGH+=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) [sucrose]cyt=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} (or 1.06 M1.06\text{ M}).

Steps

01

Calculate the Chemical Component

Part (a): Electrochemical Driving Force for HX+\ce{H+} Influx

The free energy change (ΔGHX+\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}}) for moving one mole of a charged solute across a membrane from the outside (apoplast) to the inside (cytosol) is the sum of a chemical concentration term and an electrical membrane potential term: ΔGHX+=RTln⁡([HX+]cyt[HX+]apo)+zFΔΨ\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = RT \ln \left( \frac{[\ce{H^+}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\ce{H^+}]_{\text{apo}}} \right) + z F \Delta\Psi where:

  • R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})
  • T=298 KT = 298\text{ K}
  • z=+1z = +1 (the valence of a proton)
  • F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}
  • ΔΨ=Vm=−120 mV=−0.120 V\Delta\Psi = V_m = -120\text{ mV} = -0.120\text{ V}

By definition of pH\text{pH}, [HX+]=10−pH[\ce{H^+}] = 10^{-\text{pH}}, so:

[HX+]cyt[HX+]apo=10−(pHcyt−pHapo)\frac{[\ce{H^+}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\ce{H^+}]_{\text{apo}}} = 10^{-(\text{pH}_{\text{cyt}} - \text{pH}_{\text{apo}})}

Using the identity ln⁡(10x)=xln⁡(10)\ln(10^x) = x \ln(10):

ΔGchem=RTln⁡(10)⋅(pHapo−pHcyt)\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = RT \ln(10) \cdot (\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}})

Substitute the known values:

ΔGchem=(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)(2.3026)(5.50−7.20)\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = (8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K})(2.3026)(5.50 - 7.20)

ΔGchem=(2477.57 J/mol)(2.3026)(−1.70)≈−9698 J/mol=−9.70 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = (2477.57\text{ J/mol})(2.3026)(-1.70) \approx -9698\text{ J/mol} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

02

Calculate the Electrical Component

ΔGelec=zFΔΨ=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.120 V)=−11578 J/mol=−11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F \Delta\Psi = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.120\text{ V}) = -11578\text{ J/mol} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol}

03

Determine the Total Driving Force

Sum the chemical and electrical contributions:

ΔGHX+=−9.70 kJ/mol+(−11.58 kJ/mol)=−21.28 kJ/mol≈−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol} + (-11.58\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.28\text{ kJ/mol} \approx -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}

The negative sign indicates that proton influx into the cytosol is thermodynamically exergonic (spontaneous).


Part (b): Maximum Sucrose Accumulation via Symport

In secondary active transport, the free energy released by the downhill movement of HX+\ce{H+} powers the uphill accumulation of sucrose:

HX+apo+sucroseapo⇌HX+cyt+sucrosecyt\ce{H^+}_{\text{apo}} + \text{sucrose}_{\text{apo}} \rightleftharpoons \ce{H^+}_{\text{cyt}} + \text{sucrose}_{\text{cyt}}

The overall free energy change of the coupled process is:

ΔGtotal=ΔGHX++ΔGsucrose\Delta G_{\text{total}} = \Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} + \Delta G_{\text{sucrose}}

Because sucrose is an uncharged molecule (z=0z = 0), its transport free energy depends only on its concentration gradient:

ΔGsucrose=RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = RT \ln \left( \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} \right)

At maximum accumulation, the system reaches thermodynamic equilibrium where ΔGtotal=0\Delta G_{\text{total}} = 0, giving:

ΔGsucrose=−ΔGHX+\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = -\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}}

Substitute ΔGHX+=−21282 J/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -21282\text{ J/mol}:

RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282 J/molRT \ln \left( \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} \right) = 21282\text{ J/mol}

ln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282 J/mol(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)=212822477.57≈8.590\ln \left( \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} \right) = \frac{21282\text{ J/mol}}{(8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K})} = \frac{21282}{2477.57} \approx 8.590

Exponentiate both sides to find the maximum accumulation ratio:

[sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3

Given [sucrose]apo=0.20 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}} = 0.20\text{ mM}:

[sucrose]cyt=(0.20 mM)(5.32×103)≈1.06×103 mM(or 1.06 M)[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = (0.20\text{ mM})(5.32 \times 10^3) \approx 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} \quad (\text{or } 1.06\text{ M})

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the direction of the pH gradient, calculating pH_cyt - pH_apo instead of pH_apo - pH_cyt, which reverses the sign of the concentration gradient contribution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔG(H+)=zFVm+2.303RT(pHcyt−pHapo)\Delta G(\text{H}^+) = zFV_m + 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{cyt}} - \text{pH}_{\text{apo}})

    Correct

    ΔGH+=zFVm+2.303RT(pHapo−pHcyt)\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = zFV_m + 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}})

    Because pH=−log⁡10[H+]\text{pH} = -\log_{10}[\text{H}^+], the ratio term evaluates to ln⁡([H+]cyt/[H+]apo)=−2.303(pHcyt−pHapo)=2.303(pHapo−pHcyt)\ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{H}^+]_{\text{apo}}) = -2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{cyt}} - \text{pH}_{\text{apo}}) = 2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}}). By omitting the negative sign from the definition of pH\text{pH}, you inverted the chemical driving force.

  2. Step 2

    zFVm=(1)(96485)(−0.120)=−11578 J/mol=−11.58 kJ/molzFV_m = (1)(96485)(-0.120) = -11578\text{ J/mol} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. Step 3

    2.303RT(7.20−5.50)=2.303(8.314)(298)(1.70)=+9697 J/mol=+9.70 kJ/mol2.303 RT (7.20 - 5.50) = 2.303(8.314)(298)(1.70) = +9697\text{ J/mol} = +9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    2.303RT(5.50−7.20)=2.303(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)(−1.70)=−9.70 kJ/mol2.303 RT (5.50 - 7.20) = 2.303(8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K})(-1.70) = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

    This step is mathematically evaluated correctly from your formula in step 1, but its positive sign is an error propagated from inverting the pH\text{pH} subtraction order. Inward proton movement down a concentration gradient is exergonic and must be negative.

  4. Step 4

    ΔG(H+)=−11.58+9.70=−1.88 kJ/mol\Delta G(\text{H}^+) = -11.58 + 9.70 = -1.88\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGH+=−11.58 kJ/mol+(−9.70 kJ/mol)=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol} + (-9.70\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}

    You added your two components correctly, but the result reflects the propagated sign error on the chemical term.

  5. Step 5

    ΔG(sucrose)=−ΔG(H+)=+1.88 kJ/mol⟹RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt/[sucrose]apo)=1880 J/mol⟹ln⁡([sucrose]cyt/[sucrose]apo)=1880/(8.314×298)=0.759⟹[sucrose]cyt/[sucrose]apo=e0.759=2.14\Delta G(\text{sucrose}) = -\Delta G(\text{H}^+) = +1.88\text{ kJ/mol} \Longrightarrow RT \ln([\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}) = 1880\text{ J/mol} \Longrightarrow \ln([\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}) = 1880 / (8.314 \times 298) = 0.759 \Longrightarrow [\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}} = e^{0.759} = 2.14

    Correct

    ΔGsucrose=−ΔGH+=+21.28 kJ/mol⟹ln⁡([sucrose]cyt/[sucrose]apo)=212822477.6≈8.590⟹[sucrose]cyt/[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = -\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = +21.28\text{ kJ/mol} \Longrightarrow \ln([\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}) = \frac{21282}{2477.6} \approx 8.590 \Longrightarrow [\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3

    Your thermodynamic coupling logic and logarithmic transformations were executed correctly, but they relied on the erroneous driving force value from part (a).

  6. Step 6

    [sucrose]cyt=0.20×2.14=0.43 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 0.20 \times 2.14 = 0.43\text{ mM}

    Correct

    [sucrose]cyt=(0.20 mM)(5.32×103)=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = (0.20\text{ mM})(5.32 \times 10^3) = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM}

    You multiplied the accumulation ratio by the external concentration correctly, but the final value reflects the propagated error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two components of the proton electrochemical driving force.

You calculated the electrical potential term zFVmzFV_m accurately with the proper negative sign.

You correctly applied the thermodynamic equilibrium condition ΔGsucrose=−ΔGH+\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = -\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} to find the maximum accumulation ratio.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in pH-to-chemical potential conversion

You set the chemical free energy term proportional to (pHcyt−pHapo)(\text{pH}_{\text{cyt}} - \text{pH}_{\text{apo}}) rather than (pHapo−pHcyt)(\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Forgetting that pH\text{pH} is inversely related to proton concentration ([H+]=10−pH[\text{H}^+] = 10^{-\text{pH}}) leads to an inverted sign when rewriting ln⁡([H+]in/[H+]out)\ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}/[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}) in terms of ΔpH\Delta\text{pH}. Since the apoplast has a lower pH (5.50 vs. 7.20), the outside has a higher proton concentration; hence, inward flux moves down the chemical gradient and must yield a negative ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermodynamic Directionality Check
  • Passive movement from higher solute concentration to lower solute concentration is always exergonic (ΔGchem<0\Delta G_{\text{chem}} < 0).

  • Always verify that if outside [H+]>[\text{H}^+] > inside [H+][\text{H}^+] (i.e., pHout<pHin\text{pH}_{\text{out}} < \text{pH}_{\text{in}}), the chemical term for influx is negative.

Logarithmic Sign Identity
  • ln⁡([H+]in/[H+]out)=ln⁡(10−(pHin−pHout))=−2.303(pHin−pHout)=2.303(pHout−pHin)\ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{in}}/[\text{H}^+]_{\text{out}}) = \ln(10^{-(\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}})}) = -2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{in}} - \text{pH}_{\text{out}}) = 2.303(\text{pH}_{\text{out}} - \text{pH}_{\text{in}}).

  • Write out the concentration ratio explicitly before substituting pH\text{pH} to ensure the negative sign is retained.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ΔGchem=2.303RT(pHapo−pHcyt)=2.303(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)(5.50−7.20)=−9.70 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}}) = 2.303(8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K})(5.50 - 7.20) = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. ΔGH+=ΔGelec+ΔGchem=−11.58 kJ/mol+(−9.70 kJ/mol)=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = \Delta G_{\text{elec}} + \Delta G_{\text{chem}} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol} + (-9.70\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. ΔGsucrose=−ΔGH+=+21.28 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = -\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = +21.28\text{ kJ/mol}

  4. ln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282 J/mol(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)≈8.590\ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = \frac{21282\text{ J/mol}}{(8.314\text{ J}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298\text{ K})} \approx 8.590

  5. [sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3

  6. [sucrose]cyt=(0.20 mM)(5322)=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = (0.20\text{ mM})(5322) = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM}

Final answer

(a) ΔGH+=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) [sucrose]cyt=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} (or 1.06 M1.06\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}} directly from [H+]=10−pH[\text{H}^+] = 10^{-\text{pH}} rather than memorizing formulas with ±ΔpH\pm \Delta\text{pH}.

  • Perform a physical sanity check on every transport term: if a proton enters a negatively charged cell down a concentration gradient, both electrical and chemical terms must be negative.

  • Solve the practice problems below to master calculating accumulation ratios in secondary active transport.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the electrical membrane potential term entirely, assuming the driving force across the membrane depends only on the chemical concentration difference (pH gradient).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔG(H+)=RTln⁡([H+]cyt[H+]apo)=2.303RT(pHapo−pHcyt)  ⟹  ΔG(H+)=2.303(8.314)(298)(5.50−7.20)=−9697 J/mol=−9.70 kJ/mol\Delta G(\text{H}^+) = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}}) \implies \Delta G(\text{H}^+) = 2.303(8.314)(298)(5.50 - 7.20) = -9697\text{ J/mol} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGH+=RTln⁡([H+]cyt[H+]apo)+zFΔΨ=−9.70 kJ/mol+(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.120 V)=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{H}^+]_{\text{apo}}}\right) + zF\Delta\Psi = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol} + (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.120\text{ V}) = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}

    Protons are charged ions (z=+1z = +1), so moving them across a membrane with an electrical potential difference requires both a chemical work term (RTln⁡([H+]cyt/[H+]apo)RT \ln([\text{H}^+]_{\text{cyt}}/[\text{H}^+]_{\text{apo}})) and an electrical work term (zFΔΨzF\Delta\Psi). Omitting the electrical term leaves out −11.58 kJ/mol-11.58\text{ kJ/mol} of driving force.

  2. Step 2

    RTln⁡([Sucrose]cyt[Sucrose]apo)=9700 J/mol  ⟹  ln⁡([Sucrose]cyt[Sucrose]apo)=3.915  ⟹  [Sucrose]cyt[Sucrose]apo=50.15  ⟹  [Sucrose]cyt=0.20×50.15=10.03 mMRT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = 9700\text{ J/mol} \implies \ln\left(\frac{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = 3.915 \implies \frac{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = 50.15 \implies [\text{Sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 0.20 \times 50.15 = 10.03\text{ mM}

    Correct

    RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=−ΔGH+=21282 J/mol  ⟹  [sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103  ⟹  [sucrose]cyt=1.06×103 mMRT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = -\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = 21282\text{ J/mol} \implies \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3 \implies [\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM}

    Your algebraic manipulation and coupling logic ($ Δ\Delta G_{sucrose\text{sucrose}} = -Δ\Delta G_{H\text{H}^+}$) were completely correct, but the numerical answer was affected by the missing electrical term from part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the chemical potential difference of protons in terms of pH.

You correctly computed the chemical free energy component as −9.70 kJ/mol-9.70\text{ kJ/mol}.

You set up the thermodynamic equilibrium condition for secondary active symport accurately by equating ΔGsucrose\Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} to −ΔGH+-\Delta G_{\text{H}^+}.

You correctly converted the natural logarithm ratio to the cytosolic concentration.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Membrane Potential in Electrochemical Potential

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the proton driving force as a purely chemical concentration gradient, forgetting that for charged solutes (ions), the total electrochemical potential includes both concentration ($ Δ\Delta G_{chem\text{chem}})andelectricalmembranepotential() and electrical membrane potential (zFΔ\Delta\Psi$)._

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Charged vs. Uncharged Solutes
  • For uncharged solutes like sucrose, ΔG=RTln⁡(Cin/Cout)\Delta G = RT \ln(C_{\text{in}}/C_{\text{out}}). For charged solutes (ions), you must include the electrical potential: ΔG=RTln⁡(Cin/Cout)+zFΔΨ\Delta G = RT \ln(C_{\text{in}}/C_{\text{out}}) + zF\Delta\Psi.

  • Always check the valence zz of the transport substrate; if z≠0z \neq 0, calculate both chemical and electrical components.

Sign Convention for $\Delta\Psi$
  • When calculating inward movement (outside →\to inside), ΔΨ=Vinside−Voutside=Vm\Delta\Psi = V_{\text{inside}} - V_{\text{outside}} = V_m.

  • Verify that a negative inside resting potential (Vm<0V_m < 0) provides a negative (favorable) electrical driving force for positively charged cations (z>0z > 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the electrical component: ΔGelec=zFΔΨ=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.120 V)=−11578 J/mol=−11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = zF\Delta\Psi = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.120\text{ V}) = -11578\text{ J/mol} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol}.

  2. Sum the chemical and electrical contributions: ΔGH+=−9.70 kJ/mol+(−11.58 kJ/mol)=−21.28 kJ/mol≈−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol} + (-11.58\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.28\text{ kJ/mol} \approx -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}.

  3. Equate the energy available from H+\text{H}^+ influx to sucrose accumulation: RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282 J/molRT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = 21282\text{ J/mol}.

  4. Solve for the ratio: ln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282(8.314)(298)≈8.590  ⟹  [sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103\ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = \frac{21282}{(8.314)(298)} \approx 8.590 \implies \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3.

  5. Calculate cytosolic sucrose concentration: [sucrose]cyt=0.20 mM×5.32×103=1.06×103 mM=1.06 M[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 0.20\text{ mM} \times 5.32 \times 10^3 = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} = 1.06\text{ M}.

Final answer

(a) ΔGH+=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) [sucrose]cyt=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} (or 1.06 M1.06\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the full formula for electrochemical potential: Δμ=RTln⁡(C2/C1)+zFΔΨ\Delta\mu = RT \ln(C_2/C_1) + zF\Delta\Psi.

  • Practice identifying which solutes are charged (z≠0z \neq 0) versus neutral (z=0z = 0) in membrane transport problems.

  • Rework coupled transport problems by calculating the proton-motive force (pmf) as the sum of ΔpH\Delta\text{pH} and ΔΨ\Delta\Psi.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the negative sign of the membrane potential as opposing inward movement of positively charged protons, treating the electrical work as positive (+11.58 kJ/mol).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔGchem=2.303RT(pHapo−pHcyt)=2.303(8.314)(298)(−1.70)=−9.70 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{apo}} - \text{pH}_{\text{cyt}}) = 2.303(8.314)(298)(-1.70) = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. Step 2

    ΔGelec=−zFVm=−(1)(96485)(−0.120)=+11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = -z F V_m = -(1)(96485)(-0.120) = +11.58\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGelec=zFΔΨ=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.120 V)=−11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F \Delta\Psi = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.120\text{ V}) = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol}

    The electrical work term in membrane transport thermodynamics is ΔGelec=zFΔΨ\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F \Delta\Psi, not −zFΔΨ-z F \Delta\Psi. A positively charged ion (z=+1z = +1) entering an inside-negative compartment (Vm=−120 mVV_m = -120\text{ mV}) is energetically favorable, so ΔGelec\Delta G_{\text{elec}} must be negative (−11.58 kJ/mol-11.58\text{ kJ/mol}).

  3. Step 3

    ΔG(HX+)=−9.70+11.58=+1.88 kJ/mol\Delta G(\ce{H^+}) = -9.70 + 11.58 = +1.88\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔGHX+=−9.70 kJ/mol+(−11.58 kJ/mol)=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol} + (-11.58\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}

    You summed your calculated terms logically, but the result is incorrect due to the positive electrical value from step 2.

  4. Step 4

    Because \text{Because } Δ\Delta G(HX+\ce{H^+})  is positive \text{ is positive } (+1.88 kJ/mol\text{ kJ/mol}), inward transport is non-spontaneous and cannot accumulate sucrose above external concentration \text{inward transport is non-spontaneous and cannot accumulate sucrose above external concentration }   ⟹  \implies Maximum \text{Maximum } [sucrose\text{sucrose}]{cyt\text{cyt}} = 0.20 mM\text{ mM}

    Correct

    RT \ln([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = -Δ\Delta G_{HX+\ce{H^+}} = +21.28 kJ/mol\text{ kJ/mol}   ⟹  \implies [sucrose\text{sucrose}]_{cyt\text{cyt}} ≈\approx 1.06 ×\times 10^3 mM\text{ mM}  (or \text{ (or } 1.06 M)\text{ M)}

    Because proton influx is actually strongly exergonic (ΔGHX+=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}), it couples energetically to pump sucrose against a steep concentration gradient up to 1.06×103 mM1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the chemical potential component to the transmembrane pH difference.

You accurately converted units and performed the numerical arithmetic for both individual terms.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula sign confusion in electrochemical potential

You likely confused the membrane transport electrical work formula ΔG=zFΔΨ\Delta G = z F \Delta\Psi with the redox cell potential equation ΔG=−nFEcell\Delta G = -n F E_{\text{cell}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sign convention of electrical work in membrane transport. In membrane bioenergetics, moving a charge zz through an electric potential change ΔΨ=Ψin−Ψout\Delta\Psi = \Psi_{\text{in}} - \Psi_{\text{out}} contributes +zFΔΨ+z F \Delta\Psi to the Gibbs free energy ΔG\Delta G. Because the cytosol is negative relative to the apoplast, moving a cation inward is downhill (negative ΔGelec\Delta G_{\text{elec}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electrochemical Potential Sign Rule
  • For influx (outside to inside), ΔGelec=zF(Vin−Vout)=zFVm\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F (V_{\text{in}} - V_{\text{out}}) = z F V_m.

  • Always verify that moving a positive charge into a negatively charged interior produces a negative (favorable) electrical free energy change.

Redox vs. Membrane Transport Formulas
  • ΔG=−nFE\Delta G = -n F E applies to galvanic/electrolytic cell electromotive force, whereas ΔGtransport=RTln⁡(Cin/Cout)+zFΔΨ\Delta G_{\text{transport}} = RT \ln(C_{\text{in}}/C_{\text{out}}) + z F \Delta\Psi.

  • Do not include an initial negative sign in front of zFΔΨz F \Delta\Psi when computing transport free energy.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the electrical term: ΔGelec=zFVm=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.120 V)=−11578 J/mol=−11.58 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = z F V_m = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.120\text{ V}) = -11578\text{ J/mol} = -11.58\text{ kJ/mol}.

  2. Sum both components for proton influx: ΔGHX+=−9.70 kJ/mol+(−11.58 kJ/mol)=−21.28 kJ/mol≈−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -9.70\text{ kJ/mol} + (-11.58\text{ kJ/mol}) = -21.28\text{ kJ/mol} \approx -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}.

  3. Equate the coupled reaction free energy to zero at maximum accumulation: ΔGtotal=ΔGHX++ΔGsucrose=0  ⟹  RTln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=−ΔGHX+=+21282 J/mol\Delta G_{\text{total}} = \Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} + \Delta G_{\text{sucrose}} = 0 \implies RT \ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = -\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = +21282\text{ J/mol}.

  4. Solve for the concentration ratio: ln⁡([sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo)=21282(8.314)(298)≈8.590  ⟹  [sucrose]cyt[sucrose]apo=e8.590≈5.32×103\ln\left(\frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}}\right) = \frac{21282}{(8.314)(298)} \approx 8.590 \implies \frac{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}}}{[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{apo}}} = e^{8.590} \approx 5.32 \times 10^3.

  5. Calculate cytosolic sucrose: [sucrose]cyt=0.20 mM×5.32×103≈1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 0.20\text{ mM} \times 5.32 \times 10^3 \approx 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} (or 1.06 M1.06\text{ M}).

Final answer

(a) ΔGHX+=−21.3 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\ce{H^+}} = -21.3\text{ kJ/mol}; (b) [sucrose]cyt=1.06×103 mM[\text{sucrose}]_{\text{cyt}} = 1.06 \times 10^3\text{ mM} (or 1.06 M1.06\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between the redox free energy formula ΔG=−nFE\Delta G = -n F E and the membrane electrochemical formula ΔG=RTln⁡(Cin/Cout)+zFΔΨ\Delta G = RT \ln(C_{\text{in}}/C_{\text{out}}) + z F \Delta\Psi.

  • Perform a physical intuition check: ask whether attraction between opposite charges should make inward cation transport spontaneous (negative ΔG\Delta G).

  • Practice coupled secondary active transport problems to get comfortable calculating concentration accumulation ratios.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A bacterium has an extracellular pH\text{pH} of 6.006.00 and an intracellular pH\text{pH} of 7.507.50 at 298 K298\text{ K} (2.303RT=5.71 kJ/mol2.303 RT = 5.71\text{ kJ/mol}). Calculate the chemical driving force ΔGchem\Delta G_{\text{chem}} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) for inward proton movement.

Answer

ΔGchem=2.303RT(pHout−pHin)=(5.71 kJ/mol)(6.00−7.50)=(5.71)(−1.50)=−8.57 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = 2.303 RT (\text{pH}_{\text{out}} - \text{pH}_{\text{in}}) = (5.71\text{ kJ/mol})(6.00 - 7.50) = (5.71)(-1.50) = -8.57\text{ kJ/mol}.

02

A fungal cell has Vm=−150 mVV_m = -150\text{ mV}, an external pH\text{pH} of 4.004.00, and an internal pH\text{pH} of 7.007.00 at 298 K298\text{ K} (F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol}, 2.303RT=5.71 kJ/mol2.303 RT = 5.71\text{ kJ/mol}). Calculate the total electrochemical driving force ΔGH+\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} (in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}) for inward proton flux.

Answer
  1. ΔGelec=(+1)(96485 C/mol)(−0.150 V)=−14.47 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{elec}} = (+1)(96485\text{ C/mol})(-0.150\text{ V}) = -14.47\text{ kJ/mol}.\n2. ΔGchem=(5.71 kJ/mol)(4.00−7.00)=−17.13 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{chem}} = (5.71\text{ kJ/mol})(4.00 - 7.00) = -17.13\text{ kJ/mol}.\n3. ΔGH+=−14.47+(−17.13)=−31.6 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -14.47 + (-17.13) = -31.6\text{ kJ/mol}.
03

An H+\text{H}^+:amino acid symporter couples the inward transport of 2 H+2\text{ H}^+ to 11 neutral amino acid. If the net driving force for 1 H+1\text{ H}^+ influx is ΔGH+=−18.0 kJ/mol\Delta G_{\text{H}^+} = -18.0\text{ kJ/mol} at 298 K298\text{ K} (RT=2.478 kJ/molRT = 2.478\text{ kJ/mol}), calculate the maximum theoretical internal-to-external amino acid concentration ratio [AA]in/[AA]out[\text{AA}]_{\text{in}}/[\text{AA}]_{\text{out}}.

Answer
  1. Coupled driving force released: 2×(−18.0 kJ/mol)=−36.0 kJ/mol2 \times (-18.0\text{ kJ/mol}) = -36.0\text{ kJ/mol}.\n2. At equilibrium: ΔGAA=+36.0 kJ/mol=RTln⁡([AA]in/[AA]out)\Delta G_{\text{AA}} = +36.0\text{ kJ/mol} = RT \ln([\text{AA}]_{\text{in}}/[\text{AA}]_{\text{out}}).\n3. ln⁡([AA]in/[AA]out)=36.0/2.478=14.53\ln([\text{AA}]_{\text{in}}/[\text{AA}]_{\text{out}}) = 36.0 / 2.478 = 14.53.\n4. Ratio =e14.53≈2.04×106= e^{14.53} \approx 2.04 \times 10^6.
Loading workspace…