Resources

In humans, red-green color blindness is an X-linked recessive condition governed by allele XbX^b, where normal vision is governed by XBX^B. A couple with normal phenotypic vision has three children: a color-blind son, a son with normal vision, and a daughter with normal vision. Determine the exact genotypes of both parents, and calculate the probability that the daughter is a heterozygous carrier of the color blindness allele.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Mother's genotype: XBXbX^B X^b; Father's genotype: XBYX^B Y; Probability that the phenotypically normal daughter is a carrier: 12\frac{1}{2} (0.50.5 or 50%50\%).

Steps

01

Determine the Father's Genotype

Human males are hemizygous for genes on the X chromosome because they possess one X chromosome and one Y chromosome (XY\text{XY}).

  • The father has normal phenotypic vision, which is governed by the dominant allele XBX^B.
  • Since he has only one X chromosome, his genotype must be XBYX^B Y.

02

Determine the Mother's Genotype

Human females possess two X chromosomes (XX\text{XX}).

  • The mother has normal phenotypic vision, meaning she must carry at least one dominant allele: XBX?X^B X^?.
  • The couple has a son who is red-green color-blind (XbYX^b Y).
  • A son inherits his Y\text{Y} chromosome from his father and his X\text{X} chromosome from his mother. Therefore, the recessive allele XbX^b must have been inherited from the mother.
  • Combining these facts, the mother must be a heterozygous carrier with the genotype XBXbX^B X^b.

03

Calculate the Probability That the Daughter Is a Carrier

Set up a Punnett square for the cross between the mother (XBXbX^B X^b) and the father (XBYX^B Y):

& X^B & Y \\ \hline X^B & X^B X^B & X^B Y \\ X^b & X^B X^b & X^b Y \\ \end{array}$$

Looking specifically at the female offspring:

  • An egg carrying XBX^B fertilized by a sperm carrying XB  ⟹  XBXBX^B \implies X^B X^B (homozygous normal vision, non-carrier).
  • An egg carrying XbX^b fertilized by a sperm carrying XB  ⟹  XBXbX^B \implies X^B X^b (heterozygous carrier with normal vision).

Because the father always contributes a dominant XBX^B allele to his daughters, all female offspring produced by this couple are phenotypically normal.

Within the set of possible daughters:

  • P(XBXB)=12\text{P}(X^B X^B) = \frac{1}{2}
  • P(XBXb)=12\text{P}(X^B X^b) = \frac{1}{2}

Therefore, the probability that the phenotypically normal daughter is a heterozygous carrier (XBXbX^B X^b) is 12\frac{1}{2} (0.50.5 or 50%50\%).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the carrier probability out of all possible children from the cross rather than conditioning on the child being a normal-vision female.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Father: XBYX^B Y

  2. Step 2

    Color-blind son is XbYX^b Y, so he gets XbX^b from mother ⟹ Mother is normal vision: XBXbX^B X^b

  3. Step 3

    Punnett square: XBXBX^B X^B, XBXbX^B X^b, XBYX^B Y, XbYX^b Y

  4. Step 4

    Carrier child is XBXbX^B X^b ⟹ P(carrier daughter)=14P(\text{carrier daughter}) = \frac{1}{4}

    Correct

    P(XBXb∣female)=12P(X^B X^b \mid \text{female}) = \frac{1}{2}

    The question specifies that the child is already known to be a daughter. Because her sex is predetermined, the sample space is restricted to female offspring (XBXBX^B X^B and XBXbX^B X^b), giving a probability of 12\frac{1}{2} rather than 14\frac{1}{4}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the father's hemizygous genotype as XBYX^B Y.

You deduced that the mother must be a carrier (XBXbX^B X^b) by tracing the son's X chromosome.

You generated all correct offspring combinations from the parental cross.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conditioning on Sex

You divided by the total number of offspring (44) instead of the total number of daughters (22).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating unconditional probability of having a carrier daughter across all births, P(female and carrier)=14P(\text{female and carrier}) = \frac{1}{4}, with the conditional probability given that the child is a daughter, P(carrier∣daughter)=12P(\text{carrier} \mid \text{daughter}) = \frac{1}{2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Given vs. Unknown Conditions
  • When a question asks for the probability that 'the daughter' or 'a son' has a trait, the child's sex is already fixed as part of the given condition.

  • Restrict the denominator to only the offspring of the specified sex before evaluating favorable genotypes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all possible female genotypes from the cross: XBXBX^B X^B (normal non-carrier) and XBXbX^B X^b (carrier).

  2. Count the number of carrier genotypes among female offspring: 11 out of 22.

  3. Compute the conditional probability: 12\frac{1}{2}.

Final answer

Mother: XBXbX^B X^b; Father: XBYX^B Y; Probability that the daughter is a carrier: 12\frac{1}{2} (50%50\%)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Circle the relevant row or column in your Punnett square corresponding only to the specified sex whenever sex is fixed in the prompt.

  • Practice translating phrases like 'probability that the son has...' into conditional probability notation P(trait∣sex)P(\text{trait} \mid \text{sex}) to avoid including all four boxes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets sex-linked inheritance as standard autosomal recessive inheritance, incorrectly using a 2/3 carrier probability among phenotypically normal offspring.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Let B=normal,b=color-blind  ⟹  Father: Bb, Mother: Bb\text{Let } B = \text{normal}, b = \text{color-blind} \implies \text{Father: } Bb, \text{ Mother: } Bb

    Correct

    Father: XBY, Mother: XBXb\text{Father: } X^B Y, \text{ Mother: } X^B X^b

    You treated the condition as autosomal instead of X-linked. Red-green color blindness is on the X chromosome. Human males are hemizygous (XYXY) and carry only one allele, so a normal-vision father must be XBYX^B Y. The mother has normal vision but passed an XbX^b allele to her affected son, making her XBXbX^B X^b.

  2. Step 2

    Cross Bb×Bb gives BB,Bb,Bb,bb\text{Cross } Bb \times Bb \text{ gives } BB, Bb, Bb, bb

    Correct

    Cross XBXb×XBY gives XBXB,XBY,XBXb,XbY\text{Cross } X^B X^b \times X^B Y \text{ gives } X^B X^B, X^B Y, X^B X^b, X^b Y

    Because the parental genotypes were set up as autosomal Bb×BbBb \times Bb, the cross produced autosomal ratios (1 BB:2 Bb:1 bb1\,BB : 2\,Bb : 1\,bb) instead of sex-specific offspring genotypes.

  3. Step 3

    Daughter has normal vision, so she is \text{Daughter has normal vision, so she is } BB, Bb,  or \text{ or } Bb   ⟹  \implies P(carrier daughter\text{carrier daughter}) = 23\frac{2}{3}

    Correct

    Daughters inherit \text{Daughters inherit } X^B  from father and either \text{ from father and either } X^B  or \text{ or } X^b  from mother\text{ from mother}   ⟹  \implies P(X^B X^b) = 12\frac{1}{2}

    Because you used the autosomal ratio among phenotypically normal offspring, you obtained 23\frac{2}{3}. In an X-linked cross, all daughters inherit the dominant XBX^B from the father, so the daughter's genotype is determined entirely by whether she receives XBX^B or XbX^b from her mother, yielding P(XBXb)=12P(X^B X^b) = \frac{1}{2}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the affected son requires a recessive allele to be present in the family.

You understood that a normal phenotype combined with an affected child implies the mother must carry the recessive allele.

You correctly conditioned the carrier probability on the daughter having normal vision within your modeled cross.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Autosomal vs. Sex-Linked Model Confusion
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating an X-linked recessive trait as an autosomal recessive trait. This led to assigning a diploid heterozygous genotype (BbBb) to the father instead of recognizing that human males are hemizygous (XBYX^B Y), which fundamentally skewed the Punnett square and the conditional probability for the daughter.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Chromosome Linkage
  • Traits explicitly specified as X-linked must be tracked on the sex chromosomes (XX and YY). Males are hemizygous (XAYX^A Y or XaYX^a Y) and cannot be heterozygous carriers for non-pseudoautosomal X-linked genes.

  • Always write male genotypes with one X and one Y chromosome (XalleleYX^{\text{allele}} Y) whenever a problem states that a gene is X-linked.

Evaluate Daughters Separately
  • In an X-linked cross, a father passes his single XX chromosome to all daughters and his YY chromosome to all sons. An XBYX^B Y father guarantees that every daughter receives at least one normal XBX^B allele.

  • Separate the Punnett square outcomes by sex (XXXX vs. XYXY) before calculating conditional probabilities for sons or daughters.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Assign the father's genotype as XBYX^B Y because he is male and has normal vision.

  2. Assign the mother's genotype as XBXbX^B X^b because she has normal vision and has an affected son (XbYX^b Y) who must have received XbX^b from her.

  3. Cross XBXb×XBYX^B X^b \times X^B Y. The female offspring can only be XBXBX^B X^B or XBXbX^B X^b, each occurring with equal probability 12\frac{1}{2}.

  4. Since all female offspring have normal vision, the probability that the normal daughter is a carrier (XBXbX^B X^b) is 12\frac{1}{2}.

Final answer

Mother: XBXbX^B X^b; Father: XBYX^B Y; Probability that the daughter is a carrier: 12\frac{1}{2} (or 50%50\%)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice explicitly writing sex chromosome superscripts (XB,Xb,YX^B, X^b, Y) whenever 'X-linked' or 'sex-linked' appears in the problem statement.

  • Review conditional probability problems for X-linked traits, paying special attention to how a father's genotype guarantees the phenotype of all his daughters.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Hemophilia A is an X-linked recessive disorder (XhX^h). A carrier female (XHXhX^H X^h) and a normal male (XHYX^H Y) have a child. If an ultrasound confirms the fetus is male, what is the probability that the child will have hemophilia?

Answer

The possible male genotypes are XHYX^H Y and XhYX^h Y. Since the child is confirmed male, the sample space consists of 22 possible male outcomes. Exactly 11 of these has hemophilia, so P(hemophilia∣male)=12P(\text{hemophilia} \mid \text{male}) = \frac{1}{2} (50%50\%).

02

A woman with normal vision whose father was red-green color-blind (XbYX^b Y) marries a color-blind man (XbYX^b Y). Calculate: (a) the probability that their first child is a color-blind daughter, and (b) the probability that their daughter is color-blind.

Answer

The mother is XBXbX^B X^b (she received XbX^b from her father) and the father is XbYX^b Y. Offspring: XBXbX^B X^b, XbXbX^b X^b, XBYX^B Y, XbYX^b Y. (a) Across all children, color-blind daughter (XbXbX^b X^b) is 11 out of 44, so P=14P = \frac{1}{4} (25%25\%). (b) Given that the child is a daughter, outcomes are XBXbX^B X^b and XbXbX^b X^b. Exactly 11 of 22 is color-blind, so P=12P = \frac{1}{2} (50%50\%).

03

In fruit flies, white eyes (ww) is an X-linked recessive trait and red eyes (WW) is dominant. A heterozygous red-eyed female (XWXwX^W X^w) is crossed with a red-eyed male (XWYX^W Y). Among the phenotypically red-eyed offspring only, what is the probability that a randomly chosen fly is male?

Answer

The four cross outcomes are XWXWX^W X^W (red-eyed female), XWXwX^W X^w (red-eyed female), XWYX^W Y (red-eyed male), and XwYX^w Y (white-eyed male). Restricting the sample space strictly to phenotypically red-eyed flies yields 33 outcomes (XWXW,XWXw,XWYX^W X^W, X^W X^w, X^W Y). Among these 33, exactly 11 is male (XWYX^W Y). Thus, P(male∣red-eyed)=13P(\text{male} \mid \text{red-eyed}) = \frac{1}{3}.

Loading workspace…