Resources

A population of alpine pocket gophers experiences both recurrent mutation and directional natural selection at a locus controlling metabolic efficiency. Wild-type allele AA mutates to a deleterious recessive allele aa at a forward mutation rate of μ=3.0×10−5\mu = 3.0 \times 10^{-5} mutations per gene per generation. Individuals with genotype aaaa suffer a fitness disadvantage with selection coefficient s=0.040s = 0.040, while genotypes AAAA and AaAa have relative fitness 1.01.0. (a) Calculate the equilibrium frequency of the deleterious allele (q^\hat{q}) under mutation-selection balance. (b) If immigration suddenly introduces individuals carrying allele aa at rate m=0.002m = 0.002 from an adjacent valley where qm=0.15q_m = 0.15, determine the initial change in allele frequency solely due to this gene flow event before selection acts, Δqmig=m(qm−q^)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) q^≈0.0274\hat{q} \approx 0.0274; (b) Δqmig≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

Steps

Part (a): Equilibrium Frequency Under Mutation-Selection Balance

  1. Identify the Mode of Selection and Given Parameters:

    • Mutation introduces the deleterious allele aa from wild-type AA at rate μ=3.0×10−5\mu = 3.0 \times 10^{-5}.
    • The relative fitnesses of the genotypes are:
      • wAA=1.0w_{AA} = 1.0
      • wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0
      • waa=1−s=1−0.040=0.960w_{aa} = 1 - s = 1 - 0.040 = 0.960
    • Because the heterozygote has the same fitness as the homozygous wild-type (wAa=wAAw_{Aa} = w_{AA}), the deleterious allele is completely recessive.
  2. Apply the Equilibrium Formula for a Completely Recessive Allele: In a large random-mating population, new recessive alleles are created at a rate proportional to μ\mu, while selection removes them primarily in homozygotes (aaaa) at rate sq2s q^2. Setting the rate of input by mutation equal to the rate of removal by selection (μ≈sq2\mu \approx s q^2) gives the mutation-selection equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q}: q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}}
  3. Calculate q^\hat{q}: q^=3.0×10−50.040=7.5×10−4≈0.027386≈0.0274\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{3.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.040}} = \sqrt{7.5 \times 10^{-4}} \approx 0.027386 \approx 0.0274

    Common Pitfall: Do not use the formula for a partially dominant or additive allele (q^≈μhs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{hs}), because here h=0h = 0 (complete recessiveness), which concentrates selection only on the homozygous recessive genotype.


Part (b): Change in Allele Frequency Due to Gene Flow

  1. Understand the Gene Flow Formula: When migrants enter a resident population at rate mm (the fraction of the new population composed of immigrants), the one-generation change in allele frequency due to gene flow alone is: Δqmig=m(qm−q0)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - q_0) where:

    • Migration rate m=0.002m = 0.002
    • Immigrant allele frequency qm=0.15q_m = 0.15
    • Resident initial allele frequency before gene flow q0=q^≈0.027386q_0 = \hat{q} \approx 0.027386
  2. Compute Δqmig\Delta q_{\text{mig}}: Δqmig=0.002×(0.15−0.027386)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.027386) Δqmig=0.002×0.122614≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times 0.122614 \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

The positive sign indicates that gene flow increases the frequency of the deleterious allele in the alpine population because the donor population has a higher frequency of allele aa (0.15>0.02740.15 > 0.0274).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the equilibrium formula for a dominant or partially dominant deleterious allele, q̂ = μ / s, omitting the square root required for a recessive allele.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q^=μs  ⟹  q^=3.0×10−50.040  ⟹  q^=0.00075\hat{q} = \frac{\mu}{s} \implies \hat{q} = \frac{3.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.040} \implies \hat{q} = 0.00075

    Correct

    q^=μs=3.0×10−50.040≈0.0274\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} = \sqrt{\frac{3.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.040}} \approx 0.0274

    Because the deleterious allele aa is completely recessive (wAa=wAA=1.0w_{Aa} = w_{AA} = 1.0), natural selection acts only against aaaa homozygotes at rate sq2s q^2. Setting mutation rate equal to selection loss gives μ≈sq2\mu \approx s q^2, which yields q^=μs\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} rather than μs\frac{\mu}{s}.

  2. Step 2

    Δqmig=m(qm−q^)  ⟹  Δqmig=0.002×(0.15−0.00075)  ⟹  Δqmig=0.002×0.14925=0.0002985\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}) \implies \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.00075) \implies \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times 0.14925 = 0.0002985

    Correct

    Δqmig=m(qm−q^)=0.002×(0.15−0.0274)≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.0274) \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

    You chose the correct gene flow formula and performed the multiplication accurately, but your numerical answer is off because it carries forward the incorrect value of q^\hat{q} from part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the one-generation gene flow formula Δqmig=m(qm−q^)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}).

You substituted your parameters and carried out the arithmetic consistently without computational slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Recessive vs. Dominant Mutation-Selection Balance

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the equilibrium formula for a dominant or partially dominant deleterious allele (q^≈μs\hat{q} \approx \frac{\mu}{s}) instead of accounting for complete recessiveness, where the deleterious allele is sheltered in heterozygotes and removed only in homozygotes (sq2s q^2), requiring a square root.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check dominance of the deleterious allele
  • If the heterozygote has the same fitness as the wild-type (wAa=1.0w_{Aa} = 1.0), the allele is completely recessive, so selection acts at rate sq2s q^2.

  • Always verify heterozygote fitness before picking the balance equation: use q^=μ/s\hat{q} = \sqrt{\mu / s} for recessive alleles and q^=μ/s\hat{q} = \mu / s (or μ/hs\mu / hs) when the allele is expressed in heterozygotes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the correct recessive equilibrium: q^=3.0×10−50.040=7.5×10−4≈0.027386\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{3.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.040}} = \sqrt{7.5 \times 10^{-4}} \approx 0.027386.

  2. Substitute the updated equilibrium frequency into the migration equation: Δqmig=0.002×(0.15−0.027386)=0.002×0.122614≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.027386) = 0.002 \times 0.122614 \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}.

Final answer

(a) q^≈0.0274\hat{q} \approx 0.0274; (b) Δqmig≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how heterozygote masking shelters recessive alleles from selection, creating the q2q^2 dependency.

  • Practice matching the correct mutation-selection balance formula to the specified dominance relationship (h=0h = 0, 0<h<10 < h < 1, or h=1h = 1).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the direction of gene flow and subtracts immigrant allele frequency from resident frequency in the migration formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    q^=μs⟹q^=3.0×10−50.040=7.5×10−4≈0.0274\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} \Longrightarrow \hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{3.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.040}} = \sqrt{7.5 \times 10^{-4}} \approx 0.0274

  2. Step 2

    Δqmig=m(q^−qm)⟹Δqmig=0.002×(0.0274−0.15)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(\hat{q} - q_m) \Longrightarrow \Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (0.0274 - 0.15)

    Correct

    Δqmig=m(qm−q^)=0.002×(0.15−0.0274)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.0274)

    You reversed the order of subtraction in the gene flow equation. The change in allele frequency depends on how the immigrant pool compares to the resident population, so the formula is Δq=m(qm−q0)\Delta q = m(q_m - q_0), not m(q0−qm)m(q_0 - q_m).

  3. Step 3

    Δqmig=0.002×(−0.1226)=−0.000245\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (-0.1226) = -0.000245

    Correct

    Δqmig=0.002×0.1226=2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times 0.1226 = 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

    Your arithmetic was accurate based on your formula, but the result has the incorrect negative sign due to the reversed subtraction in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly selected the equilibrium formula q^=μ/s\hat{q} = \sqrt{\mu / s} for a completely recessive deleterious allele.

You carried out the square root calculation and rounding accurately in part (a).

You accurately substituted the numerical values of mm, q^\hat{q}, and qmq_m into your arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed order of terms in gene flow formula

You set up the gene flow difference as (q^−qm)(\hat{q} - q_m) instead of (qm−q^)(q_m - \hat{q}), resulting in a negative frequency change.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of gene flow: when incoming migrants have a higher allele frequency than residents (qm>q0q_m > q_0), gene flow introduces that allele and must increase its frequency in the recipient population (Δq>0Δq > 0). Subtracting resident minus immigrant inverts the biological direction of change.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Biological Sanity Check on Gene Flow
  • If immigrants carry a higher frequency of an allele than the recipient population (qm>qq_m > q), gene flow must increase that allele's frequency (Δq>0Δq > 0).

  • Compare qmq_m and q0q_0 before calculating. If qm=0.15>0.0274q_m = 0.15 > 0.0274, ensure your final ΔqmigΔq_{\text{mig}} is positive.

Standard Migration Equation
  • The new frequency after migration is q′=(1−m)q+mqm=q+m(qm−q)q' = (1 - m)q + m q_m = q + m(q_m - q), so Δq=m(qm−q)Δq = m(q_m - q).

  • Always write the difference as (immigrant−resident)(\text{immigrant} - \text{resident}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard gene flow equation: Δqmig=m(qm−q^)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}).

  2. Substitute the given migration rate and allele frequencies: Δqmig=0.002×(0.15−0.0274)\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = 0.002 \times (0.15 - 0.0274).

  3. Compute the difference: 0.15−0.0274=0.12260.15 - 0.0274 = 0.1226.

  4. Multiply by the migration rate: 0.002×0.1226=2.452×10−4≈2.45×10−40.002 \times 0.1226 = 2.452 \times 10^{-4} \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}.

Final answer

(a) q^≈0.0274\hat{q} \approx 0.0274; (b) Δqmig≈2.45×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} \approx 2.45 \times 10^{-4}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the derivation of q′=(1−m)q+mqmq' = (1 - m)q + m q_m to see why the factor is always (qm−q)(q_m - q).

  • Perform a directional sanity check whenever computing ΔqΔq: verify whether immigrants are enriching or diluting the allele.

  • Practice paired migration and selection problems to build confidence with algebraic sign conventions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A locus in a wild sunflower experiences recurrent mutation to a deleterious recessive allele bb at rate μ=4.0×10−6\mu = 4.0 \times 10^{-6}. The relative fitness of genotype bbbb is 0.900.90, while BBBB and BbBb both have relative fitness 1.01.0. Calculate the equilibrium allele frequency q^\hat{q} under mutation-selection balance.

Answer

q^≈0.00632\hat{q} \approx 0.00632. Since allele bb is completely recessive, s=1−0.90=0.10s = 1 - 0.90 = 0.10. Using q^=μs=4.0×10−60.10=4.0×10−5≈0.00632\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} = \sqrt{\frac{4.0 \times 10^{-6}}{0.10}} = \sqrt{4.0 \times 10^{-5}} \approx 0.00632.

02

In a beetle population at mutation-selection balance for a recessive lethal allele (s=1.0s = 1.0) with mutation rate μ=1.6×10−5\mu = 1.6 \times 10^{-5}, an influx of migrants arrives each generation at rate m=0.01m = 0.01 with allele frequency qm=0.05q_m = 0.05. Find: (a) the resident equilibrium frequency q^\hat{q}, and (b) the change in allele frequency Δqmig\Delta q_{\text{mig}} in the first generation of gene flow.

Answer

(a) q^=1.6×10−51.0=0.0040\hat{q} = \sqrt{\frac{1.6 \times 10^{-5}}{1.0}} = 0.0040. (b) Δqmig=m(qm−q^)=0.01×(0.05−0.0040)=0.01×0.046=4.6×10−4\Delta q_{\text{mig}} = m(q_m - \hat{q}) = 0.01 \times (0.05 - 0.0040) = 0.01 \times 0.046 = 4.6 \times 10^{-4}.

03

Contrast two loci with identical mutation rates μ=2.0×10−5\mu = 2.0 \times 10^{-5} and identical selection coefficients s=0.05s = 0.05. At Locus 1, the mutant allele is completely dominant. At Locus 2, the mutant allele is completely recessive. Calculate the equilibrium frequency at both loci and state which locus maintains a higher frequency of the deleterious allele and why.

Answer

Locus 1 (dominant): q^1=μs=2.0×10−50.05=4.0×10−4\hat{q}_1 = \frac{\mu}{s} = \frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.05} = 4.0 \times 10^{-4}. Locus 2 (recessive): q^2=μs=2.0×10−50.05=4.0×10−4=0.020\hat{q}_2 = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{s}} = \sqrt{\frac{2.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.05}} = \sqrt{4.0 \times 10^{-4}} = 0.020. Locus 2 maintains a 50-fold higher frequency because recessive alleles are sheltered from natural selection within heterozygous carriers (AaAa).

Loading workspace…